- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kunjanam Antony (Dead) By Lrs. v. State Of Kerala And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The proceedings concern 17.74 acres of land in Survey No. 12/11 of Vedakkethara village, Alathur taluk, Kerala (“the disputed area”). The appellant claims ownership and asserts that the land is part of a rubber estate.
Under the Kerala Private Forests (Vesting and Assignment) Act, 1971 (“Forest Act”), ownership and possession of all private forests vested in the State on 10 May 1971 unless the land fell within specified exclusions, including land “used principally for the cultivation” of rubber.
Alleging interference by Forest authorities, the appellant filed an application under Section 8 of the Forest Act before the Forest Tribunal seeking a declaration that the land was exempt as a rubber plantation. The Tribunal ruled in the appellant’s favour. On the State’s appeal, the Kerala High Court remanded the matter for additional evidence. After remand, the Tribunal again held for the appellant. The State appealed once more (MFA No. 513 of 1985). By order dated 3 October 1990, a Division Bench of the High Court reversed the Tribunal, holding the appellant was not entitled to exemption. The present appeal challenges that High Court order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the disputed 17.74 acres qualify as “private forest” under the Forest Act or fall within the statutory exclusion for land “used principally for the cultivation of rubber.”
- Whether the appellant discharged the burden of proving that the land was principally used for rubber cultivation at the relevant time.
- The evidentiary value, in Forest Act proceedings, of an earlier order of the Thaluka Land Board under the Kerala Land Reforms Act exempting 32.74 acres (including the disputed land) as rubber plantation.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- An earlier, final order of the Thaluka Land Board under the Kerala Land Reforms Act exempted 32.74 acres as rubber plantation; this order should bind, or at least strongly influence, Forest Act authorities.
- Accordingly, the disputed land should be excluded from vesting and regarded as part of a rubber estate.
State's Arguments
- The appellant told the Tribunal that the rubber plantation had been destroyed by fire but provided no dates or particulars; the Ceiling Act declaration contained no reference to such destruction.
- Evidence indicated cultivation of tapioca rather than rubber, undermining the claim of principal use as a rubber plantation.
- The appellant failed to establish that any absence of rubber cultivation was temporary or for ancillary purposes.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court first clarified that an order of the Thaluka Land Board is binding on Land Reforms authorities, but in Forest Act proceedings it is only a piece of evidence, to be given due weight unless contrary material is shown.
Reviewing the record, the Court found:
- No evidence corroborated the alleged destruction of the rubber plantation by fire.
- Material existed showing cultivation of tapioca, not rubber.
- No proof indicated the appellant’s intention to continue or resume rubber cultivation, nor that any cessation was merely temporary or ancillary.
Because the statutory exclusion applies only where land is “used principally” for rubber cultivation, the appellant bore the burden of proof. The Court agreed with the High Court that this burden had not been met.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is dismissed without costs.
Immediate Effect: The High Court’s order stands, meaning the disputed 17.74 acres are treated as private forest vested in the State of Kerala. No broader doctrinal rule is articulated beyond application of the statutory burden of proof within the Forest Act framework.
Order
1. In this appeal, the order of a Division Bench of the High Court of Kerala in MFA No. 513 of 1985, dated 3-10-1990, is brought under challenge.
2. The proceedings arise out of the Kerala Private Forests (Vesting and Assignment) Act, 1971 (for short “the Forest Act”) which came into force on 10-5-1971. Section 3 of the Forest Act is a vesting section which says, inter alia, that notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, or in any contract or other document with effect on and from the appointed day (10-5-1971) the ownership and possession of all private forests in the State of Kerala shall by virtue of that Act stand transferred to and vested in the Government free from all encumbrances, and the right, title and interest of the owner or any other person in any private forest shall stand extinguished. This provision is subject to sub-sections (2) and (3) of Section 3 with which we are not concerned here.
3. For understanding the scope of this provision, it is necessary to examine the definition of the expression “private forest” in clause (f) of Section 2 of the Forest Act. The relevant provision of the definition reads as under:
“2. (f) ‘private forest’ means,—
(1) in relation to the Malabar district referred to in sub-section (2) of Section 5 of the State Reorganisation Act, 1956 (Central Act 37 of 1956),—
(i) any land to which the Madras Preservation of Private Forests Act, 1949 (Madras Act 27 of 1949), applied immediately before the appointed day excluding—
(A) land which are gardens or nilams as defined in the Kerala Land Reforms Act, 1963 (1 of 1964);
(B) lands which are used principally for the cultivation of tea, coffee, cocoa, rubber, cardamom or cinnamon and lands used for any purpose ancillary to the cultivation of such crops or for the preparation of same for the market.”
4. A plain reading of the definition, extracted above, shows, inter alia, that if any land is under the Madras Preservation of Private Forests Act, 1949 (Madras Act 27 of 1949) before the appointed day, it would be a private forest. From the scope of the private forest are excluded lands, inter alia, which are used principally for the cultivation of tea, coffee, cocoa, rubber, cardamom or cinnamon and also those lands which are used for any purpose ancillary to cultivation of such crops or for preparation of the same for the market. For exclusion of the land from the application of the Act as not being private forest, it is not necessary that the land should be in actual cultivation of rubber, tea, coffee etc. at all times. It is enough to prove that it is used principally for the cultivation of rubber, tea, coffee etc. There should be continuity in cultivation of rubber, tea, coffee etc. to prove principal use; and absence of cultivation for short periods due to clearing, felling or other ancillary purposes would not militate against the principal use of the land for cultivation of rubber, tea, coffee etc.
5. The appellant claims to be the owner of an extent of 17.74 acres of land in RS No. 12/11 of Vedakkethara village in Alathur taluk (referred to as “the disputed area”) and that it contains rubber plantation therein.
6. On the ground that the authorities under the Forest Act were not allowing her to enter the disputed area (17.74 acres), the appellant filed an application under Section 8 of the Forest Act before the Forest Tribunal for a declaration that the said area did not vest in the State as a private forest and that it was a part of the rubber estate. The Forest Tribunal found that the disputed area was not a private forest, and, accordingly, granted declaration to the appellant holding it to be a rubber plantation. That finding was challenged in the High Court by the respondent State. A Division Bench of the High Court deemed it fit to remand the matter to the Forest Tribunal to enable the appellant to lead further evidence to establish that the disputed area was principally used as a rubber plantation. After remand, the Forest Tribunal, after giving opportunity to the parties, came to the conclusion that the area in dispute continued to be a rubber estate. That finding was again challenged by the State before the High Court in MFA No. 513 of 1985. A Division Bench of the High Court, by an order dated 3-10-1990, set aside the finding of the Tribunal and held that the appellant was not entitled to the exemption as the land was not principally used for cultivation of rubber plantation. It is this order of the High Court which is brought under challenge in this appeal.
7. Mr T.L.V Iyer, the learned Senior Counsel for the appellant, has strenuously contended that just before the vesting of the land under the Forest Act, proceedings were conducted under the Kerala Land Reforms Act in which a total extent of 32.74 acres of land was exempted as rubber plantation; that order of the Thaluka Land Board had become final and would bind the authorities under the Forest Act; therefore, the Forest Act does not apply to the land in dispute.
8. Mr Ramesh Babu, learned counsel for the State, pointed out that the appellant stated before the Tribunal, contrary to the claim before the ceiling authorities, that the rubber plantation was destroyed by fire but no specific date of destruction of the rubber plantation was mentioned and that when the appellant approached the Tribunal in October 1977, no particulars of destruction of the forest by fire had been furnished. It is also brought to our notice that the declaration given under the Ceiling Act did not disclose any destruction of the rubber plantation by fire; on the contrary, submitted the learned counsel, the appellant had been cultivating tapioca in the land in question, as such it cannot be accepted that the principal object of the appellant was to cultivate the land for rubber plantation.
9. There can be no doubt that the order of the Thaluka Land Board, a statutory authority, is binding on the authorities under the Land Reforms Act. So far as the proceedings under the Forest Act are concerned, the order of the Thaluka Land Board would be a piece of evidence but it cannot be treated as binding on the authorities under the Forest Act. Unless a contrary state of affairs is shown to exist, the order of the Thaluka Land Board would have to be given due weight. From the material placed before the High Court and also before us, it appears that there is no evidence in regard to the destruction of the rubber plantation due to fire. There is, however, material to show that the appellant has been cultivating tapioca. Further, the High Court recorded a finding that there was no evidence indicating that the appellant had intention to cultivate the land which only meant cultivation of rubber plantation. There is also nothing on record to show that absence of rubber plantation was for a short period and that the land was in the process of rubber plantation.
10. For these reasons, we are of the view that the High Court is right in holding that the burden of showing that the land was not a private forest was on the appellant and the appellant had failed to establish her claim.
11. On the above facts, we are unable to hold that the appellant established that the lands were used principally for cultivation of rubber plantation, so, we do not find any valid ground to interfere with the order under challenge.
12. The appeal is, accordingly, dismissed but, in the circumstances of the case, without costs.
Alert