Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

J.L Koul And Others v. State Of Jammu And Kashmir And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Oct 27, 2009
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants are Kashmiri Pandits who, while in Government service, were allotted residential quarters in Jammu during 1989-1990. After militant violence in the Kashmir Valley destroyed or damaged their personal homes, the State permitted them to retain those quarters even after retirement. Meanwhile, serving Government employees awaiting allotment filed Writ Petitions Nos. 139, 339 and 621 of 1995 before the Jammu & Kashmir High Court complaining that accommodation was not being made available to them. The appellants were not parties to those writ petitions.

On 24-1-1997 the learned Single Judge ordered, inter alia, immediate eviction of all persons who had ceased to be Government servants. The appellants’ continued occupation thus became vulnerable. A Letters Patent Appeal (OWP No. 50 of 1997) filed by the appellants was dismissed on 14-3-1997, though liberty was given to seek relief from the authorities. The appellants then approached the Supreme Court, which on 11-4-1997 ordered maintenance of status quo regarding possession. Over the next twelve years the Court repeatedly pressed the State to devise a rehabilitation scheme. Ultimately, a detailed affidavit dated 6-10-2009 was filed by the Chief Secretary outlining a ₹1618.40-crore “Return and Rehabilitation Package”.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellants, now retired Government employees and internally displaced persons, could be lawfully evicted from Government accommodation in Jammu pursuant to the High Court’s directions.
  2. Whether the State was under an obligation to frame and implement a concrete rehabilitation scheme before enforcing eviction against Kashmiri migrant retirees.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court traced the matter’s history from the writ petitions through the dismissal of the Letters Patent Appeal. Recognising the appellants’ status as victims of terrorism who had lost their homes, the Court issued interim orders preserving the status quo and repeatedly required the State to prepare a rehabilitation plan. Multiple opportunities were granted—orders dated 29-4-2008, 3-12-2008 and 17-9-2009 directed the State to formulate a scheme, eventually prompting a personal affidavit from the Chief Secretary.

The affidavit revealed that:

  • Out of 54 appellants, 23 had vacated Government quarters; 31 remained in occupation.
  • A comprehensive ₹1618.40-crore package covering housing assistance, transit accommodation, continuation of cash relief, education, employment and other measures had been approved by the State Cabinet on 1-10-2009.
  • Land had been identified for transit accommodations and flats were nearing completion for returning migrants.
  • An Apex Advisory Committee was constituted to oversee implementation.

Finding that the State had now framed and begun implementing a viable rehabilitation scheme—and had resources earmarked for that purpose—the Court concluded that no further coercive directions were necessary. However, to avoid hardship, it permitted the remaining 31 appellants to stay in their current quarters until they receive appropriate alternate accommodation under the scheme.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISPOSED OF.

The Court expressed a “pious hope” that the State would earnestly rehabilitate all victims of terrorism, including the appellants. Pending such rehabilitation, the 31 remaining migrant retirees are entitled to continue occupying their present Government quarters. The order affects only the parties before the Court and does not set a new legal precedent; its practical implication is to tie eviction to the actual rollout of the State’s rehabilitation package.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. This appeal has been preferred by the appellants against the judgment and order dated 14-3-1997 passed by the Division Bench of the Jammu and Kashmir High Court by which letters patent appeal (OWP No. 50 of 1997) against the judgment and order of the learned Single Judge dated 24-1-1997 passed in OWPs Nos. 139, 339 and 621 of 1995 has been dismissed.

2. The facts and circumstances giving rise to this case are that the appellants are Kashmiri Pandits and had been in employment of the State Government. They had been allotted residential accommodation at Jammu in 1989-1990 being the government servants. The houses of the appellants were either destroyed or burnt down by the militants in the Valley. The appellants were permitted to retain their respective accommodation at Jammu for safety reasons though they had retired and had no right to continue in possession of their respective accommodation and the accommodation could have been allotted to other government employees who were waiting in the queue. However, such a step was considered necessary by the State Government as the atmosphere was not congenial for the appellants to move in the Valley. More so, they had lost their respective houses.

3. The government employees, who were waiting for allotment of residential accommodation but could not get the same because the appellants were occupying the government houses, filed Writ Petitions Nos. 139, 339 and 621 of 1995 before the High Court complaining that they were not provided with the government accommodation by the State Government. None of the appellants herein had been impleaded in either of those writ petitions nor had any pleadings been taken against them. The claim of the writ petitioners had been that the Government was duty-bound to provide for residential accommodation which was not being done. Therefore, the High Court was requested to issue appropriate direction for providing them the government accommodation.

4. The learned Single Judge vide judgment and order dated 24-1-1997 allowed the writ petition and issued the following directions:

“1. That all those persons who have ceased to be government servants, for any reasons, shall be evicted from the houses allotted to them as government servants immediately, this direction shall not, however, apply to persons whose eviction has been stayed by the High Court in any proceedings.
2. Persons who are not in government service but require government accommodation, because of security reasons, should be tried to be accommodated within one complex so that their security is ensured and the State has to incur lesser amount for their security.
3. No person who is not a government servant, but is provided the government accommodation for security reasons, shall be given more than one unit of accommodation in the State of Jammu and Kashmir. Persons who are at present having government houses both at Jammu and Srinagar be asked for a choice and evicted from the other house. This shall also be done within one month.
4. The houses and the accommodation units available with the State Government shall be classified by a committee to be appointed by the Chief Secretary of the State within six months and the entitlement of a particular officer to a particular type of accommodation shall be determined by that classification. A separate queue shall be maintained for separate type of accommodation in which applications shall be considered for the type of accommodation to which the applicant will be entitled on the basis of his status and grade, which may be classified by the committee.
5. A government officer who has his own house at the place where he is stationed, shall not be entitled to government accommodation.”

5. In view of the fact that the present appellants, who were occupying the said government accommodation, were directed to be evicted from the houses allotted to them and no other accommodation was available, they preferred the letters patent appeal (OWP No. 50 of 1997) which stood dismissed vide judgment and order dated 14-3-1997. However, the High Court had given the opportunity to the appellants to approach the authorities concerned for appropriate relief.

6. Being aggrieved, the appellants approached this Court and this Court vide order dated 11-4-1997 passed the interim order to maintain status quo regarding possession of the properties. The matter had been heard on several occasions since then and this Court made an attempt to find out as to whether it could be practically possible to ask the appellants to occupy their own houses and whether it would be possible for the State to ensure protection of their person and properties as is evident from the order dated 26-8-1997.

7. During this period of 12 years this case remained pending and the Court had been insisting upon the State to frame the scheme of rehabilitation of the appellants and particularly for providing them accommodation. When the matter was heard on 29-4-2008, the State authorities were given time to prepare the rehabilitation scheme. But no steps were taken by the respondent State. This Court vide order dated 3-12-2008 directed the respondent State to frame the rehabilitation scheme within a period of six months and place it before the Court. As no material/scheme could be placed by the respondent State before this Court, this Court vide order dated 17-9-2009 directed the Chief Secretary of the State to file his personal affidavit as to what steps had been taken in pursuance of the orders passed by this Court on 29-4-2008 and 3-12-2008.

8. In pursuance of the said order, the Chief Secretary has filed the affidavit dated 6-10-2009. In the said affidavit it has been disclosed that out of 54 appellants 23 had already handed over the government accommodation to the State Department and the same had been allotted to the government employees. Only 31 migrants/retirees are presently in occupation of the government accommodation. It has further been clarified that there are 37,280 families who have been registered for the relief including the accommodation and out of them only 5000 families could be provided the accommodation in the camps. However, it had been undertaken that the Government would provide such facilities to all Kashmiri migrants till they are residing at the present places.

9. The relevant part of the affidavit reads as under:

“5. That it is further submitted that the Government formulated a package for return and rehabilitation of Kashmiri migrants which involves an outlay of Rs 1618.40 crores. This is for the first time since 1990 that the Government of India has come up with a policy for return and rehabilitation of Kashmiri migrants. The policy has been framed on the recommendations of a working group constituted by the Government of India to suggest various confidence-building measures in the J&K State.
While framing the policy various needs of the migrants have been taken into consideration, such as housing, education, revival of agriculture and horticulture land, employment, etc. The details of the package announced on 5-6-2008 are reproduced as under:
(i) Return and rehabilitation package of Kashmiri migrants.— The total package involves an outlay of Rs 1618.40 crores. The main components of the package are as under:
(a) Housing
(i) Assistance @ Rs 7.5 lakhs for fully or partially damaged house left behind by migrant.
(ii) Rs 2.00 lakhs for dilapidated/unused houses.
(iii) Rs 7.5 lakhs for purchase/construction of a house in Group Housing Societies for those who have sold their properties during the period after 1989 and before the enactment of ‘The J&K Migrant Immovable Property (Preservation, Protection and Restraint of Distress Sale) Act, 1997’ on 30-5-1997.
(b) Transit accommodation.—Construction of transit accommodation at three sites @ Rs 20.00 crores each for total of Rs 60.00 crores. Alternatively, Rs 1.00 lakh per family towards rental and incidental expenses to those families who may not be accommodated in transit accommodation.
(c) Continuation of cash relief to migrants.—Migrant families at Jammu and Delhi who are recipients of cash relief and free ration would continue to receive the same @ Rs 5000 per family per month (including rations) for a period of two years after their return to the Valley.
7. That it may be further submitted that unemployed youth were asked to convey their willingness for serving in Kashmir Valley. In response to the same, 14,074 unemployed youth have expressed their willingness in writing for serving in Kashmir Valley.
8. That it is further submitted that a form called ‘Expression of Interest’ was circulated among the migrants in order to ascertain their willingness to return to the Valley and so far 1676 families have expressed their willingness to return to the Valley and avail the concession available under the package.
9. That it is further submitted that lands at the following three sites have already been identified for construction of transit accommodation, the details whereof are as under:

(a) Land at Vessu, District Kulgam 100 kanals (b) Land at Qazigund, District Anantnag 25 kanals (c) Land at Khanpura, District Baramulla 50 kanals

10. That it may be further submitted that 200 flats are nearing completion at Sheikhpora Budgam. In addition to this, 18 flats are available at Mattan Anantnag. These flats are to be used as transit accommodation by the Kashmiri migrants who wish to return to the Valley. The migrants shall stay in the transit accommodation till they reconstruct or renovate their houses.
11. That it may be further submitted that the State Government had also constituted an Apex Advisory Committee to oversee the implementation of return and rehabilitation package for Kashmiri migrants in the month of September 2009 and immediately after the constitution of the Apex Level Committee, various suggestions were put forth in a meeting held on 23-9-2009.
12. That it may be further submitted that the State Cabinet vide its Decision No. 130/11/2009 dated 1-10-2009 has approved the package for return and rehabilitation of Kashmiri migrants to Kashmir Valley. However, with regard to implementation of the employment scheme a Committee has also been ordered to be constituted to go into the legal and other implications for making recruitments of the migrant youth against various posts before the said scheme is formally notified. The Committee has to submit its report within a period of two weeks.
13. That the State Government is keen to rehabilitate the Kashmiri migrants in the Kashmir Valley and shall provide every type of assistance for their return and rehabilitation. The process for the rehabilitation in the Valley has been initiated in June 2008 after the Government of India announced the package for their return.”

The aforesaid affidavit makes it clear that the State authorities have framed the rehabilitation scheme and for implementation of the same, it has got the resources also. In such a fact situation no further action/direction is required.

10. In view of the above affidavit/undertaking given by the State and after hearing Mrs Purnima Bhat Kak, learned counsel for the appellants and Mr Anis Suhrawardy, learned counsel for the State, we dispose of the appeal with a pious hope that the State shall take all endeavours to rehabilitate the persons who have been victim of terrorism and till the State is able to rehabilitate and provide the appropriate accommodation to 31 appellant retirees/oustees, they shall continue to possess the accommodations which are in their respective possession on this date.