Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Talson Real Estate (P) Ltd. v. State Of Maharashtra And Others

Supreme Court Of India
May 2, 2007
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant company owns land bearing Survey No. 23/2/1 in Village Kondhwa Budruk, Taluka Haveli, District Pune, admeasuring 1 hectare and 82 ares. In 1996 the Maharashtra State Electricity Board (MSEB) requested acquisition of several parcels of land, including the appellant’s, for installation of a 132 kV sub-station. Pursuant to that request:

  • 1-4-1997: The Special Land Acquisition Officer (SLAO) issued a Section 4 notification under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894.
  • 17-4-1997: The notification was published in the Maharashtra Government Gazette and two newspapers (Kesari and Prabhat); substance was posted on-site on 30-4-1997.
  • 18-4-1998: A Section 6 declaration was issued and later published in the Gazette and two newspapers (Aaj Ka Anand and Rashtratej), and on-site.
  • 2000: Corrigenda to both the Section 4 notification and Section 6 declaration were issued and similarly published in the Gazette, newspapers, and on-site.
  • 14-6-2000: The SLAO passed an award granting Rs 73,86,740 as compensation to 84 claimants, including the appellant.

The appellant filed Writ Petition No. 726 of 2002 before the Bombay High Court challenging the acquisition and award, alleging non-compliance with Section 5-A. The High Court dismissed the petition on 24-8-2005 but granted a 12-week status-quo order. The present appeal (now granted special leave) challenges that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondents failed to comply with the mandatory requirements for publication of the Section 4 notification and Section 6 declaration under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The newspapers used for publishing the Section 4 notification (Kesari, Prabhat) and Section 6 declaration (Rashtratej, Aaj Ka Anand) were insignificant and not widely circulated in the locality, defeating statutory notice requirements.
  • The corrigendum amending Survey No. 23 (Part) was vague; the referenced survey number allegedly did not exist in land records, rendering the acquisition invalid for lack of specific identification.
  • Because the corrigendum was published on 1-6-2000 and the award followed on 14-6-2000, the appellant was denied the 30-day period under Section 5-A to file objections, depriving it of a vested right to be heard.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The publications fully complied with statutory requirements; no perversity or infirmity existed in the notifications or corrigenda.
  • Developments in the area and the appellant’s own Section 18 reference weigh against disturbing the acquisition when 83 of 84 landowners are satisfied.
  • Section 45 notice requirements are inapplicable because Sections 4 and 5-A do not mandate personal notice absent objections; the appellant never filed objections within time.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court undertook a step-by-step examination of statutory compliance:

  • Confirmed that the Section 4 notification was published in the Official Gazette, two newspapers, and on-site; similar multi-channel publication existed for the Section 6 declaration and both corrigenda.
  • Held that the appellant produced no evidence showing the cited newspapers lacked circulation in the locality.
  • Emphasised that Sections 4 and 5-A require only general—not personal—notice; Section 45 therefore does not apply where no objections were filed.
  • Clarified that the 30-day objection period under Section 5-A runs from the original Section 4 publication (17-4-1997); the appellant failed to object within that time.
  • Found the corrigenda merely clarified inclusion of the entire Survey No. 23 without altering total area or identity of affected owners; thus no new right to object arose.
  • Reasoned that owners who do not object under Section 5-A cannot later challenge the inquiry or assert invalidity of the Section 6 declaration.
  • Observed that the appellant already sought a Section 18 reference, demonstrating acceptance of acquisition while disputing compensation.
  • Concluded that the High Court’s findings were correct and that no statutory violation or prejudice to the appellant was shown.

Holding and Implications

Appeal DISMISSED. The Supreme Court affirmed the Bombay High Court’s judgment, upholding the land acquisition and associated award. The immediate consequence is that acquisition proceedings remain valid and the appellant’s only pending remedy lies in its Section 18 reference regarding compensation. The decision turns on factual compliance with publication requirements and does not announce any new legal precedent.

Show all summary ...

Judgment

1. Special leave granted.

2. This appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 24-8-2005 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Bombay whereby and whereunder the High Court has dismissed Writ Petition No. 726 of 2002 filed by the appellant-petitioner challenging the validity of land acquisition proceedings initiated by the respondents under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short “the Act”).

3. The brief facts leading to the filing of the appeal are as under:

The appellant Company herein is the owner of the suit property bearing Survey No. 23/2/1 situate in Village Kondhwa Budruk, Taluka Haveli, District Pune, admeasuring 1 hectare and 82 ares. In the year 1996, the Executive Engineer, Civil Construction Division, Maharashtra State Electricity Board, Pune (for short “MSEB”) approached the Collector, Pune, for the acquisition of the land situate in Village Kondhwa Budruk bearing Survey Nos. 23/2/1, 23/1/1/1, 23/1/2, 23/1/1, 23/1/3/1 and 23/1/2/2, total 2 hectares and 78 ares including the land of the appellant Company for public purpose, namely, to “install”/“erect” 132 kV sub-station. The Collector, Pune, accordingly, vide Order No. PLO/CR/25/96 dated 1-2-1996 forwarded the proposal of the Executive Engineer to the office of the Land Acquisition Officer, Pune, to acquire the above extent of land under the provisions of the Act. On 1-4-1997, the Special Land Acquisition Officer (SLAO) (14), Pune, issued Notification No. LAO/48/570, under Section 4 of the Act for acquisition of the abovesaid lands. The notification was published in the Maharashtra Government Gazette (MGG), Pune Division, Part I (Supplement) on 17-4-1997. Also, in compliance with the requirements of the Act, the said notification was published in two newspapers, namely, daily Kesari and daily Prabhat on 17-4-1997 and on 30-4-1997 it was published on the site. On 26-9-1997, SLAO held mandatory enquiry under Section 5-A of the Act and submitted his report to the Commissioner, Pune Division, Pune, through the Collector, Pune. Subsequent thereto, on 18-4-1998 the Additional Commissioner, Pune Division, issued a declaration under Section 6 of the Act, which was published in MGG, Pune Division, Part I (Extraordinary) dated 18-4-1998 and Part I (Supplement) dated 11-6-1998 respectively. Section 6 declaration was published in daily Aaj Ka Anand on 29-4-1998 and on 30-4-1998 it was published in daily Rashtratej and on site on 8-7-1998.

4. It appears that subsequently a corrigendum, No. LAQ/48/30/2000 was issued by SLAO (14), Pune, to the notification under Section 4 which was published in MGG, Pune Division, Part I (Supplement), Pune, on 2-3-2000 in two daily newspapers Kesari and Prabhat on 1-6-2000. Similarly, corrigendum to the declaration under Section 6 of the Act was issued by the Additional Commissioner, Pune Division, Pune, on 1-6-2000. The corrigendum to Section 6 was published in MGG, Pune Division, Part I (Supplement), Pune, on 2-3-2000 and in daily newspapers Saanz Samachar on 1-3-2000 and Samana on 1-6-2000. It appears from the record that detail of the publication of the corrigendum issued under Section 6 of the Act was published on website on 12-6-2000. The record also reveals that the general notice under Sections 4(1), 6(1), 6(2), 9(1) and 9(2) were notified on notice board at Talathi and Tehsil notice board. Details of such publication are as below:

Talathi Tehsil 1. Section 4(1) notification 30-4-1997 2-5-1997 2. Corrigendum to Section 4(1) notification 17-5-2000 22-5-2000 3. Sections 6(1), (2) notification 20-6-1998 22-6-1998 4. Corrigendum to Sections 6(1), (2) notification 17-5-2000 22-5-2000 5. Sections 9(1), (2) public notice 20-6-1998 22-6-1998 6. Corrigendum to Sections 9(1), (2) public notice 17-5-2000 22-5-2000

5. SLAO (14), Pune, finally made an award of the acquired lands bearing Survey No. 23 (Part), admeasuring 2 hectares and 78 ares and awarded a sum of Rs 73,86,740 as compensation payable to as many as 84 claimant owners of the lands including the appellant Company.

6. Feeling aggrieved, the appellant Company filed WP No. 726 of 2002 before the High Court of Judicature at Bombay seeking quashing of the acquisition proceedings and the award made by the Collector inter alia on the ground of failure of the respondents to afford an opportunity to the appellant Company to file objection and also not giving personal hearing to it under Section 5-A of the Act.

7. It appears that on 15-2-2002 while issuing notice to the respondents, the Division Bench of the High Court granted liberty to the appellant Company to file a reference application under Section 18 of the Act without prejudice to the contentions raised in the writ petition. The appellant, accordingly, filed a reference application. Finally, the Division Bench in the impugned judgment came to the conclusion that the appellant Company could not make out any justification for interference in the land acquisition proceedings initiated by the respondents and accordingly, dismissed the writ petition. However, at the request of the learned counsel for the appellant Company, status quo order for a period of 12 weeks from the date of recording of the judgment i.e 24-8-2005, was ordered. Hence, the appellant Company has filed this appeal.

8. We have heard Mr Arun Jaitley, learned Senior Advocate appearing for the appellant Company, Mr U.U Lalit, learned Senior Advocate for the State of Maharashtra and Land Acquisition Officer, Respondents 1 and 2 herein and Mr Altaf Ahmed, learned Senior Advocate for MSEB, Respondent 3.

9. Mr Jaitley contended that newspapers, namely, daily Kesari and daily Prabhat in which Section 4 notification was published as well as daily Rashtratej and daily Aaj Ka Anand in which Section 6 declaration was published are insignificant newspapers and are not widely circulated in the area where the lands were situated.

10. He contended that the amendment of Survey No. 23 (Part) brought in by the corrigendum to Section 4 of the Act is vague and the said survey number did not exist in the land records. Therefore, for want of specific identification of the land sought to be acquired, land acquisition proceedings suffered from various infirmities and illegality.

11. Mr Jaitley then contended that the appellant Company, being a person interested, ought to have been given 30 days' time to file objections to the acquisition of its land as envisaged under Section 5-A of the Act but such vested right was not afforded to the appellant as the corrigendum was published on 1-6-2000 in two daily newspapers and the award came to be made by SLAO on 14-6-2000 without waiting for the expiry of stipulated period within which objection could have been filed.

12. The learned counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, made submissions and supported the judgment of the High Court. They contended that the notification under Section 4 and declaration under Section 6 of the Act and the corrigendum issued by SLAO and Additional Commissioner, Pune respectively, did not suffer from any perversity or infirmity warranting interference by this Court in the land acquisition proceedings taken by the respondents for public purpose. They added that having regard to the developments that have taken place in that area and having regard to the reference application filed by the appellant Company under Section 18 of the Act before the Collector, this Court may not disturb the well-reasoned judgment at the instance of the appellant Company who is one of the claimant owners out of 84 claimant owners whose lands were acquired under the same notification and except for the appellant Company other claimant owners were fully satisfied with the correctness and validity of the land acquisition proceedings initiated by the respondents.

13. Having regard to the respective contentions, the question that arises for consideration is—“Whether the respondents have failed to comply with the mandatory provisions of the publication of the notification under Section 4 and declaration under Section 6 of the Act?”

14. It is not in dispute that Section 4(1) notification was published in MGG, Pune Division, Part I (Supplement) on 17-4-1997 and two daily newspapers, namely, Kesari and Prabhat on the same day. The notification was also published on site on 30-4-1997. In the schedule to the notification, survey numbers of the proposed lands with respective areas were provided in Columns 1 and 2 and the public purpose for which the lands were required was stated as installation of “132 kV sub-station”. The aforesaid notification was followed by a declaration under Section 6 of the Act issued by the Additional Commissioner, Pune Division, on 18-4-1998 which was published in MGG, Pune Division, Part I (Extraordinary) dated 18-4-1998 and Part I (Supplement) dated 11-6-1998 respectively. The declaration under Section 6 was also published in two daily newspapers Aaj Ka Anand on 29-4-1998 and Rashtratej dated 30-4-1998 as also on the site on 8-7-1998. A clarification to the notification under Section 4 by way of corrigendum was issued on 1-2-2000 by SLAO, Pune which was published in MGG, Pune Division, Part I (Supplement) dated 2-3-2000 and in two daily newspapers Kesari and Prabhat on 1-6-2000. The corrigendum was also published on the site. Similarly, corrigendum to declaration under Section 6 was issued on 16-2-2000 which was also published in MGG, Pune Division, Part I (Supplement) dated 2-3-2000 and in two daily newspapers, namely, Saanz Samachar dated 1-3-2000 and Samana on 1-6-2000. The corrigendum was also published on the site on 12-6-2000. Joint notices under Sections 4(1), 6(1), 6(2), 9(1) and 9(2) were duly published on notice board at Talathi and Tehsil notice board on the dates specified in Columns 2 and 3 of the above extracted table.

15. The essential requirements of publication of primary notification under Section 4 of the Act is to indicate the intention of the appropriate Government that the land in any locality is likely to be needed for any public purpose and for achieving the said purpose, a notification to that effect shall be published in the Official Gazette and in two daily newspapers circulating in that locality and the Collector shall call public notices of the substance of such notification to be given at convenient places in the said locality. In the present case, as noticed above, the respondents have wholly complied with the requirements of the provisions of law. The appellant Company has not brought on record any iota of evidence to show that the abovenamed newspapers are not widely circulated in the locality where the land, in question, was situated. The High Court has rightly come to the conclusion that the provisions of Section 45 of the Act will not be attracted in cases where there is no obligation cast upon the authorities to issue notice to the persons interested once it is clear that neither Section 4 nor Section 5-A of the Act contemplates any personal notice to the person interested other than the objectors for the purpose of conducting inquiry under Section 5-A of the Act. Therefore, the question of applicability of Section 45 in the case of the appellant Company would not arise at all as the appellant Company had not filed any objection under Section 5-A to the acquisition proceedings consequent to the issuance of notification under Section 4 of the Act.

16. The provisions of Section 5-A of the Act are attracted only when a person interested in any land which has been notified under Section 4(1) makes objection in writing to the Collector within 30 days from the date of the publication of the notification. The period of 30 days will have to be counted from the last day of the publication of the notification under Section 4 of the Act which, in the present case, was admittedly published in the Official Gazette on 17-4-1997 and in two daily newspapers on the same day. The substance of such notification was notified on the site on 30-4-1997. The appellant Company did not choose to file objections under Section 5-A of the Act against the acquisition of its land bearing Survey No. 23/2/1, admeasuring 1 hectare 82 ares.

17. The record placed before us would reveal that the Joint Measurement Plan supplied by TILR, Haveli, did not indicate the hissas of Survey No. 23. The owners of the hissa at the time of inquiry conducted under Section 9 of the Act by SLAO stated that the lands notified for acquisition had some built-up constructions and sheds, etc. The appellant Company was the holder of Hissa No. 23/2/1 which was a part of Survey No. 23. The subject-matter of the corrigendum issued under Section 4 on 1-2-2000 by SLAO (14) was published in MGG, Pune Division, Part I (Supplement) dated 2-3-2000 and in two daily newspapers on 1-6-2000. Had the appellant Company been diligent, it would have approached the authorities with whom the plan of the lands under acquisition was available and the appellant Company could have filed objections under Section 5-A of the Act within the time prescribed therein from the date of notification under Section 4(1) admittedly, issued on 1-4-1997 and published in the Official Gazette on 17-4-1997 and two daily newspapers on the same day. By publishing the corrigendum under Section 4 and declaration under Section 6, SLAO had not changed the survey numbers of the lands under acquisition, but the entire Survey No. 23 (Part) came to be included in the corrigendum. On perusal of the corrigendum, we find no infirmity or vagueness in the identification of the lands covered by Section 4 notification published on 17-4-1997 and declaration under Section 6 of the Act. The only insignificant clarification contained in the corrigenda was that in the notification under Section 4 and declaration under Section 6, min-survey numbers of the entire Survey No. 23 of the land were notified with the extent of the land in each min-survey number, but the total area intended to be acquired for the public purpose remained the same and all the landowners including the appellant Company were granted compensation by SLAO vide award made on 14-6-2000. Therefore, there was no obligation or requirement on the part of SLAO to give 30 days' time to the appellant Company to file objections under Section 5-A of the Act. Notification under Section 4 remained the same by which adequate and reasonable opportunity was given to the interested persons including the appellant Company, whose land was intended to be acquired, to inspect the map showing the proposed survey numbers and the area involved therein and if any person interested was aggrieved, he could have filed objections under Section 5-A of the Act and SLAO was under obligation to decide such objections in accordance with law.

18. The appellant Company, being the owner of the land, has not filed objection under Section 5-A, in principle, it must be accepted that it had no objection to Section 4 notification operating in respect of its property. Those claimant owners of the lands who have not filed objection under Section 5-A could not be allowed to contend that Section 5-A inquiry was bad and that consequently Section 6 declaration must be struck down and that then the Section 4 notification would lapse.

19. The appellant Company has failed to point out that the corrigendum issued to Section 4 notification and declaration under Section 6 of the Act, indicating Survey No. 23 (Part) in any manner has misled the appellant Company about the identity of its lands involved in the land acquisition proceedings. The respondents have followed the prescribed statutory procedures laid down in the Act, completed the acquisition proceedings which finally culminated in the making of award on 14-6-2000 by SLAO. The appellant Company admittedly, has preferred reference application under Section 18 of the Act during the pendency of the writ petition before the High Court and the said application is stated to be still under consideration of SLAO or civil court.

20. We are, therefore, not impressed by any of the submissions made on behalf of the appellant Company. We have, in view of the above discussion, not been persuaded to take a view different than the one taken by the High Court.

21. The judgment passed by the High Court is a well-reasoned judgment and the same does not require any interference in the present appeal.

22. The appeal is, accordingly, dismissed with no order as to costs.