- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Pragjyotish Gaonlia Bank (Now Known As Assam Gramin Vikash Bank) And Another v. Brijlal Dass .
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, a Regional Rural Bank governed by circulars issued by the National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (Nabard), re-classified 17 additional Scale I branches as Scale II branches in 1997. A circular dated 10-6-1997 announced that promotions from Officer Scale I to Scale II would be made on a merit-cum-seniority basis. Forty marks were allotted for length of service and 110 marks for workplace performance and interview. Although no statutory reservation existed for Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe (SC/ST) officers, the circular incorporated a “concession” allowing SC/ST officers who fell within the number of vacancies, and were not found unfit, to be promoted automatically.
Sixty-eight eligible officers, including Respondent 1 (Brijlal Dass), were interviewed for the 17 vacancies. Respondent 1 ranked 39th and was not selected. He and another officer filed Civil Writ Petition No. 1601 of 1998 before the Gauhati High Court challenging the circular and seeking promotion on the ground of reservation. The learned Single Judge, noting disciplinary punishment dates incorrectly, directed that Respondent 1’s promotion be considered during the next promotion exercise.
On appeal, the Division Bench (Writ Appeal No. 518 of 2002) set aside the Single Judge’s order and directed the Bank to promote Respondent 1 with effect from the date his juniors were promoted. The Bank filed the present civil appeal before the Supreme Court challenging that directive.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the “concession” for SC/ST officers in the Bank’s circular dated 10-6-1997 constitutes a reservation of posts or merely allows automatic promotion only if such officers fall within the number of available vacancies.
- Whether Respondent 1, positioned 39th in seniority, was entitled to promotion to Scale II under the circular despite not securing marks sufficient for selection.
- Whether the Division Bench erred in directing Respondent 1’s promotion without first determining his eligibility under the applicable promotion policy.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant Bank’s Arguments
- No reservation exists for promotions from Scale I to Scale II; the circular merely grants a concession permitting automatic promotion of SC/ST officers who are already within the number of vacancies.
- Respondent 1, ranked 39th, was entitled only to compete; lacking sufficient marks, he could not claim automatic promotion.
- The Division Bench misread both the circular and the factual matrix, ignoring the threshold issue of eligibility.
- Permitting promotion contrary to policy would undermine the entire promotion process and adversely affect officers already promoted.
- Candidates who participate in a selection process and fail cannot later challenge that process (relying on G.N. Nayak v. Goa University).
Respondent’s Arguments
- The circular’s language on “Reservation posts” evidences an intent to reserve posts for SC/ST candidates within the zone of consideration.
- Because no roster was maintained, at least one of the 17 vacancies should have been reserved for an SC candidate, consistent with the State Government’s 7% reservation policy.
- Even if the State statute is inapplicable, Nabard’s 1994 circular and the Bank’s own 1997 circular require that Respondent 1 be appointed against one of the vacancies.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| National Federation of SBI v. Union of India (1995) 3 SCC 532 | Explains that SC/ST “concession” allows automatic promotion only when the candidate’s seniority position falls within the actual number of vacancies; coming merely within the zone of consideration is insufficient. | The Court relied on this decision to interpret the Bank’s circular, holding that Respondent 1, placed 39th, could not claim automatic promotion. |
| G.N. Nayak v. Goa University (2002) 2 SCC 712 | A candidate who participates in a selection process and is unsuccessful cannot subsequently challenge that process. | Used to reinforce the argument that Respondent 1, having taken part in the interview and failed, was not entitled to assail the promotion procedure. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court held that the Division Bench misinterpreted the clause on “Reservation posts” within the Bank’s circular. Drawing on the precedent in National Federation of SBI, the Court clarified that the circular provided only a concession: an SC/ST officer who already figures within the number of available vacancies is exempted from further selection procedures. It did not mandate that any of the vacant posts be earmarked in advance for SC/ST candidates.
Because Respondent 1 ranked 39th, he fell outside the figure of 17 vacancies and therefore had to compete on merit like all other candidates. His failure to secure sufficient marks rendered him ineligible for promotion. Consequently, the High Court’s assumption that an SC candidate is entitled to occupy one of the vacancies irrespective of merit was erroneous.
Holding and Implications
Appeal Allowed; High Court judgments set aside.
Respondent 1 is not entitled to promotion to Officer Scale II. The decision reaffirms that concessions for SC/ST officers in promotion policies do not equate to reservation of posts unless expressly stated. While the ruling clarifies the scope of such concessions for Regional Rural Banks, it does not create a new legal standard beyond the principles already settled in National Federation of SBI.
Altamas Kabir, J.— Leave granted.
2. The appellant Bank, which is a rural bank and is governed by the circulars issued from time to time by National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (hereinafter referred to as “Nabard”), has challenged the decision of the Division Bench of the Gauhati High Court, allowing Writ Appeal No. 518 of 2002, and directing the appellant Bank to issue necessary orders for giving effect of promotion to Respondent 1, Brijlal Dass, to the officer Scale II grade from the date his juniors in the grade of officers Scale I i.e Respondents 17, 18 and 19, were promoted to the officers Scale II grade.
3. In 1997 the appellant Bank categorised 17 additional Scale I branches as additional Scale II branches. The Bank, therefore, proposed to promote 17 officers of Scale I grade to the grade of officers Scale II and issued a circular to that effect on 10-6-2007 (sic 10-6-1997).
4. As per the eligibility criteria, all officers who had put in minimum service of 8 years in the officers' cadre as on 31-12-1996, were eligible to appear for an interview for internal promotion. The total number of candidates would be restricted to four times the number of vacancies.
5. It was decided by the Bank that such promotion would be on the basis of merit-cum-seniority, and that out of a maximum of 150 marks 40 marks were set apart for the number of years in service. The remaining 110 marks were allocated towards performance at the workplace and in the interview, indicating that the selection procedure was to be on the basis of merit-cum-seniority.
6. The case of the appellant Bank is that no reservation had been provided for the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe candidates in the matter of promotion by selection from Scale I to Scale II and from Scale II to Scale III posts in Regional Rural Banks, and that candidates were generally subjected to interview/written tests. However, in order to provide some benefit to the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe candidates a concession was included in the Circular dated 10-6-1997 which was in keeping with certain conditions which had been provided by the Circular dated 9-11-1994 issued by Nabard and also certain other government circulars.
7. The said concession is set out hereinbelow:
“Reservation posts.—The Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe officers, who are senior enough in the zone of consideration for promotion so as to be within the number of vacancies for which the select list has to be drawn up would be included in the list provided they are not considered unfit for promotion.”
In terms of the said concession, officers belonging to the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, falling within the number of vacancies from the list drawn up on the basis of seniority, would be promoted to the officers Scale II grade automatically, provided they were not unfit for promotion.
8. At this stage it may be indicated that since 17 vacancies were available, 68 candidates were called for interviews for filling up the said 17 vacancies. Respondent 1 did not fall within the first 17 names in the aforesaid list but was placed at Sl. No. 39 as per his seniority. As a result, though he was called for the interview, he was not automatically selected for promotion to Scale II grade. Respondent 1 and one Shri Nagendra Chander Dass, both of whom figured in the list of 68 eligible candidates and were within the zone of consideration, were called for the interview but were not found fit for promotion.
9. They, accordingly, filed Civil Writ Petition No. 1601 of 1998 for quashing the abovementioned Circular dated 15-9-1997 issued by the Bank on the basis whereof the successful candidates have been promoted and also prayed that since both of them belong to the Scheduled Caste community they should have been appointed against the reserved posts and that the reservation policy followed by the Bank was contrary to the reservation policy followed by the Government of Assam.
10. The learned Single Judge disposed of the writ petition on 17-7-2002, without expressing any opinion with regard to Nagendra Chander Dass as he had been promoted in the month of February 2000, after he succeeded in the promotion test held on 15-2-2000 during the pendency of the writ petition.
11. While disposing of the writ petition the learned Single Judge while taking note of the fact that Respondent 1 had been punished in a disciplinary proceeding erroneously noted the dates when the punishment was imposed and when it came to an end. Instead of indicating that the punishment awarded to Respondent 1 whereby five increments had been stopped w.e.f 1992 and ending in 1997 the learned Single Judge observed that the punishment had been imposed in 1995 and it came to an end in the year 2000. The importance of the said error would be evident from the fact that whereas the punishment of Respondent 1 came to an end in March 1997, the Departmental Promotion Committee meeting was held on 15-9-1997 and on that date the learned Single Judge found that Respondent 1 was eligible for promotion since the period of punishment was already over, and directed that Respondent 1's promotion should be considered by the Bank along with other eligible candidates as and when the next promotion was considered by the authorities. This lapse on the part of the Single Judge was used to his advantage by the respondent in preferring an appeal before the Division Bench of the Gauhati High Court.
12. The Division Bench without going into the question of eligibility, apart from the aforesaid error in noting the dates relating to the punishment order of 2001 set aside the order of the Single Judge dismissing the writ petition and allowed the writ appeal with a direction to appoint Respondent 1 in the officers Scale II grade from the date his juniors in the cadre of officers Scale I had been promoted to the higher scale.
13. The Bank has filed the present appeal against the aforesaid order of the Division Bench and has in particular challenged the direction given to the Bank to promote Respondent 1 to the officers Scale II grade.
14. Appearing for the appellant Bank, Mr Dhruv Mehta submitted that the Division Bench of the High Court had decided the appeal on an erroneous understanding of the issue involved. Mr Mehta submitted that without applying its mind to the facts of the case, the Division Bench simply repeated the findings of the learned Single Judge. The Division Bench lost sight of the fact that first of all the question of eligibility for being considered for promotion had to be cleared before clearing the cases of the candidates who had been called for the interview could be taken up for consideration.
15. Mr Mehta emphasised the fact that no reservation was provided for in respect of the 17 vacancies and only a concession had been made which is reflected in the Circular dated 15-9-1997 issued by the Bank for making the promotions in the vacancies to the post of officer Scale II. The relevant portion of the Circular dated 10-6-1997 regarding reservation posts has been extracted hereinbefore and according to Mr Mehta the same was not for the purpose of reservation of posts as such, but for providing a benefit or concession to a Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe candidate in the matter of promotion subject to eligibility.
16. Mr Mehta submitted that Respondent 1 and Shri Nagendra Chander Dass were within the seniority which brought them into the zone of consideration and enabled them to appear in the interview, but on the strength of their performance they were not considered eligible to fill up any of the vacant 17 posts. Mr Mehta urged that had they been of sufficient seniority they would have been included in respect of one of the 17 vacancies which would have entailed them to be automatically included within the available number of vacancies for automatic appointment. Mr Mehta urged that this was the extent of reservation as was contemplated in the Bank's Circular dated 10-6-1997. In other words, it was not the post which was sought to be reserved but any of the available post could have been filled in by a Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe candidate if he was found eligible according to the norms. Having been placed at the 39th position in the list of candidates who were to be interviewed for the vacant 17 posts, Respondent 1 was duly interviewed but he did not clear the requisite number of marks which would have made him eligible for being automatically promoted and appointed.
17. Mr Mehta urged that this point had been completely misunderstood or overlooked by the Division Bench while allowing the writ appeal and also directing the Bank to give appointment to Respondent 1. It was submitted that the same was contrary to the policy of the appellant and, if followed could have serious consequences not only for Respondent 1 herein, but also for all those who had already been appointed against the vacancies in question.
18. Referring to a three-Judge Bench decision of this Court in National Federation of SBI v. Union of India (1995) 3 SCC 532, (1995) 29 ATC 622 Mr Mehta submitted that the provisions similar to that of the Circular dated 10-6-1997 had fallen for consideration and the same had been very lucidly explained to mean that the list of eligible candidates for consideration for filling up the vacancies is but another name for “the zone of consideration” referred to in the Circular of the Bank dated 10-6-1997, whereas those candidates who came within the preferred requisite vacancies would be automatically given the benefit of promotion without any further process of selection. In other words, if the Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe candidates, on the basis of the marks awarded came within the first 17 vacancies he would not be subjected to any further selection process but would be automatically granted promotion which would not be the case with a candidate from the general category. Respondent 1 having been placed at Sl. No. 39 was entitled to be called for interview, but Mr Mehta submitted that the said concession in the Circular dated 10-6-1997 would not apply to him since he was not within the first 17 candidates which would have entitled him to automatic selection.
19. Mr Mehta urged that the direction given by the Division Bench of the High Court was contrary to the concession contained in the Circular dated 10-6-1997 and was liable to be set aside, having regard to the fact that Regional Rural Banks were governed by the Regional Rural Banks Act, 1976, and the circulars issued by Nabard and not by the State Government. Furthermore, having once submitted to the selection process and having proved unsuccessful Respondent 1 was not entitled to challenge the selection process as was held by this Court in G.N Nayak v. Goa University (2002) 2 SCC 712.
20. On the other hand, it was urged by Mr Manish Goswami, learned advocate for the respondent, that the claim of the appellant Bank was erroneous and the matter had been considered by the Division Bench in its correct perspective and did not warrant any interference.
21. It was urged that the question of reservation had been categorically included in the Circular dated 10-6-1997 issued by the Bank in order to provide for reservation and by not following the said directions, the appellant Bank had erred in negating the claim of Respondent 1. Mr Goswami submitted that the provisions for promotion, as engrafted in the Circular dated 10-6-1997, was to benefit the candidates from the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes coming within the zone of consideration and was not confined only to candidates who came within the number of vacancies.
22. Replying to Mr Mehta's contentions, Mr Goswami submitted that the respondent was the lone Scheduled Caste candidate amongst all the candidates and since no roster was maintained and no post was reserved within the 17 vacancies available, at least one post out of the 17 vacancies should have been reserved for a Scheduled Caste candidate, in view of the fact that at least 7 per cent of the vacancies were required to be kept reserved according to the reservation policy of the State Government.
23. It was also pointed out that even if the Assam Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Reservation of Vacancies in Service and Posts) Act, 1978, was held not applicable to Regional Rural Development Banks which are governed by Nabard and the Central Government circulars, in view of the policy of reservation indicated both in the Nabard Circular dated 9-11-1994 and the Bank's Circular dated 10-6-1997, Respondent 1 was entitled to be appointed against one of the 17 vacancies.
24. Having carefully considered the submissions made on behalf of the respective parties, we are inclined to agree with Mr Mehta that the provision relating to reservation posts extracted hereinabove, contained in the Circular dated 10-6-1997, has been wrongly interpreted by the Division Bench of the High Court. The said condition is in the nature of a concession as was contemplated in the Circular dated 9-11-1994, issued by Nabard in order to give an opportunity to a Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe candidate to be automatically appointed, if he came within the number of vacancies available. It was a concession to enable such a candidate to avoid the process of selection, which all the other candidates were required to undergo.
25. The said provision has been very elaborately explained by a three-Judge Bench of this Court in National Federation of SBI v. Union of India (1995) 3 SCC 532, (1995) 29 ATC 622. As has been explained in the said judgment, the zone of consideration is the list of selected candidates chosen in order of seniority to be considered for the purpose of filling up the available vacancies and merely by coming within the zone of consideration a Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe candidate would not be entitled to automatic selection. The concession relating to reservation does not mean that any of the vacant posts were required to be kept reserved for such Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe candidate. It is only when such a candidate came within the number of vacancies that such a concession would be applicable to him/her for appointment without going through the selection process.
26. In the instant case, Respondent 1 was at Sl. No. 39 and did not, therefore, come within the number of available vacancies and, consequently, he had to compete with all the other candidates for being selected for one of the vacancies. The High Court's understanding that as a Scheduled Caste candidate, the petitioner was entitled to be considered for one of the vacancies is, therefore, erroneous since the provision relating to the aforesaid concession does not contemplate such a right in favour of a Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe candidate.
27. The appeal filed on behalf of the Bank must, therefore, succeed and is allowed. The judgments of both the learned Single Judge as well as the Division Bench of the High Court are set aside. There will, however, be no order as to costs.
Alert