Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of Bihar And Others v. Amrendra Kumar Mishra .

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 26, 2006
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Bihar State Subordinate Service Selection Board advertised 225 posts of Livestock Assistants in the Animal Husbandry Department. The respondent applied, was selected, and along with other successful candidates was recommended on 21-12-1992. Appointment letters were issued to 195 out of 200 recommended candidates; one such letter (Memo No. 323 dated 21-2-1992) asked the respondent to join within fifteen days. He did not join.

Claiming never to have received the letter, the respondent wrote representations to the Director, Animal Husbandry on 20-7-1994, 22-6-1995 and again in 1999/2000. The Department rejected the last representation after obtaining the Advocate-General’s opinion, asserting that the selection panel had lapsed after one year.

In 2001 the respondent filed CWJC No. 801/2001 before the Patna High Court. In 2004 the High Court, noting vacant posts and taking a sympathetic view, directed the authorities to accept his joining within four weeks. A Letters Patent Appeal was summarily dismissed on 3-3-2005.

The State filed a special leave petition. Although notice issued on 16-12-2005, the respondent was allowed to join in July 2006, subject to the Supreme Court’s final decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, after the expiry of one year from the preparation of the select list, the respondent retained any enforceable right to appointment.
  2. Whether the High Court could issue a writ of mandamus directing appointment on grounds of sympathy despite the lapse of the panel and the respondent’s prolonged inaction.

Arguments of the Parties

State/Appellant’s Arguments

  • The select panel was valid for only one year; once it lapsed no appointment could be made without a fresh requisition/advertisement.
  • The respondent’s alleged representations of 1994, 1995 and 2000 were not traceable in departmental records.
  • The High Court’s direction was based solely on sympathy and ignored binding precedent limiting appointments from expired panels.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • He never received the original appointment letter and therefore could not join within the stipulated fifteen days.
  • Candidates junior to him had been appointed; fairness demanded that he also be allowed to join against existing vacancies.
  • Vacancies continued to exist, as acknowledged before the High Court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Madan Lal v. State of J&K, (1995) 3 SCC 486 Select list is exhausted once notified vacancies are filled; excess candidates are merely wait-listed. Reiterated that appointments cannot exceed the vacancies requisitioned/advertised.
State of U.P. v. Harish Chandra, (1996) 9 SCC 309 A select list under statutory rules subsists only for one year from its preparation. Used to conclude that the respondent’s right, if any, expired after one year.
Surinder Singh v. State of Punjab, (1997) 8 SCC 488 Waiting lists are not perennial sources of recruitment; no vested right accrues beyond notified vacancies. Supported the view that the respondent had no enforceable claim once the list lapsed.
Gujarat State Dy. Executive Engineers’ Assn., 1994 Supp (2) SCC 591 Explained limited purpose and duration of waiting lists in service jurisprudence. Cited (through Surinder Singh) to reinforce that waiting lists cannot be used indefinitely.
Prem Singh, (1996) 4 SCC 319 Fact-specific decision on waiting lists; distinguished in later cases. Referred to show the limits of relying on earlier sympathetic rulings.
Maruti Udyog Ltd. v. Ram Lal, (2005) 2 SCC 638 Courts cannot override statutory provisions out of sympathy. Relied upon to caution against sympathetic orders contrary to law.
A. Umarani v. Registrar, Coop. Societies, (2004) 7 SCC 112 Misplaced sympathy cannot justify orders lacking legal foundation. Quoted to emphasize that mandamus cannot issue where no legal right exists.
Teri Oat Estates (P) Ltd. v. U.T., Chandigarh, (2004) 2 SCC 130 Sympathy or sentiment is not a ground for orders contrary to statute. Used to underline that extraordinary jurisdiction cannot defeat statutory limits.
Latham v. Richard Johnson & Nephew Ltd., (1911-13) All ER 117 Courts must not let sympathy affect legal judgment. Cited illustratively within the discussion on sympathy.
Ramakrishna Kamat v. State of Karnataka, (2003) 3 SCC 374 Regularisation cannot be ordered merely on sympathetic grounds absent legal entitlement. Further authority that sympathy cannot substitute for legal right.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted that the advertisement was issued in 1987 and the select list prepared in 1992. By settled law, the life of such a panel is only one year. After that period, no appointment can be made unless the Government extends the panel or issues a fresh requisition. The respondent, despite knowing in 1994 that juniors had joined, waited until 2001 to seek judicial relief. Thus, any putative right had long since extinguished.

Citing Madan Lal, Harish Chandra and Surinder Singh, the Court held that even a waiting list must be acted upon strictly in accordance with the advertisement and cannot remain operative indefinitely. The Court also invoked Maruti Udyog and related cases to stress that sympathy cannot justify a writ of mandamus in the absence of a legal right.

Although the High Court relied on the existence of some vacancies, the Supreme Court observed that vacancies arising after the panel’s expiry could not be filled from that panel. Postal despatch of the original appointment letter raised a statutory presumption of service; even if there was delay, it did not revive an expired right. Consequently, the High Court’s order, based solely on sympathy, was legally unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; High Court judgment set aside.

Direct consequences:

  • The respondent’s appointment pursuant to the High Court’s order stands invalidated, though the Court directed that no recovery be made for the period during which he actually worked.
  • No costs were awarded.

Broader implications: The decision reaffirms that courts cannot compel appointments from expired select lists and that sympathy cannot override statutory limits on the validity of panels or waiting lists. It underscores that mandamus issues only where a clear legal right exists.

Show all summary ...

S.B Sinha, J.— Leave granted.

2. The Bihar State Subordinate Service Selection Board issued an advertisement for appointment on 225 posts of Livestock Assistants in the Animal Husbandry Department. The respondent herein pursuant to or in furtherance of the said advertisement applied therefor. He was declared successful. On or about 21-12-1992, the respondent herein along with other successful candidates had been recommended by the Board. Appointment letters were issued to 195 successful candidates, out of the 200 candidates recommended by the Commission. By Memo. No. 323 dated 21-2-1992 (sic), an appointment letter was sent to the respondent asking him to join the post within fifteen days. He failed to join. Allegedly, on 20-7-1994, he requested Director, Department of Animal Husbandry, to issue an appointment letter to him, stating:

“I came to know that the Department had appointed maximum candidates till date and the appointment proceeding is going on for the remaining advertised 225 posts. My serial number is more above in the recommended merit list and persons junior to me have been appointed but I have not received any appointment letter till date for my joining. During the period of enquiry, I have come to know that the appointment letters of the selected candidates have been forwarded, whereas I have not received appointment letter till now.
In the above facts and circumstances, I, therefore, request you to kindly pass the appropriate order immediately for giving me appointment letter.”

3. No reply thereto was allegedly given. He did not take any steps in regard thereto and only on 22-6-1995, he again requested the Director of Animal Husbandry to issue him an appointment letter in order to enable him to join the said post, stating:

“With respect, it is to say with regard to earlier application dispatched by me in the aforesaid subject-matter that in the light of the subject-matter, advertisement by the Bihar Public Service Commission, I had been recommended for appointment.
It comes to know that the Department had appointed maximum candidates but till date, I have not received my appointment letter. I have been reminding the Department for a very long period but I have not received any appointment letter by the Department till date.”

4. A notice on similar terms was issued by him in the year 2000. As his prayer was not acceded to, he filed a writ petition in the High Court of Judicature at Patna, which was marked as CWJC No. 801 of 2001. The State in its counter-affidavit categorically raised a contention that the panel remained valid only for one year. It was contended that the purported representations made by him in the years 1994, 1995 and 2000 were not available in the Department, stating:

“That it is further stated that in the month of December 1999, the petitioner had submitted another representation in this Department, the case of the petitioner was referred to the Law Department, Government of Bihar, for opinion and the opinion of the learned Advocate General, Bihar was also sought and tendered. In the light of the opinion given by the Law Department/learned Advocate General, the representation of the petitioner was rejected vide Annexure 5 of the writ application.”

5. The said writ petition was taken up for hearing in 2004. The High Court allowed the same, stating:

“While hearing the matter on 29-6-2004 I had verbally asked learned GP 6 to find out as to whether any post of Pashudhan Sahayak is vacant pursuant to which a supplementary counter-affidavit has been filed. In para 56 of the affidavit it is stated that some posts of Pashudhan Sahayak are vacant in the office. Since the petitioner was already selected for this post and he could not report his joining due to some unavoidable circumstances, in my opinion, his case should be considered for the post of Pashudhan Sahayak which is still vacant.
In the given facts and circumstances of the case, therefore, the authorities concerned are directed to accept the joining of the petitioner on the post of Pashudhan Sahayak pursuant to his selection vide order as contained in Annexure 2 within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt/production of a copy of this order.”

6. A letters patent appeal preferred by the appellants was summarily dismissed by an order dated 3-3-2005.

7. A notice was issued by this Court on 16-12-2005. Despite pendency of the special leave petition, the respondent was permitted to join his services in July 2006 subject to the decision of this Court in this matter.

8. The post was advertised in the year 1987. The selection process was completed in the year 1992. It may or may not be that the respondent herein had actually received his appointment letter. It was, however, expected that he would make enquiries thereabout; particularly when on his own showing those who were below him in the selection list had already been permitted to join. Admittedly, he came to know thereabout in 1994. He allegedly filed a representation and although no reply thereto was given, he did not take any step soon thereafter. He filed another representation only in 1995. He filed the writ petition after a long period i.e in 2001 when his purported representation filed in the year 1999 was rejected.

9. In the aforementioned situation, in our opinion, he did not have any legal right to be appointed. Life of a panel, it is well known, remains valid for a year. Once it lapses, unless an appropriate order is issued by the State, no appointment can be made out of the said panel.

10. In Madan Lal v. State of J&K (1995) 3 SCC 486, (1995) 29 ATC 603 this Court held:

“It is easy to visualise that if requisition is for 11 vacancies and that results in the initiation of recruitment process by way of advertisement, whether the advertisement mentions filling up of 11 vacancies or not, the prospective candidates can easily find out from the Office of the Commission that the requisition for the proposed recruitment is for filling up 11 vacancies. In such a case a given candidate may not like to compete for diverse reasons but if requisition is for larger number of vacancies for which recruitment is initiated, he may like to compete. Consequently the actual appointments to the posts have to be confined to the posts for recruitment to which requisition is sent by the Government. In such an eventuality, candidates in excess of 11 who are lower in the merit list of candidates can only be treated as wait-listed candidates in order of merit to fill only the 11 vacancies for which recruitment has been made, in the event of any higher candidate not being available to fill the 11 vacancies, for any reason. Once the 11 vacancies are filled by candidates taken in order of merit from the select list that list will get exhausted, having served its purpose.”

11. In State of U.P v. Harish Chandra (1996) 9 SCC 309 this Court stated the law in the following terms:

“9. Coming to the merits of the matter, in view of the statutory rules contained in Rule 26 of the Recruitment Rules the conclusion is irresistible that a select list prepared under the Recruitment Rules has its life only for one year from the date of the preparation of the list and it expires thereafter.”

12. Yet again in Surinder Singh v. State of Punjab (1997) 8 SCC 488 this Court stated the law thus:

“15. Prem Singh case (1996) 4 SCC 319 was decided on the facts of that case and those facts do not hold good in the present case. In the case of Gujarat State Dy. Executive Engineers' Assn. 1994 Supp (2) SCC 591, (1994) 28 ATC 78 this Court has explained the scope and intent of a waiting list and how it is to operate in service jurisprudence. It cannot be used as a perennial source of recruitment filling up the vacancies not advertised. The Court also did not approve the view of the High Court that since vacancies had not been worked out properly, therefore, the candidates from the waiting list were liable to be appointed. Candidates in the waiting list have no vested right to be appointed except to the limited extent that when a candidate selected against the existing vacancy does not join for some reason and the waiting list is still operative.”

13. The decisions noticed hereinbefore are authorities for the proposition that even the wait list must be acted upon having regard to the terms of the advertisement and in any event cannot remain operative beyond the prescribed period.

14. It may be true that the appointment letter was sent by ordinary post but even in relation thereto a statutory presumption arises. It is also well known that postal delay by itself may not be a ground to take a sympathetic view.

15. In Maruti Udyog Ltd. v. Ram Lal (2005) 2 SCC 638 it was observed:

“44. While construing a statute, ‘sympathy’ has no role to play. This Court cannot interpret the provisions of the said Act ignoring the binding decisions of the Constitution Bench of this Court only by way of sympathy to the workmen concerned.
45. In A. Umarani v. Registrar, Coop. Societies (2004) 7 SCC 112 this Court rejected a similar contention upon noticing the following judgments:
‘68. In a case of this nature this Court should not even exercise its jurisdiction under Article 142 of the Constitution of India on misplaced sympathy.
69. In Teri Oat Estates (P) Ltd. v. U.T, Chandigarh (2004) 2 SCC 130 it is stated:
“36. We have no doubt in our mind that sympathy or sentiment by itself cannot be a ground for passing an order in relation whereto the appellants miserably fail to establish a legal right. It is further trite that despite an extraordinary constitutional jurisdiction contained in Article 142 of the Constitution of India, this Court ordinarily would not pass an order which would be in contravention of a statutory provision.
37. As early as in 1911, Farwell, L.J in Latham v. Richard Johnson & Nephew Ltd. (1911-13) All ER Rep 117, (1913) 1 KB 398 observed: (All ER p. 123 E)
‘We must be very careful not to allow our sympathy with the infant plaintiff to affect our judgment. Sentiment is a dangerous will o’ the wisp to take as a guide in the search for legal principles.' ”
70. Yet again, recently in Ramakrishna Kamat v. State of Karnataka (2003) 3 SCC 374 this Court rejected a similar plea for regularisation of services stating:
“We repeatedly asked the learned counsel for the appellants on what basis or foundation in law the appellants made their claim for regularisation and under what rules their recruitment was made so as to govern their service conditions. They were not in a position to answer except saying that the appellants have been working for quite some time in various schools started pursuant to resolutions passed by Zila Parishads in view of the government orders and that their cases need to be considered sympathetically. It is clear from the order of the learned Single Judge and looking to the very directions given, a very sympathetic view was taken. We do not find it either just or proper to show any further sympathy in the given facts and circumstances of the case. While being sympathetic to the persons who come before the court the courts cannot at the same time be unsympathetic to the large number of eligible persons waiting for a long time in a long queue seeking employment.” ' ”

16. In the facts and circumstances of this case, in our opinion, the High Court should not have allowed the respondent herein to join his services only on the basis of sympathy.

17. It is now also well settled that in absence of any legal right, the Court should not issue a writ of or in the nature of mandamus on the basis of sympathy.

18. We, therefore, are of the opinion that the High Court committed a manifest error in allowing the writ petition of the respondent. It is set aside accordingly. The appeal is allowed. However, no recovery shall be made for the period he has actually worked. No costs.