Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Arjun Singh Rathore And Others v. B.N Chaturvedi And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Oct 12, 2007
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The case concerns promotions from Category 6 to Category 7 (Scale II officers) in Kshetriya Gramin Bank. The Regional Rural Banks (Appointment and Promotion of Officers and Other Employees) Rules, 1988 governed such promotions until they were superseded by the 1998 Rules, published on 29-7-1998. By 1-4-1999 fifteen vacancies had arisen, but no promotions had yet occurred.

Although the Bank initially adopted the 1998 Rules, its sponsoring bank (Bank of Baroda) issued a directive on 15-10-1999—relying on Supreme Court precedent—that vacancies arising before the 1998 Rules must be filled under the 1988 Rules. Consequently, the Bank circulated a notice on 13-6-2000 and filled the fifteen vacancies on 18-9-2000 under the 1988 regime, promoting all fifteen appellants.

Respondents 1–5 challenged these promotions via Writ Petition No. 3641/2000. The Single Judge dismissed the petition on 25-9-2002, but a Division Bench reversed that decision on 18-8-2005, quashing the promotions and directing that future promotions be made under the 1998 Rules. The present appeal to the Supreme Court followed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether vacancies that arose before the promulgation of the 1998 Rules must be filled under the 1988 Rules or the 1998 Rules.
  2. Whether Appellant 3 (Ram Narayan Meena), against whom disciplinary proceedings were initiated after his 2000 promotion, is entitled to the same promotional benefit subject to the outcome of those proceedings.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The Supreme Court’s decision in State of Rajasthan v. R. Dayal (1997) 10 SCC 419, relying on Y.V. Rangaiah v. J. Sreenivasa Rao (1983) 3 SCC 284, establishes that vacancies must be filled under the rules in force when they arose; therefore the 1988 Rules apply.
  • The sponsoring bank’s letter dated 15-10-1999 explicitly directed compliance with this principle.
  • Because the disciplinary charge-sheet against Appellant 3 was issued in November 2005—years after his 2000 promotion—he should receive the same promotional benefit as the other appellants, subject to the final outcome of the enquiry.

Respondents’ Position

The opinion records that Respondents 6 and 7 “did not seriously dispute” the appellants’ legal position; detailed counter-arguments were not provided.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Rajasthan v. R. Dayal (1997) 10 SCC 419 Vacancies must be filled according to the rules in force at the time the vacancies occurred. Relied upon as the primary authority to conclude that the 1988 Rules govern the disputed vacancies.
Y.V. Rangaiah v. J. Sreenivasa Rao (1983) 3 SCC 284 Earlier vacancies are not affected by subsequent amendments to service rules. Cited within R. Dayal; reinforced the same principle adopted by the Court in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court reaffirmed the principle that promotions must be regulated by the rules existing when the vacancy arises. Because all fifteen vacancies arose before the 1998 Rules came into force, the 1988 Rules controlled. The Court noted that Respondents 6 and 7 offered no substantial rebuttal.

Applying this principle, the Court held that the Single Judge’s decision—upholding promotions under the 1988 Rules—was correct and should be restored. Regarding Appellant 3, the Court observed that the disciplinary proceedings commenced well after his 2000 promotion. Accordingly, he too is entitled to promotion under the 1988 Rules, with his final status contingent on the outcome of the pending enquiry.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; judgment of the Division Bench set aside and that of the Single Judge restored.

The fifteen appellants’ promotions effected on 18-9-2000 under the 1988 Rules stand validated. Appellant 3 receives the same benefit, subject to the disciplinary proceedings’ result. No costs were awarded.

Implications are confined to the parties: the decision enforces an established principle rather than creating new precedent, confirming that service vacancies are governed by the rules extant on the vacancy date.

Show all summary ...

H.S Bedi, J.— Leave granted.

2. This appeal is directed against the judgment and order of the Division Bench of the Rajasthan High Court dated 18-8-2005 setting aside the judgment of the learned Single Judge thereby allowing the writ petition filed by the respondents and further directing that promotion to the post of Scale II officers be held as per the Rules of 1998. The facts leading to the filing of the appeal are as under:

On 28-9-1988 the Department of Economic Affairs (Banking Division), Ministry of Finance, Government of India, after consultation with National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development and in exercise of the powers conferred by Section 29 of the Regional Rural Banks Act, 1976 notified the Regional Rural Banks (Appointment and Promotion of Officers and Other Employees) Rules, 1988 (hereinafter called “the Rules of 1988”) which came into force w.e.f 28-9-1988. The Second Schedule of these Rules provided for the mode of appointment to different categories of officers. The appellants herein fell in Category 6 whereas Category 7 dealt with the appointment of Area Managers or Senior Managers by promotion of officers from Category 6 and inter alia provided that all the vacancies were to be filled in by promotion from qualified and eligible persons working in the Bank and that the mode of selection would be interview and assessment of performance reports for the preceding three years' period. The Board of Directors of the respondent Kshetriya Gramin Bank adopted the Rules in a meeting held on 26-9-1988. It is the case of the appellants that by the first day of April, 1999, 15 posts in all had become available for promotion under Category 7 as no appointments had, in fact, been made for several years. While the vacancies still existed, the Regional Rural Banks (Appointment and Promotion of Officers and Other Employees) Rules, 1998 (hereinafter called “the Rules of 1998”) were framed and published in the Official Gazette on 29-7-1998. The Board of Directors of Kshetriya Bank adopted these Rules and issued a Circular dated 15-5-1999 conveying the information that the Rules of 1988 had been superseded and that henceforth the Rules of 1998 alone would form the basis for promotion, etc. Bank of Baroda which was the sponsoring Bank under the Regional Rural Banks Act of 1976 thereafter made an enquiry from the quarters concerned and on 15-10-1999 addressed a letter to the Regional Rural Banks that in view of the judgment of the Supreme Court in State of Rajasthan v. R. Dayal (1997) 10 SCC 419, “any post which had fallen vacant prior to the amendment of the Rules would be governed by the original Rules and not by the amended Rules” and in order to make matters more explicit repeated the directive by reiterating that the “posts which fell vacant prior to the publication of the amended Rules i.e Rules of 1998 would be governed by the old Promotion Rules and not by the amended Rules”. A copy of the Letter dated 15-10-1999 has been appended as Annexure P-1 to the appeal.

3. The respondent, Kshetriya Bank thereupon issued a Circular dated 13-6-2000 directing that all the vacancies which were available as on 31-3-1998 be filled in under the Rules of 1988. 15 persons, the appellants herein, were thereafter interviewed on 18-9-2000 and were found fit for promotion and the said list was also approved by the Board of Directors and all 15 appellants were accordingly promoted to Scale II under order dated 18-9-2000. Respondents 1 to 5 herein however preferred a joint Writ Petition No. 3641 of 2000 in the High Court which was dismissed by the learned Single Judge on 25-9-2002 vide judgment appended as Annexure P-2. An appeal was thereafter taken to a Division Bench which reversed the order of the Single Judge thus allowing the writ petition and directing that the promotions and the Circulars dated 13-6-2000 and 18-9-2000 respectively be quashed and further directing Kshetriya Bank to make the promotions of Scale II officers as per the Rules of 1998. It is in this circumstance that the present special leave petition has been filed.

4. Notice was issued and all the respondents have been served. However, Respondents 6 and 7 alone have put in appearance and a reply has been filed by the Chairman of the respondent Bank. We have accordingly heard the learned counsel who have appeared before us.

5. Mr Calla, the learned Senior Counsel for the appellants has argued that the matter was fully covered by the judgment of this Court in State of Rajasthan v. R. Dayal (1997) 10 SCC 419 wherein it had been held that the vacancies to be filled by promotion were to be filed under the rules which were in operation on the date when the vacancies had occurred. Relying on and referring to an earlier judgment in Y.V Rangaiah v. J. Sreenivasa Rao (1983) 3 SCC 284 it was opined as under:

“8. … This Court has specifically laid (sic) that the vacancies which occurred prior to the amendment of the Rules would be governed by the original Rules and not by the amended Rules. Accordingly, this Court had held that the posts which fell vacant prior to the amendment of the Rules would be governed by the original Rules and not the amended Rules. As a necessary corollary, the vacancies that arose subsequent to the amendment of the Rules are required to be filled in in accordance with the law existing as on the date when the vacancies arose.”

6. The above legal position has not been seriously disputed by the learned counsel for Respondents 6 and 7. We are therefore of the opinion that the vacancies which had occurred prior to the enforcement of the Rules of 1998 had to be filled in under the Rules of 1988 and as per the procedure laid down therein. We are therefore of the opinion that the judgment of the learned Single Judge needs to be restored. We order accordingly.

7. There is another aspect of the matter which needs to be taken care of. It has been brought to our notice during the course of hearing that pursuant to the order of the Division Bench the exercise for promotion under the Rules of 1998 had been carried out and that all 15 original respondents (present appellants) had appeared in the written examination and been declared successful but the result of 14 had been declared on 22-11-2005 whereas the result of one Ram Narayan Meena, Appellant 3 before us, had been kept in a sealed envelope as a disciplinary enquiry was pending against him. It has however been pointed out that Ram Narayan Meena had been subjected to a charge-sheet dated 9-11-2005 on the basis of a complaint dated 16-6-2005, that is, long after the promotions had been made under the Rules of 1988, and as such he too should be given the benefit of this judgment insofar as the promotion was concerned though subject to the outcome of the proceedings against him. We find merit in this plea as well. It needs to be highlighted that the promotion under the Rules of 1988 had been made way back in September 2000 i.e long before the complaint had been made against Ram Narayan Meena. We are therefore of the opinion that he too should be given the benefit of this judgment subject to the outcome of the disciplinary proceedings. We accordingly allow the appeal in the above terms. There will be no order as to costs.