- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Union Of India And Others v. Gyan Chand Chattar .
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent, Gyan Chand Chattar, was appointed as a Shroff in Western Railways on 8-2-1971 and later worked as a Cashier. A departmental charge-sheet dated 8-4-1980 levelled six charges against him, chiefly centred on events of 24-11-1979 and earlier refusals to disburse payments. After a domestic enquiry, all charges were held proved; the disciplinary authority removed him from service on 2-5-1981, later modified on appeal to a penalty of reversion to a lower post.
Chattar challenged the punishment in Special Civil Application No. 101 of 1982. On 27-12-1982, a Single Judge of the Gujarat High Court found only Charges 4 and 5 (refusal to accept control messages/memos) partly proved and directed the disciplinary authority to impose only a minor penalty. The Union of India filed Letters Patent Appeal No. 25 of 1983. On 1-5-2002, the Division Bench affirmed the Single Judge on facts, but, considering the lapse of twenty years, set aside even the direction to impose a minor penalty and awarded the employee 50 % back wages and full consequential benefits.
The Union of India appealed to the Supreme Court, leading to the present judgment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court, in exercise of limited judicial review, was justified in re-appreciating evidence and upsetting the concurrent departmental findings on all six charges.
- Whether the charges—particularly allegation of corruption (Charge 6)—were sufficiently specific to sustain disciplinary action.
- Whether, after a lapse of over two decades, any direction to impose a minor penalty was warranted or the matter should be closed with monetary relief.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (Union of India)
- The High Court exceeded its jurisdiction by interfering with concurrent findings of fact recorded by the enquiry officer, disciplinary authority and appellate authority.
- All six charges, including demand of 1 % commission (corruption), stood proved, establishing gross indiscipline warranting major punishment.
- The Division Bench erred in removing even the minor penalty option and awarding 50 % back wages.
Respondent Employee
- No legal evidence supported initiation of disciplinary proceedings; findings were perverse.
- Charges were either unproved or based on vague, hearsay material (especially the corruption charge).
- Given the twenty-year delay and mental agony suffered, the Division Bench rightly terminated the matter with monetary relief instead of remitting it for fresh punishment.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Municipal Committee, Bahadurgarh v. Krishnan Behari (1996) 2 SCC 714 | In corruption cases, dismissal is the only appropriate punishment; sympathy is misplaced. | Cited to stress that if Charge 6 (corruption) were proved, only dismissal could follow—hence the charge must be strictly scrutinised. |
| Ruston & Hornsby (I) Ltd. v. T.B. Kadam (1976) 3 SCC 71 | Punishment must be proportionate to misconduct. | Reinforced need for proportionality; minor lapses cannot justify major penalties. |
| U.P. SRTC v. Basudeo Chaudhary (1997) 11 SCC 370 | Doctrine of proportionality in disciplinary action. | Supports High Court’s view that major penalty was disproportionate to proved conduct. |
| Janatha Bazar v. Sahakari Noukarara Sangha (2000) 7 SCC 517 | Stringent view against proven acts of dishonesty. | Referenced while contrasting unproven corruption charge with standard for dismissal. |
| Karnataka SRTC v. B.S. Hullikatti (2001) 2 SCC 574 | Dismissal appropriate for acts involving moral turpitude. | Same contextual use as above. |
| Rajasthan SRTC v. Ghanshyam Sharma (2002) 10 SCC 330 | Punishment must align with gravity of misconduct. | Bolstered proportionality analysis. |
| NEKRTC v. H. Amaresh (2006) 6 SCC 187 | Principle of proportionality and intolerance of corruption. | Supports strict scrutiny of vague corruption charges. |
| U.P. State Road Transport Corporation v. Vinod Kumar (2008) 1 SCC 115 | Severity of punishment in corruption matters. | Affirmed that dismissal is mandatory if corruption is proved. |
| Surath Chandra Chakrabarty v. State of W.B. (1970) 3 SCC 548 | Vague charges violate principles of natural justice. | Used to hold Charge 6 unsustainable due to vagueness. |
| State of A.P. v. S. Sree Rama Rao AIR 1963 SC 1723 | If statement of allegations clarifies a general charge, enquiry may still be valid. | Distinguished; here no detailed statement accompanied vague corruption charge. |
| Sawai Singh v. State of Rajasthan (1986) 3 SCC 454 | Charges must be clear, definite and specific even in domestic enquiries. | Relied upon to invalidate enquiry based on vague and hearsay allegations. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court examined each charge in light of evidence and departmental rules:
- Charge 1 (first-class travel): Enquiry officer never determined whether the respondent was entitled to first-class travel when no second-class reservation existed. Inquiry thus incomplete; finding unsustainable.
- Charge 2 (refusal to disburse payments): Railway circulars required presence of a gazetted officer for sums > Rs 500. Respondent’s refusal, therefore, could not be misconduct.
- Charge 3 (playing cards): Evidence merely showed playing cards during travel, not during disbursement; no breach of Rule 3 of the Railway Service Conduct Rules, 1966.
- Charges 4 & 5 (refusal to accept control messages): Partly proved. However, such conduct warranted only a minor penalty, not removal or reversion.
- Charge 6 (demand of 1 % commission): Based entirely on hearsay; no witness cited a direct demand. Charge was vague, lacking particulars of person, time or manner. Applying Surath Chandra and Sawai Singh, the Court held the enquiry on this charge violated natural justice.
The Court emphasized that disciplinary proceedings must rest on specific, proven facts—not conjecture or suspicion—and that major penalties are reserved for serious misconduct, especially corruption, proved beyond doubt.
Holding and Implications
DISPOSED OF: The Supreme Court affirmed the High Court’s decision to set aside the disciplinary punishment and minor-penalty direction. It ordered the Union of India to pay the respondent 50 % of pay and allowances (without interest) up to the date of superannuation, and arrears of retiral benefits with 9 % interest, within three months.
Implications: The decision ends over three decades of litigation, grants monetary relief to the employee, and reiterates that (1) vague or hearsay charges cannot sustain disciplinary penalties, and (2) proportionality governs punishment, with dismissal reserved for clearly proven corruption. No new legal precedent was established; the Court applied established principles to the specific facts.
Dr. B.S Chauhan, J.— This appeal has been preferred against the judgment and order of the Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court at Ahmedabad passed in Letters Patent Appeal No. 25 of 1983 by which while affirming the judgment and order of the learned Single Judge dated 27-12-1982 passed in Special Civil Application No. 101 of 1982, allowed the cross-objections filed by the respondent employee and set aside the order giving liberty to the disciplinary authority to pass a fresh order of minor punishment on two charges.
2. The facts and circumstances giving rise to this case are that the respondent employee, Gyan Chand Chattar was appointed in the Western Railways as Shroff in the Department of Pay and Cash in the scale of Rs 260-400 w.e.f 8-2-1971 vide official letter dated 8-2-1971. He was thereafter posted as cashier in the year 1977 in the pay scale of Rs 330-480.
3. The respondent was served a charge-sheet dated 8-4-1980 containing 6 charges that he travelled in the train in first class on 24-11-1979 though he was not entitled to travel in that class; refused to arrange payment of certain amount to the employees against bills dated 12-11-1979, 16-11-1979 and 21-11-1979; while on duty on 24-11-1979 travelled in first class compartment of the train, played cards with RPF Rakshaks; that on 24-11-1979 the train in which he was travelling was detained by the agitators, the railway staff who demanded payment of their pay allowance, he acted extremely irresponsibly and made no attempt to convince them about his difficulties; refused to receive “control message/memo” from the superior officer; and wanted commission of 1% for payment of pay allowance to the employees.
4. During the course of enquiry both parties led evidence, oral as well as documentary. The enquiry officer completed the enquiry and submitted his report dated 22-4-1981 to the disciplinary authority holding all six charges proved against the said respondent employee. The disciplinary authority agreeing with the findings recorded by the enquiry officer and considering the reply to the enquiry report submitted by the delinquent employee, passed the order of punishment dated 2-5-1981 removing the respondent from service.
5. The respondent's appeal against the said order was allowed partly by the statutory appellate authority Financial Adviser and Chief Accounts Officer, Western Railway, Churchgate, Bombay vide order dated 10-11-1981 reducing the punishment of removal from service to reversion of the respondent to the lower post of clerk, Grade II in the scale of Rs 260-400(R) until he was found fit by the competent authority for being considered for the cashier post in the scale of Rs 330-560 (R).
6. Being aggrieved the respondent employee challenged the order of punishment by filing Special Civil Application No. 101 of 1982 in the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad and the same was allowed vide judgment and order dated 27-12-1982 wherein the learned Single Judge after appreciating the entire evidence came to the conclusion that the only charge which could be found proved against the respondent employee was not receiving the memo of superiors as alleged in Charges 4 and 5 against him. All other charges were found unproved. Learned Single Judge issued a direction to the disciplinary authority to pass a fresh order imposing minor punishment on the said proved Charges 4 and 5 for not accepting the “memo” sent by the superiors. Being aggrieved the Union of India filed Letters Patent Appeal No. 25 of 1983 challenging the judgment and order of the learned Single Judge which has been dismissed vide judgment and order dated 1-5-2002.
7. However, the Division Bench allowed the counter-objections filed by the respondent to the extent that the direction given by the learned Single Judge to impose minor penalty on Charges 4 and 5 was also set aside. However, considering the facts and circumstances of the case, the Division Bench directed that the respondent would be entitled to get 50% of the back wages with all consequential benefits including retiral benefits. Hence, this appeal.
8. Mr S.W.A Qadri, learned counsel appearing for the appellants submitted that there was no scope of interference by the High Court in exercise of its limited powers of judicial review against the finding of facts recorded by the enquiry officer, approved by the disciplinary authority and confirmed by the appellate authority. It was a case of gross indiscipline and of corruption. Six charges against the said employee including the demand of 1% commission for making the payment of pay allowances stood proved. Punishment order passed by the appellate authority did not warrant any interference. More so there could be no justification for the Division Bench allowing the counter-objections filed by the respondent employee and quashing the direction given by the learned Single Judge to the disciplinary authority to pass an order of minor punishment on Charges 4 and 5. Therefore, the appeal deserves to be allowed.
9. On the contrary, Shri Bhargava V. Desai, learned counsel appearing for the respondent employee submitted that the High Court after appreciating the entire evidence reached the conclusion that there was no occasion for the disciplinary authority to initiate the disciplinary proceedings and there was no evidence on the basis of which any of the charges levelled against him could be held to have been proved. The High Court rightly quashed the order of punishment passed by the statutory authorities. The Division Bench of the High Court set aside the direction to the disciplinary authority to pass a fresh order of minor punishment, as a period of twenty years had elapsed and the delinquent had suffered from mental agony and harassment Therefore, the appeal is liable to be dismissed.
10. We have considered the rival submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
11. The disciplinary authority framed the following charges against the respondent employee.
“1. You have travelled in first class on 24-11-1979 by 47 DN when you are not entitled to this case.
2. You refused to arrange payment of the following amounts to the following employees against bills bearing Nos. C06 No. EBS/186 dated 12-11-1979, C06 No. EBS/40 dated 16-11-1979, PMR No. 2145 dated 21-11-1979, when the staff approached you for the said payment:
(a) Vana Anop P. Man Rs 476.65 (b) Mohan Jetha -do- Rs 211.05 (c) Kesha Bhika -do- Rs 298.00 (d) Raiji Mansukh T/S Rs 256.90 (e) Bechav Mansing -do- Rs 175.00 (f) Manoo M -do- Rs 265.75 (g) Soma Salu P. Man Rs 92.75
3. While you were on duty on 24-11-1979, in a first class compartment, Train No. 47 DN you played cards with RPF Rakshaks on duty. This was contrary to Rules 3(i), (ii) and 3(i), (iii) of the Railway Service Conduct Rules, 1966—in that you have shown absolutely lack of devotion to duty and your conduct was unbecoming of a railway servant.
4. On 24-11-1979 at about 11.00 hrs Train No. 47 DN was detained by agitators, the railway staff who demanded payment of their pay allowance covered under PMR No. 2145 dated 20-11-1979. Even after knowing about this detention, as a railway man you acted extremely irresponsibly and made no attempt to convince them about your difficulties. On the other hand you refused to receive ‘control message/memo’ from DOS leading to greater detention of the train.
5. In the background of detention of train brought out under Charge 4, Senior DAO/BRC was contacted by control and he wanted you to speak to him in control. When you were told about this and were handed over control message/memo to this effect, you refused to accept the said memo thereby showing a great sense of irresponsibility, lack of duty and a wilful disobedience of orders of your superiors.
6. It is also alleged by the staff of Chandodia Station that you refused to make payment to the staff concerned on 24-11-1979 because you wanted a commission of 1% on the arrears which the staff were unwilling to pay. Your refusal to make the payment on the said day and the consequent agitations and detention of train arose from your alleged mala fide intention of receiving commission on the arrears payment.”
The enquiry officer found all the six charges proved against the delinquent. The disciplinary authority agreed with those findings and imposed the punishment of removal from service which was modified by the appellate authority imposing the punishment of reversion to lower rank.
12. The learned Single Judge dealt with all the issues elaborately. The judgment runs to 140 pages. In order to appreciate the facts in correct perspective, it may be necessary to make reference to the findings recorded by the learned Single Judge and the grounds on which the opinion had been formed.
13. So far as Issue 1 is concerned, after appreciating the evidence, the learned Single Judge came to the conclusion that the respondent had been asked by the higher authorities to travel by Train No. 47 DN known as Viramgam Passenger for disbursing the cash as the regular disbursing cashier was ill. Thus, the respondent employee had travelled in a first class compartment. However, the said charge could not have been held proved unless a finding of fact was recorded by the enquiry officer or the disciplinary authority that he was not entitled to travel in first class compartment. Certain circulars had been referred to and relied upon by the respondent employee that for a person performing such a duty, there has to be reservation in second class compartment by the Railway Department itself; otherwise he would be entitled to travel in first class compartment.
14. As the second component of the issue i.e as to whether the respondent was entitled to travel in first class compartment or not had not been dealt with at all, the first charge could not be held to have been proved. The learned Single Judge held that as per the submissions made by the respondent employee before the department in the enquiry and in the memo of appeal that he was entitled to travel by first class compartment to facilitate safety of the cash and its transaction and nothing contrary having been proved, it was not a charge in which it could be held that the railway employee committed a misconduct warranting major punishment of removal from service or reduction in rank in such facts and circumstances.
15. The learned Single Judge reached the following conclusion:
“It must be held that so far as Charge 1 is concerned, it is not established on the record of this case in the light of the evidence led before the inquiry officer and even on the basis of the findings arrived at by him on that charge … the findings arrived at by the inquiry officer on Charge 1 do not show that all the basic requirements and ingredients of Charge 1 have been brought home to the petitioner and on the contrary, the ultimate finding on Charge 1 as arrived at by the inquiry officer is not supported by evidence on record and is totally perverse. Consequently, it must be held that Charge 1 is not legally proved against the petitioner.”
16. So far as Charge 2 is concerned, the learned Single Judge referred to the departmental circulars particularly Office Circular No. 23 of 1969 which provided that the disbursement of amount of more than Rs 500 could not be made without securing the presence of a gazetted officer to witness the payment. During the transaction, the respondent employee made his stand clear that as no gazetted officer was available at Chandodia, the disbursement was not permissible and the learned Single Judge came to the conclusion that mere error of judgment or lack of tact on the part of the employee could not make him liable to face disciplinary proceeding in such circumstances. Therefore, Charge 2 was not found to be proved.
17. Charge 3 has been dealt with elaborately by the learned Single Judge who came to the conclusion that the findings recorded by the enquiry officer that the respondent was playing cards with RPF Rakshaks while making disbursement of the amount was totally baseless as the evidence at the most could be that in the course of journey towards his destination the respondent to while away time played cards with RPF Rakshaks. That could not be a conduct unbecoming of a railway employee on duty as Rules 3(i), (ii) and (iii) of the Railway Services Conduct Rules, 1966 provided that every railway employee shall
(i) maintain absolute integrity;
(ii) maintain devotion to duty; and
(iii) do nothing which is unbecoming of a railway or government servant.
Thus, the conclusion was that there was no evidence to support the charge against him as the respondent did nothing which may fall within the mischief of either of the above clauses of Rule 3 of the Rules, 1966.
18. Charge 4 had been that the respondent employee had shown extreme irresponsibility and made no attempt to convince the agitators, the railway staff who demanded payment of their pay allowance and did not receive the control message. The learned Single Judge came to the conclusion that so far as the first part of the allegation is concerned he may be failing in being tactful but it cannot be a case of misconduct and on this count, no disciplinary proceeding could be initiated against him. However, he was found guilty of not receiving the “control message”.
19. Charge 5 was also found to be proved as the employee refused to receive the “message/memo” of his superiors.
20. So far as Charge 6 i.e asking for 1% commission for making the payment of pay allowances is concerned, the learned Single Judge has appreciated the evidence of all the witnesses examined in this regard and came to the conclusion that not a single person had deposed before the enquiry officer that the respondent employee had asked any person to pay 1% commission for making payment of their allowances. It was based on hearsay statements. All the witnesses stated that this could be the motive/reason for not making the payment.
21. Such a serious charge of corruption requires to be proved to the hilt as it brings civil and criminal consequences upon the employee concerned. He would be liable to be prosecuted and would also be liable to suffer severest penalty awardable in such cases. Therefore, such a grave charge of quasi-criminal nature was required to be proved beyond any shadow of doubt and to the hilt. It cannot be proved on mere probabilities.
22. Witnesses were examined before the enquiry officer that they have heard that the said respondent was asking but none of them was able to point out who was that person who had been asked to pay 1% commission. One of such witnesses deposed that some unknown person had told him. Learned Single Judge came to the conclusion that the knowledge of the witnesses in this regard was based on “hearsay statement of some unknown persons whom they did not know”. This was certainly not legal evidence to sustain such a serious charge of corruption against an employee.
23. Thus, the writ petition was disposed of directing the disciplinary authority to impose a minor penalty on the charges of not receiving the control message/memo. The Division Bench after considering the facts involved herein, came to the conclusion that the findings of fact recorded by the learned Single Judge did not warrant any interference being based on evidence available on record. As a long time of about two decades had elapsed and the respondent employee was not granted any benefit of the judgment and order of the learned Single Judge and it was a case of no evidence except on Charges 4 and 5 and the said employee had already suffered a lot, the matter should come to an end.
24. The Court issued the following directions:
“It would be just and reasonable to direct the appellant authorities to pay 50% of the back wages and all the consequential benefits including the retiral benefits without further imposing any minor penalty as directed by the learned Single Judge.”
25. We have considered the aforesaid findings recorded by the courts below in the light of the evidence on record. Admittedly, all the charges except Charge 2 are in respect of various incidents which occurred on the same date i.e on 24-11-1979. Charge 2 related to the incidents dated 12-11-1979, 16-11-1979 and 21-11-1979 which had been in close proximity of the subsequent incidents which occurred on 24-11-1979.
26. The enquiry officer while dealing with Charge 1 held that the respondent employee did not travel in second class compartment as admittedly there was no reservation for him in that class. The enquiry officer failed to examine the issue further as to whether in such a fact situation, the respondent was entitled to travel in first class. Thus, on Charge 1, enquiry was not complete. Thus, no finding could be recorded holding the respondent guilty of misconduct on this count.
27. On the second charge, explanation furnished by the respondent that it was not possible for him to disburse the pay and allowances in the absence of a gazetted officer as it was more than Rs 500, was worth acceptance in the light of the circulars issued by the Railways itself. Therefore, refusal to disburse the pay allowances by the delinquent could not be termed as misconduct.
28. Charge 3 was in respect of playing cards with RPF Rakshaks during disbursement of pay and allowances. The delinquent was found playing cards during the course of journey but there had been no actual disbursement of any pay and allowances to anyone at the relevant time. Therefore, the enquiry officer has not considered the issue in the correct perspective.
29. Charges 4 and 5 have partly been found proved by the learned Single Judge to the extent that he refused to accept the “control message/memo”. But for that also, major punishment could not be imposed.
30. Charge 6 was basically based on hearsay statement and it is difficult to assume as to whether enquiry could be held on such a vague charge. Charge 6 does not reveal as to who was the person who had been asked by the respondent to pay 1% commission for payment of pay allowances. It is an admitted position that if a charge of corruption is proved, no punishment other that dismissal can be awarded.
31. In Municipal Committee, Bahadurgarh v. Krishnan Behari (1996) 2 SCC 714, AIR 1996 SC 1249 this Court held as under:
“4.…In a case of such nature—indeed, in cases involving corruption—there cannot be any other punishment than dismissal. Any sympathy shown in such cases is totally uncalled for and opposed to public interest. The amount misappropriated may be small or large; it is the act of misappropriation that is relevant.”
Similar view has been reiterated by this Court in Ruston & Hornsby (I) Ltd. v. T.B Kadam (1976) 3 SCC 71, AIR 1975 SC 2025, U.P SRTC v. Basudeo Chaudhary (1997) 11 SCC 370, Janatha Bazar (South Kanara Central Coop. Wholesale Stores Ltd. v. Sahakari Noukarara Sangha (2000) 7 SCC 517, Karnataka SRTC v. B.S Hullikatti (2001) 2 SCC 574, AIR 2001 SC 930, Rajasthan SRTC v. Ghanshyam Sharma (2002) 10 SCC 330, NEKRTC v. H. Amaresh (2006) 6 SCC 187, AIR 2006 SC 2730 and U.P SRTC v. Vinod Kumar (2008) 1 SCC 115, wherein it has been held that the punishment should always be proportionate to gravity of the misconduct. However, in a case of corruption, the only punishment is dismissal from service. Therefore, the charge of corruption must always be dealt with keeping in mind that it has both civil and criminal consequences.
32. In Surath Chandra Chakrabarty v. State of W.B (1970) 3 SCC 548, AIR 1971 SC 752 this Court held that it is not permissible to hold an enquiry on a vague charge as the same does not give a clear picture to the delinquent to make an effective defence because he may not be aware as what is the allegation against him and what kind of defence he can put in rebuttal thereof. This Court observed as under:
“5. … The grounds on which it is proposed to take action have to be reduced to the form of a definite charge or charges which have to be communicated to the person charged together with a statement of the allegations on which each charge is based and any other circumstance which it is proposed to be taken into consideration in passing orders has also to be stated. This rule embodies a principle which is one of the basic contents of a reasonable or adequate opportunity for defending oneself. If a person is not told clearly and definitely what the allegations are on which the charges preferred against him are founded he cannot possibly, by projecting his own imagination, discover all the facts and circumstances that may be in the contemplation of the authorities to be established against him.”
(emphasis added)
33. In a case where the charge-sheet is accompanied with the statement of facts and the allegation may not be specific in charge-sheet but may be crystal clear from the statement of charges, in such a situation as both constitute the same document, it may not be held that as the charge was not specific, definite and clear, the enquiry stood vitiated. (Vide State of A.P v. S. Sree Rama Rao AIR 1963 SC 1723.) Thus, where a delinquent is served a charge-sheet without giving specific and definite charge and no statement of allegation is served along with the charge-sheet, the enquiry stands vitiated as having been conducted in violation of the principles of natural justice.
34. In Sawai Singh v. State of Rajasthan (1986) 3 SCC 454, AIR 1986 SC 995 this Court held that even in a domestic enquiry, the charge must be clear, definite and specific as it would be difficult for any delinquent to meet the vague charges. Evidence adduced should not be perfunctory even if the delinquent does not take the defence or make a protest against that the charges are vague, that does not save the enquiry from being vitiated for the reason that there must be fair play in action, particularly, in respect of an order involving adverse or penal consequences.
35. In view of the above, law can be summarised that an enquiry is to be conducted against any person giving strict adherence to the statutory provisions and principles of natural justice. The charges should be specific, definite and giving details of the incident which formed the basis of charges. No enquiry can be sustained on vague charges. Enquiry has to be conducted fairly, objectively and not subjectively. Finding should not be perverse or unreasonable, nor the same should be based on conjectures and surmises. There is a distinction in proof and suspicion. Every act or omission on the part of the delinquent cannot be a misconduct. The authority must record reasons for arriving at the finding of fact in the context of the statute defining the misconduct.
36. In fact, initiation of the enquiry against the respondent appears to be the outcome of anguish of superior officers as there had been an agitation by the railway staff demanding the payment of pay and allowances and they detained the train illegally and there has been too much hue and cry for several hours on the railway station. The enquiry officer has taken into consideration the non-existing material and failed to consider the relevant material and finding of all facts recorded by him cannot be sustained in the eye of the law.
37. There could be no case of substantial misdemeanour against the respondent on either of the aforesaid charges except Charge 6 on which major penalty could be imposed. Charge 6 is totally vague and no enquiry could be conducted against the respondent on such a charge. It was basically a case of no evidence on any charge except Charges 4 and 5. In fact, it was a simple case where the respondent employee failed to prove to be a tactful person or possessing a high standard of administrative capability or firmness or a man possessing quality of leadership. It might be a case of his indecisiveness or lack of presence of mind. It cannot be held that any of the aforesaid charges except Charge 6, may warrant imposition of major punishment of removal. Thus, no interference is required in the matter.
38. The Division Bench, after considering the fact that already 20 years have elapsed and the judgment of the learned Single Judge has not been complied with, considered it better to close the chapter awarding him 50% of the back wages and granted all consequential benefits including the retiral benefits. Today, the situation has become worst. About three decades have elapsed; the respondent has not been paid his pay since the date of his suspension i.e 29-11-1980, facing the disciplinary proceedings and litigation, he reached the age of superannuation long back. Thus, it is in the interest of justice that his mental agony and harassment should come to an end.
39. Therefore, we dispose of the appeal directing the present appellant to pay 50% of the pay and allowances without interest till the respondent reached the age of superannuation and arrears of retiral benefits with 9% interest to the respondent employee within a period of three months from today.
Alert