- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Asheesh Pratap Singh And Others v. Union Of India And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The writ petitioners (and similarly placed students) qualified the CPMT examination (June 1998) for admission to medical colleges in Uttar Pradesh. They were called for counselling for MBBS seats at Azamgarh Medical College, run by the All-India Children Care and Educational Development Society. They deposited fees, began classes on 12-7-1999, appeared in the 1st professional examination in May 2000, and cleared it. When they sought to join the 2nd professional course, they found a lack of lab facilities and sufficient teachers for teaching and practical classes; they nonetheless joined after assurances at a parent-management meeting dated 25-7-2000.
In Civil Appeal No. 3237 of 1999, the Supreme Court had earlier issued directions by order dated 4-5-2001 permitting the college to impart education to existing students (who had passed the 1st year) after making arrangements, directing an inspection by the Medical Council of India (MCI) in August 2001, and warning that non-compliance with the standards in the “1993 Regulations” could lead to closure of the college and possible absorption of students elsewhere.
By a judgment in CA No. 3237 of 1999 pronounced the same day as this order, the Court set aside the High Court’s order that had held there was “deemed permission” in favour of the institution, and noted that the institution would have to close in the event of non-compliance with the Court’s directions, placing students’ careers in jeopardy.
Legal Issues Presented
- What directions should be issued to protect the interests and educational continuity of students admitted to the college, given the possibility of closure for non-compliance with the standards under the 1993 Regulations?
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court recognised that, in light of its judgment setting aside the High Court’s finding of “deemed permission” and its earlier conditional directions (4-5-2001) contemplating closure upon non-compliance with the 1993 Regulations, the students’ careers were at jeopardy. The Court noted the submission of counsel for MCI that suitable arrangements could be made to accommodate the students in other medical colleges in Uttar Pradesh with the cooperation of the State Government. Having regard to the facts and circumstances and “in the interest of justice,” the Court directed the MCI and the State’s Directorate of Medical Education (or any other competent authority empowered to transfer students) to take steps, upon appropriate applications by the affected petitioners, to accommodate them in different medical colleges in Uttar Pradesh within a specified timeframe.
Holding and Implications
DISPOSED OF: The Court directed the Medical Council of India and the Directorate of Medical Education (or other competent authority in Uttar Pradesh with power to transfer students), upon appropriate applications by the petitioners, to initiate necessary steps to accommodate the petitioners in different medical colleges in Uttar Pradesh within three months. The writ petitions were disposed of accordingly, with no order as to costs.
The direct effect is to require administrative action to transfer/accommodate the petitioners in other Uttar Pradesh medical colleges within three months, to mitigate the jeopardy to their education arising from the potential closure of the institution for non-compliance. The opinion does not indicate that any new precedent was set.
S. Rajendra Babu, J.— Writ petitioners and others similarly placed in these petitions qualified themselves in the CPMT examination held in June 1998 for admission to medical colleges in the State of U.P They were called by the respondents for counselling for the MBBS seats available in Azamgarh Medical College run by the All-India Children Care and Educational Development Society, respondent in CA No. 3237 of 1999. They deposited the necessary fees and started attending the classes from 12-7-1999 and the 1st professional examination was held in May 2000 and all of them have cleared their first professional examination. When they came to join the 2nd professional course, they found that there were neither lab facilities nor sufficient teachers for teaching and conducting the course and practical classes for the 2nd professional course. However, on the assurances given to them at a parent-management meeting held on 25-7-2000 about providing adequate facilities, they joined the course.
2. However, at this stage, it is pertinent to state that considering the fact that a large number of students will be affected, this Court, in CA No. 3237 of 1999, gave the following directions by order dated 4-5-2001:
“Having perused the statements furnished by the College and the Medical Council of India and also the letter of the Director General of the Medical Colleges of the State of U.P in regard to compliance with requirements of the 1993 Regulations, we are of the opinion that it would be just and appropriate to permit the College to start after making due arrangements, imparting education to the existing students who have passed 1st year of MBBS course within two weeks from today. The College shall be inspected by the Medical Council of India with reference to the deficiencies pointed out as per the standards fixed in the 1993 Regulations in the first week of August 2001 after due notice to the applicant-respondent College, the report whereof shall be submitted in this Court in the 2nd week of August 2001 by MCI. Further orders on the IAs will be passed on the basis of inspection report of MCI. However, we make it clear that if the College does not come up to the standards fixed under the 1993 Regulations, we will be constrained to consider the question of ordering the closure of the College and at that stage appropriate order for the absorption of the students in other colleges of Uttar Pradesh will be passed, if considered necessary. We also make it clear that this arrangement is without prejudice to the contentions raised by the Medical Council of India in the appeal.”
3. Inasmuch as, by our judgment in CA No. 3237 of 1999 pronounced today, we have set aside the order made by the High Court holding that there is a deemed permission in favour of the respondent therein, and in the light of the order made by this Court on 4-5-2001 the said institution will have to be closed in the event of non-compliance with the directions issued by this Court, the career of the students is at jeopardy and this aspect cannot be seriously disputed. Learned counsel appearing for the Medical Council of India submitted that suitable arrangement could be made to accommodate these students in different medical colleges in the State of U.P with the cooperation of the Government of U.P
4. Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case and in the interest of justice, we direct that the Medical Council of India and the Directorate of Medical Education or any other competent authority in the State of U.P concerned, who has the power to transfer the students from one institution to another, on appropriate application being made by the petitioners concerned, shall initiate all the necessary steps to accommodate them in different medical colleges in the State of U.P within a period of three months from today.
5. The writ petitions shall stand disposed of accordingly. No costs.
Alert