- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Union Of India v. Sadhana Khanna (Smt) .
Factual and Procedural Background
The appeal challenged the Delhi High Court’s judgment dated 21-3-2000 in Civil Writ Petition No. 1311 of 2000.
The respondent joined the Central Secretariat Service on 13-7-1983 after passing the Assistants Grade Examination (October 1981) and was allocated to the finance cadre (Ministry of Finance). After completing eight years of regular service as an Assistant, she was granted a short-term promotion to Section Officer on 24-7-1991 and continued in that post.
A select list (seniority quota) for promotion to Section Officer for the year 1991 was issued on 28-5-1993. The respondent’s name was not included, although officers junior to her (including those who secured a lower rank in the Assistants Grade Examination, 1981) were included. The seniority list of Assistants issued on 1-10-1990 placed the respondent at Sl. No. 29, but several officers junior to her were promoted based on the 1991 select list. Promotion under the seniority quota was described as non-selection, based only on seniority.
Aggrieved, the respondent filed an Original Application (OA) before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT). The CAT allowed the OA by order dated 24-9-1999. The appellant then filed a writ petition before the Delhi High Court, which was dismissed, leading to the present appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the respondent could be denied inclusion in the 1991 seniority-quota select list for Section Officer on the ground that, as on 1-7-1991, she fell short of the minimum eight-year eligibility service requirement by twelve days.
- Whether, in light of Department of Personnel and Training office memorandums and the principle that seniors should be considered when juniors are eligible, the respondent was required to be considered for promotion despite the shortfall in eligibility service.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The respondent was not eligible for inclusion in the select list of 1991 because, on 1-7-1991, she was short of the minimum required eight years of service by twelve days (having joined as Assistant on 13-7-1983).
Respondent's Position (as reflected in the grievance and tribunal findings)
- The respondent complained that juniors were included in the select list while she was excluded, despite her seniority and qualification for inclusion.
- The CAT held that Department of Personnel and Training guidance contemplated consideration of seniors where juniors had completed eligibility for promotion, even if the seniors had not completed the eligibility period.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| R. Prabha Devi v. Govt. of India (1988) 2 SCC 233, (1988) 7 ATC 63 | The Department of Personnel and Training issued an office memorandum dated 19-7-1989 “soon after” this decision, stating that where juniors have completed eligibility requirements for promotion, seniors will also be considered even if they have not completed the eligibility period. | The Court relied on the office memorandum (linked to the decision) to support the view that excluding the respondent while considering juniors would be incongruous, and that she should have been considered. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court noted that eligibility was to be counted from 1-7-1983, but the respondent was offered appointment by a letter dated 5-7-1983 (i.e., after 1-7-1983). The Court attributed responsibility for this timing to the department, observing that some junior candidates had been issued appointment letters prior to 1-7-1983.
The Court further held that, in view of the Department of Personnel and Training office memorandums dated 18-3-1988 and 19-7-1989, the respondent was required to be considered for the select list even if she fell short of the eligibility period. The Court emphasized that otherwise an “incongruous situation” would arise in which a junior would be considered for promotion but a senior would not.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED: The Court found no merit in the appeal and dismissed it.
The direct effect is that the challenge to the CAT’s order (as affirmed by the Delhi High Court) failed, thereby maintaining the outcome favorable to the respondent regarding consideration consistent with the referenced office memorandums. The opinion does not indicate that any new precedent was set beyond the case’s application of the stated memorandums and the incongruity of excluding a senior when juniors are considered.
Markandey Katju, J.— This appeal has been filed against the impugned judgment of the Delhi High Court dated 21-3-2000 in Civil Writ Petition No. 1311 of 2000.
2. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
3. The facts of the case are that the respondent joined the Central Secretariat Service on 13-7-1983 after passing Assistants Grade Examination held in October 1981. The respondent was allocated to the finance cadre comprising the Ministry of Finance.
4. After completion of eight years of regular service in the grade of Assistant, the respondent was granted a short-term promotion to the grade of Section Officer on 24-7-1991. The respondent continues to work in this post till date.
5. Select list (seniority quota) for promotion to the Section Officers Grade for the year 1991 was issued on 28-5-1993. The respondent's name had not been included in this select list although the respondent was qualified to be included in the select list. Officers junior to the respondent who have secured lower rank in the Assistants Grade Examination, 1981 have been included in the select list for Section Officers, 1991.
6. The seniority list of Assistants Grade had been issued on 1-10-1990. In this list the respondent ranks at Sl. No. 29 whereas other officers of the same grade at Sl. Nos. 30, 32, 34, 25 and so on who are junior to the respondent in this seniority list have superseded the respondent and promoted as Section Officers on the basis of the select list of 1991. Promotion to the post of Section Officers from the grade of Assistant to the grade of Section Officers (seniority quota) is on non-selection basis, based only on seniority.
7. The grievance of the respondent was that her juniors were included in the select list but her name was not so included. Hence, she filed an OA before the Central Administrative Tribunal.
8. In the counter-affidavit filed before the Tribunal, the appellant herein (the respondent before the Tribunal) alleged that the respondent was not eligible for inclusion in the select list of 1991, since on 1-7-1991 she was short of the minimum eligibility service requirement of eight years by twelve days. The respondent joined as Assistant on 13-7-1983 and as such she could not be placed on the select list.
9. The Tribunal allowed the OA by its order dated 24-9-1999. In the said OA it was held that the Department of Personnel and Training had issued an office memorandum dated 19-7-1989 soon after the decision of this Court in R. Prabha Devi v. Govt. of India (1988) 2 SCC 233, (1988) 7 ATC 63 stating that where the juniors had completed the eligibility requirement of promotion then their seniors will also be considered even if they have not completed the eligibility period.
10. The appellant filed a writ petition before the Delhi High Court which was dismissed and hence this appeal.
11. It may be noted that the respondent was offered appointment vide letter dated 5-7-1983 which is after 1-7-1983 from which the eligibility was to be counted. Hence, it is the department which is to be blamed for sending the letter offering appointment after 1-7-1983. In fact, some of the candidates who were junior to the respondent were issued letters offering appointment prior to 1-7-1983. Hence it was the department which is to be blamed for this. Moreover, in view of the office memorandums of the Department of Personnel and Training dated 18-3-1988 and 19-7-1989 the respondent was also to be considered, otherwise a very incongruous situation would arise, namely, that the junior will be considered for promotion but the senior will not.
12. In view of the above there is no merit in this appeal and it is dismissed.
Alert