Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Lalliram And Another v. State Of Madhya Pradesh .

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 15, 2008
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Three accused — the present appellants and one Chaturbhuj — were charged under Sections 376, 392, 342 and 506 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. The prosecution alleged that on 23-9-1985 the prosecutrix, while travelling with her husband Dayaram, was overpowered near a field, her husband was locked in a room, and she was repeatedly raped through the night. The next morning the couple was released after being threatened, and a bag containing Rs 25 and an identity card was allegedly snatched.

The prosecutrix lodged First Information Report (Exh. P-1); a spot-map (Exh. P-2) was prepared and she was medically examined twice by Dr. C. P. Jain (PW 11). The first examination, dated 25-9-1985, noted no injuries and recorded “no definite opinion” on rape. The second examination on 5-10-1985 detected only fresh injuries consistent with an assault by her husband.

The Additional Sessions Judge, Ashok Nagar (Sessions Trial No. 12 of 1986) acquitted all accused. The State appealed under Section 378 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; a Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court, Gwalior Bench, set aside the acquittal for offences under Sections 376 and 342 IPC, imposed sentences of seven years and six months’ imprisonment and fines, but maintained acquittal on Sections 392 and 506(II) IPC. The present appeal challenges the High Court’s reversal of the acquittal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court, hearing an appeal against acquittal, correctly applied the governing parameters in reversing the trial court’s finding of not guilty.
  2. Whether the discrepancies in the prosecutrix’s testimony, absence of corroborating medical evidence and other contradictions rendered her evidence unreliable so as to justify restoration of the acquittal.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The High Court relied on precedents “in a mechanical manner” without demonstrating how the trial court’s view was unreasonable.
  • Improvements and contradictions in the prosecutrix’s testimony, noted by the trial court, undermined her credibility.
  • The High Court ignored the established principles governing interference with an acquittal.

State’s Arguments

  • The evidence of the prosecutrix and her husband was cogent and sufficient to sustain conviction.
  • The High Court’s judgment was free from infirmity and warranted no interference.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pratap Misra v. State of Orissa, (1977) 3 SCC 41 Where gang rape is alleged but no injuries are found, absence of injuries becomes an important factor; credibility of the prosecutrix determines need for corroboration. Used to underscore that in the present facts, absence of injuries coupled with doubtful testimony weakened the prosecution case.
Aman Kumar v. State of Haryana, (2004) 4 SCC 379 The prosecutrix is not an accomplice; her testimony can be acted upon without corroboration, but courts may seek corroboration if her version is difficult to accept at face value. Reiterated to show that although corroboration is not legally mandatory, it becomes necessary when credibility issues arise.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court examined the trial court’s findings alongside the High Court’s reasons for reversal and found the latter wanting:

  • Medical Evidence: The prosecutrix claimed repeated rape by several persons yet no injuries were found during the first medical examination. The doctor noted she was menstruating, contradicting her claim of four-month pregnancy and alleged miscarriage.
  • Inconsistencies in Testimony: The prosecutrix changed her account regarding which accused first raped her, the location of the rape, and whether she was dragged by her hair. These critical details were absent from the FIR and contradicted by medical findings.
  • Corroborative Witnesses: PW 3 and PW 4 gave versions inconsistent with each other and with PW 1 and PW 2 about when the prosecutrix was found and whether she had injuries.
  • Parameters for Interference with Acquittal: The Court emphasized that an appellate court should not overturn an acquittal unless the trial court’s view is perverse or wholly unreasonable. On the facts, the trial court’s evaluation was plausible; therefore the High Court’s interference was unjustified.
  • Use of Precedents: The Supreme Court noted that precedents on appreciation of evidence are fact-specific; the High Court failed to relate cited cases to the concrete factual matrix here.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed — Conviction Set Aside. The acquittal recorded by the trial court is restored, and the accused are to be released forthwith unless required in any other case.

Implications: The decision directly affects only the parties, reaffirming that appellate courts must exercise restraint when reviewing acquittals and must closely scrutinize credibility issues before relying solely on a prosecutrix’s testimony. No new legal precedent was created.

Show all summary ...

Dr. Arijit Pasayat, J.— The challenge in this appeal is to the judgment of a Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court, Gwalior Bench, upsetting the acquittal as recorded by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Ashok Nagar, in Sessions Trial No. 12 of 1986. Three accused persons, namely, the present appellants and one Chaturbhuj faced trial for alleged commission of offence punishable under Sections 376, 392, 342 and 506 of the Penal Code, 1860 (in short “IPC”). The trial court directed acquittal of all the three accused persons.

2. In appeal filed by the State under Section 378 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (in short “the Code”) the order of acquittal was set aside and the accused persons were found guilty of offence punishable under Sections 342 and 376 IPC. But it upheld the acquittal for offence relatable to Sections 392 and 506(II) IPC. The appellants were sentenced to undergo seven years and six months' custodial sentence and fine with default stipulation for offences relatable to Sections 376 and 342 IPC.

3. Prosecution version which led to the trial of the accused persons is as follows:

On 23-9-1985, in the evening the prosecutrix along with her husband Dayaram went to Khajuria. On the way near the field of Mangal, the appellants met them and started to abuse the prosecutrix. The appellants also started beating the husband of the prosecutrix and took the prosecutrix near the well of Kamal Singh where accused Pooran Singh and Lalliram talked to Chaturbhuj. Dayaram was locked in a room. Then the appellants took away the prosecutrix to the upper room of the house and committed rape repeatedly in the night. In the next morning they released the prosecutrix and warned her not to report to anybody. Then she brought Dayaram from the room and at that time Latura, Gyarasa, Bharo Singh, Kamal Singh and Harihar reached there. They were informed about the incident. The appellants also snatched a bag from the prosecutrix containing Rs 25 and identity card of Dayaram.

4. The prosecutrix lodged the report in Police Station Madhogarh Outpost which is Ext. P-1. Investigation was undertaken. Spot map was prepared which is Ext. P-2. The prosecutrix was sent for medical examination vide Ext. P-6 and she was examined by the lady doctor Smt C.P Jain (PW 11) twice, first time on 25-9-1985 and then on 5-10-1985. Ext. P-6 is the report pertaining to medical examination dated 25-9-1985. As per report Ext. P-6 she gave opinion that no definite opinion can be given about rape. In the report it was stated that no external injuries were found on her body. The trial court found that the evidence of Latura (PW 3) who is father of PW 2, Bharosa (PW 4) and Puliabai (PW 5) was inconsistent and the defence witness Maya probabilised the defence taken by the trial court. Doctor also categorically stated that she was not pregnant on the alleged date of occurrence.

5. The High Court referred to the evidence of PWs 1 and 2 i.e the prosecutrix and Dayaram respectively and observed that the version of the prosecutrix was sufficient to fasten the guilt on the accused. Circumstances highlighted by the trial court were not sufficient to warrant acquittal. Though the version as indicated in the first information report (in short “the FIR”) and the evidence in Court were discrepant in certain aspects, it was held to be of no consequence.

6. Stand of the State before the High Court was that the evidence of the prosecutrix and her husband was cogent and there was no scope for directing acquittal.

7. It is to be noted that the trial court had found the discrepancy in the version of the witnesses.

8. In support of the appeal learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the High Court relied on several decisions without indicating as to how the trial court's view was not justified. It is in essence submitted that the parameters relating to appeal against acquittal have not been kept in view. It is stated that the High Court relied on decisions in a mechanical manner overlooking the improvements made by the prosecutrix and the contradictory statements made by her which as rightly observed by the trial court corroded the credibility of the prosecution version.

9. Learned counsel for the State on the other hand submitted that the judgment of the High Court does not suffer from any infirmity to warrant interference.

10. The trial court noted that though the prosecutrix claimed that she was raped by several persons at several times there was no injury noticed and doctor has categorically stated that there was no sign of rape and in fact there was no injury.

11. It is true that injury is not a sine qua non for deciding whether rape has been committed. But it has to be decided on the factual matrix of each case. As was observed by this Court in Pratap Misra v. State of Orissa (1977) 3 SCC 41 where allegation is of rape by many persons and several times but no injury is noticed that certainly is an important factor and if the prosecutrix's version is credible, then no corroboration is necessary. But if the prosecutrix's version is not credible then there would be need for corroboration. (See Aman Kumar v. State of Haryana (2004) 4 SCC 379.)

12. As rightly contended by learned counsel for the appellants, a decision has to be considered in the background of the factual scenario. In criminal cases the question of a precedent particularly relating to appreciation of evidence is really of no consequence. In Aman Kumar case (2004) 4 SCC 379 it was observed that a prosecutrix complaining of having been a victim of the offence of rape is not an accomplice. There is no rule of law that her testimony cannot be acted upon without corroboration in material particulars. She stands on a higher pedestal than the injured witness. In the latter case there is injury in the physical form while in the former both physical as well as psychological and emotional. However, if the court finds it difficult to accept the version of a prosecutrix on the face value, it may search for evidence direct or circumstantial.

13. So far as testimony of the victim is concerned the High Court has found that PW 2 stated about injuries on the cheek and back of the prosecutrix. But no such injury was found in the first medical examination. PW 2 had stated that she had suffered injuries on her legs. But such injuries were also not noticed.

14. In the cross-examination, the prosecutrix stated that it was Lalliram who committed the rape first. But in her earlier statement she had stated that it was accused Pooran who first committed the rape on her. Interestingly, she had also deposed differently as to the place of rape. This aspect was noticed by the trial court. Another significant factor which was noticed by the trial court but not by the High Court was that PW 1 stated that there was miscarriage. PW 1 stated that she was four months pregnant at the time of occurrence. But the doctor stated that she was actually on menstruation period.

15. Another interesting statement of the prosecutrix was that accused Lalliram had dragged her by catching her bunch of hair for a considerable distance. The trial court noticed that if that was so there would have been injuries and interestingly she had not stated about this part in the FIR. As noted above, she had spoken about scratches on her back due to dragging and other parts of the body and that blood had also oozed out. But the medical evidence is clearly to the contrary. In her statement she had deposed that her husband Dayaram was also dragged by Pooran and Lalliram and he had also suffered several injuries. This part is also belied by the medical evidence. In cross-examination, PW 1 admitted that the accused persons harassed her and tried to kill her. She had admitted that she was assaulted by her husband. Those are relatable to the injuries which were fresh at the time of examination by the doctor on 5-10-1985.

16. It is to be noted that Smt C.P Jain (PW 11) examined her twice i.e first on 25-9-1985 and then on 5-10-1985. At the time of first examination, no injury was found on her body. It is also to be noted that PW 3 stated that after PW 1 regained consciousness she told about the incident. This is contrary to what PW 2 stated. He has stated that he was tied by the accused persons and in the morning he was untied by PW 1. By that time obviously PW 3 and PW 4 had not arrived. In fact PW 4 says that when he and PW 3 went to the place of occurrence the victim was lying unconscious.

17. In view of the aforesaid factual position the trial court was justified in directing acquittal and the High Court's judgment upsetting the acquittal is clearly unsustainable.

18. The appeal is allowed. The conviction recorded by the High Court is set aside. The accused persons who are in custody shall be released forthwith unless required to be in custody in connection with any other case.