Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

S.K Bhatt v. State Of U.P And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Mar 11, 2005
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 5-4-2004, acting on a police report under Section 190(1)(b) of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), the Chief Judicial Magistrate (CJM) took cognizance and issued summons to the accused for 21-5-2004. The accused failed to appear on that date and subsequent dates. On 31-7-2004, the CJM recorded the absence of the accused and fixed 27-8-2004 for their appearance.

The accused filed a criminal revision before the Sessions Judge, Ghazipur, challenging the proceedings; the Sessions Judge dismissed the revision as barred by Section 397(2) CrPC on the ground that the impugned order was interlocutory. The accused then filed a Criminal Miscellaneous Writ Petition in the High Court challenging the CJM’s order dated 5-4-2004 (taking cognizance and summoning) and the Sessions Judge’s order dated 27-8-2004 dismissing the revision.

The High Court, relying on four Supreme Court decisions, held that an order summoning an accused is not an interlocutory order and that the bar under Section 397(2) CrPC did not apply. It set aside the Sessions Judge’s order dated 27-8-2004 and remanded the matter for decision on merits. The Sessions Judge, aggrieved by certain remarks made about him in the High Court’s judgment dated 5-11-2004, filed the present special leave petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order dated 31-7-2004 (recording the accused’s absence and fixing a date for appearance) and the summoning order could be treated as interlocutory so as to attract the bar under Section 397(2) CrPC.
  2. Whether the disparaging remarks made by the High Court against the Sessions Judge (petitioner) should be expunged.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Amar Nath v. State of Haryana, (1977) 4 SCC 137 Cited to support the proposition that an order summoning an accused is not an interlocutory order under Section 397(2) CrPC. Referenced as relied upon by the High Court; the Supreme Court, in this order, did not express any concluded opinion on the point.
Madhu Limaye v. State of Maharashtra, (1977) 4 SCC 551 Cited to support the proposition that an order summoning an accused is not an interlocutory order under Section 397(2) CrPC. Referenced as relied upon by the High Court; the Supreme Court, in this order, did not express any concluded opinion on the point.
Rajendra Kumar Sitaram Pande v. Uttam, (1999) 3 SCC 134 Cited to support the proposition that an order summoning an accused is not an interlocutory order under Section 397(2) CrPC. Referenced as relied upon by the High Court; the Supreme Court, in this order, did not express any concluded opinion on the point.
V.C. Shukla v. State through C.B.I., 1980 Supp SCC 92 Cited to support the proposition that an order summoning an accused is not an interlocutory order under Section 397(2) CrPC. Referenced as relied upon by the High Court; the Supreme Court, in this order, did not express any concluded opinion on the point.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

  • The Court noted the petitioner’s grievance regarding certain remarks made against him by the High Court in its order dated 5-11-2004.
  • It recorded that the accused’s memorandum of revision before the Sessions Judge challenged both the CJM’s order taking cognizance and summoning, and the CJM’s subsequent order dated 31-7-2004; however, the Court expressly declined to give any concluded opinion on whether these orders were interlocutory.
  • Having regard to the facts and circumstances, the Court chose not to adjudicate the interlocutory-order issue and instead provided a procedural course to address the petitioner’s grievance: the petitioner may seek expunction of the impugned remarks directly from the High Court.
  • The Court directed that, if such an application is filed, the High Court should decide it in accordance with law and without being influenced by any observation made in the present order.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF WITH DIRECTIONS.

Direct effect: The special leave petition was disposed of with liberty to the petitioner (the Sessions Judge) to move an application before the High Court for expunging the remarks that aggrieved him. The High Court is to decide such an application independently, according to law, and uninfluenced by observations in the present order. The Supreme Court did not decide whether the challenged orders were interlocutory or the correctness of the High Court’s view on the nature of a summoning order under Section 397(2) CrPC. No broader precedent was set beyond the procedural direction.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Feeling aggrieved by the remarks made by the High Court in the judgment dated 5-11-2004, while allowing Criminal Misc. Writ Petition No. 7218 of 2004, the Sessions Judge whose order was set aside, has filed the present petition.

2. On the basis of a report submitted by the police under Section 190(1)(b) CrPC, the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate took cognizance of the offence on 5-4-2004 and directed that summons be issued to the accused for their appearance on 21-5-2004. The accused did not appear on the date fixed, and some other dates were fixed and finally on 31-7-2004 the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate passed an order specifically recording that the accused are absent and fixed 27-8-2004 for their appearance in court. A criminal revision petition was filed by the accused before the Sessions Judge, Ghazipur which was dismissed on the ground that the order under challenge was an interlocutory order and, therefore, the revision was barred by virtue of Section 397(2) CrPC. The accused then preferred criminal misc. writ petition in the High Court challenging the order dated 5-4-2004 passed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate and also the order dated 27-8-2004 passed by the learned Sessions Judge (petitioner herein). The High Court, after referring to four decisions of this Court in Amar Nath v. State of Haryana (1977) 4 SCC 137, Madhu Limaye v. State of Maharashtra (1977) 4 SCC 551, Rajendra Kumar Sitaram Pande v. Uttam (1999) 3 SCC 134 and V.C Shukla v. State 1980 Supp SCC 92 held that an order summoning an accused is not an interlocutory order and, therefore, the bar created by Section 397(2) CrPC would not operate. The High Court accordingly set aside the order dated 27-8-2004 passed by the learned Sessions Judge and remanded the matter for deciding the revision on merits.

3. The petitioner who had decided the criminal revision petition on 27-8-2004 in his capacity as Sessions Judge is aggrieved by certain remarks made against him in the order of the High Court. The main plea taken in the present special leave petition is that the order dated 31-7-2004, wherein the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate had only recorded that the accused are absent and the case be posted for appearance of the accused on 27-8-2004, was an interlocutory order and, therefore, the bar created by Section 397(2) CrPC would operate. An English translation of the memorandum of revision which was filed before the learned Sessions Judge has been filed as Annexure P-3 and it shows that the accused had specifically written that they were aggrieved by the order dated 31-7-2004 and also by the order taking cognizance of the offence and summoning them. The grounds of revision also indicate that the accused had laid challenge to the order taking cognizance of the offence and summoning them to face trial. However, we do not want to express any concluded opinion on this question.

4. Having regard to the entire facts and circumstances of the case, we consider it appropriate to dispose of the special leave petition with the direction to the petitioner to move an application before the High Court for expunging the remarks by which he feels aggrieved. If such an application is filed, the High Court will decide the same in accordance with law, without being influenced in any manner by any observation made in the present order.