Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Central Bureau Of Investigation v. V.K Bhutiani .

Supreme Court Of India
Aug 11, 2009
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) filed this appeal challenging the Delhi High Court’s order dated 20-4-2005 in Criminal Revision Petition No. 945 of 2003. In that revision petition, respondent V.K. Bhutiani—then a Senior Manager, New Bank of India—had assailed the Special Judge’s order dated 23-8-2003 framing charges against him and four co-accused.

The charges alleged that between November and December 1989 the accused conspired to defraud New Bank of India of Rs 17.20 lakhs by:

  • sanctioning and obtaining loans on the basis of forged documents and worthless securities,
  • committing offences under Sections 120-B, 420, 467, 468, 471 IPC and Section 13(2) read with Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.

The High Court relied heavily on a Central Vigilance Commission (CVC) report that found only “faulty judgment” on the part of the respondent and invoked this Court’s decision in P.S. Rajya v. State of Bihar. Dissatisfied, the CBI sought reversal of the High Court’s order before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Delhi High Court was justified in setting aside the order framing charges by relying primarily on the Central Vigilance Commission report.
  2. Whether the High Court correctly applied the precedent of P.S. Rajya v. State of Bihar (1996) 9 SCC 1 to the facts of the present case.
  3. To what extent, if any, a CVC report exonerating or partly exonerating an accused can bar criminal prosecution where the chargesheet contains material implicating the accused.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (CBI)

  • The High Court erroneously treated the CVC report as conclusive (“be all or end all”) and failed to examine the chargesheet, witness statements, and handwriting-expert reports.
  • P.S. Rajya was factually distinguishable; in that case the CVC had completely exonerated the accused, unlike the present matter where only “faulty judgment” was noted.

Respondent (V.K. Bhutiani)

  • Conceded that the CVC report did not totally exonerate him, but relied on it to seek discharge from criminal prosecution.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
P.S. Rajya v. State of Bihar (1996) 9 SCC 1 When the CVC completely exonerates an accused, prosecution may be untenable. Held inapplicable because, unlike Rajya, the CVC had not given a “clean chit” here; therefore reliance by the High Court was “totally uncalled for.”
State v. M. Krishna Mohan (2007) 14 SCC 667 CVC reports are relevant but not decisive; courts must not quash proceedings if the chargesheet contains incriminating material. Used to underscore that the High Court should not have quashed the charges merely on the basis of the CVC report.
State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335 Court’s power to quash is limited; where the chargesheet discloses material, a trial should ordinarily follow. Cited to affirm that scrutinising sufficiency of evidence for conviction at the pre-trial stage is premature.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. The Supreme Court examined the impugned High Court order and found that the High Court did not scrutinise the chargesheet, witness statements, or expert reports. Instead, it rested its decision on the CVC report and P.S. Rajya.

2. The Court compared the CVC report in this case with that in P.S. Rajya. Unlike the unequivocal exoneration in Rajya, the present report stated that the allegations were “proved” to the extent of “faulty judgment,” and therefore did not absolve the respondent of criminal liability.

3. Relying on M. Krishna Mohan and Bhajan Lal, the Court reiterated that a CVC report, while relevant, is not determinative. When the chargesheet discloses prima facie material, courts should not quash proceedings by evaluating whether conviction is likely; such an assessment is reserved for trial.

4. Consequently, the Supreme Court concluded that the High Court misapplied precedent and prematurely terminated the prosecution.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed – High Court order set aside; matter remanded for trial.

Implications: The Special Judge’s framed charges stand revived, and the trial will proceed on its merits. The decision clarifies that partial or qualified findings of the Central Vigilance Commission do not bar criminal trials, and courts must independently verify whether the chargesheet discloses material warranting prosecution. No new legal principle is created; the Court reinforces existing jurisprudence on the limited scope of judicial interference at the charge-framing stage.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. The appellant Central Bureau of Investigation has come up in this appeal against the order dated 20-4-2005 passed by the High Court of Delhi in Criminal Revision Petition No. 945 of 2003. In that revision petition, V.K Bhutiani (the respondent herein) had challenged the order on charge dated 23-8-2003 passed by the Special Judge, Delhi.

2. Those charges are as under:

“I, P.K Bhasin, Special Judge, Delhi hereby charge you V.K Bhutiani, O.P Rajvanshi, Mrs Rashmi Aggarwal, Praveen Aggarwal and Neeraj Jain as follows:
That you accused V.K Bhutiani, while being posted as a Senior Manager in New Bank of India, E-Block, Connaught Circus, New Delhi and you accused O.P Rajvanshi, Mrs Rashmi Aggarwal, Praveen Aggarwal and Neeraj Jain along with S. Mohd. Yusuf (now dead) had entered into a criminal conspiracy sometime during November and December 1989 at New Delhi for defrauding/cheating New Bank of India to the tune of Rs 17.20 lakhs by resorting to cheating, forgery of documents in the nature of valuable securities and for using those documents for getting loan facilities to the extent of Rs 17.20 lakhs in the name of M/s Vikram Enterprises, proprietorship concern of you accused O.P Rajvanshi and also by abuse and misuse of authority as a public servant you accused V.K Bhutiani and thereby you all committed offences punishable under Section 120-B r/w Sections 420/467/468/471 IPC and Section 13(2) r/w Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
Secondly, in furtherance of the aforesaid conspiracy you accused V.K Bhutiani, O.P Rajvanshi, Rashmi Aggarwal, Praveen Aggarwal and Neeraj Jain cheated New Bank of India and got released loan amount of Rs 17.20 lakhs in the name of M/s Vikram Enterprises by way of two orders dated 28-12-1989 and 26-12-1989 respectively for Rs 12.65 lakhs and Rs 2.25 lakhs in favour of M/s Hazi Gubar and S. Abdul Kareem and one pay order dated 26-12-1989 for Rs 2.30 lakhs in favour of M/s Multiple Traders and thereby you all committed an offence punishable under Section 420 IPC.
Thirdly, that in furtherance of the aforesaid conspiracy you accused O.P Rajvanshi forged one receipt dated 20-12-1989 for Rs 4,35,000 purporting to have been issued by M/s Hazi Gubar and S. Abdul Kareem in favour of M/s Vikram Enterprises and you also forged one letter dated 17-12-1989 purporting to have been written by M/s Hazi Gubar and S. Abdul Kareem to Vikram Enterprises for using the same for cheating New Bank of India by obtaining loan of Rs 17.20 lakhs and you also used these forged documents dishonestly and fraudulently and thereby you committed an offence punishable under Sections 467/468/471 IPC.
Fourthly, that in furtherance of the aforesaid conspiracy you accused Praveen Aggarwal forged one invoice dated 15-12-1989 for Rs 2.30 lakhs purporting to have been issued by M/s Multiple Traders, proprietorship concern of your co-accused Rashmi Aggarwal, in the name of Vikram Enterprises for being used for the purpose of cheating New Bank of India by obtaining loan of Rs 17.20 lakhs in the name of Vikram Enterprises, firm of your co-accused O.P Rajvanshi and you also forged a receipt of Rs 1 lakh for the same purpose purporting to have been issued by Multiple Traders in favour of M/s Vikram Enterprises and these documents were then used for cheating New Bank of India and thereby you committed an offence punishable under Sections 467/468/471 IPC.
Fifthly, that in furtherance of the aforesaid conspiracy that you accused V.K Bhutiani by corrupt or illegal means and by abusing your position as a public servant being a Senior Manager of New Bank of India sanctioned loan of Rs 17.20 lakhs for M/s Vikram Enterprises, proprietorship concerns of your co-accused O.P Rajvanshi without any public interest and thereby you committed an offence punishable under Section 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
And I hereby direct that all be tried by this court for the aforesaid offences.
Sd./-
Special Judge, Delhi
27-9-2003.”

3. The revision petition was basically on the ground that the respondent, who was a Senior Manager of New Bank of India at the relevant time, was in fact exonerated by the Central Vigilance Commission and in its report, he was found to be innocent.

4. The charges, which we have quoted above, were extremely serious and included also the charge of conspiracy with a view to defraud the Bank. In the process, it is apparent from the charge that the respondent along with other co-accused had entered into a criminal conspiracy to defraud the Bank by granting the loans which should never have been granted. The allegation is regarding the securities which have been accepted against those loans were worthless. It has also come on record that the loans were never repaid.

5. The High Court in its judgment has basically relied upon the report of the Central Vigilance Commission and also relied on the ruling of this Court in P.S Rajya v. State of Bihar (1996) 9 SCC 1.

6. We have carefully gone through the aforesaid ruling. In para 8 of the impugned order, the High Court opined as under:

“In my opinion, this judgment squarely applies in the present case. The basic factors to establish conspiracy of the petitioner were all before the Central Vigilance Commission. After taking all these factors into consideration, it found that the petitioner was not actually involved in any corrupt practice or in the conspiracy of the other accused persons intended to cheat the Bank. The discrepancy between the dates of making a prayer for loan and the recommendation for it or opening of the account were all observed to be in accordance with practice, although a haste on the part of the petitioner was proved. So far as valuation of the property offered as security is concerned, the petitioner had actually not committed any fraud. He did not overvalue the property. The Central Vigilance Commission having taken note of the fact has held that it was a case of misjudgment rather than a case of conspiracy. The Vigilance Commission also went into the question whether the petitioner was at fault in not making enough inquiries about the genuineness of the documents issued by A-3 and others and about the genuineness of the business run by A-3. Yet the Vigilance Commission has given a clean chit to the petitioner although it found the petitioner guilty to the extent of making a faulty judgment in recommending the proposal.”
(emphasis supplied)

We have deliberately quoted the above paragraph to note that the High Court did not bother to examine the chargesheet and the allegations made therein nor did it examine the statement of the witnesses and/or the reports of the handwritten (sic handwriting) experts which were the part of the chargesheet. In our opinion, the reliance of the High Court on the ruling of P.S Rajya (1996) 9 SCC 1 was totally uncalled for as the factual situation in that case was entirely different than the one prevalent here in this case.

7. We were also taken through the report of the Central Vigilance Commission. Para 7.1 of the said report reads as under:

“The allegations against Shri V.K Bhutiani are held proved only to the extent of making a faulty judgment in recommending the proposal for the PC limit as pointed out in Para 6.61 and the article of charge is held proved only to the extent as various allegations have been substantiated or otherwise as mentioned in the assessment portion of the report.”

Thus, it cannot be held that the Central Vigilance Commission had given a clean chit to the respondent-accused.

8. In para 18 of the ruling in P.S Rajya (1996) 9 SCC 1, relevant part of the report of the Vigilance Commission was quoted. Para 18 of the said judgment reads as under:

“18. It may not be out of place to extract a portion from the order exonerating the appellant from the charge framed in the departmental proceedings. It reads as follows:
‘The Commission after careful consideration of the facts and records of the case, has advised that the savings of the applicant, Shri P.S Rajya, were more than the assets acquired by him and, therefore, the charge of acquisition of assets disproportionate to income does not stand proved. A copy of the advice of the Commissioner is enclosed. The Commission has also advised that the ends of justice would be met by exonerating the charged officer, Shri P.S Rajya.
The President has given careful consideration to the facts and records of the case and advice of UPSC. The President has come to the conclusion that the advice of UPSC be accepted. It is, therefore, held that the articles of charge framed against Shri Rajya have not been proved. The President is, therefore, pleased to exonerate Shri Rajya, AIT (Retired) of the charges framed against him and drop the proceedings initiated against him.’ ”

From a mere glance of this, it will be seen that the Central Vigilance Commission had exonerated the accused therein by writing a clear-cut finding that the charge of acquisition of assets disproportionate to the income did not stand proved against the accused in that case. Such is certainly not the case here.

9. In our opinion, though the report of the Central Vigilance Commission may be a relevant factor, it cannot be held to be “be all or end all” of the matter for prosecuting the accused persons of such serious offences.

10. Mr Manoj Jain, learned Additional Solicitor General appearing on behalf of the appellant CBI very rightly argued that the High Court has treated the said report to be “be all or end all” of the matter. He submitted that the High Court was not correct in doing so. Learned counsel appearing for the respondent very candidly admitted that from the report it cannot be said that the respondent-accused in this case was totally exonerated.

11. We have deliberately quoted aforesaid Para 7.1 of the report only to show that the respondent was not totally exonerated. Thus, the reliance by the High Court on the aforementioned ruling of P.S Rajya (1996) 9 SCC 1 was uncalled for.

12. The ruling of P.S Rajya (1996) 9 SCC 1 was considered by this Court in State v. M. Krishna Mohan (2007) 14 SCC 667 wherein this Court, after elaborate discussion, found that where the fact situation was different, reliance could not be made (sic placed) altogether on the report of the Central Vigilance Commission. Relying on the ruling of State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335 this Court reiterated the position that where there could be some material found in the chargesheet, then it would not be the function of the court to examine the chargesheet with a view as to whether the accused could be convicted or not. That would be a premature exercise.

13. The judgment in M. Krishna Mohan (2007) 14 SCC 667 was against acquittal and reliance on behalf of the defence was placed on the report of the Central Vigilance Commission. In para 32 at p. 676 of the said judgment, this Court has made a clear reference that there was a clear-cut finding by the High Court to the effect:

“32. … ‘23. … We have already held that for the reasons given, on the peculiar facts of this case, the criminal proceedings initiated against the appellant cannot be pursued.’ ”

14. We do not find any such reasoning having been given in the present case by the High Court. On the other hand, a perusal of the impugned order suggests that the High Court did not examine the material available by way of chargesheet and has proceeded to follow the ruling of P.S Rajya (1996) 9 SCC 1. We are, therefore, satisfied that this appeal has to be allowed by setting aside the impugned order passed by the High Court.

15. Accordingly, the appeal succeeds. The impugned order is set aside and the matter is remanded. Now the trial court shall proceed with the trial since the charges have already been framed. All the contentions in law and fact shall be available to the respondent as well as the prosecution. This judgment shall not be treated to be an expression of opinion on our part.