Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sunil Kumar v. Ram Singh Gaud And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Nov 2, 2007
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.

Order

1. Leave granted.

2. Factual background of the case is that on 10-7-2003, the appellant was driving his Mini Truck No. MP 20 G 7705 towards Bargi along with one Ramesh Prajapati. When the mini truck reached Chulha Gulhai, a truck dumper bearing No. MP 18 6392 came from the opposite side, which was being driven in a rash and negligent manner and hit the mini truck of the appellant with the result that the appellant sustained grievous injuries on his leg. He suffered three fractures including one at tibia. He was examined by the Medical Board. After examining the injuries, the Board came to the conclusion that the appellant had suffered 45% permanent disability. The appellant was 29 years of age at the time of accident and was working as a driver and earning Rs 4000 per month.

3. FIR was lodged. A claim was also filed against the owner of the truck dumper as well as the insurance company before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (for short “the Tribunal”) for compensation under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1998 (for short “the Act”), inter alia, stating that in the accident, the appellant suffered fracture in his tibia and two other places. The appellant claimed Rs 8,20,000 by way of compensation.

4. The Tribunal by its order dated 25-6-2004 awarded a compensation of Rs 45,000 for the 45% permanent disability suffered by the appellant; Rs 21,000 towards the amount spent on the treatment and Rs 6000 for physical pain and mental agony suffered by the appellant. Thus, a total sum of Rs 72,000 was awarded as compensation along with interest @ 6% per annum from the date of the claim petition till payment.

5. Being aggrieved, the appellant filed an appeal in the High Court of Madhya Pradesh at Jabalpur which has been dismissed by the impugned order.

6. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant contends that as a result of the impact of injuries suffered by the appellant, the appellant cannot pursue his vocation of driving any longer and the Tribunal as well as the High Court have grossly erred in not awarding any compensation towards the loss of his earning capacity. That, keeping in view the injuries suffered by him, the compensation awarded is too low. Counsel appearing for Oriental Insurance Company Limited, Respondent 3, has supported the judgment and order passed by the courts below.

7. Learned counsel for the parties have been heard at length.

8. We find substance in the submission put forth by the counsel for the appellant. The Tribunal as well as the High Court have not awarded any compensation towards loss of future income. After the fracture of tibia, it is doubtful if the appellant can even drive again. Even if he pursues some other vocation, he would not be able to earn as much as he is earning now. The disability suffered by the appellant would surely reduce his earning capacity. Therefore, the appellant is required to be compensated for the loss of earning due to the injuries suffered by him in the accident.

9. Taking into consideration the present income of the appellant as Rs 4000 per month; and the permanent disability of 45% suffered by him, we are of the view that the capacity of the appellant to earn in future would be reduced by Rs 1800 per month approximately. If 1/3rd is deducted towards miscellaneous expenses, the loss of income comes to Rs 1200 per month which, in turn, comes to Rs 14,400 per annum. The appellant was 29 years of age at the time of accident. Taking the multiplier to be 18 (as per the Second Schedule to Section 163-A of the Act), the total loss of income comes to Rs 2,59,200.

10. For the reasons stated above, the loss of income is assessed at Rs 2,59,200. The appellant would be entitled to the aforesaid amount in addition to the sum already awarded by the Tribunal, which has been upheld by the High Court. The appellant would be entitled to interest at the same rate i.e 6% per annum on the enhanced amount as well from the date of filing of the claim petition till realisation.

11. Accordingly, the appeal is accepted and the order passed by the courts below stands modified to the extent indicated above.