- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Noorie Manure Mill, Sambhal v. Commissioner, Trade Tax, U.P .
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellants are registered dealers in both crushed bones and crushed horn and hoof under the Central Sales Tax Act as well as the U.P. Trade Tax Act. A series of State notifications between 1981 and 1986 treated “bones,” “crushed bones,” and “horn and hoof” differently for tax purposes. While fertiliser is generally exempt from trade tax, ambiguity arose as to whether crushed horn and hoof—sometimes sold to farmers as manure—should be taxed as “crushed bones.”
The Trade Tax Tribunal initially held that crushed horn and hoof were used only as manure and therefore tax-free. On 7 February 2006, the High Court reversed, reasoning that because horns and hooves were included within “bones” in the exemption notification, the exclusion of “crushed bones” necessarily included crushed horn and hoof, rendering them taxable. The High Court also directed a 25% pre-deposit of the disputed tax in related matters.
The present appeals challenge that High Court judgment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether crushed horns and hooves are “bones” or “crushed bones” within the meaning of the U.P. Trade Tax exemption notifications.
- Whether, when sold as manure/fertiliser, crushed horn and hoof qualify for exemption from trade tax.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants’ Arguments
- Crushed horn and hoof are neither “bone” nor “crushed bone” in common parlance, despite their mention in one notification.
- They are sold to farmers specifically as fertiliser, a category expressly exempt from trade tax.
- The High Court therefore erred in extending the tax exclusion applicable to “crushed bones” to include crushed horn and hoof.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| CST v. Bharat Bone Mill (2007) 4 SCC 136 | Commodity classification must follow its identity in common parlance; expert evidence may be necessary. | Referenced to note that the earlier decision did not examine the later exemption notifications, leaving the present issue open. |
| Commr., Trade Tax v. Noori Manure Mill (Tribunal decision) | Found as a fact that crushed horn and hoof were used solely as manure and therefore tax-free. | High Court overturned this factual finding; Supreme Court remitted for fresh consideration. |
| Hindustan Bone Mills (P) Ltd. v. Commr. of Trade Tax, 2005 UPTC 885 | Held that crushed bone is not fertiliser. | Cited by the High Court to support its view that crushed horn and hoof (treated as crushed bone) are taxable. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court applied the common-parlance test, emphasising that horns and hooves are not regarded as bone by lay understanding. It held that the High Court’s assumption that crushed bone “includes” crushed horn and hoof lacked statutory support and was therefore erroneous.
Conversely, the Court declined to affirm the Tribunal’s finding that crushed horn and hoof are used only as manure. No expert evidence supported that conclusion, and Notification 12-9-1986 specifically listed “horn combs and all other articles made from horn,” indicating broader commercial uses.
Given deficiencies in factual findings on both sides, the Court found it appropriate to remit the matter to the Tribunal for a de novo determination, permitting the parties to adduce additional evidence.
Holding and Implications
APPEALS ALLOWED; IMPUGNED HIGH COURT JUDGMENT SET ASIDE; MATTER REMITTED TO THE TRIBUNAL FOR FRESH ADJUDICATION.
The Tribunal must reconsider whether crushed horn and hoof are taxable, this time on a properly established factual record, including expert evidence if necessary. The prior requirement for a 25% pre-deposit of the disputed tax is waived. No broader precedent is set on the tax status of crushed horn and hoof; the issue remains open pending the Tribunal’s fresh decision.
S.B Sinha, J.— Leave granted.
2. “Horn” and “hoof” in common parlance do not come within the definition of “bone”. Horns and hooves whether can be used as fertiliser or crushed bone within the meaning of various notifications issued by the State of U.P under the U.P Trade Tax Act is the question involved in this case.
3. The appellants herein are dealers in crushed bones as also crushed horn and hoof. It is registered under the Central Sales Tax Act as also the U.P Trade Tax Act.
4. Horn and hoof, on the one hand, and bone or crushed bones, on the other, used to be treated differently by the State. In a notification issued by the State on or about 7-9-1981, “bones” were subjected to sales tax at the rate of 6%; the taxing event being sale to the consumer. By a Notification dated 30-9-1982, it was declared that no tax was to be paid on sale or purchase of bones but the same did not include crushed bones. The said Notification dated 7-9-1981 was amended to include “crushed bone” against Entry 8 which, as noticed hereinbefore, mentioned “bone”. By a Notification dated 31-1-1985, however, bone including horn and hoof but not including crushed bones were exempted from payment of tax. We may, however, notice that yet again by a Notification dated 12-9-1986, the following item was substituted in place of the original Item 32 which reads as under:
“Sl. No. Description of goods Rate of tax 1 2 3 32. Horn combs and all other articles made from horn.”
5. Indisputably, fertiliser is exempted from payment of trade tax. The question as to whether crushed bones when sold to the farmers for use as fertiliser despite the aforementioned notifications would be exigible to trade tax or not came up for consideration before this Court in CST v. Bharat Bone Mill (2007) 4 SCC 136, (2007) 3 Scale 383. Therein the effect of the aforementioned exemption notifications had not been gone into as this Court's attention had not been drawn thereto. This Court opined:
“11. Moreover, it is well known that the question as to whether a commodity would be exigible to sales tax or not must be considered having regard to its identity in common law parlance. If, applying the said test, it is to be borne in mind that if one commodity is not ordinarily known as another commodity; normally, the provisions of taxing statute in respect of former commodity which comes within the purview of the taxing statute would be allowed to operate. In any event, such a question must be determined having regard to the expert opinion in the field. We have noticed hereinabove the difference between ‘bonemeal’ and ‘crushed bone’. Different utilities of the said items have also been noticed by the Allahabad High Court itself. The High Court or for that matter, the Tribunal did not have the advantage of opinion of the expert to the effect as to whether crushed bones can be used only for the purpose of fertiliser or whether crushed bones are sold to the farmers for use thereof only as fertiliser.”
The said question was left open for subsequent cases.
6. In one of the cases, namely, Commr., Trade Tax v. Noori Manure Mill the Tribunal has arrived at the finding of fact:
“… Because on the crushed bones there is a tax liability at the rate of 6 per cent but against the crushed bones, no description of horns and bones has been made that is to say that the purpose of the Government is to charge tax on the crushed bones and not to charge tax on the crushed bones (sic hooves) and horns. This was also pleaded by the learned counsel that the crushed horns and hooves are used as manufacture (sic). And it cannot be put to any other use. The Department has not led any such evidence which may conclude that the crushed horns and hubes (sic) are used for any other purpose than the manure and that the manure is a tax-free commodity….”
7. In the appeals which were preferred thereagainst, the High Court, however, by reason of the impugned judgment dated 7-2-2006 held as under:
“… Bones including horn and hoof is exempted but crushed bones has been excluded and made taxable. When horns and hooves are included in the bones then in the exclusion part also crushed bone include crushed horn and hoof. In common parlance also, horns and hooves are considered as bones. Thus inclusion of horns and hooves in bones in the notification appears to be clarificatory only. Since crushed bone is excluded from the entry ‘bone including horn and hooves’, in my view the crushed horns and hooves being crushed bones are also deemed to be excluded. The Tribunal has also committed an error in treating crushed horns and hooves as fertiliser. In Hindustan Bone Mills (P) Ltd. v. Commr. of Trade Tax 2005 UPTC 885 this Court held that crushed bone is not a fertiliser. In this view of the matter, the order of the Tribunal is liable to be set aside and the appeal filed by the Commissioner of Trade Tax before the Tribunal is liable to be allowed.”
Following the said judgment, the High Court refused to interfere with the direction of the Tribunal for pre-deposit of 25% of the disputed amount of tax in the cases involving the other two appeals before us.
8. Mr Dhruv Agarwal, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant would submit that crushed horn and hoof being neither bone nor crushed bone, despite its mention in one of the exemption notifications, it does not lose its character to be sold as fertiliser and the High Court, therefore, was not correct in its view.
9. The High Court, in our opinion, committed a serious error in opining that crushed bone would also include crushed horn and hoof. It went on to hold that horns and hooves are considered as bone in common parlance and its inclusion in the notification “appeared to be a clarificatory one”. In absence of any definition of the term in the statute, the meaning thereof as understood in common parlance for the purpose of imposition of tax should be assigned. Animal horn and hoof cannot be a part of animal bone even in common parlance. The High Court, therefore, in our opinion clearly fell in error in arriving at the aforementioned conclusion.
10. We, however, cannot also agree with the finding of the Tribunal that crushed horn and hoof are used only as manure. No expert evidence has been obtained in that behalf. Even otherwise, in view of the Notification dated 12-9-1986, the said conclusion does not appear to be correct as combs and other articles are made out of horn.
11. We, therefore, are of the opinion that the interest of justice would be met if the impugned judgments are set aside and the matter is remitted back to the Tribunal for consideration of the matter afresh on merits. It will be open to the parties to adduce additional evidence before it. The direction of the Tribunal to deposit 25% of the disputed amount of tax is also directed to be waived. These appeals are allowed with the aforementioned observations and directions. In the facts and circumstances of this case, however, there shall be no order as to costs.
Alert