- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Life Insurance Corpn. Of India v. Mani Ram .
Factual and Procedural Background
Mani Ram, father and nominee of the insured Ashok Kumar, filed a complaint under Section 12 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 before the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, Bilaspur (Himachal Pradesh). Ashok Kumar had taken a life insurance policy from the Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) with the first premium of ₹5,215 paid on 21-08-1995. At the insured’s request, the policy commencement date was back-dated to 28-04-1995, making the next annual premium due on 28-04-1996 (with a one-month grace period until 28-05-1996). No further premium was paid.
Ashok Kumar died in an accident on 02-08-1996. LIC rejected Mani Ram’s claim for ₹2,50,000, asserting that the policy had lapsed on 28-05-1996 for non-payment of the second premium. The District Forum, however, treated 21-08-1995 as the operative commencement date and awarded Mani Ram ₹50,000 with interest. Both parties appealed; the Himachal Pradesh State Commission dismissed both appeals, relying on LIC v. Dharam Vir Anand. The National Commission dismissed LIC’s revision petition, affirming concurrent findings that the policy subsisted. LIC then appealed to the Supreme Court of India.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the life-insurance policy was valid and subsisting on 02-08-1996, the date of the insured’s death.
- Whether back-dating the commencement of risk to 28-04-1995 advanced the due date for payment of the next premium to 28-04-1996, thereby causing the policy to lapse when that premium was not paid within the grace period.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (LIC of India)
- The policy period ran from 28-04-1995 to 28-04-1996 because of the insured’s request to back-date commencement; consequently, the next premium was due on 28-04-1996 and, after the one-month grace period, at the latest by 28-05-1996.
- No premium was paid by 28-05-1996; under Condition 2 printed on the back of the policy, failure to pay within the grace period caused the policy to lapse.
- The forums erred in applying LIC v. Dharam Vir Anand; that decision does not govern the present facts because Condition 2 here unequivocally provides for automatic lapse.
Respondent (Mani Ram)
- The first premium was physically paid on 21-08-1995; therefore, the next premium fell due on 21-08-1996, meaning the policy was still in force on 02-08-1996.
- The concurrent findings of the District Forum, State Commission, and National Commission in the complainant’s favour should not be disturbed.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| LIC of India v. Dharam Vir Anand (1998) 7 SCC 348; JT (1998) 7 SC 167 | Interpretation of back-dated insurance policies and distinction between “date on which risk commenced” and “date of the policy.” | The Supreme Court distinguished the case, holding that Condition 2 of the present policy expressly provides for lapse upon non-payment within the grace period, making Dharam Vir Anand inapplicable to these facts. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court noted that the factual matrix was undisputed: the policy commencement date was 28-04-1995, the first premium was paid on 21-08-1995, and no subsequent premium was paid. Examining Condition 2 of the policy, the Court emphasized:
- A yearly premium must be paid on the anniversary date (28-04-1996), with a one-month grace period.
- If the premium is not paid before the expiry of the grace period, “the policy lapses.”
Because no payment was made by 28-05-1996, the policy lapsed ipso facto on that date. Consequently, on 02-08-1996 there was “no subsisting policy,” and LIC had no liability.
Addressing Dharam Vir Anand, the Court held that decision actually supports LIC’s position, since contractual terms must be given full effect. Accepting the respondent’s view would render the lapse clause meaningless, contrary to established principles of contract construction.
Holding and Implications
HELD: The appeal is allowed; orders of the District Forum, State Commission, and National Commission are set aside. Although LIC succeeds on the legal question, the Court directed that LIC shall not recover the amount already paid to Mani Ram, and made no order as to costs.
Implications: The judgment reaffirms that when a policy is back-dated, premium due dates are governed by the contractual commencement date, and failure to pay within the stipulated grace period causes automatic lapse. The decision clarifies the limited scope of Dharam Vir Anand and reinforces strict adherence to policy conditions in insurance contracts, but it sets no new broader precedent beyond these principles.
C.K Thakker, J.— Leave granted.
2. This appeal is filed by the Life Insurance Corporation of India (“Insurance Company” for short) against the order passed by the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, Bilaspur (Himachal Pradesh), confirmed by the Himachal Pradesh State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Shimla and also confirmed by the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, New Delhi.
3. Few facts giving rise to the present appeal may now be stated:
Mani Ram, the respondent herein, son of one Budhu Ram, resident of Village Khatehar, Pargana and Tehsil Sadar, District Bilaspur (H.P) filed a complaint under Section 12 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”), before the District Forum, Bilaspur. In the complaint, it was inter alia alleged by the complainant that his son Ashok Kumar had been insured with the appellant Insurance Company on 21-8-1995 and premium amount of Rs 5215 was paid on the same day. According to the complainant, the next instalment of premium was due on 21-8-1996. Ashok Kumar — the insured, however, died in an accident on 2-8-1996 at Barmana as the boundary wall of the D.A.V School fell on him and he was crushed under the debris. The complainant, in view of the subsisting policy, requested the appellant Insurance Company to pay the insurance claim amount of Rs 2,50,000 to the complainant, but under lame and false excuses, the Insurance Company did not pay the amount. Finally, by a communication dated 11-8-1997, the Insurance Company refused to pay any amount. The deceased was unmarried. It was asserted by the complainant that he was the nominee of deceased Ashok Kumar as the father. Since the amount was not paid, the complainant was constrained to approach the District Forum. Accordingly a claim of Rs 2,50,000 was made along with interest and damages on account of mental torture and financial loss suffered by the complainant.
4. The appellant Insurance Company resisted the claim of the complainant by filing a written reply. A preliminary objection was raised against the maintainability of the complaint on the ground that the policy had lapsed due to non-payment of premium within the prescribed period and hence, the complainant had no right to claim anything. The complaint was, therefore, liable to be dismissed. It was stated that deceased Ashok Kumar was insured with the Insurance Company. It was also admitted that the premium amount was paid to the Insurance Company on 21-8-1995 but the policy-holder got the policy effected from a backdate i.e from 28-4-1995. According to the Insurance Company, therefore, the next premium was due and payable after one year i.e on 28-4-1996. Giving benefit of grace period of one month, the premium amount was required to be paid latest by 28-5-1996. No premium, however, was paid on 28-4-1996 nor till 28-5-1996 and the policy lapsed. Since the deceased Ashok Kumar met with an accident on 2-8-1996, there was no subsisting policy in favour of the insured inasmuch as it lapsed on 28-5-1996, the Insurance Company could not be held liable and the complainant was not entitled to any amount.
5. The District Forum considered the rival contentions of the parties and held that the deceased was assured for Rs 50,000 on 21-8-1995. It observed that no doubt the policy was backdated to 28-4-1995 but as the premium was paid on 21-8-1995, next premium became due on 21-8-1996. Since Ashok Kumar met with an accident and died on 2-8-1996, the Insurance Company was liable. It accordingly awarded an amount of Rs 50,000 with interest @ 12% p.a and costs of Rs 500.
6. Being aggrieved by the order passed by the District Forum, both the complainant as well as the Insurance Company filed appeal before the State Commission. The grievance of the Insurance Company was that since the policy lapsed on 28-4-1996, it could not have been held liable for an accidental death of Ashok Kumar on 2-8-1996 and the District Forum had committed an error of law in holding the Insurance Company liable. The grievance of the complainant, on the other hand, was that since Ashok Kumar died due to accidental death, as per the terms and conditions of the policy, the complainant was entitled to a sum of Rs 2,50,000 and the District Forum was in error in awarding Rs 50,000 only. The State Commission heard both the appeals and dismissed them by a common judgment. The State Commission relied upon the decision of this Court in LIC of India v. Dharam Vir Anand (1998) 7 SCC 348, JT (1998) 7 SC 167.
7. The Insurance Company approached the National Commission against the orders passed by the fora below. The National Commission, however, dismissed the revision petition by observing that concurrent findings had been recorded that the policy was subsisting and the Insurance Company was liable under the said policy. According to the National Commission, since the first premium was paid on 21-8-1995, the next premium was due on 21-8-1996.
8. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties. Mr G.L Sanghi, learned Senior Counsel for the Insurance Company submitted that the fora below have committed an error of law in holding that the policy was subsisting. The counsel admitted that the first premium was paid on 21-8-1995, but in the proposal dated 19-8-1995, a request was made to make the policy effective with backdate from 28-4-1995. The request was granted by the Insurance Company and the policy was issued. The period of policy was thus from 28-4-1995 to 28-4-1996. The counsel submitted that the deposit/payment of premium amount was not at all relevant as the policy was for a period of one year from 28-4-1995. It was submitted that the next premium was due on 28-4-1996 and the amount ought to have been paid. Grace period of one month was available to the insured and payment ought to have been made by 28-5-1996. It is not disputed even by the complainant, submitted the counsel, that no payment was made on or before 28-5-1996. The policy, therefore, lapsed on 28-5-1996. Since the assured died on 2-8-1996, the Insurance Company was not liable. It was also submitted that the ratio laid down in Dharam Vir Anand (1998) 7 SCC 348, JT (1998) 7 SC 167 does not apply to the facts of the case.
9. The learned counsel for the respondent, on the other hand, submitted that the contentions raised by the appellant Insurance Company were considered by the fora below and in the light of the facts and circumstances as also the decision of this Court, orders were passed which call for no interference.
10. The question for our consideration, therefore, is whether on 2-8-1996, the policy could be said to be valid and subsisting. If the reply is in the affirmative, obviously, the complainant was entitled to the amount awarded. If, on the other hand, the policy lapsed, as contended by the Insurance Company, no claim could have been put forward by the complainant and the Insurance Company was right in rejecting the claim.
11. So far as the factual position is concerned, there is no dispute between the parties. Deceased Ashok Kumar was insured by the Insurance Company and the first premium was paid on 21-8-1995. At the request of the insured, however, the policy was backdated with effect from 28-4-1995. In our opinion, therefore, the learned counsel for the Insurance Company is right in submitting that one year came to an end on 28-4-1996 and the insured was liable to pay premium on that date as it became due and payable. Taking into account the grace period of one month, premium amount ought to have been paid latest by 28-5-1996. Admittedly, no such payment was made either in April 1996 or in May 1996. We are impressed by the argument of the learned counsel for the Insurance Company that in the circumstances, the policy lapsed on 28-5-1996.
12. In this connection, it may be profitable to refer to the terms and conditions of the policy. The policy stated that the date of commencement was 28-4-1995 and the date of maturity would be 28-4-2010 as it was for a period of fifteen years. It is further stated that the policy of assurance “shall be subject to the conditions and privileges” printed on the back of the policy. On the back of the policy, those conditions and privileges have been printed. Condition 2 thereof, is material for our purpose and reads thus:
“2. Payment of premium.—A grace period of one month i.e not less than 30 days will be allowed for payment of yearly, half-yearly, or quarterly premiums and 15 days for monthly premiums. If death occurs within this period and before the payment of the premium then due, the policy will be valid and the sum assured paid after deduction of the premium as also the unpaid premium(s) falling due before the next anniversary of this policy. If the premium is not paid before the expiry of the days of grace, the policy lapses.”
(emphasis supplied)
13. From the above condition, it is abundantly clear that payment of premium due had to be made within a grace period of one month. If such payment was made within the said period, the policy would be treated as valid and the assured would be paid the amount to which he was entitled after deducting the premium amount. But it was also made clear that if the premium was not paid before the expiry of the days of grace, the policy would lapse. As we have already observed hereinabove, the material date was not the date of deposit/payment of premium amount which was 21-8-1995, but the date of policy which was 28-4-1995. Since it was yearly, the payment was due on 28-4-1996, but the assured was entitled to grace period of one month up to 28-5-1996. Neither the premium was paid on 28-4-1996 nor on 28-5-1996. As per condition 2, the policy lapsed on 28-5-1996. In the eye of law, there was no subsisting policy, on 2-8-1996. The Insurance Company was, therefore, wholly justified in rejecting the claim of the complainant and no exception can be taken against such a decision.
14. The learned counsel for the respondent no doubt relied on the decision of this Court in Dharam Vir Anand (1998) 7 SCC 348, JT (1998) 7 SC 167. The State Commission also referred to the said decision and observed that the point was covered by the ratio laid down therein and the complainant was entitled to the benefit of that decision. In our opinion, however, the submission of the learned counsel for the Insurance Company is well founded that it was in the light of the fact situation of that case that the Court decided the matter in favour of the complainant.
15. In Dharam Vir Anand (1998) 7 SCC 348, JT (1998) 7 SC 167 the complainant had taken a policy of insurance on the life of his minor daughter. The policy was issued on 31-3-1990. The risk under the policy was, however, backdated at the request of the complainant taking advantage of the option given to him in that regard by the Insurance Company which was 10-5-1989 and the premium was paid. On 15-11-1992, the assured committed suicide. The complainant lodged a claim which was refuted by the Company. The question before this Court was whether on that date i.e 15-11-1992, the policy was subsisting or not? If the date of issuance of policy was to be taken into account, the policy was subsisting. But if backdate would be considered as relevant and material, three years were over and there was no subsisting policy. The Court considered clause 4-B of the policy which read as under:
“4-B. Notwithstanding anything mentioned to the contrary, it is hereby declared and agreed that in the event of death of life assured occurring as a result of intentional self-injury, suicide or attempted suicide, insanity, accident other than an accident in a public place or murder at any time, on or after the date on which the risk under the policy has commenced but before the expiry of three years from the date of this policy, the Corporation's liability shall be limited to the sum equal to the total amount of premiums (exclusive extra of premiums, if any), paid under the policy without interest. Provided that in case the life assured shall commit suicide before the expiry of one year reckoned from the date of this policy, the provisions of the clause under the heading ‘Suicide’ printed on the back of the policy (sic will apply).”
(emphasis supplied)
16. The Court observed that clause 4-B made it crystal clear that the date on which the risk under the policy commenced was different from the date of the policy. The Court took into consideration two expressions viz. “the date on which the risk under the policy has commenced” and “the date of the policy”. The Court held that since two expressions were used which obviously referred to two different periods, effect must be given to both of them. If the contention of the Insurance Company that the relevant date was the date on which the risk under the policy had commenced alone would be considered, the second expression (“the date of the policy”) would become redundant. The Court noted the argument on behalf of the Insurance Company that the second date had a limited application for the purpose of giving certain tax relief but negatived it. It was further observed by this Court that in construing contractual clauses, the words and terms therein must be given effect to and a part of the contract cannot be rendered meaningless while construing and interpreting the other part of the same contract. According to the Court, when the parties agree to the terms of the contract, it was not open to contend that a particular term was never intended to be acted upon. Accordingly, this Court held that on 15-11-1992, the policy was in existence and the respondent claimant was entitled to the amount.
17. In the instant case, condition 2 expressly provided the period during which the payment was to be made. It also in no uncertain terms stated that if premium was not paid before the expiry of grace period, the policy would lapse. In our view, the ratio in Dharam Vir Anand (1998) 7 SCC 348, JT (1998) 7 SC 167 would support the Insurance Company rather than the complainant. If all the terms and conditions of the policy (contract between the parties) have to be kept in mind and given effect to, acceptance of argument on behalf of the complainant would make the last part of condition 2 redundant, otiose and inoperative; and a court of law cannot construe a document in the manner suggested by the counsel for the complainant. As the premium was due on 28-4-1996 and was not paid till 28-5-1996, the policy lapsed. The fora below hence, committed an error of law in allowing the complaint of the respondent herein and the orders are liable to be set aside.
18. For the reasons stated above, the appeal deserves to be allowed and is accordingly allowed. The orders passed by all the three Commissions are hereby set aside. The learned counsel for the appellant Insurance Company, however, stated that the assured died in 1996 and the District Forum upheld the claim of the complainant in December 2000. He fairly stated that the amount was not “very high” and has also been paid and the Insurance Company was not so serious about the amount, but since the question of law had been wrongly decided, the Insurance Company had to approach this Court so that the law is settled. Therefore, though we hold the orders not to be in accordance with law and we set them aside, but we direct that no recovery will be effected from the respondent complainant pursuant to this order.
19. The appeal is allowed to the extent indicated above. In the facts and circumstances of the case, however, there shall be no order as to costs.
Alert