Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Assistant Commissioner-Cum-Land Acquisition Officer, Bellary v. S.T Pompanna Setty .

Supreme Court Of India
Dec 17, 2004
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The State of Karnataka acquired 5.99 acres in Survey No. 335/7, Sovenahalli village, Sandur taluk, for restoration of the Sovenahalli tank. A Section 4(1) notification under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 was published on 7 October 1982. The Land Acquisition Officer awarded compensation at Rs 2,728 per acre on 25 January 1984. The claimant accepted the amount under protest and sought a reference under Section 18.

The Reference Court (Civil Judge, Hospet) found the land irrigated by two wells and containing numerous mature fruit-bearing trees. Using yield capitalization with a multiplier of 15, it awarded the claimant Rs 5,00,000 plus statutory benefits on 11 September 1995 (LAC No. 72 of 1984). The High Court of Karnataka dismissed the State’s appeal on 14 November 2002 (MFA No. 270 of 1996), affirming the Reference Court. The State of Karnataka (appellant) then appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, in computing compensation on a yield basis, the courts below erred by making no deduction for cultivation or maintenance expenses of the fruit-bearing trees.
  2. Whether the Reference Court correctly applied a capitalization multiplier of 15 years, or whether a lower multiplier (normally 10) should have been used.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (State of Karnataka)

  • The High Court failed to deduct any amount toward cultivation expenses; precedent suggests up to 50% deduction is appropriate.
  • The Reference Court improperly applied a 15-year multiplier; Supreme Court jurisprudence normally limits the multiplier to 10 in yield-based valuation.
  • Consequently, the original award of Rs 2,728 per acre should be restored.

Respondent (Claimant/Landowner)

  • The case concerns fruit-bearing trees, not seasonal agricultural crops; the expenses for upkeep are minimal, so no deduction is warranted.
  • The evidence showed mature, income-producing trees; hence the Reference Court’s valuation method and the High Court’s affirmance are sound.
  • The claimant’s own claim was restricted to Rs 5,00,000 even though actual entitlement, if strictly calculated, would exceed Rs 6,00,000.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Gujarat v. Rama Rana (1997) 2 SCC 693 Ordinarily 50% deduction for cultivation expenses and application of a 10-year multiplier when valuing on yield basis. Distinguished; held not stricto sensu applicable because expenses for fruit trees are lower than for agricultural crops.
Special Land Acquisition Officer v. T. Adinarayan Setty, 1959 Supp (1) SCR 404 Enumerated three accepted valuation methods, including capitalization of net yield. Cited to reiterate permissible valuation methodologies.
Tribeni Devi v. Collector of Ranchi (1972) 1 SCC 480 Court may employ multiple valuation methods to approximate true market value. Referred to underline flexibility in choosing valuation approaches.
Special Land Acquisition Officer v. P. Veerabhadarappa (1984) 2 SCC 120 Adopted a 10-year capitalization multiplier. Used as authority indicating 10 years is the norm.
Special Land Acquisition Officer v. Virupax Shankar Nadagouda (1996) 6 SCC 124 Applied 10-year multiplier in yield-based valuation. Supports the appellant’s contention that 15 years is excessive.
Krishi Utpadan Mandi Samiti v. Malik Sartaj Wali Khan (2001) 10 SCC 660 Multiplier of 20 held excessive; Court reduced it to 10. Further confirms 10 as the appropriate multiplier ceiling.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Justice C. K. Thakker, delivering the judgment, examined both contentions:

  1. Deduction for Expenses: The Court found Rama Rana inapposite because that case addressed seasonal agricultural crops, whereas the present land contained mature fruit-bearing trees requiring far less recurring expenditure. Given evidence of the trees’ age and productivity, the absence of any deduction was not deemed illegal. Accordingly, the first contention was rejected.
  2. Appropriate Multiplier: Surveying multiple Supreme Court precedents, the Court noted that a 10-year multiplier is ordinarily applied when valuation is based on yield. The 15-year multiplier used by the Reference Court was therefore excessive. Nonetheless, because the claimant had voluntarily capped his claim at Rs 5,00,000 and would otherwise be entitled to more than Rs 6,00,000, substantial reduction was unwarranted. Balancing these considerations, the Court fixed compensation at Rs 4,75,000, modestly below the amount awarded by the courts below but above the State’s original figure.

Holding and Implications

PARTLY ALLOWED. The Supreme Court reduced the compensation from Rs 5,00,000 to Rs 4,75,000 while affirming all other directions and awarded no costs.

Implications: The judgment reiterates that a 10-year capitalization multiplier is generally appropriate in yield-based valuation but recognizes flexibility where claimant’s own valuation limits and the nature of the asset (fruit trees versus agricultural crops) justify departure from strict precedent. The ruling affects only the parties and sets no new legal rule beyond applying existing principles.

Show all summary ...

C.K Thakker, J.— Delay condoned.

2. Leave granted.

3. This appeal is directed against an order dated 14-11-2002 passed by the High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore in MFA No. 270 of 1996 (LAC). By the said order, the High Court dismissed the appeal filed by the appellant herein and confirmed the order passed by the Reference Court on 11-9-1995 in LAC No. 72 of 1984.

4. The facts in brief are that a piece of land bearing Survey No. 335/7, admeasuring 5.99 acres situated at Sovenahalli village, Sandur taluk was acquired for restoration of Sovenahalli tank for the village. A notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) was issued and published in the Karnataka Gazette on 7-10-1982. After completion of the proceedings under the Act and after observing all formalities, the Land Acquisition Officer awarded compensation at the rate of Rs 2728 per acre to the claimant vide his award dated 25-1-1984. The claimant received the amount of compensation under protest and submitted an application under Section 18 of the Act requesting the Land Acquisition Officer to refer the matter to the court. The matter was accordingly referred to the Court of Civil Judge at Hospet. The Reference Court observed that the Land Acquisition Officer had not considered the fertility and potentiality of the acquired land with other lands in respect of which sale transactions were on record. It also stated that the land in question, as disclosed in the award, had irrigation facilities in view of the presence of two wells on the land. The court also found that there were fruit-bearing trees on the land — mango 72, margosa 10, tamarind 60, coconut 1, sandalwood 1, neerala 1, hatti 1, kanaga 1 and others 90. The Reference Court, after considering evidence of the claimant as well as his two witnesses, held that the claimant was entitled to enhanced compensation. Considering the income of fruit-bearing trees, the court held that if it is multiplied by capitalisation of 15 years, the claimant would be entitled to an amount of more than Rs six lakhs. In view of the fact, however, that the claimant had claimed compensation of Rs five lakhs, he would not be entitled to more. But the amount claimed by him cannot be said to be unreasonable or excessive and accordingly the said amount was awarded. The reference was thus allowed and the claimant was held entitled to Rs five lakhs along with interest as mentioned in the order. The said order was confirmed by the High Court which is challenged in the present appeal.

5. We have heard learned counsel for the parties. The learned counsel for the appellant raised two contentions. Firstly, he submitted that the High Court has committed an error of law in not deducting amount towards cost of cultivation. Secondly, it was contended that the Reference Court had erroneously applied multiplier of 15 for capitalising the income. Such multiplier should not be more than 10. On both these grounds, therefore, according to the learned counsel, the impugned order is liable to be set aside and the order passed by the Land Acquisition Officer deserves to be restored.

6. Learned counsel for the claimant, on the other hand, submitted that having considered the rival contentions of the parties and keeping in view the evidence on record, the Reference Court enhanced compensation to be payable to the claimant and the High Court rightly did not think it proper to interfere with the said order. The present appeal, therefore, deserves to be dismissed.

7. Having given our anxious consideration to the submissions of the parties and having considered the relevant decisions of this Court, we are of the view that the appeal deserves to be partly allowed.

8. So far as the first point is concerned, the learned counsel for the appellant relied upon a decision of this Court in State of Gujarat v. Rama Rana (1997) 2 SCC 693. In that case compensation was awarded to the claimant on yield basis. There was no sufficient evidence as to the income from agriculture and the Reference Court noticed that the witnesses exaggerated the yield. In the circumstances, the Reference Court determined the market value after deducting 1/3rd towards cultivation expenses and awarded compensation on that basis. The High Court dismissed the appeal and confirmed the order. The State approached this Court. Allowing the appeal and reducing the amount of compensation, this Court observed that it is common knowledge that expenditure is involved in raising and harvesting the crop and on an average, 50% of the value of the crop realised would be spent towards cultivation expenses. Deduction of 1/3rd, in the circumstances, was improper in determining the compensation of the land on the basis of yield. The Court also applied multiplier of 10.

9. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted that in the instant case, no deduction whatsoever has been made by the Reference Court or by the High Court. It was submitted that only on the basis of yield and gross income, the Reference Court granted compensation to the claimant which was confirmed by the High Court. He, therefore, submitted that the award deserves interference.

10. Learned counsel for the claimant, on the other hand, submitted that the ratio laid down in Rama Rana (1997) 2 SCC 693 does not apply to the facts of the case. The case on hand relates to fruit-bearing trees and not agriculture. It is in evidence that the trees were sufficiently old and grown-up and were giving fruits and it has been deposed by the claimant and his witnesses. Thus, there was evidence on record to that effect. In the circumstances, there was no question of deduction of any amount towards expenses and the orders passed by the Reference Court and by the High Court cannot be said to be incorrect.

11. In the facts and circumstances, in our opinion, the ratio laid down in Rama Rana (1997) 2 SCC 693 would not stricto sensu apply in the present case inasmuch as in fruit-growing trees the expenses would not be 50% as held by this Court. Moreover, the High Court also considered an important fact that the claimant would be entitled to much more amount on yield basis but as he had claimed an amount of Rs five lakhs, nothing more could be paid to him. It, therefore, cannot be said that by not deducting the amount of expenses for cultivation, the courts below had committed any illegality. The first contention, therefore, in the facts of the case, is rejected.

12. Let us now consider the second point. This Court in Special Land Acquisition Officer v. T. Adinarayan Setty 1959 Supp (1) SCR 404, AIR 1959 SC 429, 1959 Cri LJ 526 held that in awarding compensation under the Act, the court has to ascertain the market value of the land at the date of notification under Section 4(1) of the Act. It was observed that there were several methods of valuation, such as (1) opinion of experts, (2) the price paid within a reasonable time in bona fide transactions of purchase of the lands acquired or the lands adjacent to the lands acquired and possessing similar advantages, and (3) a number of years' purchase of the actual or immediately prospective profits of the land acquired.

13. In Tribeni Devi v. Collector of Ranchi (1972) 1 SCC 480 this Court reiterated the methods of valuation and also stated that those methods do not preclude the court from taking into consideration other circumstances, the requirement being always to arrive at the nearest correct market value. It was also indicated that in arriving at a reasonably correct market value, it may be necessary to take even two or all of those methods into account since the exact valuation is not always possible as no two lands would be the same either in respect of the situation or the extent or the potentiality nor would it be possible in all cases to have reliable material from which such valuation can be accurately determined.

14. In Special Land Acquisition Officer v. P. Veerabhadarappa (1984) 2 SCC 120 this Court held that when capitalisation method for valuation is applied, proper multiplier should be 10. As in that case, the State Government submitted that proper multiplier was 12-1/2, the computation was made on that basis. Similarly, in Special Land Acquisition Officer v. Virupax Shankar Nadagouda (1996) 6 SCC 124 relying on P. Veerabhadarappa (1984) 2 SCC 120 this Court determined compensation on the basis of 10 years' multiplier. Again, in Krishi Utpadan Mandi Samiti v. Malik Sartaj Wali Khan (2001) 10 SCC 660 this Court held that computation of compensation for determination of market value may be carried out on yield basis and multiplier of 10 should be applied. Since multiplier of 20 was applied by the High Court, it was set aside by this Court by reducing the amount of compensation.

15. From the above cases, it is clear that normally in the cases where compensation is awarded on yield basis, multiplier of 10 is considered proper and appropriate. In the case on hand, multiplier of 15 has been applied which is on the higher side. To that extent, therefore, the submission of the learned counsel for the appellant is well founded and deserves to be accepted. At the same time, however, it cannot be overlooked that the High Court considered the fact and observed that the claimant would be entitled to an amount of more than Rs six lakhs. Since he had restricted his claim to Rs five lakhs, he would not be entitled to an amount more than that. In the facts and circumstances, therefore, in our opinion, ends of justice would be met if we hold that the claimant would be entitled to Rs 4,75,000 (Rupees four lakhs seventy-five thousand only) along with interest as awarded to him by the Reference Court as well as by the High Court.

16. For the foregoing reasons, in our opinion, the appeal deserves to be partly allowed and is allowed by reducing the amount of compensation to Rs 4,75,000 (Rupees four lakhs seventy-five thousand only). The rest of the directions are not disturbed. In the facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.