Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Prasad Technology Park (P) Ltd. v. Sub-Registrar And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Dec 8, 2005
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 5 March 1999 a lease-cum-sale agreement was executed between “Prasad Garments Pvt. Ltd.” and the Karnataka Industrial Areas Development Board (KIADB), the third respondent. The company paid a premium of Rs 14,49,453 (99 % of the tentative land cost) and agreed to an annual rent of Rs 966 for an 11-year term commencing 25 June 1997.

Subsequently, the company’s name was changed to “Prasad Technology Park Pvt. Ltd.” To reflect this change—and to permit the establishment of a software park in lieu of a garments factory—the parties executed a “supplementary agreement.” The instrument was presented for registration on stamp paper worth Rs 100.

The Deputy Commissioner of Stamps, invoking Article 5(d) of the Schedule to the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957, assessed additional stamp duty of Rs 1,45,100 plus a Rs 5 penalty, holding that the supplementary agreement effected a material alteration tantamount to a transfer. The appellant’s contention that the document was merely a deed of rectification was rejected.

The Karnataka High Court dismissed the appellant’s writ petition and, on intra-court appeal, affirmed that the supplementary agreement attracted duty under Article 5(d). The appellant sought relief before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether execution of the supplementary agreement, consequent upon a change in the company’s name and permissible user, constitutes a “transfer” attracting stamp duty under Article 5(d) of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957.
  2. If not, whether the document falls under the residuary provision, Article 5(i), for which duty had already been paid.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The supplementary agreement involves no transfer of property or fresh leasehold rights; it merely records a change in the company’s name and user restriction.
  • Under Section 2(1)(j) of the Act, an “instrument” attracts duty only when rights are created, transferred, or extinguished, which did not occur here.
  • Consequently, Article 5(i) (residuary) applies, not Article 5(d); appropriate duty has already been paid.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The agreement effects a substantive alteration: the lessee is now authorised to establish a software park instead of a garments factory, thus amounting to a fresh lease.
  • Clauses 2(n) and 2(q) of the original lease imposed restrictive covenants; their modification signifies a transfer of interest demanding duty under Article 5(d).
  • The appellant cannot avoid stamp duty merely by styling the document as “supplementary.”

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Surendra Nath Bose v. Ashutosh Saha, AIR 1939 Cal 181 Material alteration of an instrument may attract full stamp duty. Relied on by the Deputy Commissioner to justify treating the supplementary agreement as a fresh instrument subject to full duty.
Joharmal Beharilal v. R.M.P.M Chettyar, AIR 1936 Rang 136 Same principle regarding material alteration and stamp liability. Cited in the administrative order to support imposition of duty.
Krushnacharana Padhi v. Gourochandro Dyano Sumanto, (1939) 2 MLJ 686; AIR 1940 Mad 62 Material alteration doctrine. Also referenced by the Deputy Commissioner for the same proposition.
Madras Refineries Ltd. v. Chief Controlling Revenue Authority, (1977) 2 SCC 308 For stamp purposes, the court must ascertain the real and true nature of the instrument. Applied by the Supreme Court to examine the substance of the supplementary agreement and conclude that no transfer occurred.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court observed that under Sections 21 and 23 of the Companies Act, a change of name does not create a new legal entity; hence no fresh leasehold interest was conveyed. The supplementary agreement merely substituted the company’s new name and relaxed a restrictive covenant on user (allowing a software park instead of garment manufacture) without altering essential lease elements—term, premium, rent, or re-entry rights.

Section 105 of the Transfer of Property Act defines lease; because those essential elements remained intact, the document was neither a new lease nor a sale under Section 54. Therefore, Article 5(d), which applies to instruments effecting a transfer, was inapposite.

Invoking Section 2(1)(j) of the Karnataka Stamp Act and the principle from Madras Refineries Ltd., the Court stressed that duty depends on the instrument’s true character. As the supplementary agreement did not create or transfer any right but only recorded a permissible change, it fell within Article 5(i) (residuary), for which the appellant had already paid duty.

The High Court’s contrary view erred by recognising that no new leasehold rights were claimed yet still upholding liability under Article 5(d).

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; Impugned Judgments Set Aside.

The Supreme Court declared that the supplementary agreement did not attract stamp duty under Article 5(d); the duty already paid under Article 5(i) sufficed. The appellant is entitled to costs.

Implications are confined to the parties: the appellant recovers excess duty and penalties. The decision reiterates the principle that stamp duty hinges on the substantive effect of an instrument rather than its form, but it does not establish a new legal doctrine.

Show all summary ...

S.B Sinha, J.— Leave granted.

2. Whether the execution of a supplementary agreement entered into by and between the appellant and the third respondent herein would amount to a transfer so as to attract stamp duty payable in terms of Article 5(d) of the Schedule appended to the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957, consequent upon the change of the name of the erstwhile company to the appellant Company is the question involved in this appeal.

3. The basic fact of the matter is not in dispute. One “Prasad Garments Pvt. Ltd.” was a company registered under the Companies Act, 1956. On or about 5-3-1999, it entered into a lease-cum-sale agreement with the third respondent herein upon payment of premium of a sum of Rs 14,49,453 which amounted to 99% of the tentative cost of the land and yearly rent of Rs 966 for a period of eleven years computed from 25-6-1997. The name of the said Company, however, was changed to “Prasad Technology Park Pvt. Ltd.”

4. The appellant presented the said instrument for registration before the first respondent herein on a stamp paper of Rs 100. The first respondent, however, was of the opinion that the stamp duty on the total amount of the original lease deed as mentioned in the lease deed dated 5-3-1999 was required to be paid. In response to a notice served in this behalf on the appellant, a show-cause was filed contending that the supplementary agreement is merely a deed of rectification. The said contention was, however, rejected by the Deputy Commissioner of Stamps by an order dated 26-10-2000, holding:

“As per the abovesaid amendment, the original document, since the changes in the legal effect of the instrument and hence the supplementary agreement document in question subjected to the entire material alteration. In this regard, it held in similar cases in Surendra Nath Bose v. Ashutosh Saha AIR 1939 Cal 181, Joharmal Beharilal v. R.M.P.M Chettyar AIR 1936 Rang 136 and Krushnacharana Padhi v. Gourochandro Dyano Sumanto (1939) 2 MLJ 686, AIR 1940 Mad 62 the Hon'ble Courts held (recorded in Krishnamurthy's Indian Stamp Act, 7th Edn., p. 133 in Note 9). Therefore, in the present ‘amendment or supplementary agreement’, it is opined that the fixed deposit and annual rent as per Article 5(d), it is required to pay the entire stamp fee. Hence, the following order:
No. DR.I/47/00-01dated 26-10-2000
Taken into consideration all the abovesaid points, I the Deputy Commissioner of Stamps, exercising my power vested under Section 39 of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957, the present document of ‘supplementary agreement’ vide P.24/2000-01 dated 5-3-1999 original document of lease-cum-sale agreement mentioned fixed deposit of Rs 14,49,593.00 and annual rent of Rs 966.00 totalling to Rs 14,50,559.00 as per Article 5(d) has to pay stamp fee of Rs 1,45,100.00 along with fine of Rs 5.00, totalling to Rs 1,45,105.00 hereby directed to make payment.”

5. Aggrieved by and dissatisfied therewith, a writ petition was filed by the appellant before the Karnataka High Court, which came to be dismissed by reason of an order dated 11-8-2003 passed by a learned Single Judge, opining:

“… But unfortunately for the petitioner the supplementary agreement sought to be registered as entered into between the third respondent lessor and the petitioner lessee with the terms of the lease being the same as had been in the earlier lease deed that had come to be executed in favour of the petitioner Company in its earlier name as evidenced by the agreement dated 5-3-1999. These terms are sought to be incorporated into the subsequent agreement which is known as supplementary agreement dated 24-4-2000….”

6. The appellant herein preferred an intra-court appeal thereagainst, which was also dismissed by the impugned judgment, stating:

“In the instant case, earlier the name of the appellant Company was Prasad Garments Pvt. Ltd., which is now changed to Prasad Technology Park Pvt. Ltd. On account of change of name of the Company, a supplementary agreement was entered into between M/s Karnataka Industrial Areas Development Board and the appellant Company. So far as the argument of non-payment of stamp duty is concerned, the same is not acceptable. It cannot be said that the supplementary lease agreement is also an instrument under which the appellant Company claims certain leasehold rights from the Board, and therefore, it is liable to pay the stamp duty and cannot escape payment of stamp duty. The learned Single Judge having found no illegality in the order of the second respondent, considering the material on record and case-law relied on, by a detailed order, has dismissed the writ petition.
In our view, the appellant Company cannot escape its liability to pay the stamp duty under the supplementary agreement since there is transfer of interest in the Company, which the appellant Company can claim under the third respondent….”

7. Mr S.K Kulkarni, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant, at the outset, drew our attention to the definition of instrument as contained in Section 2(1)(j) of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 and would submit that having regard to the fact that no element of transfer was involved in execution of the said supplementary agreement, Article 5(i) of the appendix appended thereto would be attracted and not Article 5(d) thereof as has been held by the Deputy Commissioner of Stamps.

8. Mr Sanjay R. Hegde, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the first and second respondents, on the other hand, would submit that having regard to the fact that the nature of business of the Company was also altered inasmuch as whereas by the earlier instrument the demise of the premises was made only for the purpose of manufacture of ready-made garments and leather garments, the lessee now has been permitted to establish a software park; the instrument in question must be held to be one of lease. Our attention, in this behalf, has been drawn to clauses 2(n) and 2(q) of the original deed of lease, which are as under:

“2. (n) To use the demised premises only for the purpose of manufacture of ready-made garments or leather garments factory/industry and not to use the demised premises or any part thereof for any other purpose nor for the purposes of any factory which may be obnoxious, or offensive by reason of emission of odour, liquid ‘effluvia’, dust, smoke, gas, noise vibrations or fire hazards.
2. (q) The lessee shall not alienate the demised premises or any part thereof or the building, that may be constructed thereon during the period of lease. The lessee may mortgage the right, title and interest in the demised premises in favour of the Government of Karnataka or the Central Government or corporate bodies like Life Insurance Corporation of India, Karnataka State Industrial Investment and Development Corporation, Karnataka State Financial Corporation, Industrial Finance Corporation of India, Industrial Development Bank of India, Industrial Credit and Investment Corporation of India, Unit Trust of India, Trustees of Debenture Stock of Banks to secure monies advanced by such government or bodies for the erection of building, plant and machinery. However, the lessee shall obtain the no-objection certificate from the lessor in writing for creation of second and subsequent charges.”

9. Change of the name of a company can be allowed by the Registrar of Companies in terms of Section 21 of the Companies Act. Once such a name is permitted to be changed, a certificate is issued in terms of Section 23 thereof.

10. The appellant indisputably was permitted by the third respondent herein to establish a software park. The execution of supplementary agreement, it has categorically been stated, became necessary consequent upon the change in the name of the Company. By reason of such supplementary agreement although it was permitted to establish a software park but by reason thereof no fresh transaction was entered into. We have noticed hereinbefore that in terms of the aforementioned agreement dated 5-3-1999, the land in question was demised for a period of eleven years with effect from 25-6-1997 on payment of premium fixed thereunder as also on yearly lease rent stipulated thereby.

11. The said lease indisputably was governed by Section 105 of the Transfer of Property Act. By reason of the supplementary agreement, a restrictive covenant has been amended in terms whereof the appellant herein was permitted to carry on the business of a technology park instead of manufacture of ready-made garments/leather garments. Only because the name of the Company was changed, the same would not mean that a fresh transaction took place. Having regard to the change in the name of the Company, the appellant's name was sought to be substituted in the original agreement. The period of the lease, the quantum of the premium paid and other terms and conditions remained unaltered except the restriction contained in clause 2(q) of the said deed, was removed. By reason of mere change of user from carrying on one business to another, it is trite, a fresh transaction does not take place. The terms and conditions of the lease can be changed by mutual consent. Unless the essential ingredients thereof as contained in Section 105 of the Transfer of Property Act are not altered, it cannot be said that the parties to the contract entered into a fresh transaction. The third respondent merely reserved unto itself a right of re-entry on expiry of the said period of eleven years. It could in terms of the covenant of the lease also extend the period of tenancy or terminate the same. Unless the lease itself came to an end, the third respondent did not have any right to reconvey the property. By reason of mere change in the name of the Company “Prasad Garments Pvt. Ltd.” the erstwhile lessee also cannot be held to have transferred its leasehold interest in favour of the appellant herein.

12. Section 2(1)(j) of the Act defines “instrument” to mean:

“2. (1)(j) ‘Instrument’ includes every document and record created or maintained in or by an electronic storage and retrieval device or media by which any right or liability is, or purports to be, created, transferred, limited, extended, extinguished or recorded;”

13. Execution of an instrument which would attract payment of stamp duty in terms of Article 5(d) of the Act must involve transfer of the property or otherwise a right or liability may inter alia be created, transferred, etc., as envisaged in Section 3 thereof. Once it is held that the supplementary agreement is neither a deed of lease nor a deed of sale within the meaning of Section 105 or Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, as the case may be, Article 5(d) of the Schedule to the Act will have no application. If Article 5(d) has no application, indisputably the residuary clause contained in Article 5(i) would have. The appellant admittedly paid the stamp duty in terms thereof.

14. It is now well settled that for the purpose of levy of stamp duty, the real and true meaning of the instrument must be ascertained. (See Madras Refineries Ltd. v. Chief Controlling Revenue Authority, Board of Revenue (1977) 2 SCC 308.)

15. The High Court held that “the supplementary lease agreement cannot be said to be an instrument whereunder the appellant Company claims certain leasehold from the Board”; but having done so, the High Court was not correct in holding that it is liable to pay the stamp duty.

16. Having regard to the fact that the entity of the appellant cannot be said to be totally different from Prasad Garments Pvt. Ltd. and as by reason of the supplementary agreement, no fresh transaction has been entered into, the impugned judgment cannot be sustained, which is set aside accordingly. The appeal is allowed. The appellant shall be entitled to costs.