- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Jayanti Roy v. Dass Estate Pvt. Ltd. .
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent landlord instituted an eviction suit against the appellant under Sections 17(2) and 17(2-A) of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1956. The appellant, disputing the existence of any landlord-tenant relationship, filed an application under those provisions. In that application, paragraph 10 originally described one Alamohan Dass as a “licensee” of the suit premises. Later, the appellant moved an application under Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking to substitute a new paragraph 10, asserting that Alamohan Dass was only a “permissive occupier” of Dag No. 150, had no possession over Dag No. 148, and had orally surrendered his licence in 1965 in favour of the licensor on specified conditions.
The trial court, by order dated 10 April 2001, rejected the amendment, holding that it attempted to withdraw an earlier admission. The Calcutta High Court, in revision under Section 115 CPC, affirmed the rejection on 29 August 2001, adding that title questions were irrelevant in a proceeding under Sections 17(2) and 17(2-A) of the Act. The appellant obtained leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, which heard the parties on the merits of the appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the defendant–appellant should be permitted to amend her application under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC by substituting a new paragraph that changes the description of Alamohan Dass from “licensee” to “permissive occupier.”
- Whether allowing such an amendment would improperly withdraw an admission or introduce irrelevant and complicated questions of title in a proceeding under Sections 17(2) and 17(2-A) of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1956.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The defendant had, from the outset, denied any landlord-tenant relationship; the amendment merely clarifies that position based on newly discovered material.
- There is no material inconsistency between the original pleadings and the proposed amendment.
- The Supreme Court had already permitted a similar amendment between the same parties concerning an adjoining plot in Estralla Rubber v. Dass Estate (P) Ltd.
Respondent's Arguments
- The amendment would amount to withdrawing an admission that Alamohan Dass was a licensee.
- Questions related to title are irrelevant in proceedings confined to Sections 17(2) and 17(2-A) of the Act.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Estralla Rubber v. Dass Estate (P) Ltd. (2001) 8 SCC 97 | Liberal approach to allowing amendments; identical factual context between the same parties. | The Court relied on this earlier decision to maintain consistency and held that a similar amendment should likewise be allowed in the present matter. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court reiterated the settled principle that amendments moved at the appropriate stage and without undue delay should ordinarily be allowed. It found:
- The appellant had consistently disputed the landlord-tenant relationship; the proposed amendment simply elaborated that stance.
- No “material inconsistency” existed between the original pleading and the proposed new paragraph.
- Denying the amendment would be inconsistent with the Court’s own decision in Estralla Rubber, which involved the same parties and an analogous factual matrix.
Consequently, both the trial court and High Court erred in refusing the amendment on the grounds of withdrawal of admission or relevance of title disputes.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL ALLOWED; the orders of the trial court (10 April 2001) and the High Court (29 August 2001) are set aside. The appellant’s application for amendment under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC is permitted. The respondents may seek consequential amendments, which the trial court shall consider in accordance with law. No order as to costs.
Implications: The suit will now proceed before the trial court with the amended pleadings. The decision reinforces the Supreme Court’s liberal stance on allowing amendments that clarify, rather than contradict, existing pleadings, but it does not establish a novel legal principle beyond reaffirming earlier precedent.
D.M Dharmadhikari, J.— Leave to appeal is granted.
2. The parties represented in the case are finally heard on merits of the appeal.
3. In the suit filed for eviction of the appellant from suit premises under the provisions of Sections 17(2) and (2-A) of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as the Act), the application for amendment has been rejected by the trial court and the order has been upheld by the High Court of Calcutta in revision under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The appellant seeks to resist the eviction suit on the ground that there exists no relationship of landlord and tenant between the parties. In the application filed under Sections 17(2) and (2-A) of the Act initially in paragraph 10, it was stated that Alamohan Dass was the licensee of the suit premises.
4. By the amendment application, permission was sought to delete original paragraph 10 to be substituted by new paragraph 10 to make an averment that Alamohan Dass was merely a recorded “permissive occupier” of Dag No. 150 and he was not in actual possession of Dag No. 148 and was never recorded as “permissive occupier” in the record-of-rights in respect of that suit property. It was then sought to be pleaded that Alamohan Dass in 1965 had orally surrendered his licence in respect of Dag No. 150 in favour of the licensor on a condition that the answering defendant, her husband and her son would be given a fresh licence for earmarked portion of Dag No. 150.
5. The trial court by the impugned order dated 10-4-2001 rejected the application for proposing the above amendment on the ground that an attempt is being made to withdraw the admission made in the original application regarding status of Alamohan Dass as the licensee of the suit premises.
6. The order of the trial court was maintained by the High Court in revision on additional ground that in proceeding under Sections 17(2) and (2-A) of the Act, complicated questions relating to title in respect of suit property are wholly irrelevant.
7. We have heard learned counsel appearing for the appellant and the authorised Director of the respondent Company. It may be stated at the outset that similar amendment sought in proceedings of eviction between the same parties in relation to the adjacent plot, has been allowed by this Court by decision reported in Estralla Rubber v. Dass Estate (P) Ltd. (2001) 8 SCC 97 (to which one of us, Hon'ble Mr Justice D.P Mohapatra was a party).
8. It is settled that amendments to pleadings which are moved at the proper stage and not unduly delayed should not normally be refused. In the application raising dispute on payment of rent under Sections 17(2) and (2-A) of the Act the appellant has right from the beginning denied relationship of landlord and tenant between the parties. An amendment was moved stating that on discovery of additional evidence and material, Alamohan Dass was merely a “permissive occupier” in respect of one of the dags. The appellant also sought leave to explain the nature of her possession and occupation. There does not appear any material inconsistency between the original averments in the application and those proposed by amendment.
9. Since this Court allowed similar amendment in suit between the same parties concerning adjoining plot, we find no justification to make a departure and take a different view. For the reasons aforesaid, both the impugned orders dated 10-4-2001 of the trial court and dated 29-8-2001 of the High Court are set aside. The application for amendment filed by the defendant under Order 6 Rule 17 of the Civil Procedure Code is allowed. It would be open to the respondents to propose consequential amendments to their plaint and replies to application under Sections 17(2) and (2-A) of the Act which shall be considered by the trial court in accordance with law and the trial shall proceed. The appeal stands allowed with the above directions.
10. In these circumstances, we make no order as to costs.
Alert