- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dhanpal Balu Lhawale And Others v. Adagouda Nemagouda Patil (Dead) By Prop. Lrs. .
Factual and Procedural Background
The dispute concerns agricultural land over which the respondent-plaintiff, Adagouda Nemagouda Patil, claimed rights. In 1972 he filed OS No. 182 of 1972 seeking (a) a declaration of tenancy and a permanent injunction, or, in the alternative, (b) title under a will dated 27-12-1971 allegedly executed by Smt Kusabai. The appellant-defendant, Dhanpal Balu Lhawale, together with his family members, contested both the tenancy claim and the authenticity of the will.
Separately, the appellant filed OS No. 310 of 1990 for a permanent injunction on the basis of his own title. Because both suits involved the same land, they were tried together. On 15-12-1994, the trial court (i) granted an injunction to the respondent in OS No. 182 of 1972 but refused declaratory relief, and (ii) dismissed OS No. 310 of 1990.
Both parties appealed: the appellant filed RA No. 18 of 1995, and the respondent filed RA No. 23 of 1995. On 7-10-1996, the first appellate court allowed the appellant’s appeal (RA 18/1995) and dismissed the respondent’s appeal (RA 23/1995). Meanwhile, the respondent’s application for occupancy rights before the Land Tribunal was rejected on 11-11-1981, and subsequent writ proceedings (WP No. 3912/2001 and WA No. 1023/2007) were also dismissed.
The respondent then filed a second appeal (RSA No. 73 of 1997). On 7-4-1999, the High Court held that the will had not been proved but nonetheless granted an injunction to the respondent, observing that, although in unlawful possession, he was entitled to protection. The appellant’s suit for injunction was dismissed. The appellant sought special leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, leading to the present proceedings. During pendency, the appellant moved an amendment application (IA No. 1) to seek, in the alternative, a direct order for possession.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a person whose claims of tenancy and title (via will) have been rejected and who is therefore a trespasser can still retain an injunction against the true owner.
- Whether, in the interest of justice, the Supreme Court should order immediate possession to the appellant rather than compel him to file a fresh suit.
- Whether the amendment to the prayer clause in the special leave petition should be allowed under Order VI Rule 17 read with Section 151 CPC.
Arguments of the Parties
Respondent’s Arguments
- The factual record correctly shows the respondent is in possession since 1959.
- Even as a trespasser, long possession entitles him to an injunction and the appellant should be required to file a separate suit for possession.
Appellant’s Arguments
- Given that every claim of the respondent has failed, the respondent’s status is only that of a trespasser, leaving no viable defence.
- Relegating the appellant to another round of litigation for possession would cause undue hardship, as the dispute has persisted since 1972.
- The amendment to seek possession should be allowed so the matter can be finally resolved.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court first allowed the amendment application, noting that the respondent’s tenancy and testamentary claims had been definitively rejected in earlier forums, rendering him a trespasser. Recognising that the respondent had exhausted all legal remedies—trial court, first appeal, second appeal, Land Tribunal, writ petition, and writ appeal—the Court concluded that further litigation would be inequitable.
Although the respondent had been in factual possession for many years, the Court emphasised that possession without title could not justify an injunction once lawful title was established in favour of the appellant. The Court accepted the appellant’s contention that continued protection of a trespasser would perpetuate injustice and unnecessary delay. Consequently, balancing equity and finality, it ordered delivery of possession directly within a specified timeframe, subject to payment of Rs 5,000 per acre and filing of an undertaking. Failure to comply would entitle the appellant to seek police assistance.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL ALLOWED; HIGH COURT JUDGMENT SET ASIDE. The respondent must hand over possession to the appellant by the end of 2010 upon the appellant paying Rs 5,000 per acre and filing an undertaking within 12 weeks. If the undertaking is not filed, the appellant may obtain police help to effect recovery. No order as to costs.
Implications: The decision ends nearly four decades of litigation between the parties and avoids further suits by granting immediate possession to the rightful owner. It does not establish new precedent but applies existing procedural discretion to achieve finality and equity in a protracted dispute.
H.S Bedi, J.— This appeal arises out of the following facts. The respondent-plaintiff Adagouda Nemagouda Patil filed OS No. 182 of 1972 for a declaration of title and permanent injunction claiming tenancy over the suit land and in the alternative, to title on the basis of a will dated 27-12-1971 alleged to have been executed by Smt Kusabai. The appellant-defendant Dhanpal Balu Lhawale, his mother, sister and wife entered appearance and resisted the suit, and challenged the execution of the will aforesaid.
2. Dhanpal Balu, the first defendant in the aforesaid suit also filed OS No. 310 of 1990 claiming the relief of permanent injunction on the basis of title. As the subject-matter in both the suits was common, they were clubbed together.
3. On an examination of the record, the trial court vide its judgment dated 15-12-1994 decreed OS No. 182 of 1972 to the extent of granting an injunction but rejected the prayer for a declaration, whereas OS No. 310 of 1990 was dismissed. Aggrieved by the judgment in OS No. 310 of 1990 Defendant 1, the appellant in the present proceedings, Dhanpal Balu preferred RA No. 18 of 1995 whereas the plaintiff Adagouda Nemagouda too being aggrieved by only the partial decretal of OS No. 182 of 1972 preferred RA No. 23 of 1995.
4. The first appellate court on a reappreciation of the evidence allowed RA No. 18 of 1995 and dismissed RA No. 23 of 1995 vide order dated 7-10-1996. It also appears that the plaintiff, Adagouda Nemagouda, had filed an application in Form VII before the Land Tribunal claiming occupancy rights and this plea too was rejected by the Tribunal on 11-11-1981.
5. It has been pointed out to us that the order of the Land Tribunal had been challenged by Adagouda by way of Writ Petition No. 3912 of 2001 which was dismissed on 7-12-2006 and the writ appeal filed against the order of the learned Single Judge, that is Writ Appeal No. 1023 of 2007 too has been dismissed by the Division Bench on 24-9-2007.
6. Aggrieved by the order of the lower appellate court dated 7-10-1996, in which Adagouda's prayer on the basis of the will had been rejected, he preferred a second appeal in the High Court. The High Court in its judgment dated 7-4-1999 while upholding that the will had not been proved, granted a decree for injunction to Adagouda but dismissed the suit for injunction filed by Dhanpal observing that even though Adagouda was in unlawful possession of the property he was nonetheless entitled to an injunction. The present special leave petition has been filed in this Court against the order dated 7-4-1999 of the High Court.
7. During the pendency of this appeal, IA No. 1 under Order 6 Rule 17 read with Section 151 CPC has been filed by the appellant seeking to amend the prayer clause in the special leave petition as originally laid. The amendment sought is reproduced below:
“In the circumstances obtaining in this case, this Hon'ble Court be pleased to set aside the judgment of the Hon'ble High Court of Karnataka in RSA No. 73 of 1997 dated 7-4-1999 by granting the relief of injunction in favour of the petitioners or in the alternative, this Hon'ble Court be pleased to grant an order directing the respondent to hand over possession of the suit schedule property to the petitioners.”
In the facts of the case, we are of the opinion that this amendment application needs to be allowed in the face of the fact that, as of today, the claim of the respondent-plaintiff Adagouda Nemagouda, on the basis of the will and in the alternative, on the basis of a tenancy has been rejected and his status is only that of a trespasser.
8. During the course of the hearing, the learned counsel for the plaintiff-respondent herein Adagouda Nemagouda, has pointed out that the facts given above are correct and the status of the respondent was that of a trespasser and though a trespasser he was entitled to an injunction as he had been in possession since the year 1959 and it was thus appropriate that the appellant be called upon to file another suit seeking possession.
9. The learned counsel for the appellant has, however, pointed out that in view of the above admitted position and the fact that there was virtually no defence left to the respondent, and in the background of the fact that the litigation inter se the parties, has been pending in one forum or the other since the year 1972, it would be a matter of great hardship if the matter was relegated to the civil court for yet another suit for possession.
10. We are of the opinion that the assertion made by the learned counsel for the appellant has merit. We find from the record that Adagouda Nemagouda has exhausted all the remedies that were or are open to him. Admittedly he has been in possession since long, but in view of the above factual statement, his status now is that of a trespasser.
11. We accordingly in the interest of justice allow this appeal, set aside the order of the High Court dated 7-4-1999 in RSA No. 73 of 1997 and in the light of the amended prayer clause direct the respondent to hand over possession to the appellant herein by the end of the year 2010, on paying a sum of Rs 5000 per acre and filing an undertaking in the above terms within 12 weeks from today. In case the undertaking is not filed, the appellant will be entitled to seek police help to recover possession.
12. The appeal is allowed in the above terms. There will, however, be no order as to costs.
Alert