Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Commissioner Of Central Excise, Chandigarh-Ii v. Steel Strips Ltd. .

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 22, 2003
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeals arise from orders of the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal (“CEGAT”). The central dispute is whether the process of cold rolling duty-paid hot-rolled steel strips results in a new, excisable commodity liable to Central Excise duty.

Two different procedural settings are involved:

  • Refund matters (CA No. 7165 of 2000 & CAs Nos. 7706-11 of 2002):  M/s Steel Strips Ltd. paid duty on cold-rolled strips for the period 19-6-1996 to 29-6-1996 and later sought a refund based on this Court’s earlier decision in CCE v. Steel Strips Ltd. (1995) 4 SCC 241. The Assistant Commissioner rejected the claim; the Commissioner (Appeals) affirmed. CEGAT allowed the assessee’s appeal on merits but remitted the case to consider unjust enrichment.
  • Demand matter (CAs Nos. 439-42 of 2002):  A show-cause notice alleged clandestine removal of cold-rolled strips without payment of duty. The Commissioner ordered recovery of duty, interest and penalty. CEGAT set aside that order, holding that no duty was payable because no manufacture had taken place.

The Revenue filed the present batch of appeals before the Supreme Court; all cases were heard together and decided by this common judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the cold-rolling of duty-paid hot-rolled steel strips constitutes “manufacture” resulting in a commercially distinct excisable commodity under the amended Central Excise Tariff of 28-2-1986.
  2. Whether the burden of proving such manufacture lies on the Revenue and, if so, whether it has been discharged by leading appropriate evidence before the adjudicating authority.
  3. Whether the show-cause notices were defective for failing to allege that the impugned process amounted to manufacture, relying only on different tariff sub-headings.
  4. In the refund appeals, whether the assessee passed on the duty incidence to buyers, attracting the bar of unjust enrichment under Section 11-B of the Central Excise Act, 1944.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Revenue)

  • The placement of hot-rolled and cold-rolled strips under separate sub-headings in the post-1986 tariff is, by itself, determinative that two distinct excisable commodities exist.
  • The Assistant Commissioner’s order contained findings—based on material on record—that a manufacturing process occurred; hence CEGAT erred in holding that the Revenue failed to discharge its burden.

Respondents (Assessees)

  • No evidence was produced by the Department before the adjudicating authority to show that cold rolling results in a new commodity; the Assistant Commissioner’s observations were based on personal knowledge or textbooks not proved in evidence.
  • The earlier decision in CCE v. Steel Strips Ltd. places the onus squarely on the Revenue to prove manufacture and marketability; authoritative publications cannot substitute for evidence.
  • The show-cause notices did not allege manufacture; the Department cannot now enlarge their scope.
  • Classification into separate sub-headings is not conclusive of manufacture, as held in several Supreme Court precedents.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
CCE v. Steel Strips Ltd. (1995) 4 SCC 241 Burden on Revenue to prove manufacture and marketability Relied on by CEGAT and respondents; Supreme Court notes its relevance in allocating burden of proof
Hyderabad Industries Ltd. v. Union of India (1999) 5 SCC 15 Classification change not conclusive of manufacture Cited by respondents to rebut Revenue’s tariff-based argument
Hyderabad Industries Ltd. v. Union of India (1995) 5 SCC 338 Same as above Same application
Prabhat Sound Studios v. Addl. Collector of C. Excise (1997) 10 SCC 543 Proof of manufacture required beyond tariff placement Cited by respondents
Lal Woollen & Silk Mills (P) Ltd. v. CCE (1999) 4 SCC 466 Observations on tariff classification Distinguished; later case law held its observations not conclusive
CCE v. Markfed Vanaspati & Allied Industries (2003) 4 SCC 184 Tariff entry alone does not establish manufacture; burden remains on Revenue Quoted with approval to reaffirm legal position
Union of India v. Indian Aluminium Co. Ltd. 1995 Supp (2) SCC 465 Requirement of manufacture and marketability despite tariff entry Cited in Markfed Vanaspati passage
BPL Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. CCE 1995 Supp (3) SCC 1 Change in tariff item does not automatically make goods excisable Cited in Markfed Vanaspati passage
Cadila Laboratories (P) Ltd. v. CCE (2003) 4 SCC 12 Tariff coverage insufficient without manufacture & marketability Cited in Markfed Vanaspati passage

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court found the existing record inadequate to resolve whether cold rolling amounts to manufacture:

  • The Assistant Commissioner’s order refers to the manufacturing process but does not clarify whether evidence was led or whether conclusions were based on personal knowledge or publications.
  • CEGAT concluded that no evidence was produced by the Department; this finding was critical to its decision in favour of the assessee.
  • Consistent with the principle reaffirmed in CCE v. Markfed Vanaspati, tariff classification alone cannot establish manufacture; the Revenue bears the burden of proof.
  • The adequacy of the show-cause notices—whether they alleged manufacture at all—was also left unaddressed by lower authorities.
  • Given these deficiencies, the Court could not deliver a final determination on liability and considered remand necessary.

Holding and Implications

ORDER: The Court set aside the impugned orders of CEGAT and the Commissioner (Adjudication) and remitted the matters for fresh consideration:

  • In CA No. 7165 of 2000 and CAs Nos. 7706-11 of 2002:  • Assistant Commissioners to determine first whether the burden of duty was passed on to buyers (unjust enrichment under Section 11-B).  • If the assessee succeeds on unjust enrichment, CEGAT must then decide (a) whether Revenue led evidence of manufacture and (b) whether the show-cause notice was defective.
  • In CAs Nos. 439-42 of 2002: Commissioner (Appeals) to examine the two substantive questions (evidence of manufacture and validity of show-cause notice) on the existing record.

No costs were awarded.

Implications: The judgment reinforces that mere placement of goods in separate tariff sub-headings does not dispense with the Revenue’s obligation to prove manufacture and marketability. It also highlights the need for precise pleadings in show-cause notices and for adjudicating authorities to base findings on evidentiary material, not personal expertise or secondary literature.

Show all summary ...

B.P Singh, J.— This batch of appeals involves common questions and, therefore, they have been heard together and are being disposed of by a common judgment.

2. The Revenue is the appellant in all the appeals impugning the order passed by the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal in the appeals preferred by the respective respondents.

3. In CA No. 7165 of 2000 the Commissioner of Central Excise, Chandigarh-II, has impugned the order of the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal (hereinafter referred to as the Tribunal) dated 29-6-2000 whereby the Tribunal while upholding the plea of the respondent that the process of cold rolling of steel strips from hot-rolled strips does not amount to manufacture of a new excisable commodity, remitted the matter to the Assistant Commissioner so that the respondent may be able to satisfy the Assistant Commissioner on the question whether they had not passed on the burden of duty to their customers.

4. In CAs Nos. 7706-11 of 2002 in which the respondent is the same as in CA No. 7165 of 2000, the Tribunal following its earlier decision dated 29-6-2000 (which is impugned in CA No. 7165 of 2000) allowed the appeal preferred by the respondent and held that the Revenue had failed to discharge the burden of showing that the manufacture had taken place by the process of cold rolling of steel strips from hot-rolled strips. However, it remitted the matter to the Assistant Commissioner to decide the question as to whether it had not passed on the incidence of duty to the customers.

5. In CAs Nos. 439-42 of 2002 the Tribunal following its earlier decision in the case of Steel Strips Ltd. (impugned in CA No. 7165 of 2000) held that cold-rolled strips produced out of duty-paid hot-rolled steel strips do not undergo a process of manufacture and hence are not chargeable to excise duty.

6. We may at the threshold observe that while in CA No. 7165 of 2000 and CAs Nos. 7706-11 of 2002 the dispute arose when the respondent filed applications for refund of excess excise duty paid, in CAs Nos. 439-42 of 2002 the question arose in the context of a show-cause notice issued to the respondent alleging clandestine removal of cold-rolled steel strips produced out of duty-paid hot-rolled steel strips without payment of duty. The Commissioner found that there had been clandestine removal of cold-rolled strips without payment of excise duty and, therefore, ordered recovery of duty, interest, penalty etc. The Tribunal on appeal set aside the order of the Commissioner, Central Excise (Adjudication), Delhi holding that since no duty was payable on cold-rolled strips, there was no evasion of excise duty.

7. The representative facts may be taken from CA No. 7165 of 2000.

8. M/s Steel Strips Ltd., the respondent herein, held Central excise registration for the manufacture of cold-rolled steel strips. It had paid Central excise duty on cold-rolled steel strips made from hot-rolled steel strips between the period 19-6-1996 to 29-6-1996 amounting to Rs 42,07,977. It filed an application for refund of the excise duty so paid on cold-rolled steel strips relying upon the decision of this Court in its own case reported in CCE v. Steel Strips Ltd. (1995) 4 SCC 241, (1995) 77 ELT 248 According to the respondent this Court held in the aforesaid decision that hot-rolled strips upon which excise duty had admittedly been paid did not undergo the process of manufacture at the hands of the assessee which resulted in the production of cold-rolled strips and, therefore, no excise duty was payable on such cold-rolled strips. Consequently, it claimed refund of the excise duty paid on cold-rolled strips. The application for refund was examined by the Department and ultimately a show-cause notice was issued by the Assistant Commissioner, Central Excise, Division Patiala, on 14-8-1996 calling upon the respondent to show cause why the refund application should not be rejected for the reasons stated in the notice. In the show-cause notice it was stated that the judgment of the Supreme Court referred to in the application for refund related to the period prior to 28-2-1986 when the old Central excise tariff was applicable which classified under Tariff Item 26-AA all kinds of strips without making any distinction between cold-rolled and hot-rolled strips. The tariff had undergone a change and the Central excise tariff as applicable after 28-2-1986 classified hot-rolled strips and cold-rolled strips separately as they were distinguishable from each other. Separate sub-headings have been provided and while hot-rolled strips come under Sub-Heading 7211.52, cold-rolled strips come under Sub-Heading 7211.51 The notice further stated that the respondent had passed on the burden of excise duty to the buyers and, therefore, under Section 11-B of the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944 (hereinafter referred to as the Act), the respondent was required to prove beyond doubt that the burden of excise duty had not been passed on to the buyers so as to entitle it to claim refund.

9. In its reply dated 24-8-1996 the respondent denied that the excise duty had not been correctly paid and, therefore, they were not entitled to claim refund. They reiterated their claim for refund and prayed for further time to furnish a detailed explanation. However, it appears from the order of the Assistant Commissioner that no further explanation was furnished by the respondent.

10. The Assistant Commissioner by order dated 10-1-1997 rejected the claim of the respondent following an order passed by the Assistant Commissioner, Central Excise, Division Patiala in a case of the respondent. A similar claim for refund on the same ground was rejected after considering the judgment of the Supreme Court on which reliance was placed by the respondent. The order of the Assistant Commissioner on which reliance had been placed has been annexed as Annexure P-III. He held that on account of the amendment of the Central excise tariff with effect from 28-2-1986, hot-rolled strips and cold-rolled strips must be treated as two separate items which have been dealt with separately in the tariff. Under the old tariff all strips were classified under Tariff Item 26-AA, but that the legal position having changed after the amendment of the tariff, the two manufactured commodities were distinguishable and different from each other being covered by two separate sub-headings and, therefore, excise duty was payable on the cold-rolled strips as well as on hot-rolled strips. It was further held in the facts of that case that since the claimant had passed on the burden of excise duty to the buyers, it was not entitled to claim refund under Section 11-B of the Act. The Assistant Commissioner, therefore, held that the judgment of the Supreme Court, which was in respect of the period prior to 28-2-1986 was not applicable to the claim for refund which pertained to the period after the amendment of the tariff. In the said order the Assistant Commissioner also observed that cold-rolled strips are a different product from hot-rolled strips. There is difference in price on account of the fact that properties of the material completely get changed after cold rolling. It observed:

“It is evident from the examination of manufacturing process of cold-rolled strips and their use. Cold-rolled strips are being manufactured out of hot-rolled strips by the process as mentioned below.”

11. The Assistant Commissioner then went on to describe the process of manufacture and the use to which cold-rolled strips are put. He came to the conclusion that cold-rolled strips are an entirely different commodity from hot-rolled strips and that is why different sub-headings were provided in the Central excise tariff for hot-rolled strips and cold-rolled strips.

12. It is not clear from the order of the Assistant Commissioner whether any evidence was produced by the respondent in that case regarding the process of manufacturing undertaken by the claimant, or whether the observations made in the order were based on authoritative publications or on his personal knowledge.

13. The respondent preferred an appeal before the Commissioner of Excise (Appeals). The said appeal was dismissed by the Commissioner who fully agreed with the reasoning of the Assistant Commissioner and also held that the judgment of the Supreme Court referred to in the claim application was not relevant in view of the introduction of the new tariff which classified separately hot-rolled and cold-rolled strips. It also agreed with the finding of the Assistant Commissioner that the application for refund deserved to be rejected also on the ground of unjust enrichment as the burden of duty had been passed on to the buyers.

14. We may observe that though the Commissioner of Excise (Appeals) rejected the claim also on the ground of the respondent having passed on the burden of duty to the buyers, the Assistant Commissioner did not record any finding in this case on that question, having regard to the provisions of Section 11-B of the Act.

15. The respondent preferred an appeal before the Tribunal impugning the order passed by the Commissioner of Excise (Appeals). Relying upon the judgment of this Court in CCE v. Steel Strips Ltd. (1995) 4 SCC 241, (1995) 77 ELT 248 the Tribunal held that the Department was required to adduce evidence that the process undertaken by the respondent resulting in the production of cold-rolled steel strips from hot-rolled strips amounted to manufacture. No evidence had been brought on record to show that such process amounted to manufacture giving rise to duty liability. It further held that the mere fact that hot-rolled steel strips and cold-rolled strips fall under two different sub-headings under the same chapter was not sufficient to conclude that the process of cold rolling from hot-rolled strips amounted to manufacture. The burden was cast upon the Revenue to show that the manufacture had taken place but the Department had failed to discharge that burden. On these findings the Tribunal held that the refund claim was admissible on merits. However, it remitted the matter to the Assistant Commissioner to enable the respondent to satisfy him that they had not passed on the burden of duty to their customers as required by Section 11-B of the Act.

16. In the connected appeals this order of the Tribunal has been noticed and followed.

17. Learned counsel for the appellant submitted before us that the fact that hot-rolled strips and cold-rolled strips were classified under two distinct sub-headings under the amended tariff was itself sufficient to hold that they were two distinct excisable commodities. In any event, it was submitted, the Assistant Commissioner considered the material on record and came to the conclusion that the respondent undertook the process of manufacture which resulted in the manufacture of cold-rolled strips, a new excisable commodity, from hot-rolled strips, also an excisable commodity. Therefore, the Tribunal erred in holding that the Department had failed to discharge the burden cast upon it to establish that a new excisable commodity was the result of the process of manufacture undertaken by the respondents.

18. On the other hand learned counsel for the respondents submitted that there was no material whatsoever on record to establish that the respondents undertook a process of manufacture, which resulted in the manufacture of another excisable commodity. The Department had not produced any evidence in this regard and the observations made by the Assistant Commissioner in his order are based either upon his own knowledge or knowledge derived from textbooks or publications, which were not relevant. Relying upon the earlier decision in Steel Strips (1995) 4 SCC 241, (1995) 77 ELT 248 it was submitted that in a case where the Excise Authorities contend that an article is the result of the process of manufacture and it is commercially distinct and known as such, it is for the Excise Authorities to lay evidence in this behalf before the first adjudicating authority regardless of the fact that he is an officer of the Excise Department. There should, ordinarily, be no difficulty in establishing that the article is the result of a process of manufacture; in the event of difficulty, it would be open to the Excise Authorities to seek a direction requiring the assessee to set out in writing what it does to obtain the article. Failure to lay the requisite evidence cannot be made up by reference to authoritative publications.

19. In the instant case we find that while in the order of the Assistant Commissioner there is a reference to a process of manufacture undertaken by the respondents and there is also some discussion about the manner in which the manufacture of cold-rolled strips takes place, but the order is not clear as to whether any evidence was led by the Department to satisfy the adjudicating authority on this issue. The Tribunal on the other hand has observed that no evidence has been brought on record to show that such process amounted to manufacture so as to give rise to duty liability. In this state of the record placed before us, it is not possible for this Court to express its considered opinion on this issue and it has, therefore, become necessary to remit this matter for fresh consideration on the basis of the material on record.

20. Before us, it was also contended on behalf of the respondents that the show-cause notice issued to the respondents was defective inasmuch as the show-cause notice, apart from referring to the fact that the two items were covered by two separate and distinct sub-headings, did not state that the process undertaken by the respondents resulted in the manufacture of a new product. Since that was not stated in the show-cause notice, the Department cannot be permitted to go beyond the facts stated in the show-cause notice. This aspect of the matter has also not been considered by the authorities under the Act.

21. It was then contended by the respondents before us that reliance upon two distinct sub-headings under the amended excise tariff itself was not conclusive and good enough to hold that there was manufacture of cold-rolled strips by the respondents. Learned counsel for the respondents placed reliance on the following decisions:

Hyderabad Industries Ltd. v. Union of India (1999) 5 SCC 15, (1999) 108 ELT 321,
Hyderabad Industries Ltd. v. Union of India (1995) 5 SCC 338, (1995) 78 ELT 641, and
Prabhat Sound Studios v. CCE (1997) 10 SCC 543, (1996) 88 ELT 635.

22. In view of these decisions it is submitted that the observations made in Lal Woollen & Silk Mills (P) Ltd. v. CCE (1999) 4 SCC 466 towards the end of para 1 in the said decision are neither correct nor conclusive. This question is no longer res integra, as this Court has in CCE v. Markfed Vanaspati & Allied Industries (2003) 4 SCC 184 upheld the contention urged on behalf of the respondents. In the aforesaid judgment this Court, after noticing the observations in Lal Woollen & Silk Mills (P) Ltd. (1999) 4 SCC 466 held:

“5. However, it appears to us that the observations made in this authority are ‘per incuriam’. In so observing, the decision of a larger Bench of this Court in the case of Union of India v. Indian Aluminium Co. Ltd. 1995 Supp (2) SCC 465 has not been noticed or considered. In this case an argument that a goods becomes excisable because it is covered by tariff entry, has been negatived. In the case of BPL Pharmaceuticals Ltd. v. CCE 1995 Supp (3) SCC 1 it has also been held that merely because there is a change in the tariff item the goods does not become excisable. Subsequently in a judgment dated 13-2-2003 in Cadila Laboratories (P) Ltd. v. CCE (2003) 4 SCC 12 it has been held that merely because an item falls in a tariff entry, it does not become excisable unless there is manufacture and the goods is marketable. In Lal Woollen & Silk Mills case (1999) 4 SCC 466 it has not been held that the twin tests of manufacture and marketability are not to apply. It is not possible to accept the contention that merely because an item falls in a tariff entry it must be deemed that there is manufacture. The law still remains that the burden to prove that there is manufacture and that what is manufactured is marketable is on the Revenue. In this case no new evidence is placed to show that there is manufacture. ‘Spent earth’ was ‘earth’ on which duty has been paid. It remains earth even after the processing. Thus if duty was to be levied on it again, it would amount to levying double duty on the same product.”

23. In the result these appeals are disposed of by remitting to the Tribunal in Civil Appeal No. 7165 of 2000 and Civil Appeals Nos. 7706-11 of 2002, and to the Commissioner of Excise (Appeals) in Civil Appeals Nos. 439-42 of 2002 to consider and record findings on the following questions and dispose of the matters before them in accordance with law. The consideration of these questions shall be on the basis of the material on record, and no further evidence shall be allowed to be adduced:

1. Whether the Excise Authorities have led any evidence before the first adjudicating authority on the question as to whether cold-rolled strips are the result of a process of manufacture undertaken by the respondents, or whether the material referred to in the order of the Assistant Commissioner is based upon his own personal knowledge or is based on authoritative publications. The burden is on the Department to prove that the process of manufacture resulted in emergence of a commercially distinct commodity.
2. Whether the show-cause notice issued to the respondents was defective inasmuch as it did not state, apart from referring to the two sub-headings under the amended Central excise tariff, that there was manufacture of a new product, namely, cold-rolled strips from hot-rolled strips.
3. In Civil Appeals Nos. 7165 of 2000 and 7706-11 of 2002 the question whether the respondent has passed on the duty of excise to its buyers is remitted to the Assistant Commissioner concerned for his consideration and finding having regard to the provisions of Section 11-B of the Act.

24. In the appeals in which we have remitted the matters to the Assistant Commissioner to consider the question as to whether the respondents have passed on the burden of duty of excise to their buyers, which question has to be considered in the light of the provisions of Section 11-B of the Act, it is only appropriate that the Assistant Commissioner concerned should first record a finding on that question. If the finding is against the respondents, their claim applications shall have to be rejected. This, of course, is subject to the order that may be passed in appeal by the Appellate Authority and ultimately by the Tribunal. Only if it is ultimately found that the respondents have not passed on the burden of excise duty to their buyers, the other questions which we have remitted to the Tribunal may require consideration. We, therefore, direct that in the first instance those appeals shall stand remitted to the Assistant Commissioners concerned to hear the parties and decide only the question of unjust enrichment having regard to the provisions of Section 11-B of the Act. It will be open to the respondents to challenge the finding if it goes against them before the Appellate Authority and/or before the Tribunal. If no appeal is preferred against an adverse finding by the Assistant Commissioner, that will be an end of the matter and no further consideration by the Tribunal will be necessary. However, if it is ultimately found that the respondents have not passed on the burden of excise duty to their buyers then the Tribunal will consider the other questions, which we have remitted to it for its consideration and the Tribunal shall thereafter dispose of the matters in accordance with law. To enable the Tribunal/Commissioner to pass fresh orders, we set aside the impugned judgments and orders of the Tribunal in all the appeals, as also the order of the Commissioner in Civil Appeals Nos. 439-42 of 2002.

25. These appeals are disposed of accordingly. There shall be no order as to costs.