Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Maulana Naseeruddin Mohd. Haneefuddin v. State Of Gujarat .

Supreme Court Of India
Jul 17, 2007
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

An FIR dated 4 April 2003 was lodged with the DCP (Crime Branch), Ahmedabad, alleging that Mufti Sufiyan and Rasulkhan Party conspired in Ahmedabad and Hyderabad to murder Hindu leaders by sending young men to Pakistan for arms training. Offences under Sections 120-B, 121, 121-A, 122, 123 IPC and Sections 25(1)(b)(c), 27, 29 of the Arms Act were initially registered; Sections 3(1)(a)(b), 3(3), 4, 20, 21(2)(b), 22(3)(a)(b) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act, 2002 (POTA) were later added.

A charge-sheet against 82 persons (39 arrested, 43 absconding) was filed on 10 September 2003 in the Special POTA Court, followed by a supplementary charge-sheet on 21 January 2004 naming the present appellant, Maulana Naseeruddin, as Accused 40 (absconding). The appellant was arrested by Gujarat Police on 30 October 2004, produced before the Special Court, and remanded to judicial custody. His alleged confession under Section 32 POTA was recorded on 7 November 2004 and retracted about 40 days later.

The Special POTA Judge rejected the appellant’s bail application on 24 May 2005. The Gujarat High Court dismissed the ensuing criminal appeal, upholding the refusal of bail. The present Supreme Court appeal challenges that High Court order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant was entitled to bail despite the confessional statement recorded under Section 32 of POTA.
  2. Whether a confession that is subsequently retracted—allegedly beyond a “reasonable time”—can still be relied upon at the bail stage.
  3. Whether the absence of other incriminating material (e.g., recoveries, witness statements) warranted release on bail.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The only evidence against him is a Hindi confession neither written by him nor in a language he understands; he promptly retracted it, demonstrating it was concocted.
  • No witness or co-accused linked their acts to the appellant’s speeches; no incriminating articles were recovered during custody.
  • The prime offender in the post-Godhra violence was one “Rauf,” not the appellant; therefore, no prima facie case exists.
  • Medical records and health concerns were not adequately considered.

State's Arguments

  • The confession under Section 32 POTA is voluntary and inspires young men to undertake jihad training; no coercion is alleged or proved.
  • The retraction is belated and an afterthought, made well beyond any reasonable period.
  • Given the gravity of the offences and ongoing trial (commenced 18 January 2006), bail would be inappropriate.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted that both the Special POTA Court and the High Court had “elaborately dealt” with the case. Key aspects of its reasoning include:

  • The confession was recorded by an authorised officer under Section 32 POTA and forms part of the charge-sheet; even if retracted, it remains a piece of evidence that can be weighed at the bail stage.
  • Although POTA fixes no statutory period for retraction, it must occur within a reasonable time; a 40-day delay undermines credibility.
  • Medical concerns were addressed: the Special Court directed examination at a Civil Hospital, and experts found the appellant could be treated as an outpatient.
  • In light of the gravity of alleged offences and the investigative material, the lower courts did not err in refusing bail.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed — Bail Denied.

The Supreme Court affirmed the bail refusal orders of both the Special POTA Court and the Gujarat High Court. The Court also directed that the trial be completed expeditiously. The ruling leaves intact the reliance on a Section 32 POTA confession—despite delayed retraction—as sufficient ground to deny bail, but sets no new precedent beyond the immediate parties.

Show all summary ...

Dr. Arijit Pasayat, J.— Leave granted.

2. Challenge in this appeal is to the order passed by a Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court dismissing the criminal appeal filed by the appellant. The said appeal related to the rejection of prayer for bail in connection with Crime Register No. I-6 of 2003 registered with DCP (Crime Branch), Police Station Ahmedabad.

3. Factual position in a nutshell is as follows:

An FIR was lodged on 4-4-2003 with DCP, Police Station Ahmedabad, alleging that a conspiracy was hatched by Mufti Sufiyan and Rasulkhan Party at Ahmedabad and Hyderabad to commit murder of Hindu leaders through boys by imparting them training in arms in Pakistan. The complaint was filed for the alleged commission of offences punishable under Sections 120-B, 121, 121-A, 122, 123 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (in short “IPC”) and Sections 25(1)(b), (c), 27 and 29 of the Arms Act, 1959 (in short “the Arms Act”). Thereafter on 19-4-2003, in pursuance of report of Police Inspector, Mr M.M Vaghela, Sections 3(1)(a), (b), 3(3), 4, 20, 21(2)(b), 22(3)(a), (b) of the Prevention of Terrorism Act, 2002 (in short “POTA”) were added.

4. The charge-sheet was filed in POTA Court qua the co-accused on 10-9-2003 wherein 39 accused were shown as arrested and 43 accused as absconding. Confessional statements (28 in number) were recorded during the remand period and statements of 43 witnesses were taken. On 21-1-2004, supplementary charge-sheet was filed showing 8 accused including 7 absconding accused of first charge-sheet as arrested and 7 new accused were named as wanted and 5 statements under Section 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (in short “CrPC”) were recorded and confessional statements of 8 accused were attached.

5. The appellant filed Special Criminal Application No. 377 of 2004 in the High Court for quashing of proceedings which, according to the appellant is pending till date. The appellant was released on bail in another offence at Hyderabad on health grounds. Thereafter on 30-10-2004 he was arrested in connection with the present offence by Gujarat Police. He was produced before the Special POTA Court on 2-11-2004 and was remanded till 9-11-2004. Request for further remand was rejected and the appellant was sent to judicial custody. Charge-sheet qua the appellant was filed in the Special POTA Court on 27-1-2005. The appellant moved an application for bail being Crl. Misc. Appln. No. 762 of 2005. However, it was rejected by the learned Special (POTA) Judge, vide order dated 24-5-2005. Questioning the same, the appeal was filed before the High Court.

6. Before the High Court, it was contended that there is no evidence against the present appellant except the alleged confessional statement recorded on 7-11-2004 by the DCP. The confessional statement, it was contended, is unsustainable in law and it was neither in the language known to the appellant nor was it in his handwriting. The confessional statement was recorded in Hindi. In any event, the confessional statement was retracted by the appellant which goes to show that the said confessional statement is concocted with the sole object to involve the appellant falsely in the offence and hence no reliance should be placed on it. The appellant never provoked or instigated any youth to go to Pakistan for jihad training. The prime accused have not stated in their confessional statements of having been inspired by the speeches of the appellant and reference to the appellant was not done by any witness. During the course of police custody and remand no incriminating articles were recovered by the investigating agency. Serious acts in the aftermath of Godhra was done by Rauf and not by the appellant and in the absence of any prima facie material there was no basis for keeping him in custody.

7. The stand of the State on the other hand was that there is a confessional statement of the accused recorded under Section 32 of POTA. It is the appellant who inspired young boys to take jihad training in Pakistan. There is nothing on record to indicate that there was any coercion for giving the confessional statement. The belated retraction is nothing but an afterthought. It was not done within the time stipulated and therefore the appellant is not entitled to be released on bail.

8. The High Court found that the learned Special Court had elaborately dealt with various aspects of the case relating to the appellant. During the course of investigation confessional statement was recorded by DCP, an authorised officer under Section 32 of POTA which is part of the charge-sheet. The same was retracted after about 40 days by sending letter to the Special POTA Court through the jail authorities. According to the High Court even if the confessional statement recorded under Section 32 was retracted, same can be considered as a piece of evidence at the time of deciding the bail application. Further the retraction was not done within the stipulated time. The High Court was of the view that the learned Special Court was justified in refusing the bail application.

9. The stands taken before the High Court were reiterated before this Court. It was submitted by learned counsel for the appellant that the FIR relates to the incidents allegedly taking place between the period from April 2002 to April 2003.

10. In the FIR name of the present appellant, Maulana Naseeruddin was not indicated. Charge-sheet was filed before the POTA Court on 10-9-2003, where names of 82 persons were indicated; out of them 39 have been arrested and 43 were stated to be absconders. On 28-10-2003 confessional statements were recorded during the appellant's remand and 43 witnesses were examined under Section 164 CrPC. The appellant was arrested in terms of Section 151 CrPC and was granted bail in October 2004. On 21-1-2004 a supplementary charge-sheet was filed. The appellant's name was shown in Column 2 as Accused 40 as an absconded accused in addition to those who were originally shown as absconders. The confessional statement was purportedly recorded on 7-11-2004 in Hindi. In between, several applications had been filed but there is no mention about the then so-called retraction of confessional statement. On 27-1-2005, additional charge-sheet had been filed.

11. It was further submitted that on retraction confession cannot be treated as a relevant substantial evidence. Further, the medical records and documents were not looked into.

12. Learned counsel for the State on the other hand submitted that initially there was a petition filed under Section 482 CrPC before the Gujarat High Court and one SLP had also been filed and the same was subsequently withdrawn. The trial court's records have been sent back and the trial has commenced on 18-1-2006.

13. It is to be noted that the Special POTA Court had directed the jail authority to refer to the appellant to Civil Hospital and on advice of the expert to get him examined and if required, admit him to the Civil Hospital for the period as may be prescribed by doctors. The experts have expressed the view that he can be treated as an outdoor patient by examining him at Civil Hospital.

14. It is no doubt true that there is no time statutorily fixed during which the confessional statement, if any, can be retracted; but it has to be done within a reasonable time.

15. Considering the various factual aspects highlighted by the trial court and the High Court, we do not think this to be a fit case where bail can be granted to the appellant.

16. Order of the learned Special Court, POTA as affirmed by the High Court cannot be faulted and no interference is called for.

17. Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed. However, it would be in the interest of all concerned if the trial is completed expeditiously.