- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of U.P And Others v. Ashok Kumar .
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent, Ashok Kumar, was recruited as a constable in the Uttar Pradesh Police and was undergoing training. Under the relevant service rules, a trainee’s regular appointment was contingent upon successful completion of training.
While still in training, his services were terminated by order dated 15-2-1983 under the Uttar Pradesh Temporary Government Servants (Termination of Service) Rules, 1975. The order, couched as “termination simpliciter,” stated that his services were no longer required.
Kumar appealed to the Deputy Inspector General of Police, who dismissed the appeal on 28-9-1989, stating that Article 311(2) of the Constitution was not violated and directing payment of one month’s pay in lieu of notice.
He then approached the U.P. State Public Services Tribunal, which set aside the termination on the ground that he was denied the reasonable opportunity of hearing mandated by Article 311(2). The State’s writ petition to the High Court met the same fate: the High Court affirmed the Tribunal’s order. The State of U.P. thereafter filed the present civil appeal before the Supreme Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the termination of a temporary/trainee constable by an order styled as “termination simpliciter”—without a departmental enquiry—violates Article 311(2) of the Constitution of India.
- Whether the allegation that the respondent used unfair means during training constitutes the “foundation” of the termination (requiring an enquiry) or merely supplied the “motive” (permitting termination simpliciter).
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| State of Haryana v. Satyender Singh Rathore (2005) 7 SCC 518 | Clarifies the distinction between “motive” and “foundation” in termination orders and the relevance of an enquiry to determine whether an order is punitive or simpliciter. | Treated as controlling authority; Court held the present facts are “clearly covered” by this decision, making the termination valid. |
| Dhananjay v. Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, Jalna (2003) 2 SCC 386 | Part of the jurisprudence examining when termination during probation is punitive versus simpliciter. | Cited as part of the background discussion; helped illustrate settled principles but not individually analysed. |
| Mathew P. Thomas v. Kerala State Civil Supply Corpn. Ltd. (2003) 3 SCC 263 | Further authority on the punitive-vs-simpliciter distinction. | Referenced in the survey of earlier decisions to buttress the governing test; no separate application. |
| Dipti Prakash Banerjee v. Satyendra Nath Bose National Centre for Basic Sciences (1999) 3 SCC 60 | Explains when allegations behind a termination order amount to “foundation” versus “motive.” | Cited in a quoted passage illustrating that absence of an enquiry makes allegations only a motive, supporting validity of termination. |
| Pavanendra Narayan Verma v. Sanjay Gandhi PGI of Medical Sciences (2002) 1 SCC 520 | Discusses stigmatic termination and the need for enquiry. | Referenced alongside Dipti Prakash Banerjee to show the evolution of the test; not separately analysed. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court noted that the impugned order of 15-2-1983 contains no reference to misconduct and uses language of termination simpliciter. No departmental enquiry preceded the order.
Relying chiefly on State of Haryana v. Satyender Singh Rathore, the Court reiterated the settled distinction:
- If a complaint merely motivates the employer to end a temporary employee’s services and no enquiry is held, the complaint is only the motive; the order remains simpliciter and non-punitive.
- If an enquiry is conducted and findings of misconduct are reached, the complaint becomes the foundation; the order then attracts Article 311(2) safeguards.
Applying this framework, the Court found:
- The trainee constable’s alleged use of unfair means was not investigated through any enquiry.
- The termination order did not record any finding of misconduct or cast any stigma.
- Consequently, the allegation served merely as the motive, not the foundation, for the termination.
Because Article 311(2) protections are triggered only when termination is punitive or stigmatic, both the Tribunal and the High Court erred in characterising the order as violative of Article 311(2).
Holding and Implications
Appeal Allowed; orders of the Tribunal (27-8-1994) and the High Court (24-11-2001) are set aside.
Direct Effect: The respondent’s termination stands reinstated as valid termination simpliciter, and no costs are awarded. Broader Implication: The decision reinforces existing Supreme Court jurisprudence that an allegation, absent any enquiry or expression of stigma, is only a motive; hence Article 311(2) does not apply. No new legal principle is created, but the ruling reaffirms and applies the motive/foundation test to trainee or probationary employees in Uttar Pradesh.
H.K Sema, J.— Heard the parties.
2. This appeal is preferred by the State of U.P against an order of the High Court affirming the order of the Tribunal.
3. Briefly stated, the facts are as follows:
The respondent was recruited as constable and he was undergoing training. It is not in dispute that his regular appointment was to be preceded by the successful completion of training. While he was undergoing training his services were terminated by an order dated 15-2-1983 (termination simpliciter) by resorting to the Uttar Pradesh Temporary Government Servants (Termination of Service) Rules, 1975 (hereinafter “the Rules”). The order of termination reads:
“In terms of the provisions of the Uttar Pradesh Temporary Government Servants (Termination of Service) Rules, 1975, published by Appointment Section-3 vide Notification No. 20/1/74 Appointment-3 dated 11-6-1975, the undersigned Shri Haramol Singh, Superintendent of Police, Mathura, do hereby give notice to temporary recruit Constable Ashok Kumar that his services are no longer required and his services shall be deemed to have been terminated from the date of receipt of this notice.”
4. The respondent preferred an appeal before the Appellate Authority who is Deputy Inspector General of Police. The appeal was dismissed by an order dated 28-9-1989 on the ground that there was no violation of Article 311(2) of the Constitution. The order further stated that he may be paid one month's pay in lieu of the notice. Aggrieved thereby, he filed an application before the State Public Services Tribunal. The Tribunal after hearing the submission of the respondent and the appellant was of the view that the termination of the respondent's services by the impugned order was violative of Article 311(2) of the Constitution as no reasonable opportunity of hearing has been afforded to the respondent as provided under Article 311(2) of the Constitution. Aggrieved thereby, the appellant filed a writ petition before the High Court. The High Court on the same ground affirmed the view of the Tribunal. Hence, the present appeal.
5. Both the Tribunal and the High Court held that the service of the respondent was temporary. However, while holding that the service of the respondent was on temporary basis they erred in law in holding that the allegation by the appellant that the respondent was found using unfair means while undergoing training along with other trainees is the foundation of the termination order and, therefore, is violative of Article 311(2) of the Constitution.
6. The order of termination simpliciter as referred above does not disclose any stigma. Whether a complaint is the motive leading to termination simpliciter or it is the foundation of the termination order has been considered by this Court and held consistently by this Court that when there is no inquiry resulting in the termination order, the complaint is the motive of the order of termination, on the other hand where the complaint leads to the inquiry resulting in the termination order it is the foundation of the order of termination. This Court in a recent decision in State of Haryana v. Satyender Singh Rathore (2005) 7 SCC 518, after discussing the various decisions of this Court, held in para 9 of the judgment as under:
“9. We find that the High Court did not consider the question of stigma or the effect of any enquiry held before the order of termination was passed. The question whether the enquiry purportedly held provided the motive or the foundation was required to be considered by the High Court in detail. That has not been done. The question whether the termination of service is simpliciter or punitive has been examined in several cases e.g Dhananjay v. Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, Jalna (2003) 2 SCC 386 and Mathew P. Thomas v. Kerala State Civil Supply Corpn. Ltd. (2003) 3 SCC 263 An order of termination simpliciter passed during the period of probation has been generating undying debate. The recent two decisions of this Court in Dipti Prakash Banerjee v. Satyendra Nath Bose National Centre for Basic Sciences (1999) 3 SCC 60 and Pavanendra Narayan Verma v. Sanjay Gandhi PGI of Medical Sciences (2002) 1 SCC 520 after survey of most of the earlier decisions touching the question observed as to when an order of termination can be treated as simpliciter and when it can be treated as punitive and when a stigma is said to be attached to an employee discharged during the period of probation. The learned counsel on either side referred to and relied on these decisions either in support of their respective contentions or to distinguish them for the purpose of application of the principles stated therein to the facts of the present case. In the case of Dipti Prakash Banerjee (1999) 3 SCC 60 after referring to various decisions it was indicated as to when a simple order of termination is to be treated as ‘founded’ on the allegations of misconduct and when complaints could be only as a motive for passing such a simple order of termination. In para 21 of the said judgment a distinction is explained thus:
‘21. If findings were arrived at in an enquiry as to misconduct, behind the back of the officer or without a regular departmental enquiry, the simple order of termination is to be treated as “founded” on the allegations and will be bad. But if the enquiry was not held, no findings were arrived at and the employer was not inclined to conduct an enquiry but, at the same time, he did not want to continue the employee against whom there were complaints, it would only be a case of motive and the order would not be bad. Similar is the position if the employer did not want to enquire into the truth of the allegations because of delay in regular departmental proceedings or he was doubtful about securing adequate evidence. In such a circumstance, the allegations would be a motive and not the foundation and the simple order of termination would be valid.’
From a long line of decisions it appears to us that whether an order of termination is simpliciter or punitive has ultimately to be decided having due regard to the facts and circumstances of each case. Many a time the distinction between the foundation and motive in relation to an order of termination either is thin or overlapping. It may be difficult either to categorise or classify strictly orders of termination simpliciter falling in one or the other category, based on misconduct as foundation for passing the order of termination simpliciter or on motive on the ground of unsuitability to continue in service.”
7. The facts of the case at hand are clearly covered by the decision rendered in Satyender Singh Rathore (2005) 7 SCC 518. In this view of the matter we are clearly of the view that both the Tribunal and the High Court erred in law for setting aside the order of termination simpliciter. Accordingly, this appeal is allowed by setting aside the orders dated 27-8-1994 passed by the Tribunal and by the High Court dated 24-11-2001. No costs.
Alert