- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Shridhar And Another v. State Of Madhya Pradesh .
Factual and Procedural Background
On 12 March 1983, at about 7:00 p.m., deceased Hakimsingh and PW-1 Rajendrasingh were on their way to their field when they were confronted near the house of accused Shankariya. An altercation led to an assault in which Hakimsingh was beaten with lathis and a farsa by several accused. Rajendrasingh, who intervened, was also assaulted. Multiple eyewitnesses (PW-1, PW-3, PW-4, PW-5, and PW-6) witnessed the incident and raised an alarm. Both victims were medically examined; Hakimsingh suffered nine injuries and later died on 21 March 1983. A prompt First Information Report (FIR) was lodged, weapons were recovered, and charges were filed under Sections 302/149 and 323/149 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC).
The Sessions Judge convicted seven persons. During the pendency of the High Court appeal two convicts died; the High Court upheld the convictions of the remaining five. In this Supreme Court appeal, only two convicts—Shridhar and Motilal—challenged their convictions.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the evidence established the presence and participation of appellant Shridhar as a member of the unlawful assembly responsible for the fatal assault, justifying his conviction under Sections 302/149 and 323/149 IPC.
- Whether the evidence established the presence and participation of appellant Motilal, particularly in view of alleged inconsistencies between the assigned role (lathi-blow to the neck) and the medical evidence, thereby sustaining his conviction under the same sections.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- Shridhar was not present at the scene; no specific role was attributed to him in the FIR or by one of the eyewitnesses, casting doubt on his participation.
- The prosecution altered its narrative about the origin of the quarrel, weakening its credibility.
- In Motilal’s case, the prosecution alleged a lathi-blow to the neck, yet the post-mortem revealed no blunt-weapon injury to that area, undermining proof of his presence.
State's Arguments
- A blood-stained lathi was recovered from Shridhar, purportedly linking him to the assault.
- The prompt FIR and consistent eyewitness accounts sufficiently implicated Motilal despite minor discrepancies in injury location.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court scrutinised the evidentiary record with emphasis on the individual roles of the two appellants.
Regarding Shridhar: The Court noted that the FIR and witness testimonies assigned no act of assault to him, and one eyewitness failed to name him altogether. The alleged recovery of a blood-stained lathi lost probative force because chemical analysis did not confirm human blood. These factors generated reasonable doubt about his presence in the unlawful assembly, leading the Court to withhold the benefit of any presumption against him.
Regarding Motilal: In contrast, every prosecution version—from the FIR through witness depositions—consistently asserted that Motilal struck Hakimsingh with a lathi. The Court found it unrealistic to expect exact mapping of each blow to a specific wound in a multi-assailant melee. It held that minor anatomical mismatches did not vitiate otherwise coherent and prompt eyewitness testimony, especially where multiple blunt-force injuries existed on the head and body. Accordingly, the Court deemed the evidence against Motilal reliable and sufficient.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal of Shridhar is allowed; his conviction and sentence are set aside, and he is to be released forthwith unless required in another case. The appeal of Motilal is dismissed, and his sentence of life imprisonment and six months’ rigorous imprisonment under Sections 302/149 and 323/149 IPC stands affirmed.
Implications: The decision affords immediate relief to Shridhar, underscoring the Court’s willingness to extend the benefit of doubt when individual participation in a group offence is inadequately proved. Motilal must continue to serve his sentence. The ruling is fact-specific and does not establish new legal precedent beyond reinforcing evidentiary standards for group liability under the IPC.
Brijesh Kumar, J.— This appeal is preferred against the judgment and order dated 17-5-2002 passed by the Madhya Pradesh High Court dismissing the appeal of the appellants against their conviction and sentences of imprisonment for life under Sections 302/149 as well as six months' rigorous imprisonment under Sections 323/149 of the Indian Penal Code. In all, seven persons have been convicted by the Sessions Judge, out of which Shankariya and Malkhe died during the pendency of the appeal in the High Court. The remaining five accused persons who have been convicted are: Munna, Shridhar, Motilal, Sarman and Gopal; out of these persons Shridhar and Motilal are appellants before us in this appeal.
2. The prosecution case is that on 12-3-1983 at about 7.00 p.m deceased Hakimsingh and PW 1 Rajendrasingh on the way to their field passed by the house of Shankariya who is said to have accosted Hakimsingh, asking him as to why he had been visiting the wife of his brother Ramcharan. Hakimsingh protested, upon which Shankariya and Malkhe with lathis and accused Sarman with a farsa assaulted him. Gopal and Motilal are said to have given lathi-blows on the head of Hakimsingh. PW 1 Rajendrasingh tried to intervene at which he was also assaulted by Shankariya and Gopal. The alarm of Rajendrasingh attracted PW 4 Mahaveersingh, PW 3 Sagarsingh, PW 5 Raghurajsingh and PW 6 Dildarsingh to the spot.
3. PW 1 Rajendrasingh lodged the report of the incident upon which the usual investigation was conducted by the police of PS Veerpur. The weapons of the assault, namely, lathi and farsa etc. were also said to have been recovered during the course of investigation. On completion of the investigation the police filed the charge-sheet. Rajendrasingh and Hakimsingh were sent for medical examination. PW 8 Dr K.K Singh found two injuries on the person of Rajendrasingh, one of which was a lacerated wound on the forehead and the other a bruise on the left hand. On the person of Hakimsingh he noted nine injuries most of which were lacerated wounds and quite a number of them on the head. Hakimsingh, however, later died on 21-3-1983 in J.A Group of Hospitals, Gwalior. The post-mortem examination was conducted on his body and as many as ten injuries were noted on his person including stitched wounds. The injuries were on the face, head and other parts of the body.
4. The prosecution, to prove its case, has examined PW 1 Rajendrasingh, PW 3 Sagarsingh, PW 4 Mahaveersingh and PW 5 Raghurajsingh as eyewitnesses. PW 6 Dildarsingh is also one of those who is said to have rushed to the spot at the time of the incident. PW 8 Dr K.K Singh examined the injuries of Rajendrasingh and Hakimsingh and PW 7 Dr V.K Divan conducted the post-mortem examination on the dead body of Hakimsingh. The other former witnesses and the investigating officers were also examined.
5. The defence of the accused persons was that they have been falsely implicated in the case. According to them, the complainant party wanted to grab the property and land of the appellants.
6. It also appeared that a cross-report was lodged by late Shankariya, accused, at the same police station. According to them, late Shankariya, accused Munna and Sarman had received injuries.
7. The learned counsel for the appellants has mainly emphasized that the present appellants, namely, Shridhar and Motilal were not present at the spot. He further submitted that the prosecution case as initially taken up has not been pursued as to how the incident occurred and the story of Hakimsingh having illicit relations with the wife of the brother of Shankariya has been given up at the stage of the evidence. We feel that it would not be necessary to go into that aspect of the matter in view of the fact that a fight had taken place at the time and date as indicated by the prosecution is not in dispute. A cross-report has also been lodged and it was the case of the accused persons that Munna and Sarman had received injuries.
8. It is true that at the evidence stage the prosecution story was slightly changed as to how the dispute had started, as it was stated at the end that a quarrel took place as the cattle of late Shankariya had entered into their fields. But as observed above, in the facts and circumstances of this case, the question as to how the fight started no more remains important since, admittedly, the incident occurred resulting in injuries to Hakimsingh and Rajendrasingh as a result of which later on Hakimsingh died. The cause of fight, therefore, is not a point to be much concentrated upon. The other relevant question which may arise for consideration is as to which of the parties was the aggressor and further, if there was any right of private defence available to the accused persons. The trial court as well as the High Court have considered this aspect of the matter and have come to the conclusion that it would not be possible to hold that Hakimsingh and Rajendrasingh would be aggressors or they picked up a fight empty-handed. As a matter of fact, no such arguments have been advanced on behalf of the appellants before us to dislodge the findings arrived at by the two courts. The main stress on behalf of the appellants has been that they were not present at the spot. Arguments have mainly been advanced only in that direction.
9. It is submitted that so far as the appellant Shridhar is concerned, he has not been assigned any role of assault on Hakimsingh or the injured Rajendrasingh. One of the eyewitnesses has also not named him as an accused person at the spot at the time of the incident. It is submitted that it makes his presence doubtful. The submission in regard to Motilal is that he is said to have given a lathi-blow on the neck of the deceased Hakimsingh. But there is no blunt-weapon injury on the neck of Hakimsingh. Therefore, it is submitted that his presence is also not made out at the relevant time of the incident.
10. We have scrutinized the submissions made by the learned counsel for the appellants and we notice that a role has been assigned to each of the accused persons but Shridhar. It is said that Shankariya and Malkhe started assaulting Hakimsingh. The FIR also indicates the role played by different accused persons but so far as accused Shridhar is concerned, no role has been assigned to him for assault either on Hakimsingh or on Rajendrasingh. The other accused persons, namely, Sarman has been stated to have given farsa-blow whereas Motilal and Gopal are said to have given lathi-blows to Hakimsingh. It is also to be noticed that one of the eyewitnesses has also not named Shridhar as one of the accused in his statement in the Court. This circumstance makes the presence of Shridhar doubtful, more so as a member of an unlawful assembly. Otherwise there was no good reason as to why no role would have been assigned to him in the FIR or in the statements of the prosecution witnesses and one of them having not named him altogether. The learned counsel appearing for the State has, however, drawn our attention to the fact that the lathi which is said to have been recovered from Shridhar was bloodstained. The submission is that this circumstance connects very much with the incident. But a perusal of the report of the Chemical Examiner does not indicate that the weapons, namely, lathi etc. were stained with human blood. Therefore, no aid can be taken from this circumstance too. Therefore, we don't consider it prudent to infer conclusively that Shridhar was one of the members of the unlawful assembly. A doubt has also arisen, as indicated earlier, due to the fact that one of the eyewitnesses does not name him at all in his statement before the Court.
11. So far as the appellant Motilal is concerned, his case stands on a different footing. He has been assigned the role of assault on Hakimsingh with his lathi. This has been maintained throughout in the FIR as well as in the statements of all the witnesses. The learned counsel for the appellants has vehemently urged that there is no injury by any blunt weapon on the neck of the deceased Hakimsingh and the role which has been assigned to Motilal is that he had given a blow on the neck. The injury report of Hakimsingh shows that he had received a number of injuries on the front and back side of the head which had also been caused by a blunt weapon. It is difficult in a criminal case to go by exactly tallying the injuries blow by blow. Quite often, injuries may tally but it is equally possible that at times a blow aimed at a particular part of the body may hit the other neighbouring part of the body and not exactly the part where the blow is aimed at. It is a case where Hakimsingh was being assaulted by lathis and farsa by a number of persons, which blow of which accused may land on which part of the body cannot be stated with exactitude. Not much would turn upon it. Such a discrepancy as indicated and mentioned above cannot be said to be glaring or so diverse from the manner of assault that normally it may not be possible to explain it. The evidence on the point of assault by Motilal is concerned (sic), it is also described in the FIR. The FIR was lodged promptly within two hours of the incident. Therefore, we are unable to accept the submission made on behalf of the appellant Motilal that his presence is also not established because of the fact that no blunt-weapon injury was found on the neck of the dead body of Hakimsingh.
12. In view of the discussion held above, we extend the benefit of doubt to Shridhar. Thus, appeal on his behalf is allowed and the conviction and sentence as awarded to him by the trial court and confirmed by the High Court are set aside. He shall be set at liberty forthwith unless wanted in connection with any other case. So far as Motilal is concerned, his appeal is dismissed. He shall serve out the sentence.
Alert