Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kamma Otukunta Ram Naidu v. Chereddy Pedda Subba Reddy And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 19, 2003
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Fourteen accused from Village Peddaventhurla were charged with the murder of Otukunta Appaiah, arising out of a factional dispute linked to a cooperative-society election. On 21-3-1988, the deceased and prosecution witnesses boarded an early-morning bus to Koilkuntla to testify in pending criminal cases. The accused, armed with weapons and country-made bombs, boarded the same bus, alighted near a culvert, chased the prosecution party across nearby fields, and fatally assaulted the deceased. A First Information Report (FIR) was lodged the same morning at 10:30 a.m.

The trial court convicted Respondents 1–5 under Sections 302/149 and 148 of the Indian Penal Code and Section 3 of the Explosive Substances Act, sentencing each to life imprisonment (concurrent sentences). The remaining nine co-accused were acquitted. The respondents appealed, and the deceased’s son filed a revision against the acquittals. The Andhra Pradesh High Court dismissed the revision but allowed the respondents’ appeal, setting aside their convictions and acquitting them. By special leave, the State appealed to the Supreme Court, contesting only the respondents’ acquittal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court’s order acquitting the respondents was so perverse that the Supreme Court should interfere and restore the trial court’s convictions.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Medical and forensic evidence: The post-mortem conducted by PW 10 revealed 11 injuries; all but three could result from a country-made bomb explosion, while the remaining incised wounds matched the use of hunting sickles. The injuries were sufficient in the ordinary course to cause death and corresponded to the prosecution narrative. Investigating Officer PW 14’s site inspection corroborated bomb-blast signs and the location of the body.

Eyewitness reliability: PWs 1–4, who travelled with the deceased and claimed to witness the attack, gave mutually consistent accounts aligned with the FIR, medical findings, and physical evidence. The Court rejected the High Court’s view that they were “interested” witnesses whose testimony should be discarded, reiterating that sworn evidence cannot be rejected merely for being partisan when otherwise consistent and corroborated.

Supporting witness PW 5: His account confirmed the presence of both factions on the bus and their disembarkation near the culvert. The Supreme Court found the High Court’s criticism of his “belated” police examination factually incorrect; he was examined the very next day.

Perceived improbabilities dismissed: The Supreme Court held it natural for the witnesses to have boarded the 6:30 a.m. bus given the 25 km distance to court, and not improbable that they looked back while fleeing. Omission of minute details in the FIR (e.g., that the accused advanced inside the bus) was treated as a non-fatal irregularity, as the FIR is not expected to catalog every fact.

Delay in FIR transmission: The Court found no undue delay: the occurrence (7:00–7:30 a.m.), FIR lodging (10:30 a.m.), and court receipt (4:15 p.m.) were consistent with prompt action given the 10 km distance and the investigating officer’s simultaneous field visit.

Finding the prosecution evidence cogent and the High Court’s contrary conclusions unsustainable, the Supreme Court labelled the acquittal “perverse.”

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeals are allowed; the High Court’s judgment of acquittal is set aside, and the trial court’s convictions and sentences of the respondents are restored. The respondents’ bail bonds are cancelled, and they are to be taken into custody forthwith.

Implications: The decision reinstates the life sentences originally imposed, providing finality to the prosecution. The ruling turns on fact-appreciation standards for appellate interference and does not announce new legal doctrine.

Show all summary ...

B.N Agrawal, J.— Fourteen accused persons including Respondents 1 to 5 (hereinafter referred to as “the respondents”) were tried for various offences and the trial court convicted the respondents under Sections 302/149 of the Penal Code and each one of them was sentenced to undergo imprisonment for life. They were further convicted under Section 148 of the Penal Code and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of two years. Respondents 1, 2 and 4 were also convicted under Section 3 of the Explosive Substances Act and each one of them was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for two years. All the sentences, however, were ordered to run concurrently. So far as the other accused persons are concerned, they were acquitted of all the charges by the trial court itself. Against their convictions, the respondents filed appeals before the Andhra Pradesh High Court whereas the son of the victim Otukunta Appaiah filed a revision against the order of acquittal. The High Court dismissed the revision application but allowed the appeal, set aside the convictions and sentences awarded against the respondents by the trial court and acquitted them of all the charges.

2. The prosecution case, in short, is that members of the prosecution party as well as the accused persons belonged to Village Peddaventhurla in which village, there were two factions, leader to the one group being accused Chereddy Malla Reddy and all other accused persons his followers and of the other one Otukunta Channarayudu, who was the brother of Otukunta Appaiah, whose followers were members of the prosecution party. Six to seven months prior to the present incident, a dispute had arisen between the two groups over election of a cooperative society, during the course of which some incident had taken place leading to filing of two cases in which some of the accused persons were made accused and Golla Angilikam Narayana (PW 1), Kamma Otukunta Rama Naidu (PW 3) and Otukunta Appaiah (deceased) of the present case were cited as prosecution witnesses. In the said case, 21-3-1988 was the date fixed for examination of prosecution witnesses before Judicial Magistrate, 1st Class, Koilkuntla, on which date, in the morning, Otukunta Appaiah along with Golla Angilikam Narayana (PW 1) Harijana Kosangi Subbarayudu (PW 2), Kamma Otukunta Rama Naidu (PW 3) and Golla Panyam Venkata Narayana (PW 4) and three others left their village for going to Koilkuntla for deposing in the said cases and they boarded a bus at Village Perusomala at 6.30 a.m As the bus was overcrowded, the aforesaid persons had no option but to remain standing behind the driver's seat. When the bus was about to start, all the fourteen accused persons, including the respondents, came in front of the bus, stopped it and while some of them got into the bus, others climbed on its top. When the bus reached Village Ramabhadrunipalli, some passengers got down as a result of which, some of the accused persons, who were on its top, came down and got into the bus. Thereafter, when the bus was proceeding towards Koilkuntla, members of the prosecution party, having apprehended that accused persons, who were armed with weapons, might attack them as they were moving towards them and when the bus reached near a culvert, they requested the driver to stop the same and when it stopped, the members of the prosecution party got down from the bus through the door which was by the side of the driver and started running across the fields. The accused persons also got down from the bus and chased them. Respondents 1, 2 and 4, who were having three country-made bombs, hurled the same on Otukunta Appaiah which hit him and exploded. Accused Chereddy Malla Reddy instigated the other accused persons to kill Otukunta Appaiah whereupon Respondents 3 and 5 inflicted injuries upon his head and shoulder with hunting sickles which they were carrying. The prosecution witnesses, who had seen the occurrence, ran in different directions to save their lives, but PW 4 was overpowered by one of the accused persons and assaulted with an iron pipe, whereafter all the accused persons fled away and PWs 1 to 4 and their companions came near Otukunta Appaiah and found him dead.

3. A first information report was lodged at the police station concerned on the same day at 10.30 a.m on the basis of the statement of PW 1. The police after registering the case, took up investigation and on completion thereof submitted a charge-sheet, on receipt whereof, the learned Magistrate took cognizance and committed the accused persons, including the respondents, to the Court of Session to face trial.

4. Defence of the accused persons was that they were innocent and falsely implicated in the case on hand in order to feed fat the old grudge. According to them, no occurrence, much less the one alleged, had taken place and the deceased might have received injuries in some other manner of occurrence in the dead of night at some other place.

5. During trial, the prosecution examined fourteen witnesses in all, out of whom, PWs 1 to 4 claimed to be eyewitnesses, of whom, PW 1 was the informant, Golla Kancherla Veerabhadrudeu (PW 5), who was the co-passenger, stated that members of the prosecution party and the accused persons were travelling on that day in the same bus, Kattubadi Rahbamathullah (PW 6) was the driver of the bus and Alluru Bhaskara Rao (PW 7) was its conductor, both of whom have turned hostile. Basam Kondaiah (PW 8), K. Rajanna (PW 9) and Ch Veeraraghava Rao (PW 12) are the formal witnesses. Dr N.S Rama Swamy (PW 10) is the doctor who conducted the post-mortem examination over the dead body of the victim and Dr V.D Karunakara Rao (PW 11) is another doctor who examined the injuries of PW 4, S. Vema Narayana (PW 13) is the Inspector of Police who supervised the investigation and S.A Rasool (PW 14) is the investigating officer. Upon the conclusion of trial, while other accused persons were acquitted, the respondents were convicted by the trial court as stated above. On matter being taken before the High Court, the order of acquittal was upheld but convictions and sentences of the respondents have been set aside and they have been acquitted of all the charges. Hence, these appeals by special leave in which only the acquittal of the respondents by the High Court has been assailed.

6. The question which falls for our consideration is as to whether the order of acquittal recorded by the High Court suffers from perversity as it is well settled that an appellate court should not interfere with the same unless it is found to be perverse.

7. In the present case, first we proceed to consider the medical evidence. PW 10 conducted the post-mortem examination on the dead body of Otukunta Appaiah on the next day at 9.15 a.m and found the following injuries on his person:

1. A lacerated injury at right shoulder measuring 6″ × 4″ × 2″, blackening of skin present around the injury.
2. Incised injury at right shoulder 1″ medial to Injury 1 measuring 2″ × 2″ × 1 1/2″.
3. Lacerated injury on right cheek measuring 2″ × 1″ × 1″, blackening of skin present all over the cheek.
4. Lacerated injury at right mastoid area of skull 1/2″ back of ear measuring 1″ × 1″ × 1/2″, blackening of the skin present around the injury.
5. Transverse incised injury on parietal area of the skull measuring 6″ × 2″ × 1″.
6. A lacerated injury at right palm. There was destruction of complete palm. The bones of the palm were all fractured and the skin was hanging from the wound. There was blackening of the skin present all over the injury.
7. An incised injury at left scapular area of the back measuring 4″ × 1″ × 1/2″.
8. An abrasion at right inguinal area of the abdomen measuring 1/2″ × 1/2″, blackening of the skin present.
9. An abrasion at the middle of the right thigh measuring 1/2″ × 1/2″, blackening of the skin present.
10. An abrasion at right knee measuring 1/2″ × 1/2″, blackening of the skin present.
11. An abrasion at 10th intercostal space on the right side measuring 1/2″ × 1/4″, blackening of the skin present.

8. According to the doctor, all the injuries except Injuries 2, 5 and 7 could have been caused by explosion of a country-made bomb whereas Injuries 2, 5 and 7, which were incised wounds, could be by a sharp-edged weapon like hunting sickle. The doctor opined that the injuries were caused 24 to 28 hours before the post-mortem examination was conducted and the same were sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature. From a bare perusal of the medical evidence referred to above, it would appear that the same supports the prosecution case in all material particulars. Apart from this, the objective finding of the investigating officer, PW 14 also supports the prosecution case inasmuch as when immediately after registering the case, he inspected the place of occurrence, the dead body was found in the field in question together with signs of bomb explosion.

9. Turning now to the ocular version of the occurrence given by PWs 1 to 4, who claim to be eyewitnesses, it may be stated that PWs 1 and 3 were witnesses who, along with the deceased, were going to depose in the earlier two cases against some of the accused persons of present case when the alleged occurrence had taken place and PWs 2 and 4 were accompanying them. Their presence along with the deceased at the alleged place of occurrence cannot be doubted. All these witnesses have supported the prosecution case in all material particulars and their evidence is consistent, inter se, as well as the prosecution case disclosed in the first information report and by the witnesses in their statements before the police. The High Court was not justified in refusing to place reliance upon their evidence on the ground that they were interested and partisan witnesses as it is well settled that in a murder trial, sworn testimony of a witness cannot be rejected on this ground alone when the same is consistent with the prosecution case and supported by medical evidence as well as the objective finding of the investigating officer. Further, the High Court was also not justified in doubting their evidence on the ground that while running away, they could not have turned back and seen the assault upon the deceased which, in our opinion, cannot be said to be either improbable or unnatural conduct of the witnesses, especially when the deceased was the father of PW 1.

10. PW 5, who is a resident of the village of occurrence and was also travelling in the same bus as a co-passenger, stated that the accused persons and members of the prosecution party were travelling in the bus in question on the fateful day and they got down from the bus near the culvert. The statement of this witness to the aforesaid fact is consistent with the evidence of PWs 1 to 4. He had made consistent statement before the police as well as in court but the High Court was not justified in refusing to place reliance upon his evidence on the ground that his examination by the police was belated, which is factually incorrect, as the witness was examined on the very next day of the occurrence.

11. The High Court has doubted the veracity of prosecution case on the ground that there was no need for the members of the prosecution party to leave their house in the early morning for boarding the bus at 6.30 a.m which was totally irrelevant as the members of the prosecution party were going to the court for deposing in criminal cases and distance of the place where the court was situated being 25 km, it was quite natural on their part to board the bus which was scheduled to leave the village at 6.30 a.m Further, the High Court has drawn adverse inference against the prosecution for not mentioning in the first information report that as the accused persons were advancing towards them in the bus, they having apprehended danger to their lives, got down from the bus. It may be stated that in the first information report, it was enumerated that members of the prosecution party got down from the bus as they apprehended danger to their lives at the hands of the accused persons, who were armed with weapons, but the reason for apprehension that a accused persons were advancing towards them in the bus was not enumerated. In our view, this is a mere omission as it is well settled that a first information report is not the repository of everything and merely because minutest details of the occurrence were not mentioned, the same cannot make the prosecution case doubtful. Further, PW 4 having specifically deposed that tickets, which he had purchased for himself and others for travelling in the bus, were lost when he was being chased by the accused persons, the High Court was not justified in drawing an adverse inference against the prosecution for its non-production. That apart, the High Court was also not justified in holding that delay was caused in receipt of the first information report in court inasmuch as, in the present case, the occurrence is said to have taken place between 7.00 a.m and 7.30 a.m, the distance of the police station was 10 km from the place of occurrence where the first information report was lodged at 10.30 a.m and after registering the case, the investigating officer simultaneously proceeded to the place of occurrence and sent the first information report to court where the same was received at 4.15 p.m on that day itself.

12. Thus, we are of the opinion that the prosecution has succeeded in proving its case beyond reasonable doubt and the High Court was not justified in doubting the veracity of the prosecution case and recording the verdict of acquittal which suffers from the vice of perversity.

13. In the result, the appeals are allowed, the impugned judgment of acquittal rendered by the High Court is set aside and that of the trial court recording conviction of the respondents is restored. Bail bonds of the respondents, who are on bail, are cancelled and they are directed to be taken into custody forthwith for serving out the remaining period of their sentence.