- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Hari Ram v. State Of U.P .
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, Hari Ram, was tried along with his co-accused Parmanand for the murder of Kundan Lal, who was their uncle and owner of approximately 34 bighas of agricultural land. The prosecution alleged that the accused had been pressuring the deceased—who had no male heir—to transfer his land to them and had previously threatened him. On 13-11-1980, while the deceased was being escorted to collect his share of paddy, the appellant allegedly brandished a country-made pistol to deter eyewitnesses Ajudhia (PW 1) and Mangli (PW 2), while Parmanand inflicted fatal injuries with a sickle. An FIR was lodged the same day, and both accused were charged under Section 302 IPC; the appellant was specifically charged under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC (common intention).
The Additional District and Sessions Judge, Bareilly, convicted the appellant and sentenced him to life imprisonment. The Allahabad High Court affirmed the conviction and sentence. The present Supreme Court judgment addresses the appellant’s challenge to those concurrent findings.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appellant’s conviction under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC was sustainable in the absence of direct evidence showing his active participation in the stabbing of the deceased.
- Whether reliance on the testimony of related eyewitnesses (PW 1 and PW 2) without independent corroboration vitiated the conviction.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The factual matrix did not establish any overt act by the appellant; hence Section 34 IPC (common intention) was inapplicable.
- PW 1 and PW 2 were close relatives of the deceased and therefore “interested”; their uncorroborated testimony should not have been relied upon.
State's Arguments
- The sequence of events and the appellant’s conduct (threatening eyewitnesses with a pistol) clearly demonstrated common intention, justifying application of Section 34 IPC.
- The courts below had correctly found PW 1 and PW 2 to be reliable and cogent, and their relationship to the deceased did not per se undermine their credibility.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ashok Kumar v. State of Punjab (1977) 1 SCC 746, AIR 1977 SC 109 | Existence of common intention is essential for Section 34 IPC; identical acts by each accused are unnecessary. | Used to affirm that the appellant’s threatening conduct coupled with the co-accused’s act satisfied the requirement of common intention. |
| Mahbub Shah v. Emperor, AIR 1945 PC 118 | Historical clarification of the phrase “in furtherance of the common intention of all” in Section 34 IPC. | Cited to underscore the statutory basis for joint liability. |
| Chinta Pulla Reddy v. State of A.P, 1993 Supp (3) SCC 134, AIR 1993 SC 1899 | Section 34 applies even if a particular accused causes no physical injury; an overt act is not mandatory. | Relied on to reject the appellant’s plea that absence of a stabbing act by him negated liability. |
| Anil Sharma v. State of Jharkhand (2004) 5 SCC 679 | Reiteration of principles governing common intention. | Referenced to support the trial and High Court findings on Section 34. |
| Dalip Singh v. State of Punjab, AIR 1953 SC 364 | Relationship of a witness to the victim does not automatically impair credibility. | Used to rebut the appellant’s challenge to PW 1 and PW 2 on grounds of “interestedness.” |
| Guli Chand v. State of Rajasthan (1974) 3 SCC 698 | Followed Dalip Singh on credibility of related witnesses. | Cited for the same proposition. |
| Vadivelu Thevar v. State of Madras, AIR 1957 SC 614 | Evaluation of partisan witnesses. | Referred to in reaffirming acceptance of related eyewitnesses. |
| Rameshwar v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1952 SC 54 | No rigid rule that testimony of related witnesses requires corroboration solely because of relationship. | Invoked while discussing evidentiary weight of PW 1 and PW 2. |
| Masalti v. State of U.P, AIR 1965 SC 202 | Mechanical rejection of partisan evidence leads to failure of justice. | Quoted to justify reliance on the related eyewitnesses. |
| State of Rajasthan v. Teja Ram (1999) 3 SCC 507, AIR 1999 SC 1776 | Natural witnesses at the scene need not be discarded for lack of “independence.” | Further bolstered acceptance of PW 1 and PW 2. |
| Sucha Singh v. State of Punjab (2003) 7 SCC 643 | Prosecution is expected to examine those who actually witnessed the incident. | Used to dismiss criticism that other villagers were not examined. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
After restating the jurisprudence on Section 34 IPC, the Court observed that:
- The appellant’s act of brandishing a pistol to keep PW 1 and PW 2 at bay while Parmanand fatally attacked the deceased evidenced a “meeting of minds” and participation in the common intention to kill.
- Direct proof of common intention is rare; it can be inferred from surrounding circumstances, which were clearly established by the eyewitness testimony.
- The absence of “independent” or unrelated witnesses did not vitiate the prosecution case. Citing a long line of authorities, the Court held that relationship alone is no ground to discard otherwise cogent testimony.
- No material was placed by the defence to suggest false implication or enmity potent enough to motivate PW 1 and PW 2 to accuse an innocent relative.
- Accordingly, both the factual findings and legal conclusions of the trial court and the High Court were found to be free from infirmity.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED.
The Supreme Court affirmed the appellant’s conviction under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC and the sentence of life imprisonment. The decision reinforces established principles governing joint liability and the evidentiary value of related eyewitnesses but does not create new law; its immediate effect is confined to upholding the appellant’s sentence.
Arijit Pasayat, J.— Leave granted.
2. The appellant was convicted for offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (in short “IPC”) and was sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life by the learned Additional District and Sessions Judge, Bareilly. Such conviction and sentence were confirmed by the impugned judgment of the Allahabad High Court.
3. The prosecution version in a nutshell is as follows:
Kundan Lal (hereinafter referred to as “the deceased”), who was resident of Village Siraura in District Bareilly, was the real brother of Gendan Lal, the father of the appellant Hari Ram and co-accused Parmanand. Gendan Lal had another son Hardwari. The deceased had no male issue and had only one daughter named Smt Nanhi, who was married to Ajudhia (PW 1). The deceased owned about 34 bighas agricultural land, which was jointly recorded in his name and in the name of Gendan Lal, but each of them had got separated their share by mutual agreement. The deceased had given his land on crop-share basis. Since the deceased had no male issue, the appellant and co-accused Parmanand wanted to take his land and had also threatened him that in case he did not transfer his land in their favour, they would kill him. On 1-4-1980 at about 12.30 p.m Parmanand again threatened the deceased to transfer his land in his favour otherwise he would kill him. The deceased had lodged report of the said incident at Police Station Bhojipura.
4. Apprehending danger to his life at Village Siraura the deceased had come to his daughter's house at Village Ashpur and was residing there after 1-4-1980. After about a month Gendan Lal came to the deceased at Village Ashpur and apologised for mistake of his sons and asked him to go to his village, but the deceased refused to do so. Gendan Lal then asked him to give his land to him on crop-share basis. The deceased agreed to it and gave his land to Gendan Lal. Thereafter, Gendan Lal had sent wheat of his share to the deceased.
5. On 12-11-1980 i.e a day before the date of occurrence of this case, Hardwari, brother of the appellant came to the deceased at Village Ashpur at about 10.00 a.m and asked him to go to his house to take his share of paddy. The deceased agreed to it and told that he would come next day. On 13-11-1980 at about 8.00 a.m the deceased along with Ajudhia (PW 1) and Mangli (PW 2) started for Village Siraura in a bullock cart and they reached at the chaupal of the appellant and Parmanand who asked the deceased to go to khalihan to take the paddy. The deceased proceeded to khalihan along with the appellant and Parmanand as well as Ajudhia (PW 1) and Mangli (PW 2). When they reached at a distance of about one furlong towards west of village abadi in between Jwar Arhar and Jwar Patsan the appellant whipped out a country-made pistol from his waist and pointing towards Ajudhia (PW 1) and Mangli (PW 2) asked them to go back. Due to fear Ajudhia and Mangli receded back about 8 to 10 paces. The appellant stopped the deceased. Then Parmanand whipped out a sickle from his waist and inflicted injuries on his abdomen. When Ajudhia (PW 1) and Mangli (PW 2) tried to raise an alarm, the appellant again threatened them on the point of pistol that they should not raise alarm. The deceased fell down and died on the spot. Ajudhia (PW 1) came to the Pradhan of the village and narrated the entire incident. Village people also assembled there. Thereafter they asked him to lodge report. Ajudhia (PW 1) got prepared the report from one Niranjan and lodged the same at Police Station Bhojipura at 1.00 p.m
6. Chik FIR was prepared by Head Constable Madan Mohan Chaubey, who made an endorsement of the same at GD report and registered a case under Section 302 IPC against both Parmanand and Hari Ram.
7. A charge-sheet was placed and they faced trial. The prosecution mainly relied on the evidence of PWs 1 and 2 who were stated to be eyewitnesses. They were found reliable, credible and their version was held to be cogent. Accused Parmanand was found guilty of offence punishable under Section 302 IPC while the appellant was found guilty of offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC. The trial court's judgment was affirmed by a Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court by the impugned judgment.
8. In support of the appeal learned counsel for the appellant submitted that the background scenario as projected by the prosecution does not show that the appellant had any role to play in the alleged commission of offence and, therefore, Section 34 could not be applied. It was submitted that PWs 1 and 2 were related to the deceased and were not independent witnesses.
9. Learned counsel for the State supported the judgments of the courts below and submitted that the accusations have been fully established and Section 34 IPC has been rightly applied.
10. Section 34 has been enacted on the principle of joint liability in the doing of a criminal act. The section is only a rule of evidence and does not create a substantive offence. The distinctive feature of the section is the element of participation in action. The liability of one person for an offence committed by another in the course of criminal act perpetrated by several persons arises under Section 34 if such criminal act is done in furtherance of a common intention of the persons who join in committing the crime. Direct proof of common intention is seldom available and, therefore, such intention can only be inferred from the circumstances appearing from the proved facts of the case and the proved circumstances. In order to bring home the charge of common intention, the prosecution has to establish by evidence, whether direct or circumstantial, that there was plan or meeting of minds of all the accused persons to commit the offence for which they are charged with the aid of Section 34, be it pre-arranged or on the spur of the moment; but it must necessarily be before the commission of the crime. The true contents of the section are that if two or more persons intentionally do an act jointly, the position in law is just the same as if each of them has done it individually by himself. As observed in Ashok Kumar v. State of Punjab (1977) 1 SCC 746, AIR 1977 SC 109 the existence of a common intention amongst the participants in a crime is the essential element for application of this section. It is not necessary that the acts of the several persons charged with commission of an offence jointly must be the same or identically similar. The acts may be different in character, but must have been actuated by one and the same common intention in order to attract the provision.
11. As it originally stood, Section 34 was in the following terms:
“34. When a criminal act is done by several persons, each of such persons is liable for that act in the same manner as if the act was done by him alone.”
12. In 1870, it was amended by the insertion of the words “in furtherance of the common intention of all” after the word “persons” and before the word “each”, so as to make the object of Section 34 clear. This position was noted in Mahbub Shah v. Emperor AIR 1945 PC 118.
13. The section does not say “the common intentions of all”, nor does it say “an intention common to all”. Under the provisions of Section 34 the essence of the liability is to be found in the existence of a common intention animating the accused leading to the doing of a criminal act in furtherance of such intention. As a result of the application of principles enunciated in Section 34, when an accused is convicted under Section 302 read with Section 34, in law it means that the accused is liable for the act which caused death of the deceased in the same manner as if it was done by him alone. The provision is intended to meet a case in which it may be difficult to distinguish between acts of individual members of a party who act in furtherance of the common intention of all or to prove exactly what part was taken by each of them. As was observed in Chinta Pulla Reddy v. State of A.P 1993 Supp (3) SCC 134, AIR 1993 SC 1899 Section 34 is applicable even if no injury has been caused by the particular accused himself. For applying Section 34 it is not necessary to show some overt act on the part of the accused.
14. The above position was highlighted recently in Anil Sharma v. State of Jharkhand (2004) 5 SCC 679.
15. Section 34 IPC has clear application to the facts of the case and has been rightly applied.
16. The plea that there is no independent witness is of no consequence.
17. We shall first deal with the contention regarding interestedness of the witnesses for furthering prosecution version. Relationship is not a factor to affect the credibility of a witness. It is more often than not that a relation would not conceal actual culprit and make allegations against an innocent person. Foundation has to be laid if plea of false implication is made. In such cases, the court has to adopt a careful approach and analyse evidence to find out whether it is cogent and credible.
18. In Dalip Singh v. State of Punjab AIR 1953 SC 364, 1953 Cri LJ 1465 it has been laid down as under: (AIR p. 366, para 26)
“26. A witness is normally to be considered independent unless he or she springs from sources which are likely to be tainted and that usually means unless the witness has cause, such as enmity against the accused, to wish to implicate him falsely. Ordinarily a close relation would be the last to screen the real culprit and falsely implicate an innocent person. It is true, when feelings run high and there is personal cause for enmity, that there is a tendency to drag in an innocent person against whom a witness has a grudge along with the guilty, but foundation must be laid for such a criticism and the mere fact of relationship far from being a foundation is often a sure guarantee of truth. However, we are not attempting any sweeping generalisation. Each case must be judged on its own facts. Our observations are only made to combat what is so often put forward in cases before us as a general rule of prudence. There is no such general rule. Each case must be limited to and be governed by its own facts.”
19. The above decision has since been followed in Guli Chand v. State of Rajasthan (1974) 3 SCC 698 in which Vadivelu Thevar v. State of Madras AIR 1957 SC 614, 1957 Cri LJ 1000 was also relied upon.
20. We may also observe that the ground that the witness being a close relative and consequently, being a partisan witness, should not be relied upon, has no substance. This theory was repelled by this Court as early as in Dalip Singh case AIR 1953 SC 364, 1953 Cri LJ 1465 in which surprise was expressed over the impression which prevailed in the minds of the members of the Bar that relatives were not independent witnesses. Speaking through Vivian Bose, J. it was observed: (AIR p. 366, para 25)
“25. We are unable to agree with the learned Judges of the High Court that the testimony of the two eyewitnesses requires corroboration. If the foundation for such an observation is based on the fact that the witnesses are women and that the fate of seven men hangs on their testimony, we know of no such rule. If it is grounded on the reason that they are closely related to the deceased we are unable to concur. This is a fallacy common to many criminal cases and one which another Bench of this Court endeavoured to dispel in — ‘Rameshwar v. State of Rajasthan AIR 1952 SC 54, 1952 Cri LJ 547’ (AIR at p. 59). We find, however, that it unfortunately still persists, if not in the judgments of the courts, at any rate in the arguments of counsel.”
21. Again in Masalti v. State of U.P AIR 1965 SC 202, (1965) 1 Cri LJ 226 this Court observed: (pp. 209-10, para 14)
“But it would, we think, be unreasonable to contend that evidence given by witnesses should be discarded only on the ground that it is evidence of partisan or interested witnesses. … The mechanical rejection of such evidence on the sole ground that it is partisan would invariably lead to failure of justice. No hard-and-fast rule can be laid down as to how much evidence should be appreciated. Judicial approach has to be cautious in dealing with such evidence; but the plea that such evidence should be rejected because it is partisan cannot be accepted as correct.”
22. As observed by this Court in State of Rajasthan v. Teja Ram (1999) 3 SCC 507, AIR 1999 SC 1776 the overinsistence on witnesses having no relation with the victims often results in criminal justice going awry. When any incident happens in a dwelling house or nearby the most natural witnesses would be the inmates of that house. It would be unpragmatic to ignore such natural witnesses and insist on outsiders who would not have even seen anything. If the Court has discerned from the evidence or even from the investigation records that some other independent person has witnessed any event connecting the incident in question then there is justification for making adverse comments against non-examination of such person as prosecution witness. Otherwise, merely on surmises the Court should not castigate the prosecution for not examining other persons of the locality as prosecution witnesses. Prosecution can be expected to examine only those who have witnessed the events and not those who have not seen it though the neighbourhood may be replete with other residents also. (See Sucha Singh v. State of Punjab (2003) 7 SCC 643.)
23. Appeal is without merit and deserves dismissal which we direct.
Alert