- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Lal Chand (Dead) Through Lrs. v. Piayare Lal And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The landlord originally let the premises to the tenant at a monthly rent of Rs 25. After the tenant fell into arrears, eviction proceedings were initiated but settled on 2-11-1973 through a compromise under which the tenant agreed to pay an enhanced rent of Rs 35 per month.
Despite that compromise, the landlord began a second eviction application on 24-7-1974, alleging arrears from 1-10-1973 but claiming rent only at Rs 25. The tenant tendered Rs 35 per month, yet the landlord accepted only Rs 25 and refused the balance. The Controller dismissed this second application on 30-9-1978.
On 7-5-1980, the landlord launched a third eviction application under Section 13(2)(i) of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949. He sought:
- Arrears of Rs 10 per month (the difference between Rs 35 and Rs 25) for 1-12-1973 to 30-11-1977, and
- Arrears at Rs 35 per month for 1-12-1977 to 30-4-1980.
The tenant, on the first date of hearing, tendered rent at Rs 35 for the latter period. The Controller dismissed the application, holding the earlier claim barred by Order 2 Rule 2 CPC. The Appellate Authority reversed and ordered eviction. On revision, the High Court reinstated the Controller’s dismissal but reasoned that the agreed rent had reverted to Rs 25 due to the landlord’s conduct.
The landlord appealed to the present court (the opinion under analysis).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the agreed rate of rent after the 2-11-1973 compromise remained Rs 35 per month or had been reduced to Rs 25 per month by the landlord’s subsequent conduct.
- Whether, assuming the rent was Rs 35, the tenant had defaulted so as to justify eviction under Section 13(2)(i) of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949, given the tenant’s prior tenders and the landlord’s refusals.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant Landlord's Arguments
- The compromise of 2-11-1973 conclusively fixed the rent at Rs 35 per month; occasional acceptance of Rs 25 did not extinguish the right to the higher rent.
- Because the tenant had not paid the Rs 10 per month shortfall for 1-12-1973 to 30-11-1977 in the third proceeding, the statutory proviso to Section 13(2)(i) was not satisfied, entitling the landlord to eviction.
The opinion does not contain the respondent tenant’s arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
Rate of Rent: The court held that the 2-11-1973 compromise expressly fixed the rent at Rs 35 per month, and the tenant consistently offered to pay at that rate. The High Court therefore erred in deeming the agreed rent to be Rs 25.
Cause of Action for Eviction: To seek eviction under Section 13(2)(i), the landlord must establish that the tenant “has not paid or tendered” rent due. The record showed the tenant tendered the full Rs 35 per month, but the landlord voluntarily accepted only Rs 25. Because the tenant was not in default, no cause of action arose.
Compliance with Proviso: For arrears covering 1-12-1973 to 30-11-1977, the tenant’s tender satisfied the proviso to Section 13(2)(i). The landlord could not take advantage of his own wrongful refusal to accept the complete tender.
Combining the absence of default with the tenant’s statutory compliance, the court concluded that eviction was unwarranted even though the rent rate was Rs 35.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal is ALLOWED IN PART. The rent is declared to be Rs 35 per month, but the landlord’s request for eviction is REJECTED. No order as to costs.
Implications: The decision affirms the binding effect of compromise agreements on rent and clarifies that a landlord who refuses a full tender cannot claim default-based eviction. The ruling resolves the dispute between the parties but sets no new precedent beyond reinforcing existing statutory safeguards for tenants.
Order
1. A petition for eviction of tenant, on the ground available under clause (i) of sub-section (2) of Section 13 of the East Punjab Urban Rent Restriction Act, 1949 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”, for short) filed on 7-5-1980, was dismissed by the Controller. The appellate authority allowed the appeal preferred by the landlord and directed the tenant to put the landlord in possession of tenancy premises. On a revision preferred by the tenant, the High Court has set aside the order passed by the appellate authority and restored the order of the Controller, though for reason at variance with the one assigned by the latter.
2. The facts in a nutshell: the suit premises were initially let out by the landlord to the tenant on a monthly rent of Rs 25. The tenant was in arrears and proceedings for eviction were initiated. On 2-11-1973 there was a compromise arrived at between the parties. One of the terms of the compromise was that with effect from the date of compromise, the tenant shall be liable to pay rent at the rate of Rs 35 per month. With other terms of compromise, we are not concerned. The proceedings for eviction were disposed of in terms of the compromise.
3. On 24-7-1974, the landlord initiated second round of proceedings for eviction, alleging the tenant to be in arrears of rent with effect from 1-10-1973. Strangely enough, in spite of the compromise dated 2-11-1973, the landlord chose to lay a claim for recovery of rent at the rate of Rs 25 per month only.
4. The tenant offered payment of rent at the rate of Rs 35 per month and tendered the same. However, the landlord took a stand that he would accept the rent only at the rate of Rs 25 and declined the tenant's tender of rent at the rate of Rs 35 per month. On 30-9-1978, the second application for eviction was directed to be dismissed by the Controller.
5. On 7-5-1980, the landlord filed a third application for eviction under Section 13(2)(i) of the Act. In this application, the arrears of rent claimed by the landlord were at the rate of Rs 10 per month for the period from 1-12-1973 to 30-11-1977. Admittedly, for this period the tenant had tendered rent at the rate of Rs 35 per month but the landlord had himself accepted the tender in part i.e at the rate of Rs 25 per month and declined to accept the balance monthly rent at the rate of Rs 10 per month. In addition, the landlord also claimed arrears of rent at the rate of Rs 35 per month for the succeeding period i.e from 1-12-1977 to 30-4-1980. On the first date of hearing, the tenant tendered rent at the rate of Rs 35 for the period from 1-12-1977 to 30-4-1980, as contemplated by proviso to clause (i) of sub-section (2) of Section 13 of the Act.
6. The Controller dismissed the application for eviction on the ground that insofar as the period up to 30-11-1977 was concerned, the claim was barred by Order 2 Rule 2 CPC. The High Court, while restoring the Controller's order rejecting the prayer for eviction of the tenant, has assigned a different reason. In the opinion of the High Court, the landlord was entitled to recover rent only at the rate of Rs 25 per month and in view of the landlord's conduct, as disclosed during the proceedings initiated on second application for eviction, it will be assumed that the landlord had relinquished his right to recover rent at the rate of Rs 35 per month, and, therefore, the agreed rate of rent should be deemed to be Rs 25 per month only.
7. The learned counsel for the appellant landlord has submitted that the High Court is not right in holding the agreed rate of rent to be Rs 25 only and not Rs 35 per month. He has submitted that the rate of rent was concluded by the terms of the compromise dated 2-11-1973 and even if the landlord had chosen for some time not to accept the rent at the rate of Rs 35 and chose to accept the same at the rate of Rs 25 per month only, his right to recover the shortage in rent by calculating at the rate of Rs 35 per month cannot be said to have been foregone by him. He further submitted that once it is held that the landlord has the right to recover rent at the rate of Rs 35 per month, then the tenant shall be deemed to have not complied with his obligation cast on him by the proviso to clause (i) of sub-section (2) of Section 13 of the Act to the extent to which he did not pay or tender in the third proceedings i.e the present proceedings, arrears of rent at the rate of Rs 10 per month for the period from 1-12-1973 to 30-11-1977.
8. So far as the finding of the High Court regarding the rate of rent is concerned, we find merit in the submission made by the learned counsel for the appellant. In view of express terms of the compromise dated 2-11-1973 and the willingness on the part of the tenant to pay rent at the rate of Rs 35 per month, the High Court was not justified in holding the agreed rate of rent at Rs 25 only, merely because in the second round of proceedings the landlord had chosen to accept the rent at the rate of Rs 25, although the tenant had offered to pay the rent at the rate of Rs 35 consistently with the terms of the compromise dated 2-11-1973. The finding of the High Court, to the extent of rate of rent, is not correct and is, therefore, set aside.
9. The other question is: whether the appellant landlord is entitled to an order of recovery of possession. In order to give a cause of action to the landlord to seek eviction of his tenant by filing an application before the Controller, it must be alleged and proved that the tenant has not paid or tendered the rent due to him. It is an admitted case of the parties that prior to the filing of the third application, rent was tendered by the tenant at the rate of Rs 35 but the landlord chose to accept the tender in part, only to the extent of Rs 25 per month. It cannot be said that there was a default on the part of the tenant. He had tendered the rent and if that be so, then the cause of action for initiating the proceedings itself did not arise to the landlord.
10. So far as the arrears of rent for the period from 1-12-1973 to 30-11-1977 are concerned, the proviso to clause (i) of sub-section (2) of Section 13 was complied with. The landlord cannot be allowed to take advantage of his own wrong committed by refusing the tender of rent by the tenant in its entirety. The claim for eviction has to be refused to the landlord by a combined effect of two factors: partly because there was no cause of action accrued to the landlord and partly because the tenant complied with the proviso to clause (i) of sub-section (2) of Section 13.
11. For the foregoing reasons, the appeal is allowed in part. Though the rate of rent is held to be Rs 35 per month, the order of the High Court rejecting the prayer for eviction of the tenant is upheld for the reason stated hereinabove. No order as to costs.
Alert