Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Vikram Singh Junior High School v. District Magistrate (Fin. & Rev.)

Supreme Court Of India
Jan 24, 2002
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The dispute concerns 17 acres and 18 dismals of land situated at Village Prithvipur, Mazra Khamaria, Tehsil Chhibraman, District Farrukhabad, which undisputedly vests in the Gram Sabha, Khubaraiapur. The Land Management Committee passed a resolution on 5-2-1973 proposing to lease the land to the appellant, subject to approval by the Assistant Collector, First Class. The appellant sought such approval from the Sub-Divisional Officer (SDO); however, on 4-2-1975 the SDO instead ordered mutation of the appellant’s name in the revenue records.

A revision under Section 218 of the U.P. Land Revenue Act led the Board of Revenue to strike down the SDO’s order and direct deletion of the appellant’s name. The appellant’s first writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution was dismissed by the High Court. Meanwhile, consolidation proceedings commenced in the village. Treating the land as vacant, the Gram Sabha allotted it to Respondents 6–18, yet due to earlier entries the appellant’s name resurfaced in the consolidation record and chaks were proposed in his favour.

Upon learning of this anomaly, the Collector (also functioning as District Deputy Director of Consolidation) ordered on 6-4-1991 that the appellant’s name be deleted and that of Respondents 6–18 be substituted. The appellant’s second writ petition challenging that order was dismissed by the High Court. The present appeal arises from a special leave petition filed by the appellant against that dismissal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Collector had legal authority to expunge the appellant’s name from the consolidation record and substitute Respondents 6–18.
  2. Whether the appellant acquired any legally enforceable right or title to the land on the strength of (a) the unapproved 1973 resolution of the Land Management Committee, and (b) earlier erroneous revenue entries.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Once the appellant’s name was recorded in the consolidation record and chaks were ordered to be carved out, the Collector lacked jurisdiction to delete that entry and replace it with the names of Respondents 6–18.
  • Consequently, the Collector’s order dated 6-4-1991 was illegal and void.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondents' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court rejected the appellant’s jurisdictional objection, emphasising the following considerations:

  • It is undisputed that the land vests in the Gram Sabha and no valid lease was ever executed because the statutory approval of the Assistant Collector was never obtained.
  • Earlier mutation set aside. The Board of Revenue had already expunged the appellant’s name from revenue records, and that decision had attained finality when the High Court dismissed the appellant’s first writ petition.
  • Collector's order was consequential. The Collector’s 6-4-1991 direction merely corrected a continuing wrong entry in the consolidation record and therefore was a logical consequence of the Board of Revenue’s earlier order.
  • Absence of title in appellant. The appellant was neither bhumidhar, sirdar, nor asami. A mere resolution without statutory approval conveyed no title, and a mistaken entry cannot create rights.
  • Power under the Consolidation Act. Although the Collector cited an incorrect statutory provision, he was empowered under Section 48 of the U.P. Consolidation of Holdings Act to rectify erroneous entries. An error in citation does not invalidate an order that is otherwise within jurisdiction.
  • No adjudication prevented. There had been no judicial determination conferring title on the appellant; thus correction of the record did not interfere with any adjudicated right.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED. The Supreme Court affirmed the Collector’s order and the High Court’s dismissal of the writ petition. The appellant has no enforceable rights in the disputed land, and Respondents 6–18 remain the allottees according to the corrected consolidation record. The decision resolves the dispute between the parties but establishes no new legal precedent beyond reaffirming the Collector’s corrective powers under Section 48 of the U.P. Consolidation of Holdings Act.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. It is not disputed that the land measuring 17 acres and 18 dismals situated at Village Prithvipur, Mazra Khamaria, Tehsil Chhibraman, District Farrukhabad vests in Gram Sabha, Khubaraiapur. On 25-8-1973, the Land Management Committee, Khubaraiapur (hereinafter referred to as “the Land Management Committee”) by means of a resolution dated 5-2-1973 proposed to let out the said plot of land in favour of the appellant, herein subject to the approval by the Assistant Collector, First Class, in charge of the sub-division. Accordingly, the appellant submitted an application before the Sub-Divisional Officer (in short “SDO”) for according approval for grant of lease by the Gram Sabha with respect to the aforesaid plot in its favour. The SDO, instead of granting approval to the proposed lease by the Gram Sabha, passed an order dated 4-2-1975 directing for mutation of the name of the appellant in the revenue record as lessee. The said order of the SDO was challenged by means of a revision petition under Section 218 of the U.P Land Revenue Act and the same was referred by the Additional Commissioner to the Board of Revenue. The Board of Revenue, after hearing the parties found that the order of the SDO was erroneous as, on the application for grant of approval to the proposed lease in favour of the appellant, he could not have directed for mutation of the name of the appellant in the revenue record. Consequently, the revision petition was allowed and the mutation of the name of the appellant in the revenue record was directed to be expunged. The appellant thereafter filed a writ petition before the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution, but the same was dismissed. In between time, the village where the plot in dispute is situate was brought under consolidation of holding operations. During the consolidation proceedings, the Gram Sabha treating the land as a vacant land, allotted the same in favour of Respondents 6 to 18. However, in the consolidation proceedings, the name of the appellant came to be recorded in respect of the plot in dispute in pursuance of earlier entries and chaks were directed to be carved out in the name of the appellant. When the said fact came to the notice of the Collector, he, by order dated 6-4-1991, directed for deletion of the name of the appellant from the consolidation record and substituting the names of Respondents 6 to 18 in its place. It is at this stage, the appellant filed the second writ petition challenging the order of the Collector. But the said writ petition was dismissed by the High Court and it is against the said judgment and order of the High Court, the appellant has filed this appeal by way of special leave petition.

2. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant urged that once the name of the appellant came to be recorded in the consolidation record and further chaks were to be carved out in the consolidation record during the consolidation proceedings, it was not open to the Collector to pass an order for expunging the name of the appellant and substituting the names of Respondents 6 to 18 and, therefore, the impugned order of the Collector was wholly illegal and without jurisdiction. We do not find any merit in the argument. It is not disputed that the land vested in the Gram Sabha. It is also not disputed that no lease with the approval of the Assistant Collector has been executed by the Gram Sabha in favour of the appellant. It is also not in dispute that earlier, the name of the appellant recorded in the revenue record was directed to be expunged by the order of the Board of Revenue which was affirmed by the High Court in the writ petition. Under such circumstances, the order passed by the Collector dated 6-4-1991 by which the name of the appellant was directed to be expunged from the revenue record in respect of the plot in dispute, was only a consequential order for correcting the wrong entry continuing in the revenue record.

3. The matter may also be examined from another angle. The appellant was neither a bhumidhar, sirdar nor asami of the land in dispute. The alleged resolution dated 15-8-1973 had no legal sanctity in the absence of an approval of the Assistant Collector, First Class, in charge of the sub-division and, therefore, the resolution did not convey any title whatsoever in favour of the appellant. The entry in the revenue record must have a legal basis. Further there was no adjudication of dispute as regards continuance of the wrong entry. The appellant could not have claimed any title over the land in dispute merely on the basis of wrong entry which continued in its favour through negligence or failure of the Revenue Officer or the Consolidation Officer to correct the record, in pursuance of the order of the Board of Revenue which had attained finality. In the consolidation proceedings, the Collector is also the District Deputy Director of Consolidation under the U.P Consolidation of Holdings Act and is authorised to correct any wrong entry continued in the consolidation record in that capacity in the exercise of power under Section 48 of the U.P Consolidation of Holdings Act. Merely because a wrong provision was quoted by the Collector for exercising his power while deleting the name of the appellant from the revenue record would not invalidate the order if it is shown that such an order could be passed under the other provisions of the Act viz. under Section 48 of the U.P Consolidation of Holdings Act. In that view of the matter, we do not find any infirmity in the order passed by the Collector.

4. For the aforesaid reasons, we are satisfied that there is no merit in this appeal. The appeal is accordingly dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.