Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Subodh Kumar Jaiswal And Others v. Union Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Mar 5, 2008
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondent 4 (Gulabrao Dharmu Pol/Suresh A. Kakkar) was appointed on 18-4-1979 as a trainee Deputy Superintendent of Police (Dy. SP) in the State of Maharashtra, subject to successful completion of training and tests. After meeting these conditions he began officiating as Dy. SP/ACP on 3-8-1981 and was confirmed w.e.f. 31-12-1987. On 8-3-1991 he, along with seven others, was promoted to the Indian Police Service (IPS) and allotted the year 1987, making him junior to the appellants—direct recruits of 1985.

In 1994–1995 Respondent 4 first represented that he should have been considered for promotion against the 1988 vacancies and sought the allotment year 1984. OA No. 807/1996 before the Central Administrative Tribunal was dismissed as time-barred; review was also rejected. Respondent 4’s writ petition in the Bombay High Court succeeded: the court condoned the delay, set aside the Tribunal’s orders and directed that his seniority be fixed by treating him as entitled to promotion against 1988 vacancies. A contempt petition compelled the Union of India to alter his allotment year to 1984, thereby placing him above the appellants, who had not been parties before the High Court.

The appellants obtained leave and filed the present special leave petitions, challenging the High Court’s decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Bombay High Court erred in condoning an unexplained six-year delay and allowing a stale claim relating to the 1988 promotion vacancies.
  2. Whether the High Court’s directions—first fixing 1987 as the year of allotment and simultaneously declaring Respondent 4 “entitled to be promoted” for 1988 vacancies—were internally inconsistent and legally sustainable.
  3. Whether failure to implead directly affected IPS officers (the appellants) vitiated the High Court proceedings and order.
  4. What procedure the Central Government must follow for determining year-wise seniority lists and eligibility when selections for certain years were not held.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • Their rights were directly affected, yet they were not impleaded before the High Court.
  • Respondent 4’s claim was first raised only in 1994, rendering the OA hopelessly barred by limitation; the High Court lacked grounds to condone such delay.
  • The High Court exceeded its jurisdiction in ordering that Respondent 4 be treated as entitled to promotion for 1988 vacancies without a proper selection process.
  • Had the appellants been heard, they could have demonstrated factual and legal errors in Respondent 4’s claim.

Respondent 4’s Arguments

  • No direct relief was sought against the appellants; hence their presence was unnecessary.
  • Upon discovering that he had been bypassed, he promptly represented to the authorities.
  • The Union of India’s own stand indicated that separate selection lists should have been prepared for each relevant year, which was not done owing to the Tribunal’s and High Court’s earlier orders.
  • The writ petition concerned both eligibility for 1988 vacancies and consequent seniority; the High Court’s relief was therefore appropriate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Union of India v. Vipinchandra Hiralal Shah (1996) 6 SCC 721 Guidance on determining IPS allotment year and seniority when promotion is delayed. Quoted by the High Court to justify granting Respondent 4 an earlier allotment year; the Supreme Court noted but did not rely on it.
Devendra Narayan Singh v. State of Bihar (1996) 11 SCC 342; AIR 1997 SC 595 Principle that eligible officers must be considered for promotion vacancies of the relevant year. Invoked by the High Court to support its direction that Respondent 4 be considered for 1988 vacancies; the Supreme Court found the High Court’s reliance produced inconsistent directions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court identified internal inconsistencies in the High Court’s order: it simultaneously treated 1987 as the allotment year while declaring Respondent 4 “entitled to be promoted” in 1988, effectively predetermining the selection outcome. The Court emphasised that IPS recruitment occurs via separate channels—promotion and direct recruitment—and that proper procedure requires the Central Government to prepare year-wise eligibility lists. By directing a specific seniority outcome, the High Court had bypassed this statutory scheme.

The Court also noted the absence of any satisfactory explanation for Respondent 4’s prolonged delay in approaching the Tribunal; the Tribunal’s dismissal on grounds of limitation had been overridden without adequate reasoning. Furthermore, the High Court’s directions caused administrative complications by compelling re-fixation of seniority without hearing affected officers.

Accordingly, the Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s judgment as “clearly inconsistent” and remitted the matter to the Central Government with directions to:

  • Prepare year-wise lists for the relevant years;
  • Determine Respondent 4’s eligibility for the 1988 vacancies strictly in accordance with the applicable regulations;
  • Complete the exercise within two months, uninfluenced by observations of either the High Court or the present judgment.

The Court preserved any appointments already made pursuant to its interim order dated 17-9-2007, pending the fresh decision.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeals are allowed; the Bombay High Court’s order is set aside. The Central Government must re-determine Respondent 4’s eligibility and seniority by preparing year-wise lists within two months.

Implications: The decision restores the procedural framework for IPS promotions, ensuring that seniority disputes are resolved through statutory mechanisms rather than judicial directions that predetermine outcomes. Immediate impact is confined to the parties, with existing appointments protected temporarily; no new legal precedent is created beyond reaffirming adherence to the promotion regulations and limitation principles.

Show all summary ...

Dr. Arijit Pasayat, J.— Leave granted.

2. Challenge in these appeals is to the order passed by a Division Bench of the Bombay High Court allowing the writ petitions filed by Gulabrao Dharmu Pol, Respondent 4 in appeal relating to SLP (C) No. 12364 of 2006 and Mr Suresh A. Kakkar, Respondent 4 in appeal relating to SLP (C) No. 1178 of 2007.

3. A brief reference to the factual position would suffice. The position as obtaining in the appeal relating to SLP (C) No. 12364 of 2006 is noted as the factual scenario is common to both the appeals.

4. On 18-4-1979, Respondent 4 was appointed as trainee Deputy Superintendent of Police by the Government of Maharashtra subject to completion of training, practical training and passing of tests in certain subjects. According to the appellants, only if these conditions are fulfilled, he was to be appointed on regular basis to a cadre post in the cadre of Dy. SP/ACP. In other words, it is stated that on completion of the probation satisfactorily, Respondent 4 was appointed to the cadre post and started officiating as Dy. SP/ACP on regular basis w.e.f 3-8-1981 in terms of the Home Department, Government of Maharashtra Order dated 1-2-1982. The appellants were directly recruited to the Indian Police Service (in short “IPS”) and allocated to the State of Maharashtra with the allotment year as 1985.

5. By Order dated 13-4-1989, Respondent 4 was confirmed as DSP w.e.f 31-12-1987. According to the appellants, there was no challenge to the delay, if any, in his confirmation. On 3-8-1989, in terms of the third proviso to Regulation 5(2) of the applicable regulations i.e the Indian Police Service (Appointment by Promotion) Regulations, 1955 (in short “the Regulations”) he became eligible for consideration for promotion to IPS on completion of eight years of continuous service in the post of DSP in the State cadre.

6. On 26-2-1990, the Selection Committee met and considered the candidates who were substantive Dy. SPs who were eligible as on 1-1-1990 including Respondent 4. On 8-3-1991, Respondent 4 was promoted to IPS along with seven others, including Shri S.A Khopde. They all became juniors to the appellants who were appointed at least six years earlier. Respondent 4 did not press his claim for consideration for promotion in the year 1988 itself. On 9-2-1993, he and other promotees of his batch were confirmed in IPS w.e.f 8-3-1992. They were given 1987 as the year of allotment in IPS.

7. On 27-7-1994, a representation was made by Respondent 4 to treat 1984 as the year of allotment by treating him as having been appointed in the year 1988 itself. Subsequently, another representation was made in January 1995. OA No. 807 of 1996 was filed before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Mumbai Bench (in short “the Tribunal”) praying for appropriate year of allotment in IPS on the ground that though he was eligible, he was not considered for the vacancies of 1988. The Union of India and the Union Public Service Commission (in short “UPSC”) resisted the claim of Respondent 4. The Tribunal dismissed the OA inter alia holding that the OA was barred by time and suffered from delay and laches as Respondent 4 made a representation for the first time on 27-7-1994, much after his alleged claim for the year of allotment being 1988. It was held that if his claims were to be allowed, it would unsettle the settled position for about eight years. The review petition filed by Respondent 4 was also dismissed.

8. A writ petition was filed by Respondent 4 challenging the judgments of the Tribunal. The same was allowed by condoning the delay in approaching the Tribunal and it was directed that the official respondents were to re-determine his year of allotment as 1987 (which was later corrected to be 1988). It was also held that if Respondent 4 was eligible for being considered for the vacancies in 1988, his seniority shall be determined treating him as entitled to be promoted in the year 1988 and his year of allotment should be determined accordingly.

9. A contempt petition (CP No. 10 of 2006) was filed by Respondent 4 and the Union of India implemented the judgment of the High Court without preparing any seniority list for the year 1988 by changing his year of allotment from 1987 to 1984 and placing him above the appellants who were direct recruits of the year 1985. This was done under threat of contempt. The High Court disposed of the contempt petition as not pressed since the judgment had been complied with. As the appellants were not parties before the High Court, after obtaining permission to file SLP, the special leave petitions were filed.

10. Mr P.P Rao, learned Senior Counsel for the appellants, primarily challenged the judgment of the High Court on the ground that the appellants who would be directly affected by the order of the High Court were not parties before the High Court. In any event, there was not even an application for condonation of delay in moving the Tribunal. A stale claim purportedly relating to 1988 was raised for the first time in 1994. The High Court could not have directed that the official respondents were to determine the seniority of Respondent 4 treating his year of allotment as 1988 and he was entitled to be promoted in the vacancies occurring in the year 1988. It was further submitted that had the appellants been impleaded as parties, they could have pointed out the fallacy in the claim of Respondent 4 and as to how he was not entitled to be considered for promotion.

11. Learned counsel for Respondent 4, however, submitted that no direct relief was claimed against the appellants and, therefore, there was no need to implead them as parties. Additionally, it is submitted that when Respondent 4 noticed that his claim has been bypassed without any legitimate reason, he made the representation. From the stand of the Union of India, it appears that the proper course was to prepare three separate lists, which is the normal procedure, for the years in question if for any year the selection was not held. But that apparently was not done in view of the High Court's direction. The writ petition before the High Court related to both eligibility and promotion.

12. As has been pointed out by learned counsel for the appellants, there are two channels for appointment to IPS, one is by promotion from the service candidates and the other is by direct recruitment. The direction of the High Court is somewhat confusing. The same reads as follows:

“13. Under the aforesaid facts and circumstances, especially in the light of the above two Supreme Court judgments, in Union of India v. Vipinchandra Hiralal Shah (1996) 6 SCC 721 and Devendra Narayan Singh v. State of Bihar (1996) 11 SCC 342, AIR 1997 SC 595, we set aside both the aforesaid orders of the Central Administrative Tribunal and we hold that in the case of the petitioner, the year of allotment would be 1987 and he is eligible for being considered for promotion in the vacancies occurring in the year 1988. Our view that in the case of the petitioner, the year of allotment would be 1987 is reiterated by the Government of India's communication to the petitioner dated 26-5-1994. In the light of the above, the respondents shall determine the petitioner's seniority treating his year of allotment as 1987 and that the petitioner was entitled to be promoted in the vacancies occurring in the year 1988 itself. Rule is accordingly made absolute with costs.”

Subsequently, para 13 was corrected to read as follows:

“Now the corrected para 13 in our aforesaid judgment and order will read as under:
‘13. Under the aforesaid facts and circumstances, especially in the light of the above two Supreme Court judgments, in Union of India v. Vipinchandra Hiralal Shah (1996) 6 SCC 721 and Devendra Narayan Singh v. State of Bihar (1996) 11 SCC 342, AIR 1997 SC 595 we set aside both the aforesaid orders of the Central Administrative Tribunal and we hold that in the case of the petitioner, he is eligible for being considered for promotion in the vacancies occurring in the year 1988. In the light of the above, the respondents shall determine the petitioner's seniority treating the petitioner as entitled to be promoted in the vacancies occurring in the year 1988 itself and his year of allotment/seniority should be determined accordingly. Rule is accordingly made absolute with costs.’ ”

13. Somewhat inconsistent directions were given; first was to consider the year of allotment to be 1987 and consider Respondent 4's case. Subsequent part was the conclusion that Respondent 4 was entitled to promotion. It is pointed out by learned counsel for the Union of India and the State of Maharashtra that if all eligible persons are to be impleaded, that would be impossible because it is not known how many persons all over the country would be affected. We find that nobody else has moved this Court. Therefore, that question may not strictly arise for consideration in the present case. Additionally, as rightly contended by learned counsel for the appellants, there was practically no explanation for the belated approach to the Tribunal, and the normal procedure of preparing year wise seniority list was given a go-by because of the High Court's direction.

14. Be that as it may, in our view, the judgment of the High Court is clearly inconsistent and is set aside. We direct the Central Government to draw up year wise lists for the years concerned, determine the eligibility of Respondent 4 and take a decision in that regard within a period of two months from today. Needless to say that the Central Government, while undertaking the exercise, shall not be influenced by any observations made by the High Court or by us in the present judgment. It shall be open to the parties, if any or all of them affected by the decision, to avail such remedies as are available in law. We express no opinion in that regard.

15. By order dated 17-9-2007, a Bench of this Court passed the following order:

“The Government would be entitled to fill in the vacancies subject to the result of the special leave petition.”

16. If any action has been taken pursuant to the said order, it shall continue to be operative until fresh decision is taken by the Central Government. It needs no reiteration that by giving this protection, we have not expressed any opinion on the merits of the case.

17. The appeals are accordingly disposed of without any order as to costs.