Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

John Mathai Abrraham v. British Physical Laboratory India Ltd. .

Supreme Court Of India
Oct 30, 2001
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, landlord of premises No. 12/1, Primrose Road, Bangalore, leased the property to the respondent company in 1976 at an initial rent of Rs 1300 per month, later raised to Rs 1800. In 1989 the appellant initiated eviction proceedings under Section 21(1)(h) of the Karnataka Rent Control Act, 1961, claiming a reasonable and bona fide requirement of the premises for his own residential and professional use, citing difficulties co-habiting with his father and step-mother.

The learned Rent Controller (HRC No. 10541 of 1989) upheld the appellant’s claim and ordered eviction on 5-7-1995. The respondent filed HRRP No. 1256 of 1995 before the High Court of Karnataka, which on 22-2-1999 allowed the revision and dismissed the eviction petition. The appellant obtained special leave and filed the present appeal challenging the High Court’s decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant has proved a reasonable and bona fide requirement of the premises so as to warrant eviction of the respondent under Section 21(1)(h) of the Karnataka Rent Control Act, 1961.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The eviction proceedings were started during the lifetime of the appellant’s father because co-existence with his step-mother had become impossible.
  • The trial court correctly found that the appellant’s need for the premises was genuine and bona fide.
  • The High Court erroneously reversed findings of fact, which is unsustainable in law.

Respondent's Arguments

  • After the death of the appellant’s father, the appellant has sufficient space in the existing large family house for residential and professional purposes; hence his need for the leased premises is not bona fide.
  • The High Court properly re-evaluated the evidence and concluded that the requirement was not genuine; under Article 136 the Supreme Court should not interfere with these factual findings.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted that the respondent did not dispute ownership of the leased premises by the appellant and acknowledged the long tenancy since 1976. It examined the High Court’s reliance on three facts: the size of the family house, the absence of other family members who live abroad, and the step-mother’s alleged indifference to the tenancy. The Court found these factors insufficient to negate the appellant’s bona fide need.

Crucially, the Court held that mere occupation of a part of a building in which the appellant holds only a fractional, undivided share does not bar him from seeking eviction under Section 21(1)(h). It emphasized that no evidence established the appellant as sole owner of the family house; at best he possessed a share, which did not satisfy his independent residential and professional requirements.

Accordingly, the Supreme Court concluded that the Rent Controller’s original findings were correct and that the High Court’s reversal was unjustified.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; eviction order of the Rent Controller dated 5-7-1995 restored.

The respondent is granted time until 30-4-2002 to vacate the premises upon filing the usual undertaking within four weeks. Costs are awarded against the respondent. The decision directly affects the parties by reinstating the eviction but does not articulate any broader precedent beyond affirming that partial or shared occupancy elsewhere does not defeat a landlord’s bona fide requirement under Section 21(1)(h) of the Karnataka Rent Control Act.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. This appeal brings under challenge the validity of the order of the High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore in HRRP No. 1256 of 1995 on 22-2-1999 allowing the revision filed by the respondent (Respondents 1 to 3 are avatars of the same company and are referred to as “the respondent”) and dismissing the eviction petition filed by the appellant.

2. The appellant is the landlord of premises being No. 12/1, Primrose Road, Bangalore (for short “the premises”) of which the respondent is a tenant on a monthly rent of Rs 1800. The appellant filed eviction petition seeking eviction of the respondent on two grounds but only one ground under Section 21(1)(h) of the Karnataka Rent Control Act, 1961 (for short “the Act) survives — he reasonably and bona fide requires accommodation for his personal occupation, both for residence as well as for professional requirements. The respondent contested the petition denying the personal requirement of the appellant and taking the plea that the house in occupation of the appellant being a big house has enough accommodation for his residence and his professional activities.

3. On considering the evidence placed on record, the learned Rent Controller found that a case under Section 21(1)(h) was made out and ordered eviction of the respondent on 5-7-1995. Aggrieved by the said order of the learned Rent Controller, the respondent filed revision before the High Court which was allowed by the impugned order. It is against that order that the appellant is in appeal before us, by special leave.

4. Mr M.S Ganesh, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant, has contended that the appellant initiated proceedings for eviction of the respondent during the lifetime of his father and it had become impossible for him to get along with his stepmother; the ground of bona fide requirement was established and the trial court gave effect to it but the High Court reversed the findings of fact recorded by the trial court which is unsustainable in law.

5. Mr Nageswara Rao, learned Senior Counsel for the respondent, argues that after the death of his father the house in occupation of the appellant is available to him both for personal as well as professional requirements and, therefore, it cannot be said that he reasonably and bona fide requires the premises for his personal occupation. As the Rent Controller did not correctly appreciate the facts, the High Court on a proper consideration of the material placed before it reversed the findings taking the view that the need was not bona fide and this Court, under Article 136 of the Constitution, would not disturb such findings.

6. The only question that arises for consideration is: whether the appellant has proved reasonable and bona fide requirement of the premises to warrant eviction of the respondent under clause (h) of sub-section (1) of Section 21 of the Act.

7. The facts are not in dispute. The premises in question belong to the appellant and that he let them out to the respondent sometime in 1976 on a monthly rent of Rs 1300 which was subsequently enhanced to Rs 1800 per month. The appellant, finding it difficult to get along with his father and the stepmother on account of day-to-day disputes, invoked the jurisdiction of the Rent Controller under Section 21(1)(h) of the Act seeking eviction of the respondent. The trial court on appreciation of the evidence found that the need of the respondent was established. However, the High Court in revision took note of the facts that the building of the appellant's father, in which he is presently residing, is a huge building, that the stepbrothers and sisters are staying abroad; that the stepmother had not demanded the respondent to vacate the premises. On that premise, it concluded that the appellant's claim that he cannot pursue his professional activities in the premises in which he is presently living, was not substantiated. We are unable to agree with the conclusion arrived at by the High Court. The case set up by the respondent is that after the death of the father of the appellant, he became the sole owner of the premises and therefore he had enough accommodation available both for his residence as well as for professional requirements as such requirement of the premises is not real and bona fide. This was not admitted by the appellant. Nothing has been placed on record to show that the appellant has become the sole owner of that building in which he and his stepmother are living. At the best the appellant might be having a share in it. Merely because the appellant is living in a room of the huge building which does not exclusively belong to him, it cannot be said that his requirement to occupy the premises for his residence and professional requirements is not reasonable and bona fide. In our view being in occupation of a portion of a building holding a fractional undivided share, is no bar to invoke the provision of Section 21(1)(h) of the Act. In this view of the matter, we set aside the order under challenge and restore the order of the learned Rent Controller, in HRC No. 10541 of 1989 dated 5-7-1995.

8. Learned counsel for the respondent seeks six months' time to vacate the premises. Having regard to the fact that the respondent is a business concern and has been in occupation of the premises for over 25 years, we consider it just and appropriate to grant time till 30-4-2002. The respondent shall file usual undertaking within four weeks from today.

9. The appeal is accordingly allowed with costs.