- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Narcotics Control Bureau, Jodhpur v. Murlidhar Soni And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
On 23-9-1994, officers of the Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB), Jodhpur, acting on confidential information, organised a raid under the supervision of an Assistant Director (a gazetted officer). At about 9:00 p.m. near Manthan Cinema in Pali, they approached the respondent and his father, Murlidhar Soni, who was carrying a cloth bundle. After informing the accused of their right to be searched before a Magistrate or a gazetted officer, the Assistant Director himself searched the bundle and recovered 2.41 kg of heroin. Samples were taken, the contraband was sealed, and both men were arrested. Further investigation led to the arrest of three additional persons, but only the respondent and his father were ultimately convicted by the Special Judge, NDPS Court, Jodhpur (Sessions Case No. 155 of 1994) under Section 21 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (NDPS Act) and sentenced to 10 years’ rigorous imprisonment and a ₹1 lakh fine.
The High Court of Rajasthan, Jodhpur, allowed their appeal, holding that various mandatory provisions of the NDPS Act were violated and noting coercion in obtaining confessional statements. The NCB appealed to the Supreme Court against the High Court’s acquittal of the respondent; the father had meanwhile died.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the alleged non-compliance with Sections 42, 43, 50 and 57 of the NDPS Act vitiated the search, seizure, and arrest.
- Whether a gazetted officer who is part of the raiding party can conduct the search under Section 50.
- Whether the respondent could be held in “conscious possession” of the heroin when the bag was physically carried by his father.
- Whether the confessional statements recorded under Section 67 of the NDPS Act were inadmissible because they were obtained under coercion and bodily injury.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant’s Arguments (NCB)
- Section 42 was inapplicable because the search occurred in a public place; only Section 43 governed the situation.
- Section 50 applies exclusively to searches of a person’s body, not to searches of bags or containers; hence its requirements were not triggered.
- A gazetted officer who is a member of the raiding party is legally competent to conduct the search under Section 50.
- The High Court erred in finding violations of Sections 42, 43, 50 and 57 and in concluding that the search was illegal.
- Relied on multiple Supreme Court decisions to support the above propositions.
Respondent’s Arguments
- Even if statutory violations are ignored, the respondent lacked “conscious possession” because only the father carried the bundle and no evidence showed the respondent’s knowledge of its contents.
- The High Court correctly found that the Section 67 statements were extracted under duress, evidenced by medical reports showing injuries (including a fractured rib) sustained while in custody.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ganga Bahadur Thapa v. State of Goa, (2000) 10 SCC 312 | Scope of Section 50 and searches of containers | Raised by appellant; Court did not rule on it. |
| Narayanaswamy Ravishankar v. Asstt. Director, DRI, (2002) 8 SCC 7 | Applicability of Section 50 | Raised by appellant; Court did not rule on it. |
| Rajendra v. State of M.P., (2004) 1 SCC 432 | Requirements under Sections 42 and 50 | Raised by appellant; Court did not rule on it. |
| Kalema Tumba v. State of Maharashtra, (1999) 8 SCC 257 | Search and seizure procedure under NDPS Act | Raised by appellant; Court did not rule on it. |
| Sarjudas v. State of Gujarat, (1999) 8 SCC 508 | Effect of non-compliance with Section 50 | Raised by appellant; Court did not rule on it. |
| Gurbax Singh v. State of Haryana, (2001) 3 SCC 28 | Mandatory nature of Section 50 | Raised by appellant; Court did not rule on it. |
| State of Punjab v. Balbir Singh, (1994) 3 SCC 299 | Interpretation of Sections 42 and 50 | Raised by appellant; Court did not rule on it. |
| M. Prabhulal v. Asstt. Director, DRI, (2003) 8 SCC 449 | Gazetted officer’s authority in searches | Raised by appellant; Court did not rule on it. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court confined itself to factual findings and expressly declined to examine the High Court’s conclusions on Sections 42, 43, 50 and 57. It agreed with the High Court that:
- The confessional statements under Section 67 were obtained under duress. Medical evidence showed injuries, including a fractured rib, sustained while in custody, undermining the voluntariness of the statements.
- The respondent’s involvement was limited to transporting his father on a scooter; the heroin-filled bundle was carried solely by the father. There was no proof that the respondent knew of the bundle’s contents, negating “conscious possession.”
Because the prosecution produced no independent evidence linking the respondent to the contraband, the Court held that the conviction could not stand.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED.
Consequently, the High Court’s acquittal of the respondent remains intact. The decision affects only the parties to the case; the Supreme Court set no new precedent because it resolved the matter purely on factual grounds without addressing the contested statutory interpretations.
N. Santosh Hegde, J.— The Narcotics Control Bureau, Jodhpur has preferred this appeal against the judgment of the High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jodhpur by which judgment the High Court allowed the appeal of the respondent and his father filed against the judgment of the Special Judge, Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Court, Jodhpur in Sessions Case No. 155 of 1994 whereby the trial court had convicted the appellant and his father of an offence punishable under Section 21 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (the NDPS Act) and sentenced them to undergo 10 years' RI and to pay a fine of Rs 1 lakh. Brief facts necessary for the disposal of this appeal are as follows:
On the basis of certain confidential information received by the officers of the Department on 23-9-1994 a raiding party was organised under the supervision of the Assistant Director of the Bureau who incidentally was a gazetted officer. The said team saw the respondent and his father Murlidhar Soni at about 9 p.m on that day standing near Manthan Cinema at Pali at which point of time the accused Murlidhar Soni (since dead) was carrying a cloth bundle. The raiding party then went to these 2 accused persons and identified themselves and expressed their desire to search the bag carried by Murlidhar Soni. The two accused persons were told that they have the right to be searched in front of a gazetted officer or a Magistrate. Thereupon the said persons expressed their desire to be searched by a gazetted officer and the Assistant Director, Narcotics Control Bureau being a gazetted officer conducted the search of the cloth bag from which 2.41 kg of heroin was recovered. After taking the necessary samples the contraband goods were seized in front of witnesses and sealed and the said 2 persons were arrested. During the course of investigation it came to the knowledge of the investigating authority that there were 3 other persons involved in the purchase and sale of narcotics from the respondent herein and his father hence they were also arrested and charged for the offences as stated above.
2. The trial court came to the conclusion that the prosecution had established its charges against the respondent and his father Murlidhar Soni and convicted them accordingly while it found the prosecution has failed to establish charges against other accused persons, hence acquitted them.
3. The said convicted accused persons as stated above preferred an appeal before the High Court which came to be decided by the impugned judgment, allowing the said appeal and setting aside the conviction and sentence imposed on the appellants therein.
4. Very many questions involving the application of Sections 42, 43, 50 and 57 of the NDPS Act were urged before the High Court and the High Court in the course of the judgment held that on the facts of the case Section 43 of the Act was applicable since the recovery in question was made in a public place. It also came to the conclusion that there has been violation of various provisions of the Act like non-recording of the information received in advance, non-compliance with Section 57 of the NDPS Act in not reporting the arrest of the accused persons. It also came to the conclusion though the accused persons were informed of their legal right of being searched by a gazetted officer or a Magistrate as per their desire, they ought to have been taken to the nearest gazetted officer to be searched and the search made by the Assistant Director who himself was a gazetted officer was contrary to the provisions of Section 50 of the Act since he was a member of the raiding party. After recording its finding in regard to the non-compliance with the statutory provisions of the NDPS Act, the High Court also came to the conclusion that there was material on record to show that the statements of these accused were obtained under coercion and bodily injury which itself creates serious doubt as to the prosecution case.
5. Mr P.P Malhotra, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant contended that the finding of the courts below that there has been violation of Sections 42, 43, 50 and 57 of the Act is wholly erroneous and contrary to the decisions of this Court. He pointed out that though on the basis of prior information a raiding party was constituted, still provisions of Section 42 did not apply to the facts of the case since the search and seizure was made in an open place and not in a place as contemplated under Section 42 of the Act. In this regard he pointed out from the impugned judgment of the High Court itself that the High Court had held that a search and seizure in this case actually falls under Section 43 of the Act but it still applied the requirement of Section 42 to the facts of the case. He also pointed out that as per the law laid down by this Court, when a recovery and seizure is made not from the person of the accused but from a bag, suitcase or a container, the provisions of Section 50 did not apply because that section operates only in cases where a search of a person (body) is conducted. He further submitted that the High Court seriously erred in coming to the conclusion that a gazetted officer who is a member of the raiding party cannot be a gazetted officer empowered to search under Section 50. In support of his contention learned counsel relied on the judgments of this Court in Ganga Bahadur Thapa v. State of Goa (2000) 10 SCC 312, Narayanaswamy Ravishankar v. Asstt. Director, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (2002) 8 SCC 7, Rajendra v. State of M.P (2004) 1 SCC 432, Kalema Tumba v. State of Maharashtra (1999) 8 SCC 257, Sarjudas v. State of Gujarat (1999) 8 SCC 508, Gurbax Singh v. State of Haryana (2001) 3 SCC 28, State of Punjab v. Balbir Singh (1994) 3 SCC 299 and M. Prabhulal v. Asstt. Director, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (2003) 8 SCC 449.
6. Mr Kailash Vasdev, learned Senior Counsel for the respondents contended that assuming for argument's sake that the finding of the High Court in regard to the statutory provisions of law is wrongly decided even then the respondent now before the Court cannot be held guilty of the offence as charged for factual reasons. He pointed out that even according to the prosecution the bag in question was being carried by the respondent's father and there is no material to show that this respondent had any knowledge as to the contents of the said bag. In such situation, the possession of the narcotics by his father could never be construed as conscious possession of this respondent also. He also submitted that the High Court has come to the conclusion that the accused persons were subjected to bodily injury and the so-called statements recorded under Section 67 of the Act were in fact made to be given by the accused because of such bodily injury. This finding of the Court by itself is sufficient to uphold the impugned judgment of the High Court.
7. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the records we are of the opinion that it is not necessary for us to go into the legal arguments addressed by the learned counsel as to the applicability of the various provisions of the Act since we think this appeal can be disposed of on the factual finding arrived at by the High Court with which we are in agreement. Therefore we do not express any opinion on the findings of the High Court on the applicability of Sections 42, 43, 50 and 57 of the Act and proceed to examine the facts which justify the dismissal of the appeal. The High Court in the course of its judgment has observed that the alleged statements of these accused persons purportedly made under Section 67 of the Act were obtained under duress.
8. We are in agreement with this finding of the High Court. It is to be noted that even though these accused persons were arrested on 24-9-1994, they were produced before the Court only on 27-9-1994 on which date both the accused submitted before the Court that they had suffered injuries at the hands of the investigating agency and it is under such physical threat their statements were recorded under Section 67 of the Act. The said Court had directed a medical examination of these accused on that day itself. The medical report and the evidence of DWs 1 and 2, the doctors who examined them, clearly shows that these accused had suffered injuries and Murlidhar Soni had actually suffered a fracture of the 10th left rib. The defence of the prosecution that these injuries might have been suffered by an accidental fall of the accused, cannot be accepted, thus, we are in agreement with the finding of the High Court that the statements of these accused persons have been obtained by the prosecuting agency under duress. It is also to be noted that even according to the prosecution case so far as this respondent is concerned, his only role in regard to the contraband was to take his father on his scooter to the place where they were allegedly arrested. The bundle in question which contained the contraband was carried by Murlidhar Soni and there is no material whatsoever to show that the present respondent had the knowledge that the bundle contained any contraband. In our opinion since the prosecution has not placed any material to show the conscious possession of the contraband by the respondent herein and since Murlidhar Soni is dead, we think the contention advanced on behalf of the respondent as to the possession of the contraband by the respondent has to be accepted.
9. For the reasons stated above, this appeal fails and the same is dismissed.
Alert