Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

P.C Kesavan Kuttynayar v. Harish Bhalla And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 23, 2003
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The present order arises out of pending appeals in which the learned amicus curiae was invited to seek directions from the Supreme Court on the functioning of an Ad hoc Committee established by the Court on 20 November 2002 to supervise the Medical Council of India (MCI). The immediate trigger for the interlocutory applications (IAs) is the allegation—made by Senior Counsel Mr. Harish N. Salve (amicus) and Mr. K.K. Venugopal for the MCI—that the Central Government has been issuing permissions to medical colleges to increase student intake or renew permissions in violation of Section 10-A of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 and the Regulations framed thereunder, thereby bypassing the MCI.

The Court had earlier empowered any member of the Ad hoc Committee to approach it for directions if practical or legal difficulties arose. Acting on this liberty, the amicus has sought the present directions. The matter also encompasses Writ Petition (Civil) No. 317 of 2000, wherein the Attorney General proposed amendments to the MCI’s Code of Ethics—an issue the Court has taken note of but adjourned for four weeks.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Central Government can grant or renew permissions for increased student intake in medical colleges without adhering to the procedure prescribed in Section 10-A of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 and without obtaining recommendations from the Medical Council of India.
  2. Whether permissions already granted by the Central Government in August 2003 are valid when prima facie the concerned colleges were not compliant with statutory and regulatory requirements.
  3. What interim measures are necessary to ensure compliance with the Act, including inspections by the MCI and restraint on further governmental permissions.
  4. In W.P.(C) No. 317 of 2000, whether the suggested clauses 8.7 and 8.8 should be incorporated into the MCI Code of Ethics to expedite disciplinary proceedings against delinquent physicians.

Arguments of the Parties

Medical Council of India & Amicus Curiae

  • The Central Government has issued several orders increasing student strength or renewing permissions without following the mandatory procedure under Section 10-A, thereby bypassing the MCI.
  • Such permissions ignore serious deficiencies found during MCI inspections—for example, Government Medical College, Anantapur admitted students and increased seats without renewed permission, triggering potential action under Section 10-B.
  • Existing Supreme Court precedent requires strict adherence to statutory provisions to protect the quality of medical education and public health.

Union of India

  • Contends that its actions fall within the powers conferred by Section 10-A(iv) of the Act.
  • Maintains that statutory requirements have not been bypassed and that MCI recommendations were either considered or not mandatory in the circumstances.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
A.P. Christians Medical Educational Society v. Govt. of A.P., (1986) 2 SCC 667 Court cannot direct violation of statutory provisions or university regulations; upholds rule of law. Cited to emphasise that permissions cannot contravene Section 10-A and MCI Regulations.
State of Punjab v. Renuka Singla, (1994) 1 SCC 175 Courts should not issue directions that require authorities to breach statutory admission limits. Relied on to caution against compassionate or ad-hoc seat increases that violate the Act.
Medical Council of India v. State of Karnataka, (1998) 6 SCC 131 Insists on adequate infrastructure and compliance to prevent “half-baked” medical professionals. Used to justify strict scrutiny of colleges’ facilities before any seat enhancement.
K.S. Bhoir v. State of Maharashtra, (2001) 10 SCC 264 Compliance with Act and Regulations is mandatory; Central Government cannot grant permissions absent such compliance. Referenced to underline that even one-time capacity increases require a scheme approved under Section 10-A.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed the statutory scheme of Section 10-A and prior case law that mandates strict compliance with regulatory standards in medical education. It noted multiple letters and inspection reports showing deficiencies in colleges that nevertheless received Central Government permissions. Although the Union argued that Section 10-A(iv) empowered it to act, the Court found prima facie that the Government lacks authority to issue such permissions where colleges are non-compliant.

Balancing the immediate academic interests of students already admitted, the Court refrained from cancelling the permissions outright. Instead, it ordered:

  • The MCI must conduct fresh inspections of all colleges that received the impugned permissions in August 2003 and report within four weeks.
  • The Central Government shall not grant any further permissions without adhering strictly to the procedure in Sections 10-A(i), (ii), (iii) and (vii).
  • Pending a DGHS inquiry against Dr. Rangabashyam is stayed.

Regarding W.P.(C) No. 317 of 2000, the Court recorded the Attorney General’s suggested amendments (clauses 8.7 and 8.8) to the MCI Code of Ethics and directed the Council to initiate appropriate statutory steps.

Holding and Implications

INTERIM DIRECTIONS ISSUED; MATTER ADJOURNED FOR FOUR WEEKS.

Immediate consequences include mandatory MCI inspections of the affected medical colleges and a moratorium on further Central Government permissions until statutory procedures are followed. The order reinforces existing jurisprudence that statutory safeguards in medical education are non-negotiable, but sets no new precedent beyond re-affirming strict compliance with Section 10-A. The stay on the DGHS inquiry is temporary, and ethical code amendments remain under consideration.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Heard the learned amicus curiae and the counsel for the parties.

2. In pending appeals, the learned amicus curiae is required to approach this Court for appropriate directions including the manner of working of the Ad hoc Committee in the matter of recognition, renewal including grant of permission in respect of medical colleges.

3. The reason for seeking this relief is, as contended by the Senior Counsel Mr Salve and Mr Venugopal, that for some reason the Central Government granted permission to increase the strength of students in medical colleges in violation of Section 10-A of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) and the Regulations framed by the Medical Council of India.

4. This Ad hoc Committee was appointed by this Court's order dated 20-11-2002. Relevant part of this order is as under:

“4. For enhancing the confidence of the people in the functioning of the Medical Council of India, which is having wide powers under the Medical Council Act, 1956, we order accordingly. We appoint a Committee of four eminent doctors, namely, Dr N. Rangabashyam of Chennai, Prof. P.N Tandon of New Delhi, Dr S.K Bhansali of Mumbai and Dr (Mrs) S. Kantha of Bangalore, as members of Ad hoc Committee to assist and monitor the work of the Medical Council of India. The Ad hoc Committee would work harmoniously and in full cooperation with the Executive Committee of the Council. The Committee would associate itself particularly in selection and appointment of Inspectors and scrutinize their reports and make recommendations for grant of recognition to the medical college.
5. If any member of the Ad hoc Committee in course of working finds any practical or legal difficulty, it would be open for him/them to approach this Court for appropriate orders through learned Senior Counsel Mr Harish N. Salve (amicus curiae). It would also be open to them to make recommendations, how the functioning of the Executive Committee can be made more effective and prompt.”

5. Thereafter, the Ad hoc Committee started its work in harmony with the Executive Committee of the Medical Council of India overseeing, inter alia, the process of inspection of colleges and dealing with the recommendation to be made for the recognition/grant of permission to such colleges.

6. The contention which is raised in the present IAs is with regard to the exercise of power by the Central Government by bypassing MCI as well as the provisions of Section 10-A of the Act.

7. This Court has repeatedly considered the provisions of the Act and has held that statutory provisions and rules prescribed for medical education should be strictly adhered to. As early as in the case of A.P Christians Medical Educational Society v. Govt. of A.P (1986) 2 SCC 667, the Court observed thus:

“Any direction of the nature sought by Shri Venugopal would be in clear transgression of the provisions of the University Act and the regulations of the University. We cannot by our fiat direct the University to disobey the statute to which it owes its existence and the regulations made by the University itself. We cannot imagine anything more destructive of the rule of law than a direction by the court to disobey the laws.”
(emphasis supplied)

8. Thereafter, in 1994 again, this Court considered this aspect in State of Punjab v. Renuka Singla (1994) 1 SCC 175 and held thus:

The High Courts or the Supreme Court cannot be generous or liberal in issuing such directions which in substance amount to directing the authorities concerned to violate their own statutory rules and regulations, in respect of admissions of students. Technical education, including medical education, requires infrastructure to cope with the requirement of giving proper education to the students, who are admitted. Taking into consideration the infrastructure, equipment, staff, the limit of the number of admissions is fixed either by the Medical Council of India or Dental Council of India. The High Court cannot disturb that balance between the capacity of the institution and number of admissions, on ‘compassionate ground’. The High Courts should be conscious of the fact that in this process they are affecting the education of the students who have already been admitted, against the fixed seats, after a very tough competitive examination. There does not appear to be any justification on the part of the High Court, in the present case, to direct admission of Respondent 1 on ‘compassionate ground’ and to issue a fiat to create an additional seat which amounts to a direction to violate Section 10-A and Section 10-B(3) of the Dentists Act.

9. The reason for taking this much caution is well reflected in the decision rendered by this Court in Medical Council of India v. State of Karnataka (1998) 6 SCC 131 wherein the Court held as under:

“29. A medical student requires gruelling study and that can be done only if proper facilities are available in a medical college and the hospital attached to it has to be well equipped and the teaching faculty and doctors have to be competent enough that when a medical student comes out, he is perfect in the science of treatment of human beings and is not found wanting in any way. The country does not want half-baked medical professionals coming out of medical colleges when they did not have full facilities of teaching and were not exposed to the patients and their ailments during the course of their study.”
(emphasis supplied)

10. This case was referred to with approval in the case of K.S Bhoir v. State of Maharashtra (2001) 10 SCC 264. The Court also held that the compliance with the requirements under the Act and the Regulations being mandatory, in the absence of their compliance, no permission could be granted by the Central Government for the increase in admission capacity in any course in any medical college. The Court further held that for one-time increase in admission capacity the colleges should have submitted the scheme prepared in accordance with the Act and the Regulations to the Central Government.

11. Despite the aforesaid law, it is contended by the learned Senior Counsel Mr Venugopal for the Medical Council as well as by the learned Amicus Curiae Mr Salve that the Central Government bypassed the Medical Council and the Act and had issued various orders granting permission to increase the strength of the students in some colleges or renewal of permission to the medical colleges. As against this, Mr Rakesh Dwivedi, learned Senior Counsel for the Union of India submitted that the Central Government has neither bypassed the Medical Council nor the statutory requirements for grant of permission to increase the strength of the students in the existing medical colleges/renewal of permission for the colleges.

12. No doubt, deciding the question whether the permission granted by the Central Government is without complying with the statutory requirement and thus violative of Sections 10-A and 10-B of the Act requires consideration.

13. However, prima facie, there appears to be substance in what is contended by the learned Senior Counsel for the Medical Council as well as amicus curiae that on 23-1-2003, the Medical Council of India had brought the following to the notice of the Central Government:

“Sir,
I am directed to inform you that inspection for renewal of permission for admission of third batch of students for the academic session 2002-03 at Government Medical College, Anantapur was carried out by the Council Inspectors on 30-7-2002 and 31-7-2002 and the inspection report was considered by the Executive Committee at its meeting held on 5-8-2002. On going through the inspection report the Committee observed that 34 of the faculty members i.e 6 Professors, 16 Readers and 12 Assistant Professors joined the institution on 27-7-2002 i.e 3 days before the inspection after transfer from other Government Medical Colleges of the State.
In view of the above and other deficiencies pointed out in the inspection report, the Committee decided to defer the consideration of the matter for obtaining the information from the Director, Medical Education, Government of Andhra Pradesh and college authorities as to how the resultant vacancies created with the transfer of teachers from the Government Medical Colleges to this College have been filled up.
On receipt of the above clarification and the compliance on rectification of the deficiencies from the Director, Government of Andhra Pradesh, the matter was again placed before the Executive Committee at its meeting held on 31-10-2002 where it was decided to verify the same by way of an inspection. Inspection to verify the compliance was carried out by the Council Inspectors on 2-1-2003 and 3-1-2003 and the compliance verification inspection report was considered by the Executive Committee at its meeting held on 9-1-2003 where the members of the Ad hoc Committee appointed as per the Hon'ble Supreme Court order dated 20-11-2002 were also present. The decision taken by the Executive Committee is recorded as under for your information and necessary action:
‘The Executive Committee on a perusal of the compliance verification report (2-1-2003 and 3-1-2003) of Government Medical College, Anantapur, noted that the College has already admitted students against the academic session 2002-03 (third batch) without getting the permission renewed by the Central Government as under:
(a) 99 students including 14 NRI students against the session 2002-03.
(b) 14 NRI students of the batch 2000-01 against this session (total 113 students).
Thus the College has not only admitted students against the said session without getting the permission renewed by the Central Government but has also increased the seats from 100 to 113 which calls for action under Section 10-B of the IMC Act, 1956.’
The Executive Committee, therefore, decided to initiate action under Section 10-B of the IMC Act, 1956 against the admissions made by the college authorities for the academic session 2002-03 without getting the permission renewed by the Central Government for which the institution be directed to send a meritwise list to the Council immediately. The Committee also decided that the Central Government may be requested to take up the matter with the Secretary (Medical Education) and Director, Medical Education, Government of Andhra Pradesh to take steps to rectify the violations immediately.
Since the College had already admitted students for the academic session 2002-03, the Committee decided not to consider the inspection report carried out for renewal of permission for admission of third batch of students at Government Medical College, Anantapur.”

14. Despite this, it appears that by order dated 21-8-2003, the Director, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare issued the following order:

“The Secretary,
Health, Medical and Family Welfare Department,
Government of Andhra Pradesh,
Hyderabad.
Sub: Increase in seats in Government Medical Colleges at Kurnool and Warangal during the academic year 2003-04 — renewal of permission — regarding.
Madam,
I am directed to refer to your Letter No. 11964.E1/2001-57 dated 4-8-2003 on the subject cited above and to say that it has been decided as a one-time measure to allow admission of fresh batches of students in the following medical colleges against increased intake during the academic year 2003-04:
1. Kurnool Medical College, Kurnool — from 130 to 150 seats.
2. Kakatiya Medical College, Warangal — from 100 to 150 seats.
This renewal of permission is subject to the condition of implementation of neutralization formula already accepted by the State Government vide their letter dated 18-6-2001 (copy enclosed) and conveyed in this Department's letter of even number dated 12-7-2001 (copy enclosed). However, the State Government shall ensure compliance with all the requirements under the MCI Regulations and any deficiencies pointed out by the Medical Council of India in respect of the above medical colleges. This permission is further subject to the condition that the Government of Andhra Pradesh shall sort out the pending issues of admissions made in these colleges during the year 2002-03 with the Medical Council of India.”

15. Similar orders are produced on record to indicate that the recommendations of the Medical Council were not called for.

16. As against this, it has been pointed out by Mr Rakesh Dwivedi, learned Senior Counsel that under Section 10-A(iv) the Central Government has such powers.

17. Prima facie, we do not think that the Central Government has the power to issue such permission when the college is not complying with the requirements of the Regulations framed by the Medical Council of India or the requirements of the Act. As the permission is already granted and probably, it appears that the colleges might have given admissions on the basis of the so-called increase in the strength/renewal of permission for a college, we direct the Medical Council of India to carry out further inspection to find out whether there is compliance with the requirement of the Act and the Rules in all the colleges where increase of strength/renewal of permission for a college is permitted by the Central Government by its various orders issued in August 2003. The Medical Council of India is to carry out the inspection within a period of four weeks.

18. In the meantime, the Central Government is directed not to grant any further permission without following the procedure prescribed under Sections 10-A(i), (ii), (iii) and (vii).

19. For the time being, the DGHS inquiry as directed by the Central Government against Dr Rangabashyam is stayed. However, it would be open to the aggrieved person to take appropriate action before an appropriate forum, if called for.

20. Stand over for four weeks.

Writ Petition (C) No. 317 of 2000

21. Heard the learned counsel for the parties.

22. As suggested by the learned Attorney General, the following provisions could be added in the Code of Ethics prescribed by the Medical Council of India:

“8.7 Where either on a request or otherwise the Medical Council of India is informed that any complaint against a delinquent physician has not been decided by a State Medical Council within a period of six months from the date of receipt of complaint by it and further, MCI has reason to believe that there is no justifiable reason for not deciding the complaint within the said prescribed period, the Medical Council of India may—
(i) impress upon the State Medical Council concerned to conclude and decide the complaint within a time-bound schedule;
(ii) may decide to withdraw the said complaint pending with the State Medical Council concerned straight away or after the expiry of the period which had been stipulated by MCI in accordance with para (i) above to itself and refer the same to the Ethics Committee of the Council for its expeditious disposal in a period of not more than six months from the receipt of the complaint in the Office of the Medical Council of India.
8.8 Any person aggrieved by the decision of the State Council on any complaint against a delinquent physician, shall have the right to file an appeal to MCI within a period of sixty days from the date of receipt of the order passed by the said Medical Council:
Provided that MCI may, if it is satisfied that the appellant was prevented by sufficient cause from presenting the appeal within the aforesaid period of 60 days allow it to be presented within a further period of 60 days.”

23. For inclusion of the said or similar provisions, the Medical Council would take appropriate steps under the Act.

24. With regard to the other issues including the aforesaid issue, adjourned for four weeks.