Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bihar Public Service Commission And Others v. Kamini And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 16, 2007
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Bihar Public Service Commission (“the Commission”) advertised on 21-12-1999 for the post of District Fisheries Officer-cum-Chief Executive Officer (Class II). The advertisement required, inter alia, a B.Sc. (Honours) in Zoology together with specified fisheries qualifications. Miss Kamini, the first respondent, held a B.Sc. (Honours) degree in Chemistry with Zoology and Botany as subsidiary subjects (1989, Tilka Manghi Bhagalpur University). Despite lacking Zoology Honours, she was erroneously called for interview on 17-10-2002. At the interview on 5-11-2002 the Commission discovered the mistake and rejected her candidature.

Upon a representation dated 6-11-2002, the Commission constituted an Expert Committee which, on 24-11-2002, opined that only a graduate who studied Zoology as the principal (Honours) subject could be called a B.Sc. in Zoology. Relying on this report, the Commission maintained the rejection.

Miss Kamini challenged the decision in CWJC No. 12618 of 2002. A learned Single Judge of the Patna High Court dismissed the petition on 1-4-2003. Her Letters Patent Appeal (LPA No. 381 of 2003) was allowed by a Division Bench on 13-5-2003, which set aside the Single Judge’s order. The Commission appealed to the Supreme Court, resulting in the present decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the educational qualification “B.Sc. (Honours) in Zoology” in the advertisement required Zoology to be the principal subject at the graduate level.
  2. Whether the Commission acted lawfully in rejecting the respondent’s candidature after initially summoning her for interview.
  3. Whether the Division Bench of the High Court erred in overruling the Single Judge by treating admission to a postgraduate fisheries course as proof of possessing the requisite Zoology qualification.
  4. Whether earlier appointments of similarly qualified candidates (in 1993) created an entitlement for the respondent under Article 14 of the Constitution.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant – Bihar Public Service Commission

  • The advertisement unequivocally required B.Sc. (Honours) with Zoology as the principal subject; a subsidiary subject is insufficient.
  • The Expert Committee’s report, based on academic criteria (eight papers for Honours versus two for subsidiary), confirmed ineligibility; courts should defer to such expert opinion.
  • The initial interview call was an inadvertent error that could not confer eligibility.
  • Isolated past deviations (1993 appointments) cannot be invoked to perpetuate illegality under Article 14.

Respondent – Miss Kamini

  • Her academic background was considered adequate by the Central Institute of Fisheries Education, Mumbai, which admitted her to and certified her in a fisheries course—this should suffice as evidence of Zoology qualification.
  • The Commission initially considered her eligible and called her for interview.
  • Two similarly situated candidates were appointed in 1993; parity of treatment is required.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
University of Mysore v. C.D. Govinda Rao, AIR 1965 SC 491; (1964) 4 SCR 575 Courts should exercise restraint in academic matters and defer to expert bodies. Relied upon to uphold the Expert Committee’s determination that only Honours graduates in Zoology are eligible.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court held that the advertisement’s wording—“B.Sc. (Honours) Zoology”—plainly demanded Zoology as the principal (Honours) subject. The respondent’s degree, with Chemistry as the Honours subject and Zoology as merely subsidiary, did not satisfy this criterion.

The Commission’s initial interview call was a clerical lapse that could not create a legal right. Upon realizing the error, the Commission acted promptly and appointed an Expert Committee, whose academic assessment was rational and entitled to deference under the principle in University of Mysore v. C.D. Govinda Rao.

The Division Bench’s “litmus test” of postgraduate admission at the Central Institute of Fisheries Education was found irrelevant; eligibility for the advertised post must be gauged strictly against the advertisement, not subsequent academic pursuits.

The Court rejected the Article 14 argument based on two appointments made in 1993. Erroneous past decisions do not mandate repetition of illegality; equality cannot be claimed to perpetuate mistakes.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; order of the Division Bench set aside; order of the learned Single Judge restored; writ petition dismissed.

Consequently, Miss Kamini remains ineligible for appointment to the advertised post, and the Commission’s interpretation of “B.Sc. (Honours) Zoology” as requiring Zoology as the principal subject stands validated. The decision reinforces judicial deference to academic expertise and clarifies that past administrative errors do not create enforceable equality rights. No new precedent on broader legal principles was established beyond application of existing doctrine.

Show all summary ...

C.K Thakker, J.— Leave granted.

2. This appeal is filed against the judgment rendered by a Division Bench of the High Court of Judicature at Patna on 13-5-2003 in Letters Patent Appeal No. 381 of 2003. By the said judgment, the Division Bench allowed the appeal filed by the respondent herein, the original petitioner and set aside the judgment of the learned Single Judge dated 1-4-2003 in CWJC No. 12618 of 2002.

3. Necessary facts leading to the filing of present appeal by the Bihar Public Service Commission (“the Commission”, for short) are that the first respondent, Miss Kamini, passed her BSc (Hons.) in the year 1989 in Chemistry with Zoology and Botany in first class from Tilka Manghi Bhagalpur University in the State of Bihar. Her principal/main subject in BSc degree was Chemistry, along with Zoology and Botany as subsidiary/optional subjects. An advertisement was issued on 21-12-1999 by the Commission inviting applications from eligible candidates for appointment to the post of District Fisheries Officer-cum-Chief Executive Officer in the pay scale of Rs 6500-10,500 in the Bihar Fisheries Service Class II. It was stated therein that the candidate must have qualifications of BSc, Zoology with a two years' diploma in Fisheries Science from Central Institute of Fisheries Education, Mumbai or a graduate degree in Fisheries Science (BFSC) from a recognised university or MSc (Inland Fisheries Administration and Management) with Zoology from the Central Institute of Fisheries Education, Mumbai. Though the first respondent was not eligible as she did not possess the requisite qualifications of BSc, Zoology, inadvertently, a letter was issued by the Commission on 17-10-2002 calling upon her to appear before the Interview Board on 5-11-2002/6-11-2002. On closer scrutiny of the marksheet, however, it was found that she was not having Honours degree in Zoology and was not eligible for the post. On 5-11-2002, therefore, when she appeared for the interview, she was informed that she was not possessing requisite educational qualifications and her candidature had been rejected. She made a representation on 6-11-2002 to the Chairman of the Commission to reconsider the decision of cancellation of her candidature. Since there were some cases of this nature, an Expert Committee was constituted by the Commission to consider a question whether a student can be called a graduate in Zoology subject if he/she has cleared the degree examination with Zoology as a subsidiary/optional subject and not as the principal subject. The Committee submitted its report on 24-11-2002. As per the said report, a student will be considered a graduate in the subject if he/she has obtained the degree in that subject at the graduate level. The first respondent, as per the said report, was found ineligible. Her cancellation was, therefore, held proper.

4. The first respondent was not satisfied with the report of the Expert Committee and challenged the said decision by filing a writ petition in the High Court of Judicature at Patna. The learned Single Judge dismissed the petition but the letters patent appeal was allowed by the High Court. The Commission has challenged the said decision of the Division Bench.

5. The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the Division Bench of the High Court was wholly wrong in allowing the appeal and in setting aside the order passed by the learned Single Judge and in ignoring the report submitted by the Expert Committee. He also submitted that even otherwise, the action of the Commission could not be said to be illegal or contrary to law. When the requisite educational qualification was BSc, Zoology, such person must have passed BSc with Zoology as principal/main subject and not as a subsidiary or optional subject. Admittedly, the first respondent had passed BSc with Chemistry as principal subject and Zoology as optional/subsidiary subject. She, therefore, could not be held qualified and the action of the Commission was in consonance with law and was legal and proper. It was also submitted that after the representation was received from the first respondent, the Commission constituted an Expert Committee for considering the grievance of the first respondent and even the Expert Committee opined that in its opinion i.e in the opinion of the Committee, a student would be called graduate in the subject if he/she has Honours in that subject at the graduate level. If the subject is subsidiary (or side subject), he/she could not be called a graduate in that subject. It was because an Honours student at the graduate level studies eight papers in that subject whereas he/she studies only two papers in subsidiary subject. In accordance with the report, the action was taken which was proper. The counsel also submitted that the learned Single Judge was wholly right in upholding the contention of the Commission that the first respondent could not be said to be BSc Honours in Zoology and dismissed the petition. The Division Bench was in error in setting aside the said order which deserves interference.

6. The learned counsel for the first respondent, on the other hand, supported the order passed by the Division Bench. He submitted that the first respondent was eligible and possessed requisite educational qualifications. It was because of her eligibility that she applied for the post of District Fisheries Officer. Even the Commission was satisfied about her qualifications and was asked to appear for interview. The counsel also submitted that the Division Bench was right in observing that the first respondent was granted admission by the Central Institute of Fisheries Education, Mumbai. Had the first respondent not possessed a Bachelor of Science degree with Zoology, the Institute would not have given her admission. It was, therefore, clear that the first respondent was treated as BSc with Zoology, she applied to the Central Institute of Fisheries Education, Mumbai, she was admitted in the Institute and also cleared the course. It was also asserted in the counter-affidavit filed in this Court by the first respondent (the original petitioner) that two similarly situated persons, namely, (i) Jai Prakash, and (ii) Shailendra Kumar had been appointed in the year 1993 though they had similar qualifications. It was, therefore, submitted that the Division Bench was right in issuing necessary directions and the appeal deserves to be dismissed.

7. Having heard learned counsel for the parties, in our opinion, the appeal deserves to be allowed. The advertisement is explicitly clear and states that the candidate must be Honours in BSc, Zoology. It is not in dispute that the first respondent has obtained BSc degree with first class but her main subject was Chemistry of eight papers of 800 marks and in addition to Chemistry, she had two papers of Zoology and Botany. In pursuance of the advertisement, which was clear, the first respondent was not eligible for the appointment to the post of District Fisheries Officer. In spite of that, she applied for the said post. True it is that initially a letter was issued by the Commission on 17-10-2002 calling upon her to appear before the Commission for interview. It was, however, a mistake on the part of the Commission. As soon as the appellant Commission realised that the first respondent was not having requisite qualifications for the post and was not eligible, her candidature was rejected. When a representation was made by the first respondent that cancellation of her candidature was not proper and that the decision should be reconsidered by the Commission, the Commission thought it fit to look into her grievance and an Expert Committee was appointed. The Expert Committee considered the question and submitted a report on 24-11-2002, inter alia, stating that in its “considered opinion”, a student would be called a graduate in the subject if he/she has Honours in the subject at the graduate level, meaning thereby that it must be the principal subject. In our opinion, such a decision could not be said to be contrary to law.

8. Again, it is well settled that in the field of education, a court of law cannot act as an expert. Normally, therefore, whether or not a student/candidate possesses requisite qualifications, should better be left to educational institutions (vide University of Mysore v. C.D Govinda Rao AIR 1965 SC 491, (1964) 4 SCR 575). This is particularly so when it is supported by an Expert Committee. The Expert Committee considered the matter and observed that a person can be said to be Honours in the subject if at the graduate level, he/she studies such subject as the principal subject having eight papers and not a subsidiary, optional or side subject having two papers. Such a decision, in our judgment, cannot be termed arbitrary or otherwise objectionable. The learned Single Judge, in our opinion, was, therefore, right in dismissing the petition relying upon the report of the Committee and in upholding the objection of the Commission. The Division Bench was in error in ignoring the well-considered report of the Expert Committee and in setting aside the decision of the learned Single Judge. The Division Bench, while allowing the appeal, observed that the “litmus test” was the admission granted to the first respondent by the Central Institute of Fisheries Education, Mumbai. According to the Division Bench, if the first respondent did not possess Bachelor of Science degree with Zoology, the Institute would not have admitted her to the said course. The Division Bench observed that not only the first respondent was admitted to the said course, she had passed it with “flying colours”. In our opinion, the Division Bench was not right in applying “litmus test” of admission of the first respondent by the Central Institute of Fisheries Education, Mumbai. The controversy before the Court was whether the first respondent was eligible for the post of District Fisheries Officer, Class II. The correct test, therefore, was not admission by the Mumbai Institution. If the requirement was of Honours in BSc with Zoology and if the first respondent had cleared BSc Honours with Chemistry, it could not be said that she was eligible to the post having requisite educational qualifications. By not treating her eligible, therefore, the Commission had not committed any illegality.

9. With regard to two instances cited by the first respondent in her counter-affidavit before this Court, it is sufficient to state that the letters patent appeal was not allowed by the Division Bench of the High Court on that ground. Even otherwise, the learned counsel for the appellant Commission is right in submitting that the cases related to remote past in 1993. He further stated that the advertisement was issued in 1999, several other candidates who had not obtained degree of BSc (Hons.) with Zoology as principal subject had applied and all of them have been treated ineligible and were not called for interview.

10. In our opinion, the submission of the learned counsel for the Commission is well founded and must be accepted. Therefore, even if in 1993, some ineligible candidates were wrongly treated as eligible, the first respondent cannot insist that she also must be treated eligible though she is ineligible. In our considered opinion, such an action cannot give rise to equality clause enshrined by Article 14 of the Constitution. It is well settled and needs no authority that misconstruction of a provision of law in one case does not give rise to a similar misconstruction in other cases on the basis of doctrine of equality. An illegality cannot be allowed to be perpetuated under the so-called “equality doctrine”. That is not the sweep of Article 14. Even that contention, therefore, has not impressed us.

11. For the foregoing reasons, the appeal deserves to be allowed and is accordingly allowed. The order passed by the Division Bench of the High Court is set aside and the order passed by the learned Single Judge is restored and the petition filed by the first respondent-original petitioner stands dismissed, however, with no order as to costs.