Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

K. Ganesh Shet v. A.K Jayarama Sheka And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Aug 27, 2004
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Proceedings for eviction of a tenant were initiated by the landlord under Section 21(1)(f) of the Karnataka Rent Control Act, 1961 (“the Act”), alleging unlawful sub-letting of the premises without the landlord’s consent.

The trial court dismissed the landlord’s claim for eviction. The landlord then filed a revision before the District Judge. The District Judge allowed the revision, held that there was sub-letting without the landlord’s consent, and directed eviction of the tenant and the sub-tenants.

The two sub-tenants challenged the District Judge’s order by filing revisions before the High Court. The High Court upheld the factual finding that the premises had been sub-let without the landlord’s consent, but nonetheless refused to grant eviction. Taking note that the original tenant had died and that the sub-tenants were thereafter holding under the legal representatives of the original tenant, the High Court considered that the sub-tenants deserved to be shown “mercy”. It enhanced the rent from Rs 600 per month to Rs 1000 per month, directed that the enhanced rent be paid directly to the landlord bypassing the tenant, and dismissed the claim for eviction.

The landlord, aggrieved by the High Court’s refusal to order eviction despite affirming the finding of illegal sub-letting, filed the present appeals by special leave. During the pendency of these appeals, the Karnataka Rent Control Act, 1961 was repealed and replaced by the Karnataka Rent Act, 1999 with effect from 31-12-1999. By reference to Section 70 of the new Act and the decision in Mahendra Saree Emporium (II) v. G.V. Srinivasa Murthy (2005) 1 SCC 481, the Court noted that these appeals would not abate and would be heard and decided as if the 1999 Act had not been passed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court was justified in refusing to evict the tenant and sub-tenants, despite a concurrent finding of illegal sub-letting without the landlord’s consent, on the grounds that the original tenant had died and the sub-tenants deserved to be treated with mercy.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Mahendra Saree Emporium (II) v. G.V. Srinivasa Murthy, (2005) 1 SCC 481 Interpretation of Section 70 of the Karnataka Rent Act, 1999, holding that pending appeals shall not abate and are to be decided as if the 1999 Act had not been passed. The Court relied on this decision to hold that the present appeals do not abate due to the repeal of the 1961 Act and must be heard and decided under the legal framework as if the 1999 Act had not come into force.
A.S. Sulochana v. C. Dharmalingam, (1987) 1 SCC 180 Earlier view that where a sub-tenancy was created by a tenant who later died, the legal heirs of the tenant and the sub-tenants could not be evicted “for the sin committed by the deceased tenant.” The High Court had relied on this precedent to show “mercy” to the sub-tenants and to refuse eviction. The Supreme Court noted this view stands overruled and thus could not justify the High Court’s refusal to order eviction.
Parvinder Singh v. Renu Gautam, (2004) 4 SCC 794 Overrules the view taken in A.S. Sulochana regarding protection of legal heirs and sub-tenants from eviction where illegal sub-tenancy was created by the deceased tenant. The Court cited this decision to state that the legal position in A.S. Sulochana has been overruled, thereby removing the basis on which the High Court had extended protection to the sub-tenants and refused eviction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first addressed the effect of the repeal of the Karnataka Rent Control Act, 1961 and its replacement by the Karnataka Rent Act, 1999. Referring to Section 70 of the 1999 Act and its own decision in Mahendra Saree Emporium (II) v. G.V. Srinivasa Murthy, the Court held that the present appeals do not abate and must be decided as if the 1999 Act had not been enacted.

The central issue was whether the High Court could, despite confirming the finding that the premises were sub-let without the landlord’s consent, refuse eviction solely because the original tenant had died and the sub-tenants were considered deserving of “mercy”. The High Court had relied on the earlier decision in A.S. Sulochana v. C. Dharmalingam, which had held that the legal heirs of a tenant and the sub-tenants could not be evicted “for the sin committed by the deceased tenant” who created the sub-tenancy.

The Supreme Court observed that the view of the law taken in A.S. Sulochana “stands overruled”, citing Parvinder Singh v. Renu Gautam (2004) 4 SCC 794. Consequently, the High Court’s reliance on that overruled principle to justify refusal of eviction and to show mercy to the sub-tenants was legally untenable.

The Court noted that the sub-tenancy had been created in 1978 without the landlord’s consent. This finding of illegal sub-tenancy had been recorded by the District Judge upon appreciation of evidence, and the High Court had upheld this factual finding. The Supreme Court expressly stated that it found no reason to interfere with that finding of fact.

Given the established and unchallenged factual finding of unlawful sub-letting without consent, the Court held that the legal consequences must follow. Under Section 21(1)(f) of the 1961 Act, such illegal sub-letting provides a valid ground for eviction. Having successfully proved this ground, the landlord was entitled to eviction, and both the tenant and the sub-tenants were liable to be evicted. The High Court’s approach of merely enhancing rent and directing payment directly to the landlord, while refusing eviction, was therefore contrary to the legal consequences mandated by the statute and applicable case law.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeals were allowed. The judgment of the High Court was set aside, and the order of the District Judge directing eviction of the tenant and the sub-tenants was restored. The decree for eviction was ordered to remain suspended for four months from the date of the judgment, conditional upon the tenant and the sub-tenants filing the usual undertaking within four weeks in the executing court. The appellant (landlord) was awarded costs throughout against the respondent tenant and sub-tenants.

Implications: The immediate effect of the decision is that the landlord’s decree for eviction under Section 21(1)(f) of the Karnataka Rent Control Act, 1961 stands restored, subject to the limited grace period and filing of undertakings. The High Court’s attempt to deny eviction on compassionate or “mercy” grounds, despite a factual finding of illegal sub-letting, was rejected. The Court applied the already established principle that the earlier decision in A.S. Sulochana has been overruled by Parvinder Singh, and no broader or new legal rule was created beyond enforcing the existing statutory ground of eviction and the binding effect of the later precedent.

Show all summary ...

R.C Lahoti, C.J— Proceedings for eviction of tenant on the ground available under Section 21(1)(f) of the Karnataka Rent Control Act, 1961 (hereinafter the Act for short) were initiated. The trial court dismissed the claim for eviction. The landlord preferred revision before the Court of District Judge which was allowed and the tenant and the sub-tenants were directed to be evicted. The two sub-tenants preferred revisions in the High Court. The High Court has upheld the finding of fact recorded by the District Judge that the premises were sub-let without the consent of the landlord. However, still the High Court has granted relief to the sub-tenants and denied relief of eviction to the landlord. The High Court has formed an opinion that in spite of the sub-tenants having been illegally inducted into the premises, the original tenant had died and the sub-tenants were holding under the legal representatives of the original tenant and the sub-tenants deserved to be shown mercy. The High Court directed the rent which was being paid by the sub-tenants at the rate of Rs 600 per month to be enhanced to Rs 1000 per month and that too directly to the landlord bypassing the tenant and having done so, directed the claim for eviction to be dismissed. Consequently, these two appeals by special leave have been filed by the landlord.

2. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, we are satisfied that the judgment of the High Court cannot be sustained.

3. During the pendency of these appeals, the Act of 1961 has been repealed and replaced by the Karnataka Rent Act, 1999 with effect from 31-12-1999. Dealing with Section 70 of the new Act we have today held in Mahendra Saree Emporium (II) v. G.V Srinivasa Murthy (2005) 1 SCC 481 that these appeals shall not abate and shall be heard and decided as if the 1999 Act was not passed.

4. The sole question which arises for decision in these appeals is whether the High Court was justified in refusing to evict the tenant and the sub-tenants simply because the original tenant had died and the sub-tenants deserved to be treated with mercy. The High Court drew support from the decision of this Court in A.S Sulochana v. C. Dharmalingam (1987) 1 SCC 180 according to which if the sub-tenancy was created by a tenant and the tenant had died then the legal heirs of the tenant and the sub-tenants could not be evicted “for the sin committed by the deceased tenant”. The view of the law so taken in A.S Sulochana case (1987) 1 SCC 180 stands overruled. (See Parvinder Singh v. Renu Gautam (2004) 4 SCC 794.) The sub-tenancy was created in 1978 without the consent of the tenant. The finding as to creation of sub-tenancy has been recorded by the learned District Judge on appreciation of evidence within his jurisdiction and has been upheld by the High Court. We find no reason to interfere with that finding of fact. The legal consequences must, therefore, follow. The landlord has successfully made out a ground for eviction and the tenant must be evicted along with the sub-tenants.

5. The appeals are allowed. The judgment of the High Court is set aside and instead that of the District Judge is restored. However, the decree for eviction shall remain suspended for a period of four months from today subject to the tenant and the sub-tenants filing the usual undertaking within a period of four weeks from today in the executing court. The appellant shall be entitled to costs throughout from the respondent tenant and sub-tenants.