- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Surendranagar District Panchayat v. Jethabhai Pitamberbhai
Factual and Procedural Background
The State of Gujarat referred an industrial dispute to the Labour Court, Surendranagar, to determine whether Shri Jethabhai Pitamberbhai was entitled to reinstatement with full back wages after his services were orally terminated on 1-4-1991. The workman, employed as a daily-wager earning Rs 22.70 per day, asserted that juniors were retained and fresh recruits were made after his termination, and that neither notice nor retrenchment compensation was given.
After considering oral testimony and xeroxed copies of attendance and muster rolls, the Labour Court held the termination illegal, ordered reinstatement, and awarded 25 % back wages from 20-6-1996.
The employer’s challenge before the Gujarat High Court failed; the High Court endorsed the Labour Court’s view that the workman had completed more than 240 days of service in the preceding year and that the employer had not produced reliable evidence to the contrary.
The employer appealed to the Supreme Court of India, leading to the present decision.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the burden of proving completion of 240 days’ continuous service in the twelve months preceding termination lies on the workman or on the employer under Sections 25-B and 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
- Whether the evidence on record established that the respondent-workman had, in fact, worked for 240 days so as to render the termination illegal and justify an order of reinstatement with back wages.
Arguments of the Parties
Respondent-Workman’s Arguments
- He had worked for about three years as a daily-wager and received Rs 22.70 per day.
- The oral termination dated 1-4-1991 violated Sections 25-F and 25-G of the Industrial Disputes Act because no notice or compensation was given, juniors were retained, and fresh workers were engaged.
Appellant-Employer’s Arguments
- The work was purely casual and dependent on availability of work and funds; hence the respondent never completed 240 days in any year.
- The oral termination was necessitated by non-availability of work and did not amount to retrenchment under the Act.
- Xerox copies of the attendance and muster registers demonstrated that the respondent had worked far less than 240 days in every relevant year.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mohan Lal v. Management of M/s Bharat Electronics Ltd., (1981) 3 SCC 225 | A workman claiming non-compliance with Section 25-F must first show completion of one year’s continuous service. | Relied on to underline that completion of 240 days is a condition precedent for claiming protection under Section 25-F. |
| Range Forest Officer v. S.T. Hadimani, (2002) 3 SCC 25 | The onus is on the workman to prove 240 days’ service; an affidavit alone is insufficient. | Cited to fault the Labour Court and High Court for placing the burden on the employer and for treating uncorroborated oral evidence as adequate proof. |
| Rajasthan State Ganganagar S. Mills Ltd. v. State of Rajasthan, (2004) 8 SCC 161 | Reiterates that the burden of proof lies on the workman to establish continuous service. | Used to support the conclusion that the respondent failed to discharge his burden. |
| Municipal Corporation, Faridabad v. Siri Niwas, (2004) 8 SCC 195 | Same principle of onus resting on the workman. | Affirmed the consistent judicial view adopted by the Court. |
| M.P. Electricity Board v. Hariram, (2004) 8 SCC 246 | Burden of proof regarding 240 days’ employment is on the claimant workman. | Further reinforced the precedent applied to overturn the lower courts’ findings. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court observed that both the Labour Court and the High Court had erroneously presumed the burden of proof to be on the employer. Citing authoritative precedents, the Court clarified that a workman alleging illegal retrenchment must first establish that he had completed 240 days of continuous service in the preceding year.
The employer produced xerox copies of attendance and muster registers showing the respondent’s actual days of work: 38 days (1984), 0 (1985), 72 (1986), 25 (1987), 0 (1988), 92 (1989), 82 (1990) and 0 (1991). These documents demonstrated that the respondent never completed 240 days in any relevant year.
Conversely, the respondent adduced only his oral testimony and did not produce wage receipts, appointment letters, or any contemporaneous records to corroborate his claim. In line with the rulings in Hadimani and other cases, the Court held that such uncorroborated evidence was insufficient.
Accordingly, the Court concluded that the mandatory condition under Section 25-B for invoking Section 25-F was not satisfied, rendering the earlier orders of reinstatement and back wages legally unsustainable.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL ALLOWED; orders of the Labour Court and the High Court are set aside.
The respondent-workman is not entitled to reinstatement or back wages. However, if reinstatement and salary were already effected pursuant to the impugned orders, the amounts paid shall not be recovered. No order as to costs. The judgment reinforces—without creating new law—the established principle that the burden of proving 240 days’ continuous service lies on the workman.
P.P Naolekar, J.— The State of Gujarat had referred the industrial dispute to the Labour Court, Surendranagar for adjudication as to whether Shri Jethabhai Pitamberbhai is to be reinstated at his original position with full payment of salary. The dispute arose as the appellant herein had terminated the services of the respondent. After notice the respondent workman filed his claim contending therein that he had been in employment with the appellant for the last three years as a daily-wager and was drawing an amount of Rs 22.70 per day; that on 1-4-1991, he was given an oral notice and was discharged from service. At the time of his discharge he was not given any written notice or payment in lieu thereof. His seniority had not been considered, and employees who were junior to him were continued in service whereas he was terminated. It was also alleged that after the termination of his service, fresh recruitments were made. In response, the employer had filed its reply and contended that the respondent was called for work, which depended upon the availability of the work and funds. The respondent had never completed 240 days in any of the years right from the beginning; that the services of the respondent were orally terminated due to non-availability of work and there was no retrenchment or termination within the meaning of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (hereinafter to be referred to as “the Act”).
2. Both the parties led evidence. It is recorded by the Labour Court in para 4 of its judgment that Exhibit 8 is the details pertaining to the attendance of the applicant, which has been produced with application. The xerox copy of attendance register and muster register has been produced as Ext. 10. On the basis of the oral evidence, the Labour Court came to the conclusion that the workman proved his case that he had worked with the employer for the last 10 years and the last wages drawn by him was Rs 22.50 and that he was discharged on 1-4-1991. That being the case, there was non-compliance with the provisions of law and therefore set aside the termination order dated 1-4-1991 declaring it illegal. The workman was awarded 25% amount of his salary from 20-6-1996 onwards.
3. The department had unsuccessfully challenged the order of reinstatement before the High Court. The High Court held that the finding of the Labour Court that the employee had completed more than 240 days in a year on the basis of the deposition of the employee was not controverted by showing any reliable evidence, and the statement showing the yearwise presence in the attendance register without proving it from the original record, could not be relied upon. The High Court held that the employee had completed more than 240 days in a year and that it was not open for it to go beyond the findings arrived at by the Labour Court.
4. From the tenor of the judgment of the Labour Court and the High Court, it is apparent to us that the judgments have proceeded on the premise as if the burden of proof lies on the employer to prove that the employee had not worked with him for 240 days in the preceding year immediately before the date of his termination. Even if we assume that the burden of proof lies on the employer, we find from the record that the employer has filed a xerox copy of the attendance register and the muster roll which indicate that in the year 1984 the workman has worked for 38 days, in the year 1985 — not a single day, in 1986 — 72 days, in 1987 — 25 days, in 1988 — not a single day, in 1989 — 92 days, in 1990 — 82 days, and in 1991 not a single day. The attendance register and the muster roll clearly indicate that in none of the years from 1984 to 1991 had the workman ever worked in the department of his employer continuously for a year to constitute continuous service of one year. The claimant, apart from his oral evidence has not produced any proof in the form of receipt of salary or wages for 240 days or record of his appointment or engagement for that year to show that he has worked with the employer for 240 days to get the benefit under Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act. It is now well settled that it is for the claimant to lead evidence to show that he had in fact worked for 240 days in a year preceding his termination.
5. In Mohan Lal v. Bharat Electronics Ltd. (1981) 3 SCC 225 it is said by this Court that before a workman can claim retrenchment not being in consonance with Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, he has to show that he has been in continuous service for not less than one year with the employer who had retrenched him from service.
6. In Range Forest Officer v. S.T Hadimani (2002) 3 SCC 25 this Court held that:
“In our opinion the Tribunal was not right in placing the onus on the management without first determining on the basis of cogent evidence that the respondent had worked for more than 240 days in the year preceding his termination. It was the case of the claimant that he had so worked but this claim was denied by the appellant. It was then for the claimant to lead evidence to show that he had in fact worked for 240 days in the year preceding his termination. Filing of an affidavit is only his own statement in his favour and that cannot be regarded as sufficient evidence for any court or tribunal to come to the conclusion that a workman had, in fact, worked for 240 days in a year. No proof of receipt of salary or wages for 240 days or order or record of appointment or engagement for this period was produced by the workman. On this ground alone, the award is liable to be set aside.”
7. More recently, in Rajasthan State Ganganagar S. Mills Ltd. v. State of Rajasthan (2004) 8 SCC 161, Municipal Corpn., Faridabad v. Siri Niwas (2004) 8 SCC 195 and M.P Electricity Board v. Hariram (2004) 8 SCC 246 this Court has reiterated the principle that the burden of proof lies on the workman to show that he had worked continuously for 240 days in the preceding one year prior to his alleged retrenchment and it is for the workman to adduce evidence apart from examining himself to prove the factum of his being in employment of the employer.
8. On the face of the aforesaid authorities, the Labour Court and the High Court committed an error in placing the burden on the employer to prove that the workman had not worked for 240 days with the employer. The burden of proof having been on the workman, he has to adduce evidence in support of his contention that he has complied with the requirement of Section 25-B of the Industrial Disputes Act. In the present case, apart from examining himself in support of his contention the workman did not produce any material to prove the fact that he worked for 240 days. In fact the employer had produced before the Labour Court the attendance register of the workman and the muster roll clearly showing that the workman had not worked continuously in the preceding year with the employer or that he had worked with the employer for 240 days in the preceding 12 months prior to his alleged retrenchment. In the absence of evidence on record the Labour Court and the High Court have committed an error in law and fact in directing reinstatement of the respondent workman. That being the case, the award of the Labour Court and the judgment of the High Court, are set aside. The appeal is allowed. However, in the circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs. If the workman has been reinstated in pursuance of the order of the Labour Court, salary and other emoluments paid to him shall not be recovered.
Alert