- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Oma Ram v. State Of Rajasthan And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
Several writ petitions were filed before the Rajasthan High Court (Jaipur Bench and Jodhpur Bench) challenging the constitutional validity of recent amendments to the Rajasthan Excise Act, 1950. The petitioners sought to strike down:
- Section 54-A and sub-sections (4)–(9) of Section 69, which empower excise authorities to confiscate vehicles and bar other fora from ordering their release, and
- Section 9-B, which bars civil-court jurisdiction over certain excise matters.
The High Court dismissed all petitions, following its earlier view in seventy-five similar matters. The aggrieved parties appealed to the Supreme Court, invoking Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution and reiterating their challenge to the vires of the impugned provisions.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Sections 54-A and 69(4)–(9) of the Rajasthan Excise Act, 1950 are ultra vires the Constitution for being:
- Contrary to Article 254 and enacted without Presidential assent,
- Repugnant to the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 and the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908,
- In violation of Articles 14, 19, 20, 21 and 301 by conferring unguided and arbitrary powers on excise authorities and curtailing judicial review.
- Whether Section 9-B, which bars civil-court jurisdiction, is constitutionally valid.
- Whether the State Legislature had competence under List II (Entries 8, 64 and 65) of the Seventh Schedule to enact the impugned amendments.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants’ Arguments
- The amendments are void under Article 254 as they were enacted without Presidential assent and conflict with central laws (CrPC and CPC).
- Sections 54-A and 69(6) unconstitutionally oust the jurisdiction of criminal courts under Sections 451–457 CrPC and the revisionary/inherent powers of higher courts.
- The provisions grant unguided and excessive powers to excise officials, violate Articles 14, 19, 20, 21 and 301, and eliminate meaningful judicial review.
State’s Arguments
- The legislation squarely falls within the State’s exclusive competence under Entries 8, 64 and 65 of List II.
- The Act is a special statute regulating production, transfer, storage and sale of liquor; any incidental overlap with CrPC/CPC does not render it unconstitutional.
- Sections 4, 5 and 9 CrPC and Section 41 IPC permit special legislation that modifies general procedural laws.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| P.N. Krishna Lal v. Govt. of Kerala, 1995 Supp (2) SCC 187 | State competence under Entries 8, 64, 65 (List II); President’s assent under Article 254(2) cures incidental repugnancy. | Court relied on this case as a “complete answer” to the Article 254 and legislative-competence objections raised by appellants. |
| State of Karnataka v. K. Krishnan, (2000) 7 SCC 80 | Strict compliance with confiscation provisions; courts should be slow to release seized conveyances used in statutory offences. | Used to reinforce that the confiscatory scheme in Section 69 is valid and should be zealously applied. |
| Shambhu Dayal Agarwala v. State of W.B., (1990) 3 SCC 549 | Collector’s limited power to release seized essential commodities; bar of jurisdiction under Section 6-E of the Essential Commodities Act. | Analogised to justify similar bar of jurisdiction in Section 69(6) of the Excise Act. |
| Jilubhai Nanbhai Khachar v. State of Gujarat, 1995 Supp (1) SCC 596 | Regulatory measures founded on police power do not offend Article 300-A; Article 301 not violated by reasonable regulation. | Cited to dismiss the Article 301 freedom-of-trade challenge. |
| Dy. Commr., Dakshina Kannada Dist. v. Rudolph Fernandes, (2000) 3 SCC 306 | General approval of statutory confiscation mechanisms in comparable State Acts. | Referenced while “gauging the validity” of the impugned provisions. |
| State of W.B. v. Sujit Kumar Rana, (2004) 4 SCC 129 | Similar support for statutory confiscation and jurisdiction-bar clauses. | Cited in the same evaluative context as Rudolph Fernandes. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court noted that the Rajasthan Excise (Amendment) Act, 2000 received the Governor’s assent and deals with matters squarely within the State List. Relying heavily on P.N. Krishna Lal, the Court held that:
- The amendments form an integrated regulatory scheme for preventing unauthorised transport of excisable articles. In their “pith and substance” they relate to intoxicants (Entry 8) and ancillary matters (Entries 64, 65), placing them within State competence.
- Even assuming incidental overlap with CrPC or CPC (Concurrent List), Presidential assent under Article 254(2) cures any repugnancy; therefore, Sections 54-A, 69(4)–(9) and 9-B are not void.
- The bar of jurisdiction in Section 69(6) is analogous to Section 6-E of the Essential Commodities Act, validated in prior precedent. Consequently, ousting criminal-court jurisdiction over seized conveyances is constitutionally permissible.
- The confiscation provisions are regulatory, not confiscatory without due process. Adequate safeguards—notice, hearing, and appellate review to the Divisional Commissioner—are embedded, satisfying Articles 14 and 21.
- Because the provisions operate under the State’s police power, they do not offend Article 301’s freedom of trade; reliance was placed on Jilubhai Nanbhai Khachar.
- Parallels with similar excise statutes in other States further supported the view that such legislative techniques are customary and valid.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED. The Supreme Court affirmed the High Court’s decision and upheld the validity of Sections 54-A, 69(4)–(9) and 9-B of the Rajasthan Excise Act, 1950.
Implications: The Rajasthan Excise Department retains exclusive authority to confiscate conveyances used in excise offences and civil or criminal courts cannot order their release. The decision maintains the regulatory framework without creating a new constitutional doctrine, but it reinforces the legitimacy of similar confiscation and jurisdiction-bar provisions in State excise legislation.
Dr. Arijit Pasayat, J.— In all these appeals challenge is to the judgment of the Rajasthan High Court at Jodhpur dismissing the writ petitions filed under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India. Challenge in the writ petitions was to the vires of certain provision of the Rajasthan Excise Act, 1950 (in short “the Act”). Essentially the prayers were as follows:
“(a) by an appropriate writ, order or direction, incorporation of Section 54-A and sub-sections (4) to (9) in Section 69 of the Excise Act may be declared ultra vires and be struck down;
(b) by an appropriate writ, order or direction, amendment in the Excise Act, 1950 by incorporation of Section 9-B may be declared ultra vires and be struck down;
(c) by a further appropriate writ, order or direction impugned order dated 16-5-2000 passed by Respondent 2 may be declared invalid and may be quashed and set aside;
(d) pending decision, if any further order is made or action is taken prejudicial to the interest of the petitioner, the same may also be quashed and set aside.”
2. The contentions raised on behalf of the appellant in the writ petitions challenging the vires of the provisions were founded on the following allegations:
1. The provisions of the amendment are contrary to Article 254 of the Constitution and without the assent of the President those are ultra vires;
2. The amended provisions are repugnant to the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure and the Code of Civil Procedure;
3. The amended provisions confer unguided powers on the Excise Authorities;
4. By Section 9-B the remedy of judicial review is taken away and the petitioner is remediless.”
3. The respondent State prayed for dismissal of the writ petitions on the ground that the Act was within the legislative competence of the State Government under Item 8 read with Items 64 and 65 of List II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution and is a special Act dealing with right of the State to regulate production, transfer, storage, possession and sale of liquor or intoxicating drugs.
4. The High Court noted that seventy-five similar petitions were filed before the Jaipur Bench raising similar contentions.
5. Following the view of the Jaipur Bench the writ petitions were dismissed by the impugned judgment.
6. In support of the appeals, it was submitted that as per the provisions of Sections 451 to 457 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (in short “CrPC”), the criminal court has jurisdiction to release any property seized or recovered during any enquiry or trial. By the insertion of Section 54-A of the Rajasthan Excise Amendment Ordinance, 2000 which was later on substituted by the Amendment Act along with Section 54-A, Section 69 has also been amended and as per the amended sub-section (6) of Section 69 it has been provided that whenever any means of conveyance is seized in connection with commission of offence under the Act, the Excise Commissioner or any officer authorised in this behalf by the State Government shall have and notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time being in force, any court, tribunal or other authority shall not have jurisdiction to make order with regard to the possession, delivery, disposal or release of such conveyance. Grievance was that in view of the aforesaid provisions the criminal courts were not invoking jurisdiction and the power of the court has been taken away. Challenge to Section 54-A and Section 69(6) was made on the ground that they are unconstitutional, arbitrary, unreasonable and violative of Articles 14, 19, 20, 21 and 301 of the Constitution. It was submitted that the powers conferred on judicial courts by virtue of Sections 451 to 457 CrPC has been curtailed or has been taken away and indirectly the power of revision of the Sessions Judge or the High Court and inherent power of the High Court under Section 482 CrPC has been curtailed.
7. In response, learned counsel for the State made the reference to Sections 4, 5 and 9 CrPC and Section 41 of the Penal Code, 1860 (in short “IPC”).
8. The Statement of Objects and Reasons of the Rajasthan Excise (Amendment) Act, 2000 need to be noted. The same is as follows:
“Statement of Objects and Reasons.—The incidence of unauthorised transportation of excisable articles had increased in recent past and it was noticed that owners of such vehicles were indulging in these activities with impunity. It was also noticed that the vehicles indulging in such transportation even after seizure for commission of the offence were got released from courts and were again used for unauthorised transportation of excisable articles. To check this menace, it was considered necessary to provide that if any means of conveyance is used in commission of offence under the Rajasthan Excise Act, 1950, then the same shall be liable to be confiscated by order of the Excise Commissioner or the officer, not below the rank of District Excise Officer as may be authorised by the State Government in this behalf and the owner of such a means of conveyance shall be deemed to be guilty of offence for the commission of which, the said means of conveyance was used. For achieving these purposes, Section 69 of the Rajasthan Excise Act was proposed to be suitably amended and a new Section 54-A was proposed to be inserted.”
9. The amended Section 54 reads as follows:
“54. Penalty for unlawful import, export, transport, manufacture, possession, etc.—Whoever, in contravention of this Act or of any rule or order made or of any licence, permit or pass granted, thereunder—
(a) imports, exports, transports, manufactures, collects, sells or possesses any excisable article; or
(b) cultivates any hemp plant (Cannabis Sativa); or
(c) constructs or works any distillery, pot still or brewery; or
(d) uses, keeps or has in his possession any materials, stills, utensil, implements or apparatus whatsoever for the purpose of manufacturing any excisable article other than tari; or removes any excisable articles from any distillery, pot still, brewery or warehouse established or licensed under this Act; or
(e) bottles any liquor for the purposes of sale; or
(f) taps or draws tari from any tari producing tree;
shall be punishable with imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years and with fine which may extend to two thousand rupees.”
10. Sections 54-A and 69 read as follows:
“54-A. Owner of animal, cart, vessel, raft, motor vehicle or any other means of conveyance deemed to be guilty in certain cases.—Where any animal, cart, vessel, raft, motor vehicle or any other means of conveyance is used in the commission of an offence under this Act, and is liable to confiscation, the owner thereof, except in case of a motor vehicle or other means of conveyance being owned by the Central Government or any State Government or any of their undertaking, shall be deemed to be guilty of such offence and such owner shall be liable to be proceeded against and punished accordingly unless he satisfies the court that he had no reason to believe that such offence was being or likely to be committed and he had exercised due care in the prevention of the commission of such an offence.
69. What things are liable to confiscation.—(1) Whenever an offence punishable under this Act has been committed—
(a) every excisable article in respect of which such offence has been committed,
(b) every still, utensil, implement or apparatus and all materials by means of which such offence has been committed,
(c) every excisable article lawfully imported, transported, manufactured held in possession or sold along with or in addition to any excisable article liable to confiscation under Clause (a),
(d) every receptacle, package or covering in which any article as aforesaid or any materials, still, utensil, implement or apparatus is or are found together with the other contents (if any) of such receptacle or package, and
(e) every animal cart, vessel, raft or other conveyance used in carrying such receptacle or package, shall be liable to confiscation.
(2) When in the trial of any offence punishable under this Act the Magistrate decides that anything is liable to confiscation under Clauses (a) to (d) of sub-section (1) he may order confiscation:
Provided that in case of a thing other than an excisable article he may, in lieu of ordering confiscation, give the owner of the thing liable to be confiscated an option to pay any such fine as the Magistrate thinks fit.
(3) When anything mentioned in sub-section (1) is found in circumstances which afford reason to believe that an offence under this Act has been committed in respect or by means thereof, or when such an offence has been committed and the offender is not known or cannot be found, the Excise Commissioner may order confiscation of the same:
Provided that no such order shall be made until the expiration of one month from the date of seizing the thing or animal in question or without hearing the person (if any) claiming any right thereto, and the evidence (if any) which he produces in support of the claim:
Provided further that if the thing in question is liable to speedy and natural decay, or if the Excise Commissioner is of opinion that the sale of the thing or animal in question would be for the benefit of its owner, he may at any time direct it to be sold; and the provisions of this section shall, so far as may be, apply to the net proceeds of such sale.
(4) Where any means of conveyance referred to in Clause (e) of sub-section (1) is seized in connection with the commission of any offence under this Act, a report of such seizure shall, without unreasonable delay, be made by the person seizing it to the Excise Commissioner or to the officer, not below the rank of the District Excise Officer, as may be duly authorised by the State Government in this behalf and whether or not a prosecution is instituted for commission of such an offence, the Excise Commissioner or the officer authorised in this behalf by the State Government, having jurisdiction over the area where the said means of conveyance was seized, may, if satisfied that the said means of conveyance was used for commission of offence under this Act, order confiscation of the said means of conveyance:
Provided that before ordering confiscation of the said means of conveyance a reasonable opportunity of being heard shall be afforded to the owner of the said means of conveyance and if such owner satisfies the Excise Commissioner or the officer authorised by the State Government in this behalf that he had no reason to believe that such offence was being or likely to be committed and he had exercised due care in the prevention of the commission of such an offence, the Excise Commissioner or the officer authorised by the State Government in this behalf, may not confiscate the said means of conveyance:
Provided further that where such means of conveyance is owned by the Central Government or any State Government or any of their undertaking, no order of confiscation of such means of conveyance shall be passed by the Excise Commissioner or the officer authorised by the State Government in this behalf and the matter shall be referred to the State Government by the Excise Commissioner or the officer authorised by the State Government in this behalf, for making such orders regarding means of conveyance as the State Government may deem fit:
Provided also that before ordering confiscation under this sub-section the owner of the means of conveyance, referred to in Clause (e) of sub-section (1), may be given an option to pay in lieu of confiscation, a fine not exceeding the market price of such means of conveyance.
(5) Any person aggrieved by an order of confiscation made under sub-section (4), may within sixty days from the date of communication to him of such order, appeal to the Divisional Commissioner and the Divisional Commissioner after giving opportunity to the appellant to be heard, shall pass such order as it may think fit, confirming, modifying or annulling the order appealed against.
(6) Whenever any means of conveyance as referred to in Clause (e) of sub-section (1) is seized in connection with commission of an offence under this Act, the Excise Commissioner or any officer authorised in this behalf by the State Government shall have, and, notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time being in force any court, tribunal or other authority shall not have jurisdiction to make order with regard to the possession, delivery, disposal, release of such means of conveyance.
(7) Where the Excise Commissioner or the officer authorised by the State Government in this behalf is of the opinion that it is expedient in public interest or for the benefit of its owner that the means of conveyance, as referred to in Clause (e) of sub-section (1), seized for commission of offence under this Act be sold by public auction, he may at any time direct it to be sold.
(8) Where any means of conveyance is sold, as aforesaid, the sale proceeds thereof, after deduction of the expenses of such sale or auction or other incidental expenses relating thereto and in other cases, the means of conveyance which was seized or the amount of fine paid in lieu of its confiscation, shall—
(a) where no order of confiscation is ultimately passed by the Excise Commissioner or the officer authorised by the State Government in this behalf; or
(b) where an order passed on appeal under sub-section (5) so requires; or
(c) where in a prosecution instituted for commission of offence under this Act in respect of which an order of confiscation has been made under this section, the person concerned is acquitted,
be paid, returned or refunded, as the case may be, to its owner:
Provided that no interest shall be payable on the amount to be paid or refunded under this sub-section.
(9) Any order of confiscation made by the Excise Commissioner or any officer authorised by the State Government in this behalf, shall not prevent the infliction of any punishment to which the person affected thereby is liable under this Act.”
11. Section 9-B of the Act which was introduced in the Gazette Notification dated 31-7-1998 reads as follows:
“9-B. Bar of jurisdiction of civil courts.—No civil court shall have jurisdiction to entertain any suit or proceeding to set aside or modify—
(a) any original order passed by any of the officer competent to do so under the provisions of this Act;
(b) any order passed under or referred to in Section 9-A.”
12. Article 254 of the Constitution reads as follows:
“254. Inconsistency between laws made by Parliament and laws made by the legislatures of States.—(1) If any provision of a law made by the legislature of a State is repugnant to any provision of a law made by Parliament which Parliament is competent to enact, or to any provision of an existing law with respect to one of the matters enumerated in the Concurrent List, then, subject to the provisions of Clause (2), the law made by Parliament, whether passed before or after the law made by the legislature of such State, or, as the case may be, the existing law, shall prevail and the law made by the legislature of the State shall, to the extent of the repugnancy, be void.
(2) Where a law made by the legislature of a State with respect to one of the matters enumerated in the Concurrent List contains any provision repugnant to the provisions of an earlier law made by Parliament or an existing law with respect to that matter, then, the law so made by the legislature of such State shall, if it has been reserved for the consideration of the President and has received his assent, prevail in that State:
Provided that nothing in this clause shall prevent Parliament from enacting at any time any law with respect to the same matter including a law adding to, amending, varying or repealing the law so made by the legislature of the State.”
13. So far as the Amendment Act, 2000 is concerned it received assent of the Governor on 3-4-2000 by which Section 54-A was inserted and amendments were made in Section 69 of the existing provisions and sub-sections (4) to (9) were inserted and earlier some amendments were made in Section 9-B which has been quoted above.
14. In P.N Krishna Lal v. Govt. of Kerala 1995 Supp (2) SCC 187 it was observed at para 12 as follows:
“12. The scheme of the Act and the Amendment Act is a consistent whole, regulating production, manufacture, possession, transport, purchase or sale of intoxicating liquors. The Amendment Act was enacted to prohibit mixing or permitting to mix methanol in arrack or intoxicating drug or failure to take reasonable precautions to prevent acts or omissions, of mixing methanol in arrack or intoxicating drug or to be in possession thereof with knowledge of its adulteration or to prevent deleterious effect on the health of the consumers to prevent grievous hurt to human beings or their death. As a part of it, the burden of proof of the ingredients of the offence being within the special knowledge of the accused has also been laid on the accused person. Therefore, though incidentally it trenches into some of the provisions of the Evidence Act, the Penal Code and the Code, in its pith and substance, it is an integral scheme of the Act, which falls within Entry 8 read with Entries 64 and 65 of List II of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution. Under Article 246(3), the State Legislature was competent to enact the Amendment Act. Therefore, the assent of the President is not necessary. Even assuming that some of the provisions incidentally trespass into the field of operation of the Central provisions falling in the Concurrent List, which empower both Parliament and the State Legislatures to enact the law, the assent given by the President made Sections 57-A and 57-B valid. The gazette notification of the Amendment Act has been placed before us which shows that the President has given his assent to the Amendment Act on 1-12-1984. Therefore, by operation of proviso to Clause (2) of Article 254, the Amendment Act prevails over the relevant provisions in the Evidence Act, IPC and the Code in relation to the State of Kerala.”
15. This is a complete answer to most of the submissions made by the appellants.
16. In State of Karnataka v. K. Krishnan (2000) 7 SCC 80 this Court while considering a case of forest offence under the Karnataka Forest Act, 1963 observed that the provisions of the Act should be strictly complied with and generally the seized forest produce and the vehicle, boat, tools, etc. used in commission of forest offence should not be released and even if the Court is allowed to release the same, the authorised officer must specify reasons therefor and must insist on furnishing of bank guarantee as the minimum condition. In that case the forest produce was transported in violation of the provisions of the Act. The High Court had modified the conditions regarding bank guarantee stipulated by the authorised officer and instead had directed to furnish two like sureties to the extent of Rs 1,50,000 each for the purpose of getting interim custody of the vehicle. This Court held that the High Court had adopted a casual approach and its order was contrary to law.
17. Certain provisions of the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 have relevance. Section 6-A deals with confiscation of food grains, edible oil seeds and edible oils. Section 6-B deals with issue of show-cause notice before confiscation of food grains, etc. Section 6-E deals with bar of jurisdiction in certain cases. Section 6-E has been substituted to provide that except the Collector or the State Government, all other authorities, judicial or otherwise, would be debarred from making any order with regard to the possession, delivery, disposal or distribution of any essential commodity, seized in pursuance of an order made under Section 3. Thus a Magistrate has no jurisdiction to grant relief against seizure under Section 457 CrPC.
18. Section 6-A provides for confiscation of essential commodities seized in pursuance of an order made under Section 3. Collector of the district of the Presidency Town, in which such commodity is seized, may order confiscation, if he is satisfied that there has been a contravention of such an order. But, no order of confiscation shall be made under this section, if the seized essential commodity has been produced by the producer, without prejudice to any action, which may be taken under any other provision of this Act. Section 6-B of the Act provides the procedure to be adopted by the Collector before passing an order for confiscation, which provides that after issuing of notice an opportunity has to be given to the aggrieved party for contesting the same. The Collector, after giving him a hearing, has to decide the objection and pass an order either confiscating the property or refusing to confiscate the property.
19. In Shambhu Dayal Agarwala v. State of W.B (1990) 3 SCC 549 this Court held that whenever any essential commodity is seized, pending confiscation under Section 6-A, the Collector has no power to order release of the commodity in favour of the owner. Having regard to the scheme of the Act, the object and purpose of the statute and the mischief it seeks to guard, this Court held that the word “release” in Section 6-E is used in the limited sense of release for sale, etc. so that the same becomes available to the consumer public. It was further held:
“… No unqualified and unrestricted power has been conferred on the Collector of releasing the commodity in the sense of returning it to the owner or person from whom it was seized even before the proceeding for confiscation stood completed and before the termination of the prosecution in the acquittal of the offender. Such a view would render Clause (b) of Section 7(1) totally nugatory and would completely defeat the purpose and object of the Act. The view that the Act itself contemplates a situation which would render Section 7(1)(b) otiose where the essential commodity is disposed of by the Collector under Section 6-A(2) is misconceived. Section 6-A does not empower the Collector to give an option to pay, in lieu of confiscation of essential commodity, a fine not exceeding the market value of the commodity on the date of seizure, as in the case of any animal, vehicle, vessel or other conveyance seized along with the essential commodity. Only a limited power of sale of the commodity in the manner prescribed by Section 6-A(2) is granted. The power conferred by Section 6-A(2) to sell the essential commodity has to be exercised in public interest for maintaining the supplies and for securing the equitable distribution of the essential commodity.”
20. The amendments introduced, in our view, are regulatory in nature and cannot be regarded as violative of freedom guaranteed under Article 301 of the Constitution. In Jilubhai Nanbhai Khachar v. State of Gujarat 1995 Supp (1) SCC 596 after examining the principle of “eminent domain” it was held by this Court that Article 300-A is not attracted and deprivation is in exercise of police power and the said Article enjoins that such deprivation should not be without sanction of law.
21. There are similar provisions in the Excise Acts of other States, for example, the Tamil Nadu Excise Act, 1971, the Karnataka Excise Act, 1965, the Uttar Pradesh Excise Act, 1910 and the Andhra Pradesh Excise Act, 1968. The provisions are in Sections 4 and 14-A of the Tamil Nadu Excise Act, Sections 43-A and 43-B of the Karnataka Excise Act, Section 72 of the Uttar Pradesh Excise Act and Sections 46 and 46-A of the Andhra Pradesh Excise Act.
22. Reference may also be made to Dy. Commr., Dakshina Kannada District v. Rudolph Fernandes (2000) 3 SCC 306 and State of W.B v. Sujit Kumar Rana (2004) 4 SCC 129 while gauging the validity of the impugned provisions.
23. In view of what has been stated above the inevitable conclusion is that the appeals are without merit, deserve dismissal, which we direct. No costs.
Alert