Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

P.K Shaji Alias Thammanam Shaji v. State Of Kerala .

Supreme Court Of India
Oct 27, 2005
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant was accused of offences under Sections 120-B and 307 of the Indian Penal Code and was granted bail by the Sessions Court, Ernakulam, under Section 439 CrPC. The bail order required:

  • Execution of a bond for Rs 50,000 with two solvent sureties.
  • Appearance before the investigating officer every Monday and Friday between 10:00 a.m. and 12:00 noon.
  • A prohibition on entering the Sessions Division of Ernakulam except for the above purpose without prior permission.
  • An authorisation empowering the Magistrate to act “as if” he had himself granted bail, should the investigating officer report any breach.

After the appellant executed the bail bond and was released, the investigating officer reported non-compliance with the attendance condition. The Magistrate issued notice, heard counsel for the appellant—who claimed fear of police assault—and cancelled the bail. A criminal revision filed in the High Court of Kerala was dismissed, prompting the present appeal to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a Magistrate, acting on an authorisation contained in a Sessions Court’s bail order, is competent to cancel bail originally granted by the Sessions Court under Section 439 CrPC.
  2. Whether the appellant’s right to notice and an opportunity of hearing was respected before cancellation of bail.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Only the Sessions Court (or a superior court) that granted bail under Section 439 CrPC has jurisdiction to cancel it; a Magistrate lacks such power.
  • Statutory provisions (Sections 436, 437, 439 CrPC) draw a clear distinction: the court that grants bail is the court empowered to revoke it, unless overridden by a higher court.
  • The appellant’s failure to report was due to apprehension of police assault, not wilful disobedience.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gurdev Singh v. State of Bihar
(2005) 13 SCC 286; AIR 2000 SC 3556
An accused must receive notice and be heard before bail is cancelled. The Court acknowledged this principle and noted that the appellant had been issued notice and was heard by the Magistrate prior to cancellation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court held that Section 439(2) CrPC confers broad powers on the High Court or Sessions Court to cancel bail granted “by it or any subordinate court.” The Sessions Court, being a superior court to the Magistrate, could therefore delegate to the Magistrate authority to determine compliance with bail conditions and to take “appropriate action” upon breach. The authorising clause in the bail order expressly empowered the Magistrate to act “as if” he had granted bail himself.

Regarding natural justice, the Court observed that the Magistrate issued notice and heard the appellant’s explanation. The ground advanced—fear of assault—was rejected as unsubstantiated. The subsequent contention that the appellant was in custody in another case was not raised before the Magistrate and was therefore dismissed.

Consequently, the Magistrate’s cancellation order, and the High Court’s refusal to interfere, were found to be valid and within jurisdiction.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed.

The Supreme Court affirmed that a Sessions Court may, through explicit directions in a bail order, authorise a Magistrate to monitor compliance and cancel bail upon breach. The decision upholds the flexibility of superior courts to delegate supervisory powers in bail matters and confirms that cancellation ordered pursuant to such delegation is legally sustainable. No broader precedent was set beyond clarifying the permissibility of such delegation.

Show all summary ...

K.G Balakrishnan, J.— Leave granted.

2. The appellant challenges the order passed by a learned Single Judge of the High Court of Kerala. The appellant was involved in a case registered by Thrikkakara Police Station for the offences under Sections 120-B and 307 IPC. He was granted bail by the Sessions Court subject to certain conditions, one of which was that he should execute a bond for Rs 50,000 with two solvent sureties. He was also directed to make himself available for interrogation before the investigating officer on all Mondays and Fridays between 10 a.m to 12.00 noon and was further directed that except for this purpose he shall not enter the Sessions Division of Ernakulam until further orders without prior permission of the learned Magistrate. Lastly, the Sessions Court directed that the investigating officer shall scrupulously ensure that the appellant complied with all the conditions imposed therein and shall report to the Magistrate in case of any breach of conditions and the Magistrate shall take appropriate action as if the conditions have been imposed by the Magistrate himself.

3. Subsequently to the passing of the bail order, the appellant herein executed bail bonds before the Magistrate and was released on bail. The investigating officer filed a report before the learned Magistrate alleging that the appellant herein did not comply with the conditions as he had failed to report before the investigating officer on all Mondays and Fridays. Pursuant to this report, the learned Magistrate issued a notice and the learned counsel entered appearance and submitted that the appellant apprehended assault at the hands of the police and, therefore, he did not report before the investigating officer. The learned Magistrate was not satisfied with the explanation given by the learned counsel for the appellant and he cancelled the bail granted to the appellant. Aggrieved by the same, the appellant preferred a revision before the High Court and the same was dismissed by the impugned order.

4. It is contended by the appellant's learned counsel that in cases where bail is granted by the court in bailable offences under Section 436 CrPC, the very same court is given power to cancel the bail if the conditions of the bail bond, as regards the time and place of attendance, are not complied with; so also when bail is granted by a court other than the High Court or the Sessions Court for non-bailable offences under Section 437 CrPC. Under sub-section (5) of Section 437 CrPC, the court is given power to cancel the bail and direct that the person released on bail be arrested and committed to custody.

5. In the instant case, the bail was granted by the Sessions Court under Section 439 CrPC. Sub-section (2) of Section 439 CrPC specifically says that a High Court or the Sessions Court may direct that any person who has been released on bail be arrested and committed to custody. The power of the High Court or the Sessions Court under sub-section (2) of Section 439 CrPC is very wide and it specifically says that the Sessions Court or the High Court has got power to cancel the bail granted by any of the subordinate courts under Chapter 33 of the Criminal Procedure Code.

6. The plea of the appellant's learned counsel is that if the Sessions Court had granted bail, the order of cancellation of such bail should also have been passed by the Sessions Court or by any superior court and not by the learned Magistrate who is not empowered to cancel it. As a general proposition, the plea raised by the appellant is correct. It is equally true that the accused who is on bail, should be heard before an order of cancellation of bail is passed by the Court. This Court in Gurdev Singh v. State of Bihar (2005) 13 SCC 286, AIR 2000 SC 3556 (1), (2004) 4 Crimes 103 held that the accused must be given notice and opportunity of hearing before the bail granted to him is cancelled.

7. In the present case, the last condition stated in the bail order was to the following effect:

“The investigating officer shall scrupulously ensure that the petitioner complies with all conditions hereby imposed and shall report breach of conditions, if any, promptly to the learned Magistrate who on receipt of such report shall take appropriate action as if the conditions have been imposed and the petitioner released on bail by the learned Magistrate himself.”

8. The order of the Sessions Court shows that the learned Magistrate has been empowered to consider the question of violation of any of the conditions imposed by the Sessions Court and was given powers to pass appropriate orders. The plea raised by the appellant's learned counsel is that when the learned Magistrate had no such power, the Sessions Court was not empowered to invest that power in the Magistrate. We do not find any force in this contention. The superior court can always give directions of this nature and authorise the subordinate court to pass appropriate orders and the trial Magistrate would be the competent authority to decide whether any condition had been violated by the person who had been released on bail. When there is a specific direction to pass appropriate orders as if the conditions for granting bail had been imposed by the learned Magistrate himself, the impugned order is legal and valid.

9. The contention of the learned counsel for the appellant that the appellant was in prison in connection with another case and that is why he could not appear before the investigating officer, does not appear to be true as such a plea was not raised before the learned Magistrate. The learned counsel for the appellant only contended before the learned Magistrate that he apprehended assault at the hands of the police and, therefore, he refrained from making himself available before the investigating officer. The learned Magistrate rightly rejected this plea. The order passed by the learned Magistrate was correct and the High Court has rightly rejected the revision filed by the appellant.

10. We see no reason to interfere with the impugned judgment and the appeal is accordingly dismissed.