Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ctt v. Associated Distributors Ltd.

Supreme Court Of India
May 5, 2008
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute concerns the rate of sales tax applicable to “bubblegum” for Assessment Year 1994-1995 under the U.P. Sales Tax Act. The Assessing Officer treated bubblegum as an unclassified, non-scheduled good and levied tax (with additional tax) at 10%. The dealer succeeded before the first appellate authority, which held that bubblegum was “confectionery” taxable at 6.25%. On second appeal, the Sales Tax Tribunal reversed, declaring bubblegum an unclassified item liable at 10%. The dealer then obtained relief from the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, which—without giving reasons—categorised bubblegum as “confectionery” taxable at 6.25%. Aggrieved, the State (appellant) filed the present civil appeals before the Supreme Court, resulting in the impugned judgment now summarised.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether bubblegum falls within any of the specific taxable categories—“sweetmeat (mithai),” “confectionery,” or “sugar products”—listed in the relevant notifications under the U.P. Sales Tax Act.
  2. Consequently, whether bubblegum should be taxed at the concessional rate of 6.25% or at 10% as an unclassified good.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments (State/Commissioner)

  • Applied the “common parlance” test, contending that ordinary consumers in Uttar Pradesh do not regard bubblegum as sweetmeat or confectionery; it is chewed for fun or as a mouth-freshener and then discarded.
  • Emphasised that bubblegum contains substantial non-sugar ingredients (gum base, waxes) and is not “eaten” like traditional sweets.
  • Relied on precedent (Pappu Sweets and Biscuits) holding that classification must reflect how goods are understood locally, not in foreign markets.
  • Therefore bubblegum remains an unclassified commodity, attracting the default 10% rate.

Respondent’s Arguments (Dealer)

  • Although conceding that the High Court found bubblegum not to be “sweetmeat” and that no appeal was filed on that finding, counsel argued bubblegum is a “sugar product” because it contains approximately 60 % sucrose by weight.
  • Submitted that the term “sugar products” is undefined and should cover any product in which sugar is the predominant constituent and which lacks a more specific heading.
  • Sought classification under Entry 48 of the 7-9-1981 Notification (as amended 31-3-1992) covering “sweetmeats, namkins, cooked food, … rusks and sugar products.”

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pappu Sweets and Biscuits v. CTT, (1998) 7 SCC 228 Classification of goods must follow the “common parlance” or popular meaning in the local market. Used as the primary authority to hold that bubblegum, like toffee, is not treated as “mithai” by dealers or consumers in Uttar Pradesh.
CCE v. Parle Exports (P) Ltd., (1989) 1 SCC 345 Words in taxing statutes are construed as understood in ordinary trade and by consumers. Re-affirmed the need to interpret “sweetmeat” and related terms by ordinary usage rather than technical or foreign meanings.
Nutrine Chewing Gum Products Co. (P) Ltd. v. Revenue, STI 1985 (Under S. 35 UPST) 21 Chewing gum is not an item of confectionery; it is an unclassified good. Cited to demonstrate administrative and judicial consistency that chewing gum/bubblegum is not confectionery.
Gum Products (P) Ltd. v. CST, Second Appeal No. 449 of 1992 (Sales Tax Tribunal) Earlier view treating chewing gum/bubblegum as “sweetmeat” or confectionery. Considered but ultimately rejected in favour of the common parlance approach.
Annapurna Biscuit Mfg. Co. Ltd. v. State of U.P., 1975 UPTC 620 Prior classification guidance for edible products. Cited in the record; not relied upon by the Supreme Court for its ratio.
Gum India Ltd. v. CTT, 1996 STD Tri 124 Tribunal decision on taxability of gum products. Cited in background; Supreme Court did not adopt its reasoning.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court applied the common parlance test reiterated in Pappu Sweets and Biscuits and Parle Exports. It observed that:

  • When an average consumer in Uttar Pradesh is asked to procure “mithai” (sweetmeat), bubblegum would never be supplied; the product is chewed and discarded rather than eaten.
  • Bubblegum contains gum base and waxes; sugar is only one component, so it cannot automatically be categorised as a “sugar product.”
  • The relevant notifications list “sweetmeats” and “sugar products,” but neither term can, on ordinary understanding, encompass bubblegum, and “confectionery” is not an enumerated category.
  • The High Court gave no supporting reasons for treating bubblegum as confectionery and ignored the absence of that term in the notification.
  • Administrative and judicial materials (e.g., Nutrine Chewing Gum) support treating chewing gum/bubblegum as unclassified.

Consequently, the Court concluded that bubblegum is neither sweetmeat, confectionery, nor a sugar product under the specific entries, and therefore remains an unclassified good taxable at the default rate of 10% (inclusive of surcharge).

Holding and Implications

ALLOWED – High Court judgment dated 9-11-2001 set aside.

Bubblegum is to be taxed as an unclassified item at 10% for Assessment Year 1994-1995. The ruling clarifies the classification of bubblegum (and by implication similar chewing gum products) under the U.P. Sales Tax Act, reinforcing the common-parlance test for commodity classification. No costs were awarded, and the decision sets interpretative guidance but does not establish a new statutory category.

Show all summary ...

Dalveer Bhandari, J.— Leave granted in the special leave petitions.

2. These appeals are directed against the judgment and order dated 9-11-2001 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad passed in Trade Tax Revision No. 656 of 2001.

3. In these appeals, a common question of law arises, therefore, for the sake of convenience the facts of only Civil Appeal No. 6636 of 2002 are recapitulated.

4. The issue involved in these appeals is confined to the rate of tax applicable on the sales of bubblegum. According to the appellant, bubblegum is taxable as an unclassified goods and would attract the duty at the rate of 10% inclusive of surcharge. In the impugned judgment, the High Court arrived at the conclusion that bubblegum is a confectionery item and, therefore, be taxed at the rate of 6.25%.

5. The Tax Assessing Officer for Assessment Year 1994-1995 has levied the tax with additional tax at the rate of 10% treating bubblegum as unclassified and non-scheduled item. In an appeal filed by the respondent, the learned first appellate court accepted the submission of the respondent and taxed bubblegum at the rate of 6.25%. The appellant aggrieved by the said order preferred the second appeal before the Sales Tax Tribunal, Branch II, Ghaziabad. The Tribunal in detail discussed the controversy involved in the case.

6. Under the U.P Sales Tax Act, a notification fixing the rate of tax on bubblegum for the year 1994-1995 was not issued. Under the Government Notification No. Vya. Ka.-2-1225.Eleven dated 31-3-1992 and Notification No. Vya. Ka.-2-3403.Eleven dated 1-10-1994, the liability for payment of tax has been fixed for sweets, sweetmeat, namkeen, cooked food, rewari, gajak, biscuit, double-bread, cake, pastry, rusk and the products of sugar under the U.P Sales Tax Act.

7. It is pertinent to mention here that the official language of the State of Uttar Pradesh is Hindi. If any difference is found between the notifications in English and Hindi, the notification issued in Hindi will be applicable. On the said notification, the courts have decided that confectionery comes within sweets (mithai) and sweetmeat, but it has not been mentioned that bubblegum comes within the category of a sweet.

8. This Court in Pappu Sweets and Biscuits v. CTT (1998) 7 SCC 228 observed thus:

“12. ‘There is no doubt that a toffee is a sweetmeat, as understood by the people where toffee originated’ and that ‘toffee and other things of that nature are of foreign origin and are sweets or sweetmeat according to those people and their nature cannot be changed simply because their origin is different from what is usually conveyed by the word “mithai” in this part of the country’, the High Court preferred to decide the issue by relying upon how toffee is understood by the people of the country where it originated rather than by considering how ‘toffee’ is understood in India and more particularly in the State of U.P As held by this Court in CCE v. Parle Exports (P) Ltd. (1989) 1 SCC 345
‘17. The words used in the provision, imposing taxes or granting exemption should be understood in the same way in which these are understood in ordinary parlance in the area in which the law is in force or by the people who ordinarily deal with them.’
In that case, the question that had arisen for consideration was whether non-alcoholic beverage bases are food products or food preparations in terms of Central Excise Notification No. 55/75 dated 1-3-1975. This Court observed that non-alcoholic beverages are not understood in India as food products or food preparations, though they might have been regarded as such in foreign countries. The High Court, therefore, should have applied the test of popular parlance by finding out how toffee is understood in the country and more particularly in the State of U.P No evidence was led by the State to substantiate its case that ‘toffee’ is considered as sweetmeat either by the dealers in toffees or by the consumers. On the other hand, evidence was led by the appellant in CA No. 1692 of 1997 indicating that toffee is not considered as sweetmeat, that they are not sold in shops selling sweetmeats but are sold in shops selling confectioneries or other types of goods, and that the consumers do not buy toffees as sweetmeat or treat them as such. It was, however, contended by the learned counsel for the State that sometime before this exemption notification was issued by the State, the Allahabad High Court had in two cases held that toffee is a sweetmeat. But it was so held in a different context and no evidence was led by the State to show that thereafter, the dealers in toffees and consumers started treating them as sweetmeat. In the Hindi version of the notification for the word sweetmeat the word ‘mithai’ is used. The word ‘mithai’ has a definite connotation and it can be said with reasonable amount of certainty that people in this country do not consider toffee as ‘mithai’. The High Court committed a grave error in holding that as some manufacturers of toffees sell their products by describing them as sweets it can be said that in commercial circles toffee is known as sweetmeat.”

If the ratio of the aforesaid judgment is properly comprehended then bubblegum in the common parlance cannot be construed as mithai (sweetmeat).

9. When we apply common parlance test and in fact ask someone to bring the sweets from the market, he will never bring bubblegum. In common parlance, even items of confectionery will not be construed as sweetmeat (mithai). In fact, bubblegum is not an item for eating. It is kept in the mouth and after chewing the same is thrown out. The bubblegum while kept in the mouth by the children is also inflated as a balloon. In fact, it is used as a “mouth freshener”. It is not made only of sugar. It contains gum base, waxes, etc. along with sugar.

10. According to Wikipedia, the encyclopædia, bubblegum is a type of chewing gum especially designed for blowing bubbles.

11. The Commissioner, Sales Tax, U.P has relied on the judgment in Nutrine Chewing Gum Products Co. (P) Ltd. v. Revenue STI 1985 (Under S. 35 UPST) 21 and observed that: (STI p. 21, para 3)

“3. … In chewing gum, sugar is an almost insignificant…. Moreover it is not eatable. Its use is entirely different. Children use it just for a fun and athletes for controlling the breath. In common parlance also nobody treats it as an item of confectionery. I, therefore, hold that chewing gum is an unclassified item….”

12. Thus, it is clear that chewing gum and bubblegum do not fall in the category of sweetmeat (mithai). The learned appellate court has relied on the judgment dated 4-4-1998 delivered by the Sales Tax Tribunal in Second Appeal No. 449 of 1992 titled Gum Products (P) Ltd. v. CST. The Tribunal also relied on the judgment delivered by the High Court in Pappu Sweets & Biscuits v. CTT 1995 UPTC 1089; Annapurna Biscuit Mfg. Co. Ltd. v. State of U.P 1975 UPTC 620 and the judgment of the Sales Tax Tribunal, Kanpur in Gum India Ltd. v. CTT 1996 STD Tri 124. According to these judgments, chewing gum and bubblegum, etc. are taxable as “sweetmeat” and confectionery items. The Tribunal also considered the judgment delivered in Pappu Sweets (1998) 7 SCC 228.

13. In the notification issued under the U.P Sales Tax Act, the mithai (sweetmeat), cooked food, namkin, etc. are under one entry, but it does not mean that namkin and cooked food is sweetmeat (mithai). In the copy of Parts V & XI and VIII of the Food Analysis Book which has been submitted, there is a mention about several items like bread, rusk, foodmeat, white bread, cream role, ice cream, cone, Bombay halwa, etc. In this one of the items mentioned is bubblegum. It does not mean that bubblegum is a sweetmeat (mithai) or confectionery.

14. The Tribunal clearly came to the conclusion that bubblegum is neither sweetmeat (mithai) nor confectionery. The tax is liable to be paid on bubblegum as an unclassified item.

15. The respondent aggrieved by the said judgment of the Tribunal filed a revision petition before the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad.

16. The High Court came to the specific finding that the bubblegum cannot be treated as a sweetmeat but it is certainly an item of confectionery. In the impugned judgment, the High Court gave no reasons for its finding. The respondent did not give any break-up of the ingredients of bubblegum. It was never the case of the respondent that bubblegum is a sugar product. Confectionery is not even mentioned in the notification. The High Court ought to have properly comprehended the object of the notification.

17. In the facts and circumstances, the High Court should have applied common parlance test to determine proper categorisation of bubblegum. It may be pertinent to mention that the respondent has not filed any appeal against the said finding of the High Court that bubblegum is not a sweetmeat.

18. The appellant aggrieved by the judgment of the High Court dated 9-11-2001 has preferred this appeal.

19. The dispute is confined to Assessment Year 1994-1995. According to the respondent, bubblegum was covered by the specific entry at Sl. No. 48 of Notification dated 7-9-1981 as amended by Notification dated 31-3-1992. The said Entry 48 reads as under:

“Sweetmeats, namkins, cooked food, rewari, gajak, biscuits, bread, cakes, pastries, buns, rusks and sugar products, except any of the aforesaid goods which are exempt under any other notifications issued under the U.P Sales Tax Act.”

20. Learned counsel for the respondent made serious efforts to demonstrate that the bubblegum should be classified in the category of “sweetmeat”. He frankly conceded that the High Court gave a specific finding that the bubblegum cannot be treated as sweetmeat and that finding was not challenged by the respondent.

21. The learned counsel for the respondent submitted that the bubblegum contains 60% sucrose by weight and it being a product of sugar, it should come in the category of sweetmeat.

22. The respondent submitted that the expression “sugar products” has not been defined. It would mean and cover any product which is very rich in sugar. A product in which sugar is predominant constituent over other constituents and which does not have coverage by any other more specific heading is clearly a sugar product.

23. In Pappu Sweets (1998) 7 SCC 228 this Court in order to give meaning to the notification issued by the State of Uttar Pradesh has laid great emphasis on the common parlance test. The Court gave an apt illustration of a toffee. Toffee in the country of origin may be considered as sweetmeat but it cannot be considered as mithai in this part of the country (Uttar Pradesh). Similarly, by no stretch of imagination, can bubblegum be considered as mithai in the State of Uttar Pradesh. Consequently, “bubblegum” is taxable as an unclassified good.

24. These civil appeals are accordingly allowed and the impugned judgment of the High Court is set aside. In the facts and circumstances, we direct the parties to bear their own costs.