Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Union Of India And Another v. V.N Bhat .

Supreme Court Of India
Oct 16, 2003
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent joined the Ministry of Defence in 1962 as a Lower Division Clerk (LDC). On his own request he was transferred to the Postal Department and, by order dated 26-4-1982, joined the office of the Chief Postmaster General on 24-5-1982, taking seniority at the bottom of the new gradation list.

On 17-12-1983 the Postal Department introduced the “One Time-Bound Promotion Scheme” and the “Biennial Cadre Review (BCR) Scheme” to alleviate stagnation among employees who had completed 16 and 26 years of service, respectively. The respondent’s LDC post was accordingly converted into that of Postal Assistant and he was granted the time-bound promotion benefit.

A subsequent clarification dated 8-6-1994 from the Postal Directorate stated that the schemes applied only to officials who had rendered 16/26 years in the Postal Department itself. Relying on this clarification, the Department withdrew the benefit and reverted the respondent to his earlier position.

Challenging the withdrawal, the respondent filed an Original Application before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Chandigarh Bench, on 15-11-1996. The CAT set aside the reversion order and restored his promotion. The Union of India appealed to the Supreme Court. Because identical questions of fact and law arose in connected matters, the Court disposed of them by this common order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent’s 18 years of service rendered in the Ministry of Defence can be counted towards the 16-/26-year qualifying period stipulated under the One Time-Bound Promotion Scheme/BCR Scheme in the Postal Department.
  2. Consequently, whether the Postal Department was justified in withdrawing the promotion benefit granted to the respondent.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments (Union of India)

  • The schemes are expressly limited to officials who have completed 16 or 26 years in the Postal Department; the respondent had completed only 12 years there, hence he was ineligible.
  • Transfer on request entails acceptance of loss of seniority in the transferee department, and by implication the respondent cannot claim promotional benefits based on past service elsewhere.

Respondent’s Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
A.P. State Electricity Board v. R. Parthasarathi (1998) 9 SCC 425 Past service counts for eligibility to promotional benefits even after transfer on request. Cited to show that loss of seniority does not erase experience for promotion purposes.
Scientific Advisor to Raksha Mantri v. V. M. Joseph (1998) 5 SCC 305 Employees transferred on request retain benefit of prior service for determining eligibility. Relied upon as supportive authority for counting earlier service.
Renu Mullick v. Union of India (1994) 1 SCC 373 Past service is reckonable for time-bound promotions despite placement at bottom of seniority list. Invoked to reinforce that experience, not seniority, triggers the scheme.
Dwijen Chandra Sarkar v. Union of India (1999) 2 SCC 119 Even transferees on request are entitled to count prior service for promotional schemes; words “except seniority” in transfer orders do not bar such benefit. Treated as directly governing precedent; Court followed it to dismiss the present appeals.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court identified Dwijen Chandra Sarkar as a binding authority that squarely covers the controversy. In that case, the Court had interpreted similar transfer conditions and promotional schemes to hold that:

  • A transferee loses only seniority, not the advantage of earlier service for purposes of time-bound promotion.
  • The phrase “except seniority” in transfer orders ensures that existing employees’ seniority remains undisturbed, but does not deprive the transferee of counting prior service.

Applying this rationale, the Court held that the respondent’s 18 years in the Ministry of Defence must be added to his Postal Department service when computing eligibility under the One Time-Bound Promotion/BCR Schemes. Because the legal issue had already been conclusively settled, the Court found no merit in the Union’s appeal.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS DISMISSED. The Supreme Court upheld the CAT’s order restoring the respondent’s time-bound promotion and declined to award costs.

Implications: The decision reaffirms that, notwithstanding a transfer on request, an employee’s previous departmental service counts toward qualifying periods for beneficial, anti-stagnation schemes. The ruling applies existing precedent rather than establishing a new one, but it effectively settles similar disputes within the Postal Department.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Leave granted in SLP (C) No. 21749 of 1997.

2. As identical questions of fact and law being involved in these appeals, we, therefore, propose to dispose of these matters by this common order. However, for appreciating the controversy, we are referring the facts asserted in Civil Appeal No. 8375 of 1997.

3. The respondent was previously working as a Lower Division Clerk in the Ministry of Defence since the year 1962. He sought transfer from the Ministry of Defence to the Office of the Chief Postmaster General. The Directorate, by an order dated 26-4-1982, allowed the aforesaid transfer, as a result of which the respondent joined the service in the Postal Department on 24-5-1982 as a Lower Division Clerk. He took the seniority at the bottom of the gradation list as per the departmental rules. On 17-12-1983, the appellants herein introduced the Time-Bound Promotion Scheme in the operative cadres in the Post and Telegraph Department, for providing relief to the employees stagnating in the lower grades by improving their promotional avenues. The Postal Department decided to extend “One Time-Bound Promotion Scheme” and “BCR Scheme” for those employees who have rendered 16 years and 26 years of service as Postal Assistants respectively. These Schemes were applicable to the administrative staff working in the Circle Office and to the office in which the respondent was working by converting the posts of Lower Division Clerks into Postal Assistants. The respondent was given the benefit of the said Scheme and his post was converted to that of Postal Assistant. Subsequently, on an enquiry from the Postal Directorate by the Department of Posts, a clarification was received on 8-6-1994, wherein it was stated that these Schemes will be operative only in regard to the officials who have rendered service of 16/26 years in the Postal Department. As per this clarification, the benefit under the BCR Scheme given to the respondent was withdrawn and he was reverted to the post earlier held by him. It is under such circumstances, the respondent on 15-11-1996, filed an original application before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench, challenging his withdrawal of one time-bound promotion. The Central Administrative Tribunal, by the impugned order allowed the application and set aside the order of withdrawal of one time-bound promotion given to the respondent. It is against the said order and judgment of the Tribunal, the Union of India is in appeal before us.

4. The submission of the learned counsel for the appellants in short is that having regard to the admitted fact that the respondent herein has not completed 16/26 years in the postal service, the One Time-Bound Promotion Scheme or BCR Scheme is not applicable in his case. The fact that the respondent herein had completed 18 years of service in the Ministry of Defence is not disputed. The question which, therefore, arises for consideration is as to whether the period of service rendered by the respondent in the Ministry of Defence should be wiped off for all purposes. The well-settled principle of law that even in the case where the transfer has been allowed on request, the employee concerned merely loses his seniority, but the same by itself would not lead to a conclusion that he should be deprived of the other benefits including his experience and eligibility for promotion. In terms of the Schemes aforementioned, promotion is to be granted for avoiding stagnation only within the said parties. The said Schemes have been framed because they are beneficial ones and are thus required to be implemented. The Scheme merely perused that any person having rendered 16/26 years of service without obtaining any promotion could be entitled to the benefit therefor. It is, therefore, not a case where promotion to the higher post is to be made only on the basis of seniority. Even in a case where the promotion is to be made on selection basis, the employee concerned, even if he be placed at the bottom of the seniority list in terms of the order of transfer based in his favour, he cannot be deprived of being considered for promotion to the next higher post if he is eligible therefor. This aspect of the matter is clearly covered by the three decisions of this Court, namely, A.P SEB v. R. Parthasarathi (1998) 9 SCC 425, Scientific Advisor to Raksha Mantri v. V.M Joseph (1998) 5 SCC 305 and Renu Mullick v. Union of India (1994) 1 SCC 373, (1994) 26 ATC 602.

5. The aforementioned decisions have been followed by this Court in Dwijen Chandra Sarkar v. Union of India (1999) 2 SCC 119 in the following paras:

“14. The words ‘except seniority’ in the 1983 circular, in our view, mean that such a benefit of a higher grade given to the transferees will in no way affect the seniority of employees in the P&T Department when the turn of the P&T employees comes up for promotion to a higher category or post. The said words ‘except seniority’ are intended to see that the said persons who have come from another Department on transfer do not upset the seniority in the transferee Department. Granting them higher grade under the Scheme for time-bound promotion does not, therefore, offend the condition imposed in the transfer order. We are, therefore, of the view that the appellants are entitled to the higher grade from the date on which they have completed 16 years and the said period is to be computed on the basis of their total service both in the Rehabilitation Department and the P&T Department.
***
17. On the facts of the present case and especially in view of the aforesaid decisions, we are of the view that when the transfer is in public interest and not on request, the two employees transferred cannot be in a worse position than those in the above rulings who have been transferred on request and who in those cases accepted that their names could appear at the bottom of the seniority list. Even in cases relating to request transfers, this Court has held, as seen above, that the past service will count for eligibility for certain purposes though it may not count for seniority.”

6. As the contention raised by the appellants herein is squarely covered by this Court in Dwijen Chandra Sarkar (1999) 2 SCC 119 we do not find any merit in these appeals. They are, accordingly, dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.