Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Union Of India v. Chandalavada Gopalakrishna Murthy And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 10, 2008
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

An agreement dated 31-1-1981 was executed between the appellant (Railways) and the respondent contractor for construction of a laboratory, officers’ room and classroom at the Indian Railway Institute, Secunderabad. The work was to be completed by 27-10-1981 but, on the contractor’s request, time was extended under Clause 17(3) of the General Conditions of Contract and the work was ultimately completed on 31-8-1983.

The respondent raised seven claims before an arbitrator. The arbitrator allowed all seven heads. When the award was filed before the City Civil Court, that court made the award a rule of court for Claims 2-6 but set aside Items 1 and 7. On appeal, a Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court restored Item 1 but upheld rejection of Item 7. The present Supreme Court appeals, therefore, concern only Item 1 of the contractor’s claim.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in light of Clause 17(3) of the contract—which permits extension of time but disallows damages—the contractor is entitled to compensation (Item 1) for delay even when the Railways granted extensions under that clause.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ch. Ramalinga Reddy v. Superintending Engineer (1999) 9 SCC 610 When a contract period is extended under the contract itself, an arbitrator cannot award compensation for delay. Relied upon as directly governing the present dispute; the Court held the contractor is not entitled to damages under Item 1.
Northern Railway v. Sarvesh Chopra (2002) 4 SCC 45 Affirmed the principle in Ramalinga Reddy that compensation is barred where extension is granted under contractual terms. Cited as a further affirmation of the same principle, reinforcing that the High Court order was unsustainable.
K.R. Raveendranathan v. State of Kerala (1998) 9 SCC 410 The specific principle was not discussed; the Court noted the case was inapplicable to the present facts. Distinguished; offered no support to the respondent’s position.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court focused on Clause 17(3) of the contract, which stipulates that any delay attributable to the Railways may justify extension of the completion date but does not entitle the contractor to damages or compensation. Since extensions had in fact been granted under that clause, the contractual bar on damages was triggered.

The Court noted that a three-Judge Bench decision in Ramalinga Reddy had already settled that arbitrators cannot award such compensation where time has been extended pursuant to similar clauses, a view reiterated in Sarvesh Chopra. Conversely, the authority cited by the respondent (Raveendranathan) was found irrelevant to the contractual framework at hand.

Applying these binding precedents, the Court concluded that the High Court erred in reinstating Item 1 of the claim. Accordingly, the award of compensation under that head could not stand.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Allowed; High Court judgment dated 8-5-2001 set aside.

Direct Effect: The contractor’s claim under Item 1 is rejected, restoring the City Civil Court’s decision and leaving Items 2-6 only. No order as to costs.

Broader Implication: The decision reaffirms that, under contracts containing clauses similar to Clause 17(3), extensions of time preclude any claim for damages for delay, consistent with earlier Supreme Court precedent.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. These appeals are directed against the judgment and order dated 8-5-2001 passed by the Division Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court.

2. We have heard the parties at length.

3. In view of the order that we propose to pass, it is not necessary to recite the entire facts leading to the filing of the present appeal. Suffice it to say that a contract was entered into between the appellant and the respondent regarding the construction of a laboratory, an officers' room and a classroom at the Indian Railway Institute, Secunderabad. The agreement was entered into on 31-1-1981. According to the agreement, the contract was to be completed within a period of 9 months i.e up to 27-10-1981. It is stated that on request made by the respondent contractor extension of time was granted under Clause 17(3) of the general conditions of the contract. Ultimately, the contract was completed on 31-8-1983.

4. A dispute arose between the parties and the respondent made various claims under 7 heads and demanded for arbitration. The arbitrator granted award under all 7 heads. The award was filed before the City Civil Court. The City Civil Court made the award a rule of the court in respect of Claims 2 to 6 but set aside the award regarding Items 1 and 7.

5. Aggrieved thereby, the respondent filed an appeal before the Division Bench of the High Court and by the impugned order the Division Bench maintained the order of the civil court with regard to Item 7. However, the Division Bench allowed the claim under Item 1. Hence, the present appeals.

6. The dispute now to be resolved is confined only to Item 1 of the claim. To answer this question, we may refer to Clause 17(3) of the contract. Clause 17(3) reads:

“17. (3) In the event of any failure or delay by the Railway to hand over to the contractor possession of the lands necessary for the execution of the works or to give the necessary notice to commence the works or to provide the necessary drawings or instructions or any other delay caused by the Railway due to any cause, whatsoever, the said failure or delay shall in no way effect or vitiate the contract or alter the character thereof or entitle the contractor to damages of compensation thereof but in any such case, the Railway may grant such extension or extensions of the completion date as may be considered reasonable.”

Clause 17(3) thus clearly shows that if there is delay by the Railways the term of the contract can be extended as has been done in the present case. However, the contractor shall not be entitled to damages or compensation.

7. A similar question raised before this Court was considered by a three-Judge Bench of this Court in Ch. Ramalinga Reddy v. Superintending Engineer (1999) 9 SCC 610. This Court held in that case that if the contract is extended under the terms of the contract, compensation cannot be awarded by the arbitrator. The aforesaid judgment has been followed in another decision of this Court in Northern Railway v. Sarvesh Chopra (2002) 4 SCC 45.

8. The learned counsel for the respondent referred to the judgment rendered by this Court in K.R Raveendranathan v. State of Kerala (1998) 9 SCC 410 (1). The said decision is not applicable in the facts of the present case.

9. For the reasons aforestated, the case in hand is squarely covered by the two decisions of this Court. In the result, the order of the High Court is not tenable in law and is accordingly set aside.

10. The appeals are allowed. No costs.