Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of U.P And Another v. Siya Ram And Another

Supreme Court Of India
Aug 5, 2004
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondent 1, an Executive Engineer (Mechanical) in the Irrigation Department of the State of Uttar Pradesh, was transferred on 23-10-2002 from Tubewell Division I, Ghazipur, to the Office of the Joint Chief Engineer, Tubewell East, Faizabad. The transfer order expressly cited “administrative grounds.” Contesting the move, Respondent 1 filed a writ petition before the Allahabad High Court, alleging the transfer was a punitive measure linked to pending departmental proceedings and was effected without affording him a hearing. On 5-11-2003, a Division Bench of the High Court accepted this contention, quashed the transfer order, and held that the State should have awaited the outcome of the disciplinary process. The State of Uttar Pradesh appealed to the Supreme Court, resulting in the present decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned transfer order was punitive and connected to disciplinary proceedings or merely an administrative action in the public interest.
  2. Whether the High Court, in exercise of its powers under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution, was justified in interfering with the transfer.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent 1 (Writ Petitioner)

  • The transfer was imposed as a measure of punishment while departmental proceedings were underway.
  • No opportunity of hearing was granted prior to the transfer.
  • The Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission did not approve the proposed disciplinary action, yet the transfer was still ordered.

State of Uttar Pradesh (Appellant)

  • The transfer was effected purely on administrative grounds and in the public interest.
  • The post to which the respondent was shifted being “non-working” did not vitiate the legality of the order.
  • No mala fides or statutory violations were alleged or proved.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
National Hydroelectric Power Corporation Ltd. v. Shri Bhagwan, (2001) 8 SCC 574 Court or tribunal should not normally interfere with transfer orders unless shown to be mala fide or in breach of statutory provisions. Used to underline that transfer is an incident of service and judicial interference is limited.
Union of India v. Janardhan Debanath, (2004) 4 SCC 245 Reaffirmed the limited scope of judicial review over administrative transfers. Cited to reinforce the principle that absence of mala fides bars intervention.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court observed that transfer is a normal incident and condition of service for government employees in transferable posts. Judicial scrutiny is permitted only where mala fides are established or statutory prohibitions are violated. The High Court, by examining whether the transfer served the public interest, ventured into a factual domain inappropriate for writ jurisdiction. The apex court found “not an iota of material” linking the transfer to disciplinary proceedings and held that no mala fides were attributable to the State. Consequently, the High Court’s determination that the order was punitive lacked evidentiary support and conflicted with settled law.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Supreme Court set aside the Allahabad High Court’s judgment; the appeal was allowed with no order as to costs.

Implications: The decision reaffirms the narrow scope of judicial review over transfer orders, emphasizing that courts should not interfere absent proof of mala fides or statutory breach. While Respondent 1 may submit a representation against the transfer, its consideration remains an administrative matter. No new precedent is created; the ruling consolidates existing jurisprudence on employee transfers.

Show all summary ...

Arijit Pasayat, J.— Leave granted.

2. While Respondent 1 was functioning as an Executive Engineer (Mechanical), Irrigation Division I, Government of U.P, he was transferred from the Tubewell Division I, Ghazipur to the Office of Joint Chief Engineer, Tubewell East, Faizabad. The transfer order dated 23-10-2002 shows that the transfer was on administrative grounds.

3. The said order of transfer of Respondent 1 having been quashed by a Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court, the State of U.P is in appeal. The respondent filed a writ petition in the Allahabad High Court questioning the order of transfer. The primary stand taken in the writ application was that the order of transfer was as a measure of punishment. An enquiry in departmental proceedings had been initiated. Without affording him an opportunity of being heard, the transfer was done as a measure of punishment. The disciplinary action which was taken against Respondent 1 pursuant to the enquiry conducted was referred to the Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission for approval. But it was not approved. The present appellant State filed a counter-affidavit taking the stand that the transfer of the writ petitioner was on administrative grounds and merely because the writ petitioner was transferred to a non-working post, that did not in any way vitiate the order of transfer.

4. The writ petition was allowed by the impugned judgment dated 5-11-2003 holding that the order of transfer was punitive in nature and had been passed by the State Government without awaiting the decision in the disciplinary proceedings.

5. The High Court while exercising jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India had gone into the question as to whether the transfer was in the interest of public service. That would essentially require factual adjudication and invariably depend upon peculiar facts and circumstances of the case concerned. No government servant or employee of a public undertaking has any legal right to be posted forever at any one particular place or place of his choice since transfer of a particular employee appointed to the class or category of transferable posts from one place to other is not only an incident, but a condition of service, necessary too in public interest and efficiency in the public administration. Unless an order of transfer is shown to be an outcome of mala fide exercise or stated to be in violation of statutory provisions prohibiting any such transfer, the courts or the tribunals normally cannot interfere with such orders as a matter of routine, as though they were appellate authorities substituting their own decision for that of the employer/management, as against such orders passed in the interest of administrative exigencies of the service concerned. This position was highlighted by this Court in National Hydroelectric Power Corpn. Ltd. v. Shri Bhagwan (2001) 8 SCC 574.

6. The above position was recently highlighted in Union of India v. Janardhan Debanath (2004) 4 SCC 245. It has to be noted that the High Court proceeded on the basis as if the transfer was connected with the departmental proceedings. There was not an iota of material to arrive at the conclusion. No mala fides could be attributed as the order was purely on administrative grounds and in public interest.

7. In view of the settled position in law the judgment of the High Court is indefensible and is set aside.

8. Learned counsel for Respondent 1 submitted that the respondent shall file a representation highlighting the various difficulties which may result or have resulted from the transfer and the non-desirability thereof. If such representation is made to the appropriate authorities, it goes without saying that the same shall be considered in its proper perspective and in accordance with law. We do not express any opinion in that regard. The appeal is allowed to the extent indicated with no order as to costs.