- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Aero Traders (P) Ltd. v. Ravinder Kumar Suri .
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant is a tenant of a commercial premises in Karol Bagh, New Delhi, paying a monthly rent of Rs 30. The landlord (Respondent 1) initiated eviction proceedings under Section 14(1)(a) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958, alleging arrears of rent. On 20-12-1999 the Rent Controller, acting under Section 15(1) of the Act, directed the appellant to clear arrears from 1-6-1996 and to deposit future rent by the 15th of every month.
Alleging non-compliance, the landlord applied under Section 15(7) to strike off the tenant’s defence. On 19-3-2001 the Rent Controller allowed the application. The appellant’s appeal was partially allowed by the Additional Rent Control Tribunal on 22-5-2001, granting a last opportunity to deposit arrears plus an equal penalty within 30 days.
Both parties sought supervisory relief under Article 227 before the Delhi High Court. On 9-9-2003 the High Court allowed the landlord’s petition, set aside the Tribunal’s order, and restored the Rent Controller’s decision striking off the defence; the tenant’s petition was dismissed. The present appeals, filed by special leave, challenge the High Court’s judgment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the tenant had in fact complied with the Section 15(1) order to pay or deposit rent and, if not, whether striking off the defence under Section 15(7) was justified.
- Whether the Rent Control Tribunal correctly exercised its discretion in granting the tenant a further opportunity to deposit arrears with penalty.
- Whether the High Court erred in exercising supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 by restoring the Rent Controller’s order.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (Tenant)
- Asserted compliance with the Section 15(1) order, contending that rent was sent to the landlord through cheques which the landlord failed to encash.
- Argued that, even if some default occurred, Section 15(7) vests a discretionary power which should be exercised leniently in favour of continuation of the defence.
- Sought quashing of adverse factual findings recorded by the Rent Controller regarding alleged non-payment.
Respondent 1 (Landlord)
- Denied receiving any rent cheques and maintained that no evidence proved their dispatch or delivery.
- Characterised the tenant’s plea as wilful, false, and contumacious, warranting the striking off of the defence under Section 15(7).
- Supported the High Court’s view that the Tribunal’s indulgence was contrary to the settled legal approach under Section 15(7).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Jain Motor Car Co. v. Swayam Prabha Jain (1996) 3 SCC 55 | Section 15(7) gives discretionary power to strike out defence; discretion must not be exercised mechanically. | Used as the principal authority framing the scope and limits of the discretion under Section 15(7). |
| Hem Chand v. Delhi Cloth & General Mills Co. Ltd. (1977) 3 SCC 483 | Earlier exposition of principles guiding the exercise of discretion under rent legislation. | Cited in the chain of precedents validating the need for judicial, not mechanical, discretion. |
| Shyamcharan Sharma v. Dharamdas (1980) 2 SCC 151 | Reinforced the non-mechanical exercise of discretion in rent matters. | Referenced in support of the governing principle on discretion. |
| Ram Murti v. Bhola Nath (1984) 3 SCC 111 | Elaborated on factors relevant to striking off defence for non-payment of rent. | Forms part of the precedent chain guiding the current analysis. |
| Kamla Devi v. Vasdev (1995) 1 SCC 356 | Clarified tenant’s obligations and court’s powers under rent control statutes. | Cited as an additional authority on discretionary power. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court first reiterated that Section 15(7) confers a judicial discretion which must be exercised in accordance with “rules of reason and justice.” Relying on Jain Motor Car Co. and related precedents, the Court emphasised that discretion cannot be exercised where the tenant’s conduct is dishonest or contumacious.
Factually, both the Rent Controller and the Tribunal had found that the tenant’s plea of sending cheques was unsubstantiated and false. Documentary evidence of dispatch was absent, and even the amounts allegedly tendered (Rs 930) were less than the arrears actually ordered (Rs 1260). Moreover, the tenant failed to pay or deposit monthly rent from January to May 2000 within the mandated time frames.
The Tribunal, despite confirming the tenant’s lack of bona fides, extended indulgence by ordering a fresh deposit with penalty. The Supreme Court held that such indulgence was unwarranted because:
- The premises were commercial, located in a prime area, and the monthly rent was merely Rs 30, yet the tenant remained in persistent default.
- There existed “absolutely no ground” for exercising equitable discretion in favour of the tenant.
- The High Court correctly identified the tenant’s default as “wilful and contumacious,” justifying the striking off of the defence.
Consequently, the Court affirmed the High Court’s restoration of the Rent Controller’s order.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeals are dismissed with costs of Rs 10,000; the order of the Rent Controller striking off the tenant’s defence stands restored.
Implications: The tenant’s defence in the underlying eviction proceedings is permanently struck off, significantly advancing the landlord’s eviction petition. The judgment reinforces that courts will withhold discretionary relief where a tenant’s default is deliberate and unsubstantiated, but it introduces no new legal principle beyond affirming established precedent.
G.P Mathur, J.— Leave granted.
2. These appeals, by special leave, have been preferred against the judgment and order dated 9-9-2003 of the Delhi High Court by which the writ petition filed by Respondent 1 Ravinder Kumar Suri, under Article 227 of the Constitution was allowed, the order dated 22-5-2001 of the Additional Rent Control Tribunal was set aside and the order dated 19-3-2001 of the Rent Controller was restored by which the defence of the appellant was struck off. By the same order the writ petition filed by the appellant tenant was dismissed.
3. The appellant is a tenant of a commercial premises situate in Karol Bagh, New Delhi on a rental of Rs 30 per month. The landlord, Ravinder Kumar Suri, filed a petition for eviction of the appellant under Section 14(1)(a) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958 (for short “the Act”) on the ground, inter alia, that the appellant was in arrears of rent. The Rent Controller passed an order under Section 15(1) of the Act on 20-12-1999 directing the appellant to deposit or pay to the landlord within one month the entire arrears of rent w.e.f 1-6-1996 and to continue to pay the future rent by 15th of each succeeding month. The landlord (Respondent 1) moved an application under Section 15(7) of the Act for striking off the defence of the appellant (tenant) on the ground that he did not comply with the order. The appellant claimed that he had complied with the order and had sent the rent by cheques but the landlord did not encash the same. The Rent Controller held that the appellant had neither paid the rent to the landlord nor had he deposited the amount in court. Accordingly, he passed an order on 19-3-2001 by which the application filed by the landlord was allowed and the defence of the appellant was struck off. The appellant preferred an appeal before the Rent Control Tribunal which was disposed of by the judgment and order dated 22-5-2001 with a direction to the appellant to deposit the whole arrears of rent along with penalty of the same amount within 30 days, failing which his defence shall stand struck off as directed by the Rent Controller. The landlord challenged the order passed by the Rent Control Tribunal by filing a writ petition under Article 227 of the Constitution before the Delhi High Court. The appellant also filed a petition for quashing of certain findings which were recorded against him by the Rent Controller. The High Court allowed the writ petition filed by the landlord, set aside the order passed by the Rent Control Tribunal and restored that of the Rent Controller. The writ petition filed by the appellant was dismissed.
4. In order to establish his case, the appellant placed on record a letter dated 3-1-2000 sent by its counsel to the landlord, wherein it was mentioned that the rent at the rate of Rs 30 per month w.e.f 1-6-1996 to 31-12-1999 amounting to Rs 930 was being sent by cheque. The landlord seriously disputed the fact that any cheque was sent to him. The appellant did not lead any evidence whatsoever to establish that any cheque for Rs 930 was in fact sent to the landlord on 3-1-2000. Even otherwise, the arrears of rent which were required to be sent were Rs 1260 and not Rs 930. The appellant also placed on record another letter dated 30-6-2000, wherein it was mentioned that rent for the period 1-2-2000 to 31-12-2000 was being sent through cheque. This was also disputed by the landlord. The appellant did not lead any evidence to establish the fact that the amount as claimed in this letter was actually sent to the landlord. The direction in the order dated 20-12-1999 was that the appellant shall either pay or deposit the future rent by 15th of every succeeding month. Even assuming the version of the appellant to be correct, he failed to either pay or deposit the rents for the months of January to May 2000 by the 15th day of each succeeding month. On the aforesaid facts, the Rent Controller held that the order dated 20-12-1999 had not been complied with. He also noted that even by the time he had passed the order under Section 15(7) of the Act, the appellant was in arrears of rent and had not paid or deposited the rent w.e.f 1-6-1996. He, accordingly, held that it was a fit case where the defence of the appellant should be struck off. The Rent Control Tribunal, in the appeal preferred by the appellant, confirmed the findings recorded by the Rent Controller regarding non-payment of rent and in fact held that the intention of the appellant was not bona fide and rather he acted in a mischievous manner and had tried to show that he had sent the rent by way of cheques. However, he held that Section 15(7) of the Act confers a discretion whether to strike off the defence or not and since this discretion had not been exercised in accordance with the basic principles of equity, justice and good conscience, the order passed by the Rent Controller required modification. He accordingly directed the appellant to deposit the whole arrears of rent along with penalty of same amount within 30 days and if the same was done, the order of the Rent Controller shall stand set aside. The High Court in the writ petition preferred by the landlord held that the appellant had shown a wilful and contumacious default and had set up a palpably false plea about compliance with the order and consequently he was not entitled to any indulgence from the Court. The High Court accordingly set aside the order of the Rent Control Tribunal and restored that of the Rent Controller.
5. The provisions of Section 15(7) of the Act have been examined by a three-Judge Bench of this Court in Jain Motor Car Co. v. Swayam Prabha Jain (1996) 3 SCC 55, AIR 1996 SC 2951 where, after examining the earlier decisions rendered in Hem Chand v. Delhi Cloth & General Mills Co. Ltd. (1977) 3 SCC 483, AIR 1977 SC 1986, Shyamcharan Sharma v. Dharamdas (1980) 2 SCC 151, AIR 1980 SC 587, Ram Murti v. Bhola Nath (1984) 3 SCC 111, AIR 1984 SC 1392 and Kamla Devi v. Vasdev (1995) 1 SCC 356 it was held that the section confers a discretionary power on the Rent Controller to strike out the defence of the tenant and the said power should not be exercised mechanically without any application of mind to the facts of the case.
6. The question which, therefore, requires consideration is whether the appellant has made out any ground for exercising discretion in his favour of not striking out his defence. According to Black's Law Dictionary “judicial discretion” means the exercise of judgment by a judge or court based on what is fair under the circumstances and guided by the rules and principles of law; a court's power to act or not act when a litigant is not entitled to demand the act as a matter of right. The word “discretion” connotes necessarily an act of a judicial character, and, as used with reference to discretion exercised judicially, it implies the absence of a hard-and-fast rule, and it requires an actual exercise of judgment and a consideration of the facts and circumstances which are necessary to make a sound, fair and just determination, and a knowledge of the facts upon which the discretion may properly operate. (See 27 Corpus Juris Secundum, p. 289). When it is said that something is to be done within the discretion of the authorities, that something is to be done according to the rules of reason and justice and not according to private opinion; according to law and not humour. It only gives certain latitude or liberty accorded by statute or rules, to a judge as distinguished from a ministerial or administrative official, in adjudicating on matters brought before him.
7. In the present case, the finding of the Rent Controller and also of the Rent Control Tribunal is that the appellant set up a totally false plea of his having sent the rent through cheques to the landlord. Apart from pleading that he had sent the amount through cheques, he pleaded no other fact which could be taken into consideration by the Rent Controller for exercising discretion in his favour. It may be noted that the premises are commercial and are situate in Karol Bagh, which is a prime business area of Delhi and the rent is a paltry sum of Rs 30 per month. But the appellant did not pay even this small amount of rent, which is virtually a pittance, and has remained in arrears for a long period of time. There is absolutely no ground on which any discretion could be exercised in his favour. The High Court was, therefore, perfectly justified in setting aside the order passed by the Rent Control Tribunal and restoring that of the Rent Controller.
8. For the reasons discussed above, the appeals are dismissed with costs, which we quantify at Rs 10,000.
Alert