- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of Punjab v. Hardam Singh And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
On 29-11-1984 Hari Singh was fatally assaulted near the bus adda of Village Joian while returning to his Village Alampur Madran from court proceedings in Mansa. The prosecution alleged that three brothers—Hardam Singh (armed with a gandasa), Jagjit Singh (takwa) and Resham Singh (gendhali)—attacked Hari Singh at the instigation of Gurdip Singh, the Sarpanch of Joian. Hari Singh’s son, PW-1 Billu Singh, witnessed the attack from a short distance, fled on his bicycle, and lodged an FIR at Police Station Boha at 6:30 p.m. An inquest was prepared and PW-6 Dr I.B. Aggarwal conducted the post-mortem, recording twelve injuries, several of which were individually sufficient to cause death.
The Additional Sessions Judge, Bhatinda, convicted all four accused on 29-5-1986, sentencing them to life imprisonment under Section 302 read with Sections 34/109 IPC. On separate appeals, the Punjab and Haryana High Court acquitted the accused on 28-5-1987. Gurdip Singh having died meanwhile, the State appealed to the Supreme Court only against the three surviving respondents.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court erred in doubting the presence and credibility of the solitary eyewitness (PW-1) and, consequently, in setting aside the convictions.
- Whether the FIR was lodged with unexplained delay sufficient to vitiate the prosecution case.
- Whether alleged discrepancies between the ocular testimony and medical evidence rendered the prosecution version unreliable.
- Whether the conduct of PW-1 in fleeing the scene and his failure to sustain assault undermined the veracity of his testimony.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (State)’s Arguments
- The train tickets (Exts. P-2 & P-5) and testimony of court staff (PW-5) sufficiently proved PW-1’s and the deceased’s presence at Ferozepur and Mansa courts, contrary to the High Court’s finding.
- Human reactions vary; PW-1’s flight without seeking local help was natural given that Joian was the Sarpanch accused’s village.
- There was no unreasonable delay in lodging the FIR considering the indirect route PW-1 took for safety.
- Medical evidence corroborated PW-1’s version, especially Injuries 9-11, and any minor variation was immaterial.
Respondents’ Arguments
- PW-1 was inimical and his uncorroborated testimony could not safely ground conviction.
- Discrepancies existed between PW-1’s ocular description and the medical findings, particularly regarding injuries allegedly inflicted while the deceased lay face-up.
- The murder was a “blind murder”; Bant Singh (DW-1) suggested the body lay unattended since noon, casting doubt on prosecution timings.
- Presence of PW-1 at two different courts on consecutive days was unproved because no court record or official was produced.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Rana Partap v. State of Haryana, (1983) 3 SCC 327 | No universal pattern of “natural” human reaction; witnesses respond differently under stress. | Used to reject the High Court’s inference that PW-1’s failure to intervene or seek help immediately rendered his presence suspect. |
| Bachittar Singh v. State of Punjab, (2002) 8 SCC 125 | Human behaviour varies; fleeing for safety can be natural in life-threatening circumstances. | Reinforced the acceptance of PW-1’s conduct in cycling away and reporting the offence via a longer, safer route. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court undertook a point-by-point examination of the High Court’s five grounds for acquittal:
- Presence at Courts (Ground A): Train tickets and PW-5’s testimony conclusively established that PW-1 and the deceased travelled from Ferozepur to Mansa after court appearances. The High Court’s reliance on absence of formal court-record entries was termed “clearly fallacious.”
- Witness Conduct (Ground B): Citing Rana Partap and Bachittar Singh, the Court held there is no fixed rule of human reaction. PW-1’s decision to avoid Joian and reach the police via a circuitous route was reasonable given the accused Sarpanch’s local influence.
- Solitary Eyewitness (Ground C): The Court emphasised that close relatives seldom implicate innocent persons. PW-1’s testimony was inherently reliable and corroborated by PW-2, PW-5, medical findings, and documentary evidence.
- Alleged FIR Delay (Ground D): A two-and-a-half-hour gap was reasonable in the circumstances; therefore, the High Court’s conclusion of “unexplained delay” was untenable.
- Ocular vs. Medical Evidence (Ground E): The Court found no material inconsistency: Injuries 9-11 matched PW-1’s account of initial blows while the victim was standing, and subsequent injuries could occur as the victim tossed on the ground. PW-6 confirmed all injuries were ante-mortem and individually fatal.
The Court also dismissed reliance on DW-1 Bant Singh’s testimony, noting his subordination to the deceased Sarpanch accused and the trial court’s earlier decision to disregard his evidence.
Holding and Implications
Convictions restored. The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s acquittal dated 28-5-1987 and reinstated the trial court’s judgment of 29-5-1986, thereby affirming the life sentences of Hardam Singh, Jagjit Singh and Resham Singh under Section 302/34 IPC.
Implications: The decision re-emphasises that (i) solitary eyewitness testimony, if credible and corroborated by circumstance or medical evidence, suffices for conviction, and (ii) courts must recognise variability in human behaviour when assessing witness conduct. No new legal doctrine was created, but the judgment strengthens precedent on evaluating eyewitness reliability and minor FIR delays.
H.K Sema, J.— Four accused — Hardam Singh, Jagjit Singh, Resham Singh and Gurdip Singh were convicted by the Additional Sessions Judge, Bhatinda in Sessions Case No. 22.RT No. 5 of 1985 by the judgment dated 29-5-1986. By the aforesaid judgment, accused Hardam Singh, Jagjit Singh and Resham Singh were convicted under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced to undergo life imprisonment and to pay a fine of Rs 1500 each, or, in default of payment of fine, to suffer further RI for six months each. Accused Gurdip Singh was convicted under Section 302 read with Section 109 IPC and sentenced to undergo the sentence, as aforesaid, as in the case of the other three accused. Accused 1-3 are sanguinary brothers. Accused Gurdip Singh was a Sarpanch of Joian village. Aggrieved by the aforesaid convictions accused Hardam Singh, Jagjit Singh and Resham Singh filed Criminal Appeal No. 374-DB of 1986 and accused Gurdip Singh filed Criminal Appeal No. 378-DB of 1986. The High Court, by its judgment and order dated 28-5-1987 set aside the conviction and sentence recorded by the learned trial Judge. Accused Gurdip Singh died in the interregnum. Hence, this appeal is filed only against the three accused.
2. Briefly stated, the story as unfolded by the prosecution is that:
PW 1 Billu Singh and his father, deceased Hari Singh are from Village Alampur Madran and on 28-11-1984 had gone to Ferozepur to attend a case in which they were challaned under Sections 307/34 IPC for murderous assault on Jagjit Singh and his wife. It is stated that after appearing before the Special Judge, Ferozepur on 28-11-1984, PW 1 Billu Singh and his deceased father Hari Singh started from Ferozepur by train for Mansa and reached Mansa at about midnight. It is also stated that they were to appear there in a case on 29-11-1984 under Section 145 CrPC pending in the Court of Executive Magistrate, Mansa in which Hari Singh and accused Hardam Singh and Jagjit Singh were parties. After attending the court on 29-11-1984, they started for Village Alampur Madran at about 3 p.m on their bicycles, which were parked by them at Mansa while going to Ferozepur. It is further stated that the deceased Hari Singh's bicycle was followed by Billu Singh and at about 4 p.m when they reached near bus adda of Village Joian, at the trijunction of the roads, from where a road to Village Akkanwali bifurcates, accused Hardam Singh armed with a gandasa, Resham Singh armed with a gendhali and Jagjit Singh armed with a takwa emerged from the bus adda shouting that Hari Singh (Ramdasia) was not to be left alive and was to be taught a lesson for raising a dispute with them for land and for murderous assault. Deceased Hari Singh immediately threw his bicycle and ran towards the house nearby to save himself. The accused overpowered Hari Singh, threw him on the ground and started giving him blows with their weapons causing several injuries. PW 1 after seeing the incident, fearing that the accused would also chase him, hurriedly left the place on his bicycle and went towards Village Akkanwali and via Budhiada reached Police Station Boha, where he narrated the incident to SI Jagjit Singh stating that accused Hardam Singh, Jagjit Singh and Resham Singh had committed the murder of the deceased in conspiracy and under the instigation of accused Gurdip Singh, Sarpanch of the village. The prosecution story further disclosed that when PW 1 and deceased Hari Singh were in jail in connection with a case under Sections 307/34 IPC for murderous assault on accused Jagjit Singh, accused Gurdip Singh got a thumb impression of Hari Singh and an agreement of sale for his land for Rs 7000 promising to help them in the case and he got them released on bail. But when Hari Singh and his wife asked for Rs 7000 from Gurdip Singh, he insulted them and got the bail bond cancelled for which Hari Singh made a complaint against Gurdip Singh to the authorities and also got the complaint published in the newspaper. It is alleged that it is because of this, Gurdip Singh conspired with the other accused and committed murder of Hari Singh. On the basis of the complaint, FIR (Ext. PA) was lodged at 6.30 p.m In the course of investigation, the IO prepared an inquest report. Post-mortem was conducted by PW 6 Dr. I.B Aggarwal. On conclusion of the trial, the learned trial Judge, after considering the evidence on record and documents, found the accused guilty and recorded conviction, as noticed above.
3. We have heard Mr H.M Singh, learned counsel for the appellant and Mr Neeraj Kumar Jain, learned counsel for the respondents at length.
4. The High Court has upset the conviction recorded by the trial court on various grounds. We may, at this stage, point out that the grounds which weighed with the High Court are contrary to the evidence adduced and proved by the prosecution and legally untenable, which we shall be discussing presently. The High Court held:
(A) The presence of Billu Singh and deceased Hari Singh in the court at Ferozepur on 28-11-1984 and then at Mansa on 29-11-1984 is not proved inasmuch as the prosecution has not produced any record of judicial proceedings showing the appearance of Billu Singh and Hari Singh nor has any official of the Court been examined to prove this fact.
This finding, in our view, is clearly fallacious. It is in the statement of PW 1 that he and his deceased father travelled from Ferozepur to Mansa by train after attending the court at Ferozepur on 28-11-1984. Exts. P-2 and P-5 are the train tickets. Ext. P-2 was with PW 1 Billu Singh and Ext. P-5 was found by the doctor from the person of Hari Singh, deceased at the time of the post-mortem examination. The learned trial court found that a faint punching was visible on those tickets. These facts are the conclusive proof that PW 1 and Hari Singh did actually travel from Ferozepur to Mansa by train. This apart, PW 5 Brij Bhan, who was a Reader Naib Tahsildar examined by the prosecution, testified that a case under Section 145 CrPC was fixed on 29-11-1984 in which only the presence of the advocates was recorded and the presence of the parties was not recorded. It is a matter of common practice that on a date the case is fixed for hearing, the presence of the counsel is recorded in the order sheet and not of the parties. PW 2 Smt Gurdev Kaur, mother of PW 1 also stated that PW 1 was not a party in Section 145 CrPC proceedings but he used to go with his father. This would go to show that the presence of PW 1 and his father before the court on 29-11-1984 at Mansa is clearly established. The High Court also found fault with the presence of PW 1 in the Court on 29-11-1984 as this witness could not give the full description of his lawyer and did not remember his name but knew him only as one Mr Sharma. It is in the evidence on record that Billu Singh is an illiterate and is not expected to know the full description of the name of the counsel. Even in ordinary circumstances, a lawyer is always addressed by his surname or short name. It is also curious to note that the statement of PW 1 that he along with his father attended the court at Ferozepur on 28-11-1984 and at Mansa on 29-11-1984 has not been controverted in the cross-examination, not even a suggestion was put to him. Therefore, this finding of the High Court is too tenuous a ground to reject the prosecution case, which otherwise is well established by convincing evidence.
(B) The High Court rejected the prosecution story on the ground that Billu Singh had not stated that any effort was made by the accused to assault him, although the relations with him were also highly inimical. The High Court was of the view that if Billu Singh had been present with the deceased, an effort to assault Billu Singh also might have been made. The High Court also found that the place where Hari Singh is shown to have been assaulted is contiguous to the house of Surjit Singh and fields of Maghar Singh and bus adda of Village Joian is also nearby. But Billu Singh had not approached any of the persons nearby. He also did not go directly to the police station, which is at a distance of four miles but went in a circuitous route to Village Akkanwali and then to Budhiada and then to Boha where the police station is located and therefore, his conduct in not approaching anyone at either of those places is suspicious.
Before we advert further, we may at this stage point out that by now it is well-settled principle of law that there is no set rule of natural reaction. Everyone reacts in his own special way and in what way the witness should react cannot be predicted. In Rana Partap v. State of Haryana (1983) 3 SCC 327 in paragraph 6 it was pointed out as under:
“6. Yet another reason given by the learned Sessions Judge to doubt the presence of the witnesses was that their conduct in not going to the rescue of the deceased when he was in the clutches of the assailants was unnatural. We must say that the comment is most unreal. Every person who witnesses a murder reacts in his own way. Some are stunned, become speechless and stand rooted to the spot. Some become hysteric and start wailing. Some start shouting for help. Others run away to keep themselves as far removed from the spot as possible. Yet others rush to the rescue of the victim, even going to the extent of counter-attacking the assailants. Every one reacts in his own special way. There is no set rule of natural reaction. To discard the evidence of a witness on the ground that he did not react in any particular manner is to appreciate evidence in a wholly unrealistic and unimaginative way.”
This Court in Bachittar Singh v. State of Punjab (2002) 8 SCC 125 on human behaviour, held as under:
“12. Human behaviour vary from man to man. Different people behave and react differently in different situations. Human behaviour depends upon the facts and circumstances of each given case. How a man would behave in a particular situation, can never be predicted. In the given circumstances, the behaviour of Joginder Singh, PW 3 sleeping on the roof of the house of Sukhwant Singh, after seeing the accused armed with weapons and hearing the firing, jumping from the roof and running towards his Village Mastewala to inform his father and family members instead of loitering around in the Village Dholewala and informing somebody risking his life, is quite natural. One should not forget that the incident had happened at 1.00 a.m and that at that odd time, nobody would be readily available to be informed without loss of time. In the process, the life of the witness would be at great risk.”
In the present case Village Joian, where the incident had taken place, is the village of Gurdip Singh, the Sarpanch. The allegation is that the murder had been hatched under instigation and conspiracy of accused Gurdip Singh. It is a matter of common knowledge that a Sarpanch of the village wields enough power and influence. In such a situation Billu Singh going to Village Joian and approaching anybody in the said village would be risking his own life. His immediate reaction, therefore, would be to avoid approaching anybody in the said village/adjoining village to lodge a report without loss of time. We think that was the correct approach taken by PW 1 in the facts and circumstances of this case. On this ground, the otherwise creditworthy and reliable testimony of PW 1 Billu Singh could not be impeached.
Billu Singh stated that his father was ahead of him on a bicycle followed by him on his bicycle. The assault on his father had taken place at a distance of about 10 to 12 karams. He immediately ran away with his bicycle towards Akkanwali village after seeing the incident. Therefore, Billu Singh was not within the striking distance of the assailants. There was no opportunity for the assailants to have made an effort to assault Billu Singh. This would be no ground to throw away the prosecution case. It must be remembered that the assailants were on foot and Billu Singh had run away on a bicycle.
(C) The High Court was of the view that Billu Singh being the solitary eyewitness is a highly inimical witness and in the absence of any corroboration it will not be safe to base conviction on such uncorroborated testimony.
This finding of the High Court, in our view, is fallacious and highly untenable. Ordinarily, the near relation of the deceased would not depose falsely against innocent persons so as to allow the real culprit to escape unpunished, rather the witness would always try to secure conviction of the real culprit and there is no reason as to why he should depose falsely. In the instant case, the testimony of PW 1 is corroborated by the evidence of PW 2, PW 5 and his ocular evidence is corroborated by the medical evidence, which we shall be discussing presently. The testimony of PW 1 is also corroborated by Exts. P-2 and P-5. Even otherwise, we have gone through the entire testimony of PW 1 and we find that he is quite a natural witness and his testimony is creditworthy and convincing, on which alone the conviction could safely be based.
(D) The High Court also found that there was an unexplained delay in lodging the FIR inasmuch as the incident had taken place at 4 p.m and the FIR had been lodged at 6.30 p.m when the police station is only four miles away from the place of incident.
In the facts and circumstances of the case, we do not see any delay, much less unexplained delay, in lodging the FIR. As already noticed, the place of incident is Joian village, the village of Gurdip Singh, Sarpanch. We have already noted that it is quite natural that Billu Singh would not approach anybody in Joian village or any other adjoining village risking his life. We have already noticed that PW 1 went to the police station through Village Akkanwali and Budhiada to reach Boha, where the police station is located. It is under these circumstances that there could be no delay if the FIR was lodged at 6.30 p.m for the incident which took place at 4 p.m
(E) The last ground, on the basis of which the High Court has set aside the conviction, is that the ocular evidence of PW 1 with regard to the injuries on the body of the deceased is not corroborated by the medical evidence. In other words, according to the High Court, there are discrepancies between the ocular evidence and the medical evidence.
5. PW 6 Dr. I.B Aggarwal, Medical Officer, Civil Hospital, Mansa conducted the post-mortem examination on 30-11-1984 and found the following injuries:
“1. An incised wound 11 cm × 5 1/2 cm present on the front of neck. The wound was 5 cm on left and 6 cm on right from midline of neck, underlying structures i.e trachea oesophagus, all the blood vessels, muscles and the third vertebrae were cut through and through. Clotted blood was present. There was cut on both sides of coat, shirt and sweater corresponding to the injury.
2. Incised wound 3 cm × 1 1/2 cm present on the right side of chest at the level of right clavicle in its middle, underlying bone was cut. Clotted blood was present. There was corresponding cut on shirt and coat and sweater.
3. Incised wound 2 1/2 cm × 1/2 cm present on the left side of lower lip, 1 1/2 cm inwards from left outer angle of mouth, underlying bone was cut and teeth were dislocated. Clotted blood was present.
4. Incised wound 2 1/2 cm × 1 1/2 cm present on the left side of upper and lower lip starting 1 cm inwards from left angle of mouth extending upwards, underlying bone was cut, teeth were dislocated, clotted blood was present.
5. A punctured wound 1 cm × 1/2 cm present on the left side of face, 2 cm lateral to outer angle of left eye, clotted blood was present. On dissection, the temporal bone was found fractured.
6. Incised wound 4 cm × 1 cm present on the left side of forehead, 3 cm above the left eyebrow and 2 1/2 cm lateral to midline, clotted blood was present.
7. Incised wound 4 1/2 cm × 1 1/2 cm present on the left occipital region, 10 cm above the left ear pinna and 2 cm below the occipital, clotted blood was present.
8. Incised wound 3 1/2 × 1 cm present on the left occipital region, lying 1 cm medially and posteriorily to Injury 7, clotted blood was present.
9. Incised wound 4 cm × 1 1/2 cm present on the left occipital region, 2 cm below Injury 8. Clotted blood was present.
10. Incised wound 4 1/2 cm × 1/2 cm present on the left side of neck, at its back lying near the lower margin of occipit. Clotted blood was present.
11. Incised wound 3 cm × 1 1/2 cm present on the left side of back of neck, 3 cm below Injury 10. Clotted blood was present.
12. A contusion 3 1/2 cm × 2 cm present on the anterior aspect of the left shoulder.”
6. PW 1 Billu Singh stated that accused Hardam Singh caused gandasa-blow on the left shoulder of Hari Singh, Jagjit Singh gave a takwa-blow on the back side of Hari Singh and Resham Singh gave gendhali-blow on the left shoulder of Hari Singh. The High Court found that Injury 1 is on the front of the neck; Injury 2 is on the right side of the chest; Injury 3 is on the left side of lower lip; Injury 4 is on the left side of upper and lower lip; Injury 5 is on the left side of face; Injury 6 is on the left side of forehead, Injuries 7, 8 and 9 are on the left occipital region; Injury 10 is on the left side of neck; Injury 11 is on the left side of the back of neck and Injury 12, a contusion is on the anterior aspect of left shoulder.
7. In our view, there is no discrepancy in the ocular evidence of PW 1 and the medical evidence of PW 6. Injuries 9, 10 and 11 correspond to the testimony of PW 1.
8. Mr Neeraj Kumar Jain, learned counsel for the respondents strenuously urged that PW 6 opined that Injuries 7 to 11 could not have been caused if the deceased was lying on the ground with his face upwards, and since PW 1 testified that his father fell down with his face upwards, his presence at the place of incident is doubtful. According to the learned counsel, these injuries could not have been caused while Hari Singh was lying on the ground with his face upwards. The learned counsel, therefore, submits that these discrepancies in the ocular and medical evidence make the presence of Billu Singh doubtful. We are unable to accept this submission. PW 1 categorically stated in examination-in-chief that these injuries were caused by the assailants when Hari Singh was running or standing. He further stated that rest of the injuries were given to Hari Singh by the three accused on his face and neck while he was lying on the ground. The witness was not put to cross-examination on this part of the evidence. This witness also stated in the cross-examination that Hari Singh kept his face upwards, but he was moving about on sides. PW 6 opined that all the injuries were ante-mortem. It is quite natural that he must be tossing around trying to evade the strike blows dealt by the accused with their weapons and in this process he must have received various injuries which had not been witnessed by PW 1 as he hurriedly ran away on his bicycle after seeing the first incident. It must be remembered that PW 1 was following his father on a bicycle and witnessed the incident at a distance of about 10-12 karams. Having seen the accused armed with weapons and dealing blows to his father, being unarmed it could have been the sudden reaction of PW 1 to run for safety and lodge a report to the police. PW 6 in his cross-examination had stated that Injuries 2 to 11 were individually sufficient to cause the death in the ordinary course of nature. He also stated that if Injuries 1 to 11 were caused when the victim was in the standing posture, he was likely to fall. PW 6 further opined that if any of Injuries 1 to 11 was inflicted when the victim was lying on the ground he was likely to lose his senses. We have already held that Injuries 9, 10 and 11 were inflicted while in the standing posture. We do not see any discrepancies between ocular and medical evidence, which would make the presence of PW 1 at the place of incident doubtful.
9. The next submission of Mr Neeraj Kumar Jain, learned counsel for the respondents is that the murder of Hari Singh is a blind murder and he had been killed at about 12 noon and his body was lying unattended is based on the evidence of Bant Singh, DW 1. It must be remembered that Bant Singh was a chowkidar of Joian village where the accused Gurdip Singh was the Sarpanch. It is because of this reason that he was given up by the prosecution as he was alleged to have been won over by the accused. Naturally, a chowkidar of a village is very much subordinate to a Village Sarpanch and functions under his mercy and in his testimony he even denied that the Sarpanch was involved in any murder case. He even denied that the Sarpanch was ever arrested in connection with murder case. In fact, Gurdip Singh, accused surrendered himself in court on 4-10-1985 and remained in jail till he was released on bail on 9-10-1985. The testimony of DW 1 was correctly not acted upon by the trial court.
10. In the result, this appeal succeeds. The judgment and order of the High Court dated 28-5-1987 under challenge is, hereby, set aside. The order of the trial court dated 29-5-1986 convicting the accused is restored. The respondents are on bail. Their bail bonds are cancelled. They are directed to be taken back into custody forthwith to serve out the remaining part of their sentence.
Alert