- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Goetze (India) Limited v. Employees' State Insurance Corporation .
Factual and Procedural Background
The Employees' State Insurance Corporation (“the Corporation”) demanded ESI contributions from the appellant on the component of “efficiency bonus” for the period January 1988 – September 1989. The appellant challenged that demand before the ESI Court under Section 75 of the Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948 (“the Act”). While those proceedings were pending, the Corporation sought further records and, after reverification, quantified the appellant’s total contribution liability at Rs 7,54,525 for the periods 1/88–3/89 and 4/89–3/94. The appellant paid this amount in October/November 1997, and the ESI Court, by order dated 6-1-1998, released the appellant’s bank guarantee, noting that the contribution had been deposited.
Subsequently, on 11-1-2000, the Corporation demanded statutory interest of Rs 4,61,825 on the delayed contributions for 1988-1994. The appellant filed a writ petition before the Punjab and Haryana High Court contending that the earlier ESI Court order implied a compromise waiving interest. The High Court dismissed the writ petition, leading to the present appeal before the Supreme Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether statutory interest under Section 39(5)(a) of the Act read with Regulations 31 and 31-A can be waived or compromised by agreement or by a statement made before the ESI Court.
- Whether the ESI Court’s observation that “no further dues” were payable absolved the appellant from liability to pay statutory interest.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- An interim stay had been operating, so no interest could accrue for the stayed period.
- The Corporation’s counsel had stated before the ESI Court that “nothing further was payable”, amounting to a compromise and waiver of interest.
- The appellant paid the contribution “to buy peace”, relying on this Court’s decision in Whirlpool of India Ltd. v. ESIC (2000) 3 SCC 185, which allegedly supported its stand on non-liability.
Respondent Corporation's Arguments
- Interest is a statutory liability under Section 39(5)(a) and Regulation 31-A; it cannot be waived by compromise or unilateral statement.
- The ESI Court’s order merely recorded that the contribution had been paid; “no further dues” referred only to contribution, not interest.
- The High Court therefore correctly upheld the demand for statutory interest.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Whirlpool of India Ltd. v. Employees' State Insurance Corporation, (2000) 3 SCC 185 | Interprets what payments fall within “wages” under Section 2(22) of the Act. | Relied on by the appellant to argue non-liability for contribution; the Supreme Court did not treat it as governing the distinct issue of statutory interest and therefore found it of no assistance in the present matter. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court examined the statutory framework:
- Section 39(5)(a) imposes simple interest at not less than 12% per annum on contributions not paid when due.
- Regulation 31 requires payment of contributions within 21 days of the end of the month, and Regulation 31-A mandates interest for each day of default.
Because the appellant admittedly paid the assessed contributions long after they fell due (only in 1997), liability for interest necessarily attached. The Court emphasized:
- The liability is statutory and admits of no waiver; there is no power in either the Corporation or the ESI Court to compromise or relinquish interest.
- The ESI Court’s order merely recorded the appellant’s payment and accordingly released the bank guarantee. Its reference to “no further dues” related solely to contribution, not to statutory interest.
- An interim stay of recovery does not extinguish the statutory accrual of interest for delayed payment once liability is finally determined.
Consequently, the High Court correctly held that the Corporation’s demand for interest was lawful, and the appellant’s reliance on an alleged compromise or on the Whirlpool decision was misplaced.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED.
The Supreme Court affirmed that statutory interest under the Employees' State Insurance Act and accompanying Regulations is mandatory and cannot be waived by compromise, agreement, or unilateral statement. The immediate consequence is that the appellant must pay Rs 4,61,825 as interest on delayed contributions. The decision reiterates that employers cannot avoid statutory interest liability merely by settling the principal contribution at a later date; no new precedent was set beyond reinforcing this settled principle.
Dr. Arijit Pasayat, J.— Challenge in this appeal is to the order passed by a Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court dismissing the writ petition filed by the appellant.
2. Controversy lies within a very narrow compass.
Employees' State Insurance Corporation (in short “the Corporation”), the respondent herein raised a demand for contribution under the Employees' State Insurance Act, 1948 (in short “the Act”) on the component of efficiency bonus for the period January 1988 to September 1989 by order dated 23-7-1992. The demand was challenged before the ESI Court under Section 75 of the Act. Pending the proceedings before the ESI Court, the Corporation by letter dated 1-3-1997 asked for production of record for the purpose of reverification for the period from 1989 to 1991 and from 1992 to 1994 to determine the amount payable.
3. The respondent Corporation on reverification determined the actual amount payable as follows:
(a) 1/88 to 3/89 as Rs 2,26,454 (b) 4/89 to 3/94 as Rs 5,28,071 Total Rs 7,54,525
The appellant agreed to pay the contribution and paid the same in October/November 1997.
4. The appellant took the stand that there was a bona fide dispute about eligibility. Since eligibility to “efficiency bonus” under the scheme was subject to attendance of 50 days in a quarter (sic it is) is payable and paid quarterly. The appellant took the stand that it falls outside the definition of wages under Section 2(22) of the Act. The appellant took the plea that its stand was supported by a judgment of this Court in Whirlpool of India Ltd. v. ESI Corpn. (2000) 3 SCC 185
5. The ESI Court disposed of the matter on 6-1-1998 taking note of the stand of the appellant that it had deposited the definite amount after reverification and the bank guarantee furnished by the appellant was released. On 11-1-2000 the Corporation wrote a letter to the appellant demanding payment of interest on the amount paid to the Corporation for the period from 1988 to 1994 as covered by order dated 6-1-1998 and directed payment of interest amounting to Rs 4,61,825. The appellant questioned the demand before the High Court by filing a writ petition. The appellant's stand was that a compromise had been arrived at as is apparent from the order of the ESI Court to the effect that nothing was payable by the appellant. The Corporation took the stand that the liability to pay interest was statutory and, therefore, there could not have been any compromise. In any event the submission of the appellant that nothing further was payable as ESI contribution was noted and therefore, the bank guarantee was released. There was no question of any compromise to waive the interest which is not statutorily permissible. The High Court accepted the stand and dismissed the writ petition.
6. In support of the appeal learned counsel for the appellant submitted that there was an order of stay and therefore the question of any interest does not arise. Further, when the counsel for the Corporation himself stated that nothing further was payable, it clearly indicated that there was a statement on the compromise for waiver of interest. It was pointed out that with a view to buy peace the appellant had agreed to pay the amount though this case was clearly covered by Whirlpool case (2000) 3 SCC 185.
7. Learned counsel for the respondent on the other hand submitted that there is no question of any compromise to waive interest because the same is statutorily payable. There cannot be any compromise without any authority when there is no provision for any compromise or statement. It is therefore stated that the High Court's view is right.
8. In order to appreciate rival submissions it would be necessary to take note of few provisions; Section 39 and Regulations 31 and 31-A read as follows:
“39. Contributions.— ***
(5)(a) If any contribution payable under this Act is not paid by the principal employer on the date on which such contribution has become due, he shall be liable to pay simple interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum or at such higher rate as may be specified in the regulations till the date of its actual payment:
“31. Time for payment of contribution.—An employer who is liable to pay contributions in respect of any employee shall pay those contributions within 21 days of the last day of the calendar month in which the contributions fall due:
Provided that where a factory/establishment is permanently closed, the employer shall pay contribution on the last day of its closure:
31-A. Interest on contribution due, but not paid in time.—An employer who fails to pay contribution within the periods specified in Regulation 31, shall be liable to pay interest at the rate of 12 per cent per annum in respect of each day of default or delay in payment of contribution.”
9*. As there was delay in making the payment of the contribution the Corporation had issued notice on 29-6-1990 at the first instance and thereafter the order was passed under Section 45-A of the Act on 23-7-1992. The same was challenged before the ESI Court in which an interim stay was granted on 9-10-1992. During the pendency of the matter there was reverification and the quantum payable by the appellant was worked out. The liability to pay interest is statutory. There is no power of waiver. The question of any compromise or settlement does not really arise. Even otherwise the order of the ESI Court referred to and relied upon by the appellant is of no assistance to the appellant. It only noted statement of the appellant that he had deposited the contribution payable. The reference to “no further dues” is obviously relatable to the contribution payable and nothing beyond that.
10. Above being the position, the appeal is sans merit, deserves dismissal, which we direct. There shall be no order as to costs.
Alert