Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Deepak Nitrite Ltd. v. State Of Gujarat And Others

Supreme Court Of India
May 5, 2004
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

A public-interest petition was filed before the Gujarat High Court alleging large-scale pollution caused by 252 chemical industries situated in the Gujarat Industrial Development Corporation (GIDC) Estate at Nandesari, Baroda. The industries were accused of discharging effluents that exceeded the parameters fixed by the Gujarat Pollution Control Board (GPCB).

Key procedural steps included:

  • 17-4-1995: High Court directed that all 252 units, the State of Gujarat, GPCB, GIDC and others be impleaded and issued notices even to financial institutions.
  • 5-5-1995: A committee under Dr. V.V. Modi was appointed to ascertain pollution levels.
  • 7-8-1996: National Environmental Engineering Research Institute (NEERI) was appointed as consultant because the Common Effluent Treatment Plant (CETP) was not meeting GPCB norms.
  • 1996: The court intermittently restrained product removal, later allowing it against monetary deposits.
  • 9-5-1997: Relying on an earlier Gujarat High Court decision, the High Court ordered each unit to deposit 1% of the maximum annual turnover of the preceding three years for “compensation and betterment of environment.”
  • The present appeals were filed by affected industries before the Supreme Court challenging that 1% levy.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a court, absent statutory authority, can direct industries to pay a percentage of their turnover for environmental betterment.
  2. Whether the “polluter-pays” principle can be applied without a specific finding that the concerned industry actually caused environmental degradation.
  3. What methodology should be adopted by courts in quantifying environmental compensation—can a flat 1% of turnover be upheld?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • Courts lack power to impose a levy for general betterment unless authorised by statute; damages must be linked to restitution for proven harm.
  • No explicit finding of environmental degradation was recorded; mere non-compliance with GPCB norms cannot automatically justify compensation.
  • The polluter-pays principle (relying on Vellore Citizens’ Welfare Forum) requires proof that a particular unit is a polluter before liability can be fixed.
  • The 1% turnover formula applied in Pravinbhai Jashbhai Patel was fact-specific and should not be applied mechanically to other units.

Submissions of the Amicus Curiae

  • The High Court had, through expert reports (Modi Committee, NEERI and GPCB), already found that the units were polluting and violating norms.
  • The 1% methodology had previously been upheld in Pravinbhai Jashbhai Patel; many industries in the present matter had voluntarily agreed to pay it.
  • Compensation must both deter and fund restoration; turnover-based damages serve this dual objective and conform to Supreme Court jurisprudence on the polluter-pays principle.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pravinbhai Jashbhai Patel v. State of Gujarat (1995) 36 Guj LR 1210 Adoption of 1% of turnover as compensation for polluting units; enforcement of pollution norms High Court relied on this case to fix the 1% levy; Supreme Court scrutinised whether that approach was appropriate without a finding of damage
M.C. Mehta v. Union of India (1987) 4 SCC 463; AIR 1988 SC 1037 Right to a clean environment under Article 21; application of polluter-pays principle Cited by High Court to justify imposing monetary liability for environmental harm
Virender Gaur v. State of Haryana (1995) 2 SCC 577 Environmental protection as part of right to life Quoted by High Court in support of citizens’ fundamental right to live free from pollution
Consumer Education & Research Centre v. Union of India (1995) 3 SCC 42; AIR 1995 SC 922 Expansion of Article 21 to include health and environmental facets Reinforced constitutional basis for judicial intervention in environmental matters
M.C. Mehta v. Union of India (1987) 1 SCC 395 Quantum of compensation should correlate with magnitude and capacity of enterprise and act as deterrent Amicus cited to support turnover-based damages as having deterrent effect
Vellore Citizens’ Welfare Forum v. Union of India (1996) 5 SCC 647 Absolute liability of polluter; cost of restoring environment part of compensation Relied upon by appellants to argue that proof of pollution is prerequisite for liability

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court agreed that the industrial units had failed to meet GPCB standards; however, it found that the High Court never expressly determined whether such non-compliance had caused environmental degradation or identifiable harm to victims.

Key analytical steps:

  • Reaffirmed that compensation under the polluter-pays principle must have a “broad correlation” both to the polluter’s capacity and to the harm actually caused.
  • Observed that while a fixed percentage of turnover may sometimes be a “practical, simple and easy” method, its use requires a preliminary finding that pollution caused damage.
  • Emphasised that environmental compensation proceedings in public-interest litigation are distinct from private tort actions; nonetheless, a factual basis for liability remains essential.
  • Concluded that, without a finding on environmental damage, the 1% levy could not stand as imposed.

Accordingly, the Court remitted the matter to the High Court, directing it to:

  • Undertake a further, but broad, inquiry—drawing on the Modi Committee, NEERI and GPCB material—into whether environmental degradation and victim harm occurred.
  • Determine an appropriate measure of compensation in light of its findings, which may or may not include the 1% turnover formula.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS DISPOSED OF; MATTER REMANDED TO THE HIGH COURT FOR FRESH DETERMINATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL DAMAGE AND QUANTUM OF COMPENSATION.

Implications:

  • The judgment underscores that liability under the polluter-pays principle requires an evidentiary finding of environmental harm, not merely regulatory non-compliance.
  • It permits use of simplified compensation formulae (such as a percentage of turnover) but conditions their application on a factual foundation.
  • The decision provides guidance to High Courts handling environmental PILs, balancing the need for deterrence with procedural fairness to industry.
  • No new precedent was set on quantum; rather, the matter of appropriate methodology remains open for the High Court’s reconsideration.
Show all summary ...

S. Rajendra Babu, C.J These appeals arise out of a series of orders made by the High Court of Gujarat. A petition was filed before the High Court in public interest alleging large-scale pollution caused by industries located in Gujarat Industrial Development Corporation (GIDC) Industrial Estate at Nandesari. It is alleged that effluents discharged by the said industries into the effluent-treatment project had exceeded certain parameters fixed by the Gujarat Pollution Control Board (GPCB), thereby causing damage to the environment. Some of the industries have set up their own effluent-treatment plants in their factory premises, while some of them have not. The High Court, by an order made on 17-4-1995, directed that the chemical industries in Nandesari should be made parties to the proceedings; thereby 252 industrial units located in Nandesari Industrial Estate, Baroda were made parties to the proceedings, apart from the State of Gujarat, the Central Pollution Control Board, Gujarat Industrial Development Corporation and Nandesari Industries Association. The High Court also issued notices to financial institutions or banks in respect of these proceedings.

2. On 5-5-1995 the High Court appointed a Committee under the Chairmanship of Dr. V.V Modi to ascertain the position with regard to the extent of pollution in Nandesari Industrial Estate. A common effluent-treatment plant (CETP) was erected by GIDC in Nandesari Industrial Estate on the contribution made by the industrial units in Nandesari Industrial Estate to the extent of about Rs 300 lakhs. Inasmuch as CETP was not achieving the required parameters laid down by GPCB, the High Court, by an order made on 7-8-1996, appointed NEERI as a consultant to assess the treatment facilities and to provide suitable rectification measures for upgrading CETP and effluent-treatment plant facilities. Dr. Modi Committee made a report on 7-9-1996. The High Court restrained several industries from removing their products from their plant without prior permission of the High Court and thereafter, by an order made on 13-9-1996, the High Court permitted them to dispatch materials by depositing a certain sum of money which was the value of the materials. NEERI submitted its report on 31-10-1996. The High Court, while granting permission to some of the industries to carry on their activities, called for turnover figures and profitability data. On 9-5-1997 the High Court passed an order directing the industries to pay 1% of the maximum annual turnover of any of the preceding three years towards compensation and betterment of environment within a stipulated time. It is against this order that the appellants are before us.

3. The High Court in its impugned order followed a decision of the High Court of Gujarat in Pravinbhai Jashbhai Patel v. State of Gujarat (1995) 36 Guj LR 1210 wherein it was noticed that the industrial units though aware of the requirements of law had not complied with the same nor did they meet the GPCB parameters and they were irresponsible in not wanting or caring to set up effluent-treatment plants but continued to manufacture, and pollute the environment and the concern shown now in meeting with the pollution-control norms is only because of the threatened court order; that pollution caused by these industrial units was adversely affecting a large number of citizens residing in the adjacent cities or villages; that in particular water and air pollution is not only continued in the immediate area in which the pollution is generated, but the same affects other areas as well wherever water or air went; that this Court in M.C Mehta v. Union of India (1987) 4 SCC 463, AIR 1988 SC 1037, Virender Gaur v. State of Haryana (1995) 2 SCC 577 and Consumer Education & Research Centre v. Union of India (1995) 3 SCC 42, AIR 1995 SC 922 invoked the provisions of Article 21 of the Constitution of India to declare that the citizens have a fundamental right to live decently, unaffected by pollution. After noticing various contentions, the High Court took the view that 1% of the turnover would be a good measure of assessing damages for the pollution caused by the industrial units and that amount should be kept apart by the Ministry of Environment and should be utilised for the works of socio-economic upliftment of the population of the aforesaid affected areas and for the betterment of educational, medical and veterinary facilities and the betterment of the agriculture and livestock in the said villages with certain additional directions in this regard.

4. It is now submitted before us by the appellants that a court has no power to either impose penalty or fine or make any levy for general betterment unless the statute authorised the same; that, however, in awarding damages it is permissible to make the same exemplary or penal; that award of damages is by way of restitution for the damage caused to victims and for restoration or restitution and for restoration of ecology by way of punishment; that, unless a finding is given by the High Court that there had been degradation of environment, question of restitution or awarding damages could not arise; that there is no finding of degradation of environment and, therefore, it is not open to the High Court to impose 1% of the turnover by way of damages. The appellants relied upon a decision of this Court in Vellore Citizens' Welfare Forum v. Union of India (1996) 5 SCC 647 in support of this contention. Their argument is that the principle of “polluter to pay” cannot be applied unless a finding has been given that the industrial unit concerned is the polluter. In what manner pollution has been caused should have been ascertained, particularly when a separate common effluent-treatment plant had been erected and a channel was provided through which water would flow into the river which would reach the sea thereby not causing any damage anywhere. They seek to bring about difference between Pravinbhai Jashbhai Patel case (1995) 36 Guj LR 1210 and the present proceedings to contend that in those cases there was direct evidence of damage having taken place and by way of rule of thumb the High Court adopted the standard of 1% of turnover to be paid by way of damages and that this principle cannot always uniformly be applied. They commend us to apply the principle set out by this Court in Vellore Citizens' Welfare Forum case (1996) 5 SCC 647 wherein the principle of “polluter to pay” has been applied and wherein it is noticed that any principle evolved in this behalf should be simple, practical and suited to the conditions obtaining in this country; once the activity carried on is hazardous or inherently dangerous, the person carrying on such activity is liable to make good the loss caused to any other person by his activity irrespective of the fact whether he took reasonable care while carrying on his activity; consequently, the polluting industries are absolutely liable to compensate for the harm caused by them to villagers in the affected areas, to the soil and to the underground water and hence, they are bound to take all necessary measures to remove sludge and other pollutants lying in the affected areas; that the “polluter-pays principle” as interpreted by this Court means that the absolute liability for harm to the environment extends not only to compensate the victims of pollution but also the cost of restoring the environmental degradation; that remediation of the damaged environment is part of the process of sustainable development and as such the polluter is liable to pay the cost to the individual sufferers as well as the cost of reversing the damaged ecology.

5. Shri T.R Andhyarujina, learned Senior Advocate, who assisted this Court as amicus curiae with great ability, explained to us the background in which the High Court had passed the impugned order. He submitted that the High Court had followed the earlier decision in Pravinbhai Jashbhai Patel case (1995) 36 Guj LR 1210 wherein standard of 1% of turnover was adopted for closure of polluting units and payment of compensation by such units for polluting river and land; that the basis of this decision in that case was that the polluting industrial units were not meeting the GPCB norms and the continued violation of the law by industrial units had become a habit; that after elaborate discussion, the High Court had concluded that these industries had caused pollution and, therefore, gave certain directions, including for closure of the industrial units until they observed the GPCB norms; that the directions given by the High Court regarding closure and payment of compensation were complied with by the industrial units and this Court did not interfere with the order made by the High Court, therefore, the methodology adopted by the High Court in Pravinbhai Jashbhai Patel case (1995) 36 Guj LR 1210 can be applied to other industrial units which are causing pollution; that, after investigation made by the Committee or by an expert body there were reports that the industrial units were causing pollution by not complying with the norms prescribed by GPCB and the High Court, in fact, noticed that a number of units have voluntarily agreed to pay 1% of the turnover of a year out of the last three years and there was consensus between all the industries and for betterment of environment, they voluntarily stated before the Court that 1% shall be paid; that one may say that even some of the units having no treatment plant or having inadequate facilities appeared before the High Court stating that they would voluntarily stop manufacturing till installation of proper treatment plant and were in a position to discharge trade effluent meeting with the GPCB norms. Thus, in these cases, the High Court restrained firstly, several industries from removing their products from their plant without prior permission of the High Court and thereafter, such units themselves suspended operation of the polluting activities. The High Court, after having considered further reports of the Committee, NEERI and GPCB permitted to restart activities on a trial basis and at the same time, directed that “with regard to 1% payment an order will be passed after the details furnished by the learned counsel”. The High Court thereafter adopted payment of 1% of the turnover method as indicated in Pravinbhai Jashbhai Patel case (1995) 36 Guj LR 1210. He submitted that in these cases the High Court has through its investigation either by the Committee appointed by itself or expert agency like NEERI found that the industrial units in question were polluting units and had not conformed with the norms prescribed by GPCB and each of the units was discharging effluents into the effluent-channel project constructed by GIDC which in turn discharged the effluents into Mahi river which ultimately reached the sea. Thus the High Court had found that there was extensive environmental degradation as a result of the pollution because of the violation of the pollution laws and on account of such damage, the High Court ordered the payment of 1% compensation as a one-time payment for pollution and damage for a number of years from 1993 to 1996. He further submitted that in no case the High Court ordered compensation without giving a finding that there was environmental degradation and damage as a result of violation or prescribed norms. He also adverted to various decisions of this Court in M.C Mehta v. Union of India (1987) 1 SCC 395 to support the proposition that the measure of compensation must be correlated to the magnitude and capacity of the enterprise because such compensation must have a deterrent effect and such damage not only extends to restitution for the harm to the environment to compensate the victims of the pollution but also cost of restoring the environment by degradation. This Court reiterated the principle of “polluter to pay” to the effect that one of the principles is to levy damages of a certain percentage of total turnover and the right to a clean and hazardless environment has been recognised as a fundamental right under Article 21 of the Constitution. The Court has innovated new methods and strategies for the purpose of securing enforcement of fundamental rights.

6. The fact that the industrial units in question have not conformed with the standards prescribed by GPCB, cannot be seriously disputed in these cases. But the question is whether that circumstance by itself can lead to the conclusion that such lapse has caused damage to environment. No finding is given on that aspect which is necessary to be ascertained because compensation to be awarded must have some broad correlation not only with the magnitude and capacity of the enterprise but also with the harm caused by it. Maybe, in a given case the percentage of the turnover itself may be a proper measure because the method to be adopted in awarding damages on the basis of “polluter-to-pay” principle has got to be practical, simple and easy in application. The appellants also do not contest the legal position that if there is a finding that there has been degradation of environment or any damage caused to any of the victims by the activities of the industrial units certainly damages have to be paid. However, to say that mere violation of the law in not observing the norms would result in degradation of environment would not be correct.

7. Therefore, we direct the High Court to further investigate in each of these cases and find out broadly whether there has been any damage caused by any of the industrial units by their activities in not observing the norms prescribed by GPCB as reported by the Modi Committee appointed by the High Court or by an expert body like NEERI and that exercise need not be undertaken by the High Court as if the present proceeding is an action in tort but an action in public law. A broad conclusion in this regard by the High Court would be sufficient. We, therefore, direct the High Court to re-examine this aspect of the matter as to whether there is degradation of environment and as a result thereof any damage is caused to any victim, and what norms should be adopted in the matter of awarding compensation in that regard. In this process it is open to the High Court to consider whether 1% of the turnover itself would be an appropriate formula or not as applicable to the present cases.

8. We record our appreciation and gratitude to Shri T.R Andhyarujina in assisting this Court as amicus curiae.

9. With these observations, these appeals stand disposed of.