Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of Punjab And Others v. Ganpat Raj .

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 12, 2006
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent (original writ petitioner) filed Civil Writ Petition No. 943 of 2000 before the Punjab and Haryana High Court seeking a writ of mandamus directing the present appellants (State authorities) to pay 18% interest on delayed pensionary dues, including arrears of pension, DGRC, commutation of pension and GPF.

The High Court referred the matter to a Lok Adalat. Despite the appellants’ written statement contesting the claim, the Lok Adalat, on 4-3-2003, granted the respondent 12% interest without any settlement or compromise between the parties.

Challenging that order, the appellants filed Writ Petition No. 16246 of 2004 before the High Court. Although the High Court acknowledged that disposal by the Lok Adalat was inappropriate, it dismissed the appellants’ writ on the ground that the respondent was entitled to relief on merits. The appellants then approached the Supreme Court in the present civil appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under Section 20 of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, a Lok Adalat can dispose of a case on merits in the absence of a compromise or settlement between the parties.
  2. If such disposal is impermissible, whether the writ petition before the High Court ought to be restored for adjudication in accordance with law.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The Lok Adalat lacked jurisdiction to decide the writ petition because Section 20 of the Act confines its power to disposal by “compromise or settlement” only.
  • Since no compromise or settlement was reached, the award of interest by the Lok Adalat was void, necessitating restoration of the writ petition.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Even if the Lok Adalat’s procedure was defective, the High Court correctly sustained the ultimate result, as the respondent was substantively entitled to interest on delayed pensionary benefits.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Punjab v. Phulan Rani, (2004) 7 SCC 555 Illustration of how simple matters can become unnecessarily complicated, leading to delay. Invoked to highlight that the present dispute, like the earlier one, had been needlessly protracted.
NFU Development Trust Ltd., Re, (1973) 1 All ER 135; (1972) 1 WLR 1548 (Ch D) Defines “compromise” as mutual adjustment and not a total surrender. Used to elucidate the meaning of “compromise” in Section 20, reinforcing that a Lok Adalat may act only where mutual concessions exist.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court examined Section 20 of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987. Sub-section (3) expressly authorises a Lok Adalat to “dispose of the case or matter and arrive at a compromise or settlement between the parties.” Likewise, sub-section (5) contemplates a return of the case to the referring court when “no compromise or settlement could be arrived at.”

Drawing upon the accepted legal meanings of “compromise” and “settlement,” the Court emphasized that both terms presuppose mutual agreement. Because the parties in the present matter reached no such agreement, the Lok Adalat’s award of 12% interest amounted to an exercise of jurisdiction that the statute does not confer.

The High Court, having itself acknowledged the procedural impropriety, should have restored Civil Writ Petition No. 943 of 2000 instead of sustaining the Lok Adalat’s decision on merits. The Supreme Court therefore concluded that the High Court’s judgment was unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; Impugned Judgment Set Aside.

Civil Writ Petition No. 943 of 2000 is restored to its original position before the Punjab and Haryana High Court, which is requested to decide it within three months of receiving the Supreme Court’s order. No costs were awarded.

Implications: The ruling reiterates that a Lok Adalat’s power is confined to cases where parties reach a compromise or settlement; it cannot adjudicate disputes on merits in the absence of such agreement. While the decision directly affects only the parties, it reinforces statutory limits on Lok Adalats’ jurisdiction, thereby guiding lower courts and quasi-judicial forums in future referrals.

Show all summary ...

Arijit Pasayat, J.— Leave granted.

2. As noted by this Court in State of Punjab v. Phulan Rani (2004) 7 SCC 555, a simple matter has unnecessarily been complicated as a result of which there has been inordinate delay in disposing of the matter.

3. The respondent filed Civil Writ Petition No. 943 of 2000 in the Punjab and Haryana High Court praying, inter alia, to issue a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the present appellants to pay interest @ 18% on delayed payment of pension, arrears of pension, DGRC, computation of pension and arrears of GPF and other retirement benefits. The writ petition was sent to the Lok Adalat for settlement being a pension matter and the matter was allowed on 4-3-2003 without any settlement or compromise between the parties. It is to be noted that the appellants contested the claim and filed written statement to the writ petition. The Lok Adalat awarded 12% interest for the delayed payments. A writ petition was filed by the appellants before the Punjab and Haryana High Court challenging the order dated 4-3-2003 passed by the Lok Adalat in Civil Writ Petition No. 943 of 2000. The same was dismissed holding that the petition was misconceived. Though the High Court accepted that the disposal by the Lok Adalat was not the proper course, yet it was held that on merits the respondent was entitled to relief.

4. In support of the appeal, learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the matter could not have been disposed of by the Lok Adalat in view of the specific provisions contained in Section 20 of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 (in short “the Act”).

5. Per contra learned counsel for the respondent submitted that the High Court has rightly proceeded on the basis that even if the matter could not have been disposed of by the Lok Adalat, there is nothing wrong in the ultimate result holding that the respondent was entitled to relief.

6. The matters which can be taken up by the Lok Adalat for disposal are enumerated in Section 20 of the Act which reads as follows:

“20. Cognizance of cases by Lok Adalats.—(1) Where in any case referred to in clause (i) of sub-section (5) of Section 19,
(i)(a) the parties thereof agree; or
(b) one of the parties thereof makes an application to the court,
for referring the case to the Lok Adalat for settlement and if such court is prima facie satisfied that there are chances of such settlement; or
(ii) the court is satisfied that the matter is an appropriate one to be taken cognizance of by the Lok Adalat,
the court shall refer the case to the Lok Adalat:
Provided that no case shall be referred to the Lok Adalat under sub-clause (b) of clause (i) or clause (ii) by such court except after giving a reasonable opportunity of being heard to the parties.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, the authority or committee organising the Lok Adalat under sub-section (1) of Section 19 may, on receipt of an application from any one of the parties to any matter referred to in clause (ii) of sub-section (5) of Section 19 that such matter needs to be determined by a Lok Adalat, refer such matter to the Lok Adalat, for determination:
Provided that no matter shall be referred to the Lok Adalat except after giving a reasonable opportunity of being heard to the other party.
(3) Where any case is referred to a Lok Adalat under sub-section (1) or where a reference has been made to it under sub-section (2), the Lok Adalat shall proceed to dispose of the case or matter and arrive at a compromise or settlement between the parties.
(4) Every Lok Adalat shall, while determining any reference before it under this Act, act with utmost expedition to arrive at a compromise or settlement between the parties and shall be guided by the principles of justice, equity, fair play and other legal principles.
(5) Where no award is made by the Lok Adalat on the ground that no compromise or settlement could be arrived at between the parties, the record of the case shall be returned by it to the court, from which the reference has been received under sub-section (1) for disposal in accordance with law.
(6) Where no award is made by the Lok Adalat on the ground that no compromise or settlement could be arrived at between the parties, in a matter referred to in sub-section (2), that Lok Adalat shall advise the parties to seek remedy in a court.
(7) Where the record of the case is returned under sub-section (5) to the court, such court shall proceed to deal with such case from the stage which was reached before such reference under sub-section (1).”

7. The specific language used in sub-section (3) of Section 20 makes it clear that the Lok Adalat can dispose of a matter by way of a compromise or settlement between the parties. Two crucial terms in sub-sections (3) and (5) of Section 20 are “compromise” and “settlement”. The former expression means settlement of differences by mutual concessions. It is an agreement reached by adjustment of conflicting or opposing claims by reciprocal modification of demands. As per Termes de la Ley, “compromise is a mutual promise of two or more parties that are at controversy”. As per Bouvier it is “an agreement between two or more persons, who, to avoid a law suit, amicably settle their differences, on such terms as they can agree upon”. The word “compromise” implies some element of accommodation on each side. It is not apt to describe total surrender. (See NFU Development Trust Ltd., Re (1973) 1 All ER 135, (1972) 1 WLR 1548 (Ch D)). A compromise is always bilateral and means mutual adjustment. “Settlement” is termination of legal proceedings by mutual consent. The case at hand did not involve compromise or settlement and could not have been disposed of by the Lok Adalat. If no compromise or settlement is or could be arrived at, no order can be passed by the Lok Adalat. Therefore, the disposal of Civil Writ Petition No. 943 of 2000 filed by the respondent is clearly impermissible.

8. What was challenged in Writ Petition No. 16246 of 2004 to which this appeal relates related to the powers of disposal of cases by the Lok Adalats. In view of the findings recorded that the matter could not have been disposed of by the Lok Adalat, the High Court ought to have directed restoration of the writ petition filed by the respondent i.e Civil Writ Petition No. 943 of 2000 for disposal in accordance with law.

9. The inevitable result is that the appeal has to be allowed. The impugned judgment is set aside. It cannot be lost sight of that the matter is pending for long. Let Civil Writ Petition No. 943 of 2000 be restored to its original position. The High Court is requested to dispose of the writ petition within a period of three months from the date of receipt of this order. The appeal is allowed in the aforesaid terms with no order as to costs.