Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

E. Parmasivan And Others v. Union Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Feb 14, 2002
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners (15 in number) were retired officers of the Military Engineering Services (Ministry of Defence, Government of India). They retired between 31-01-1974 and 31-05-1985 while holding posts such as Senior Administrative Officer (SAO), Senior Barrack Store Officer (SBSO), or Principal Barrack Store Officer (PBSO).

They filed Original Application (OA) No. 1935 of 1995 before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Principal Bench, Delhi, seeking fixation of pay on promotion in terms of a concordance table notified in the Ministry of Defence Office Memorandum (OM) dated 12-01-1976. They relied on earlier CAT decisions (including a Principal Bench judgment dated 13-11-1992 in OAs Nos. 211 and 498 of 1986) and other CAT bench judgments granting similar relief to similarly placed MES officers.

By judgment dated 06-02-1996, the Tribunal dismissed the OA as barred by limitation, rejecting the petitioners' contention that the grievance constituted a continuing cause of action. The present order addresses the challenge to that dismissal and notes that this case stood on a different footing from certain other grouped civil appeals disposed of on 13-02-2002.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether OA No. 1935 of 1995 seeking pay fixation under the Ministry of Defence OM dated 12-01-1976 was barred by limitation.
  2. Whether the petitioners' claim constituted a continuing cause of action so as to avoid the bar of limitation.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court upheld the Tribunal's conclusion that the OA was time-barred. It noted that the pay-scale anomaly arose as early as 12-01-1976 when the Government of India declined to extend the revised pay scale (per the concordance table) to members of the Store Officers and Administrative Officers cadres. The court reasoned that the petitioners should have raised objections at that time, or at least upon retirement, by seeking pay fixation and corresponding pension calculation on that basis.

The court emphasized that the petitioners retired long before the Principal Bench CAT judgment dated 13-11-1992, and that the CAT judgments placed on record involved applicants who were still in service. The petitioners did not take steps to assert their claim until 1995. On these facts, the court agreed that limitation applied and that the “continuing cause of action” contention had been correctly rejected.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED: The petition was dismissed as devoid of merit, affirming that the original application was barred by limitation and that no relief could be granted.

The direct effect is that the petitioners are denied pay fixation under the OM dated 12-01-1976 (and any consequential pension recalculation) due to delay. The opinion does not indicate any broader implications or the laying down of new precedent.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. This case stands on a different footing from the other cases of the group i.e Civil Appeals Nos. 2490-91 of 1994 and Civil Appeals Nos. 749697 of 1997 which were disposed of on 13-2-2002.

2. The petitioners in this case, who are fifteen in number, are retired officers of the Military Engineering Services in the Ministry of Defence, Government of India. They retired from service between 31-1-1974 to 31-5-1985 while holding posts of Senior Administrative Officer (SAO) or Senior Barrack Store Officer (SBSO) or Principal Barrack Store Officer (PBSO). They filed original application, OA No. 1935 of 1995 in the Central Administrative Tribunal (for short “CAT”), Principal Bench, Delhi, claiming fixation of their pay on promotion in terms of the concordance table notified in the Ministry of Defence OM dated 12-1-1976. The main basis of their case is that in similar cases, OAs Nos. 211 and 498 of 1986, the Principal Bench, CAT by judgment rendered on 13-11-1992 directed the Union of India and the officers concerned to treat the applicants therein as entitled to pay fixation in terms of the aforesaid OM. The applicants also cited the judgments of Benches of CAT at a different place wherein relief had been granted to similarly placed officers of the MES cadre. The Tribunal by its judgment dated 6-2-1996 dismissed the original application on the ground that it is barred by limitation. The Tribunal rejected the contention raised on behalf of the petitioners that the grievance made by them in the case is continuing and the cause of action for the application is a continuing cause of action, in such a case question of limitation does not stand in the way of the claim made by them. As noted above all the petitioners had retired from the service long before the judgment of the Principal Bench, CAT, dated 13-11-1992. In the judgments of different Benches of CAT copies of which have been placed on record in the case the applicants were officers in service. The anomaly in the scale of pay of the petitioners arose as early as on 12-1-1976 when the Government of India declined to extend the revised scale of pay in terms of the concordance table to members of the cadres of the Store Officers and Administrative Officers. Therefore the petitioners would have raised objection regarding the anomaly in their scale of pay at that point of time. Even thereafter when they retired from the service they could have made the claim for pay fixation in terms of the concordance table and for calculation of pension on that basis. They did not take any step in that regard till 1995.

3. In the circumstances of the case the Tribunal, in our view, was right in holding that the original application filed by the petitioners was barred by limitation and hence no relief as claimed by them could be granted to them. Thus the petition being devoid of merit is dismissed.