- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Rajib Kumar Paul And Another v. Gurudas Mitra And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
Premises No. 4H, Panchanantala Road, Calcutta, was originally sanctioned for residential use. Without obtaining approval from the Calcutta Municipal Corporation (CMC), the owners converted substantial garage space and two upper floors to commercial use, housing businesses such as M/s Atithi (restaurant), M/s Avinandan (sweet-meats), M/s Avisar (furniture), M/s Apsara (beauty parlour) and, later, M/s Aithi Guest House.
On 29-6-1993 the owners applied to the Municipal Commissioner seeking regularisation of both the change of use and the unauthorised construction. After considering complaints and the application, the Special Officer, Building, ordered demolition of the unauthorised structure on 10-6-1994. An appeal to the Building Tribunal failed. In W.P. No. 21521(W) of 1999 the learned Single Judge upheld the demolition order but remanded the matter for fresh consideration; however, a Division Bench set aside that remand on 18-4-2001 and directed immediate enforcement of the demolition order and stoppage of unauthorised use under Section 416 of the Calcutta Municipal Corporation Act, 1980.
The owners (Civil Appeals Nos. 6831-33 of 2001) and Allahabad Bank, a tenant occupying the 1st and 2nd floors (Civil Appeals Nos. 6834-36 of 2001), then filed the present appeals.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the demolition order dated 10-6-1994 was invalid because the CMC failed to dispose of the owners’ application of 29-6-1993 for regularisation before ordering demolition.
- Whether a CMC circular dated 24-12-1998, allegedly permitting regularisation of existing trades, applied to the appellants’ unauthorised construction and change of use.
- Whether Allahabad Bank’s absence as a formal party before the Single Judge and Division Bench constituted a violation of the principles of natural justice.
Arguments of the Parties
Owners/Appellants (CAs 6831-33 of 2001)
- The Special Officer, Building, ordered demolition without first deciding the pending application dated 29-6-1993 for regularisation; hence the order was illegal.
- The CMC circular of 24-12-1998 created a new scheme permitting regularisation of trades carried on in buildings originally sanctioned for residential use, and their case should be processed under that scheme.
Allahabad Bank (CAs 6834-36 of 2001)
- The Bank was not impleaded before the learned Single Judge or the Division Bench, amounting to a denial of natural justice.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
1. Disposition of the 1993 application: After examining the demolition order of 10-6-1994, the Supreme Court found that the Special Officer, Building, had expressly noted and considered the owners’ application for regularisation. Therefore, the assertion that the order was passed without such consideration was rejected.
2. Applicability of the 24-12-1998 circular: The Court observed that the High Court had already examined the circular and ruled it inapplicable. Moreover, the circular expressly excluded cases involving unauthorised construction; the present case concerned precisely such unauthorised construction. Accordingly, the circular could not aid the appellants.
3. Natural justice claim by Allahabad Bank: The record of the Special Officer, Building, showed that an advocate had appeared on behalf of Allahabad Bank during the demolition proceedings. As the Bank was a tenant whose interests were inseparable from those of the owner, it would “sail or drown” with the owner. Consequently, there was no denial of natural justice.
The Court therefore found no merit in any of the appellants’ contentions.
Holding and Implications
All appeals dismissed; demolition order to stand; no costs.
Immediate effect: the direction of the Division Bench to carry out demolition and cease all unauthorised commercial use remains operative against the owners, tenants (including Allahabad Bank) and any other occupants. The judgment turns on application of the Calcutta Municipal Corporation Act, 1980 to undisputed unauthorised construction and does not establish a new legal precedent beyond reaffirming municipal authority to enforce demolition orders.
H.K Sema, J.— These appeals are directed against the judgment and order dated 18-4-2001 passed by the High Court of Calcutta in MATs Nos. 1746, 1626 and 1627 of 1999.
2. We have heard the parties.
3. The undisputed facts are:
Premises No. 4H, Panchanantala Road, Calcutta, was originally sanctioned as residential. It is also not disputed that the said building was subsequently converted from residential to commercial (change of land use) unauthorisedly without obtaining sanction from the appropriate authority. In the said building, the major portion of the garage space was being used as commercial and the appellants have started business like M/s Atithi (restaurant), M/s Avinandan (sweat meats), M/s Avisar (furniture) and M/s Apsara (ladies beauty parlour). It is also not disputed that the appellants have also started another business, namely, M/s Aithi Guest House during June 1990. It is alleged that the said guest house has also been misused for immoral activities. We are not concerned.
4. The aforesaid admitted facts are borne out from the application dated 29-6-1993 addressed to the Municipal Commissioner, Calcutta Municipal Corporation. In the said application, the appellants prayed for regularisation of the entire irregularity and requested to allow the change of use of the places from residential to commercial. The application dated 29-6-1993 speaks for itself. It is extracted:
Rajib Kr. Paul &
Rajdeep Kr. Paul
4H, Panchanantala Road
Calcutta 700 029.
Dated Calcutta 29-6-1993
The Municipal Commissioner
Calcutta Municipal Corporation
5, B.N Banerjee Road,
Calcutta 13
Dear Sir,
Ref.: Premises No. 4H, Panchanantala Road, Calcutta 700 020.
Sub.: Regularise the change of use from residential to commercial.
With reference to our discussion with your kind self along with the city architect at your office on 26-6-1993 at about 11 a.m you were pleased to advise us to apply before your kind self for change of use and occupation by us at the abovecited premises including photocopy and measurement to regularise the existing position.
Originally the building was sanctioned as residential, but with effect from 5-10-1989 in the major portion of the garage, space of the said building were being used as commercial as we have started some business viz. M/s Atithi (restaurant), M/s Avinandan (sweat meats), M/s Avisar (furniture) and M/s Apsara (ladies beauty parlour) for which we have already obtained certificate of enlistment (trade licence) for the year 1989-1990 on 16-10-1989; xerox copies of certificate of enlistment (trade licence) as above are enclosed hereto for your record and ready reference.
We have started another business viz. M/s Aithi Guest House during June 1990 and certificate of enlistment (trade licence) for the same was obtained for the first time on 19-6-1990 for the year 1990-1991; a xerox copy of the same is also enclosed hereto for your record and ready reference.
For regularisation of the entire irregularity on our part as stated above we also furnish herewith the actual measurement of each business place along with coloured photocopy as advised by your kind self, which also you will find enclosed hereto.
In view of the fact as stated above and under the circumstances your honour is earnestly requested to allow the change of use of the places as cited above from residential to commercial, so that we may continue the business legally in view of the CMC Act is concerned and thus make us free from hazards and encumbrances.
Thanking you in anticipation and a favourable consideration.
We remain,
Yours faithfully,
(Rajib Kr. Paul)
(Rajdeep Kr. Paul)
Encl.: 1. Plan showing the ground floor garage space and 3rd and 4th floor 2 flats converted into 4 shop rooms and guest house respectively including measurement.
2. No. coloured photo showing all above converted commercial places.
3. Xerox copies of trade licence as above.
5. The Special Officer, Building, Calcutta Municipal Corporation, after taking into account the application for regularisation and the complaint, directed to demolish the unauthorised construction by its order dated 10-6-1994. Aggrieved thereby, the appellants preferred an appeal before the Building Tribunal, which upholds the order of demolition passed by the Special Officer, Building. Aggrieved thereby, Writ Petition No. 21521(W) of 1999 was preferred. The learned Single Judge by his judgment and order dated 23-4-1999 although upheld the order of the Tribunal, remanded the case to the Tribunal for fresh consideration.
6. The Division Bench of the High Court set aside the order of the learned Single Judge and allowed the appeal. The Division Bench of the High Court further directed the corporation authority to take immediate steps in terms of the order of the Special Officer and confirmed by the Tribunal. The authority was further directed to stop unauthorised use of the building either by guest house or by the bank or any other organisation and/or firm and/or association under Section 416 of the Calcutta Municipal Corporation Act, 1980.
7. The main thrust of arguments by the learned counsel for the appellants in CAs Nos. 6831-33 of 2001 is that the appellants' application dated 29-6-1993 for regularisation of the change of use from residential to commercial, was not disposed of by the authority. However, by an order dated 10-6-1994 the Special Officer, Building, without considering and disposing of the application dated 29-6-1993 ordered the demolition of the unauthorised construction and, therefore, the order of demolition is not tenable in law.
8. We are unable to countenance with this contention of the appellants. We have been taken through the entire order of the Special Officer, Building, passed on 10-6-1994. On perusal of the aforesaid order, it emerges that the Special Officer, Building, did take note of the application filed by the appellants on 29-6-1993 and after having considered the various provisions and after hearing the parties passed the order of demolition. The consideration of the request of the appellants in CAs Nos. 6831-33 for regularisation of the unauthorised construction and unauthorised land is implicit in the order itself. Therefore, it cannot be said that the demolition order dated 10-6-1994 has been passed without considering the application dated 29-6-1993.
9. The next contention of the learned counsel for the appellants is that now a new scheme has been formulated by the Corporation on 24-12-1998 in which it has been decided that the use of the building in trades in deviation from the sanctioned use for residential purpose may be regularised in case of existing trades being carried out with CE from the CMC Act, 1980. We may point out at this stage that the same Circular dated 24-12-1998 placed before the High Court was considered by the High Court and the claim of regularisation was rejected. Apart from that, the said circular has expressly excluded the cases of unauthorised construction of any building or part thereof and the same will be guided by the relevant provisions of the CMC Act, 1980. The present is the case of unauthorised construction of building and, therefore, the aforesaid Circular dated 24-12-1998 is not applicable in the facts of the present case at hand.
Civil Appeals Nos. 6834-36 of 2001
10. These appeals have been preferred by Allahabad Bank. Learned counsel for the appellant strenuously urged that the appellant was not a party before the Single Judge and the Division Bench, and, therefore, there was a clear violation of principles of natural justice. This contention is belied by the fact. In the order dated 10-6-1994 passed by the Special Officer, Building, it is clearly recorded that one Ashok Roy, Advocate, appeared on behalf of Allahabad Bank, a tenant in respect of the 1st and 2nd floor of the premises in question. It is also admitted by the counsel for the appellant that Allahabad Bank is functioning on the 1st and 2nd floor of the premises. Undisputedly, the appellant Bank is a tenant of the owner of the house. The Bank has to sail or drown with the owner of the house. When the entire building of four floors is ordered to be demolished, the 1st and 2nd floors alone cannot survive. Therefore, there is no substance in the contention of the appellant Bank.
11. For the reasons aforestated, all these appeals are devoid of merits, and are, accordingly dismissed. No costs.
Alert