Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jain Studios Ltd. Through Its President v. Shin Satellite Public Co. Ltd. .

Supreme Court Of India
Jul 11, 2006
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicant filed a review petition challenging the order dated 31-1-2006 in Shin Satellite Public Co. Ltd. v. Jain Studios Ltd. in which the nominee of the Hon’ble Chief Justice of India had appointed a sole arbitrator under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The applicant sought (i) restoration of the original arbitration petition for fresh consideration and (ii) permission to nominate Hon’ble Mr Justice Satpal, retired Judge of the Punjab & Haryana High Court, as one of three arbitrators to be constituted under the UNCITRAL rules. Notice of the review petition was issued on 4-5-2006 and the matter was heard on 11-5-2006.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a review petition is maintainable against an order made by the Chief Justice of India or his nominee under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
  2. Whether the earlier order appointing a sole arbitrator should be reviewed to correct alleged factual errors and to permit the constitution of a three-member arbitral tribunal in accordance with the UNCITRAL rules.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The impugned order contains two apparent errors: it wrongly records that the applicant agreed to arbitration in London or Singapore; and it fails to provide for a three-member tribunal as required by Article 5 of the UNCITRAL rules.
  • Because the respondent failed to appoint an arbitrator within 15 days of notice, three arbitrators should have been appointed.
  • Article 137 of the Constitution empowers the Supreme Court to review its own orders; therefore the present petition is maintainable.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The review petition is not maintainable; Section 11(7) of the Arbitration Act renders the earlier decision “final,” and SBP & Co. v. Patel Engineering Ltd. classifies the Section 11 function as judicial but does not contemplate review.
  • The applicant is merely re-arguing points already rejected, using the review jurisdiction as a dilatory tactic.
  • Allowing the petition would amount to an impermissible rehearing of the original matter.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
SBP & Co. v. Patel Engineering Ltd. (2005) 8 SCC 618 The function performed by the Chief Justice or his nominee under Section 11 is “judicial,” though the decision is declared “final” by Section 11(7). Used to affirm that because the function is judicial, an order under Section 11(6) is subject to the Supreme Court’s constitutional power of review under Article 137.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Maintainability of Review: Relying on SBP & Co. and Article 137 of the Constitution, the Court held that an order passed by the Chief Justice of India or his nominee under Section 11(6) is an “order” amenable to review. The preliminary objection to maintainability was therefore rejected.

Correction of Factual Error: The respondent did not dispute that the earlier order incorrectly recorded the applicant’s stance on the place of arbitration. The Court directed that this mistake be rectified.

Substantive Relief Sought: The Court emphasized that review jurisdiction is limited and cannot be used as a “second innings.” The applicant had already sought appointment of its own arbitrator during the original hearing, and that request had been refused. Re-litigating the same issue under the guise of review was impermissible. The Court reiterated that review is not equivalent to an appeal and may be exercised only in exceptional circumstances, which were absent here.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The review petition is partly allowed to the limited extent of correcting the factual error regarding the applicant’s position on the place of arbitration; the principal prayer for reconsideration of the earlier order and for appointment of a three-member tribunal is rejected. No order as to costs.

Implications: The decision leaves the appointment of a sole arbitrator intact, thereby allowing the arbitral proceedings to proceed without further delay. The Court’s reasoning affirms that while orders under Section 11(6) are judicial and therefore reviewable, the scope of such review remains narrow, preserving finality and discouraging repetitive litigation.

Show all summary ...

C.K Thakker, J.— The present review petition is filed against an order dated 31-1-2006 passed in Shin Satellite Public Co. Ltd. v. Jain Studios Ltd. (2006) 2 SCC 628 The prayer is to review the said order and restore the arbitration petition to the file for reconsideration. A further prayer is made to permit the applicant to nominate the Hon'ble Mr Justice Satpal, Retired Judge, High Court of Punjab and Haryana as one of the arbitrators.

2. Notice was issued by me on 4-5-2006 making it returnable on 11-5-2006. On returnable date, the parties were heard.

3. It is not necessary to narrate the facts in detail in the present review petition since they had been stated in the main order. It was submitted by the learned counsel for the applicant that there were two obvious errors in the order wherein it was observed as if the applicant (the respondent in the arbitration petition) submitted that the arbitration may be held in London or in Singapore where the arbitration proceedings were going on between the parties and the applicant had no objection if the matter was referred to arbitration in London or in Singapore.

4. On merits, it was submitted by the learned counsel for the applicant that the dispute between the parties under the agreement was to be finally resolved by arbitration under the rules of UNCITRAL. Article 5 relates to composition of the Arbitral Tribunal and provides that if the parties had not previously agreed to the number of arbitrators and if within fifteen days after the receipt by the respondent of the notice of arbitration, the parties had not agreed that there should be only one arbitrator, three arbitrators should be appointed. According to the applicant, Shin Satellite, through its advocate, served a notice and called upon the applicant herein to appoint an arbitrator but no appointment was made by the applicant. On that eventuality, submitted the counsel, three arbitrators ought to have been appointed. It is not disputed that the applicant contested the matter urging that there was no legal and valid arbitration agreement between the parties. It is also not disputed that in the light of the objection by the applicant herein, an application was made by Shin Satellite to the Hon'ble the Chief Justice of India for appointment of arbitrator under sub-section (6) of Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (“the Act” for short) and as a nominee of the Hon'ble the Chief Justice of India, by an order dated 31-1-2006 (2006) 2 SCC 628, I allowed the application and appointed Hon'ble Mr Justice M.L Pendse, Retired Judge as the sole arbitrator. The counsel, however, submitted that as per UNCITRAL Model, three arbitrators ought to have been appointed. To that extent, therefore, the order deserves to be reviewed and an appropriate order requires to be passed for appointment of three arbitrators.

5. The learned counsel for the respondent contested the review petition. He raised a preliminary objection that the review petition is not maintainable and it is liable to be dismissed on that ground alone. He submitted that there is no inherent power of review in a court or in any other authority. Such power must be conferred expressly by a statutory provision. It is also submitted that the judgment of a larger Bench of this Court in SBP & Co. v. Patel Engg. Ltd. (2005) 8 SCC 618 makes it clear that the power exercised by the Chief Justice of a High Court or his nominee or by the Chief Justice of India or his nominee under sub-section (6) of Section 11 of the Act is “judicial”. Relying on sub-section (7) of Section 11 of the Act, the counsel submitted that the decision of the Chief Justice or his nominee is “final” and no review lies against such order.

6. On merits, it was submitted that the applicant seeks to reagitate the same point which was advanced at the time of hearing. A prayer was made when the main matter was argued that the applicant may be granted time to make the appointment of an arbitrator but the prayer was rejected. By invoking review jurisdiction, virtually the same prayer has been made, which was expressly negatived earlier. The learned counsel submitted that the review is yet another dilatory tactic adopted by the applicant who is not interested in speedy resolution of dispute between the parties. He, therefore, submitted that the review application may be dismissed with costs.

7. So far as the maintainability of review petition is concerned, in my opinion, the preliminary objection raised by the learned counsel for the respondent is not well founded. In Patel Engg. Ltd. (2005) 8 SCC 618 this Court by a majority of 6:1 held the function performed by the Chief Justice of a High Court or his nominee or by the Chief Justice of India or his nominee to be a “judicial” one. Once the function performed by the Chief Justice of India or his nominee is held to be judicial, it cannot be contended that an application for review of an order passed by the Chief Justice of India or his nominee is not maintainable. In my opinion, the learned counsel for the applicant is right in relying upon Article 137 of the Constitution which reads thus:

“137. Review of judgments or orders by the Supreme Court.—Subject to the provisions of any law made by Parliament or any rules made under Article 145, the Supreme Court shall have power to review any judgment pronounced or order made by it.”

8. An order passed by the Chief Justice of India or his nominee under Section 11(6) of the Act is indeed an “order” within the meaning of Article 137 of the Constitution and is subject to review under the aforesaid provision.

9. I accordingly hold the review petition to be maintainable and proceed to consider it on merits.

10. Regarding correction of errors shown by the applicant, the learned counsel for the opponent does not dispute the position and accordingly the submission is accepted by observing that it was not the case of the applicant herein (the respondent in the main matter), that arbitration be held in London or in Singapore. The mistake is ordered to be corrected accordingly.

11. So far as the grievance of the applicant on merits is concerned, the learned counsel for the opponent is right in submitting that virtually the applicant seeks the same relief which had been sought at the time of arguing the main matter and had been negatived. Once such a prayer had been refused, no review petition would lie which would convert rehearing of the original matter. It is settled law that the power of review cannot be confused with appellate power which enables a superior court to correct all errors committed by a subordinate court. It is not rehearing of an original matter. A repetition of old and overruled argument is not enough to reopen concluded adjudications. The power of review can be exercised with extreme care, caution and circumspection and only in exceptional cases.

12. When a prayer to appoint an arbitrator by the applicant herein had been made at the time when the arbitration petition was heard and was rejected, the same relief cannot be sought by an indirect method by filing a review petition. Such petition, in my opinion, is in the nature of “second innings” which is impermissible and unwarranted and cannot be granted.

13. For the aforesaid reasons, the limited prayer to the extent of clarification of the order as to the stand taken by the applicant and the statement made on its behalf is granted. The larger prayer for reconsideration of the order passed in the arbitration petition and allowing the applicant to nominate Hon'ble Mr Justice Satpal, Retired Judge of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana as one of the arbitrators, however, is rejected. In the facts and circumstances of the case, however, there shall be no order as to costs.