Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Agra District Coop. Bank Ltd. v. Labour Court

Supreme Court Of India
Feb 27, 2001
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondents 2 and 3 were selected on 28-4-1980 as clerks/cashiers by a Selection Committee constituted under the U.P. Cooperative Societies Employees’ Service Regulations, 1975. Although they received appointment letters and joined duty, the Managing Committee of Agra District Cooperative Bank Ltd. subsequently cancelled the recruitment by a resolution dated 9-5-1980.

Challenging the cancellation, the respondents filed a writ petition before the High Court, which declined to intervene and directed them to pursue alternative remedies. They then initiated a dispute before the Labour Court, but the Labour Court refused to entertain it on the ground that the High Court had already ruled. The respondents again approached the High Court, which set aside the Labour Court’s order and remanded the dispute for a decision on the merits.

Upon remand, the Labour Court declared the termination invalid and ordered reinstatement with back wages. The Bank appealed this award to the High Court, raising three principal objections. After the High Court rejected those objections, the Bank brought the present appeal to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the original selection process of 1980 was vitiated for non-compliance with the U.P. Cooperative Societies Employees’ Service Regulations, 1975.
  2. Whether the participation of a nominee in place of the Assistant Registrar on the Selection Committee invalidated the recruitment.
  3. Whether the Labour Court lacked jurisdiction under Section 70 of the U.P. Cooperative Societies Act to adjudicate the termination dispute.
  4. Whether any irregularities in recruitment were cured by the respondents’ uninterrupted service of more than twenty years.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Agra District Cooperative Bank Ltd.)

  • The selection process was not conducted strictly in accordance with the relevant Regulations and was therefore invalid.
  • The Assistant Registrar, a statutory member of the Selection Committee, did not personally participate; his nominee’s participation allegedly vitiated the selection.
  • Under Section 70 of the U.P. Cooperative Societies Act, the proper forum was not the Labour Court; hence the Labour Court had no jurisdiction.
  • Relying on Ashwani Kumar v. State of Bihar (1997) 2 SCC 1, the Bank contended that, even if appointments were irregular, they should be regularised only through a scheme rather than outright reinstatement.
  • At the Supreme Court stage, counsel sought to raise an additional argument that vacancies were not advertised to the Employment Exchange.

Respondents 2 and 3

  • Countered all three objections, asserting full compliance with the Regulations, validity of the nominee’s participation pursuant to a Government Order dated 27-7-1979, and the Labour Court’s jurisdiction to entertain employment disputes.
  • Emphasised their continuous service for over two decades, arguing that it would be unjust and inequitable to disturb their employment at this late stage.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Cooperative Central Bank Ltd. v. Industrial Tribunal, (1969) 2 SCC 43; (1970) 1 SCR 205 Labour Courts/Industrial Tribunals have jurisdiction over employment disputes in cooperative societies despite provisions of cooperative legislation. Relied upon to uphold the Labour Court’s jurisdiction under similar statutory provisions.
Ashwani Kumar v. State of Bihar, (1997) 2 SCC 1 Irregular appointments made against non-existent vacancies require framing of a regularisation scheme. Distinguished; the Court held the present case did not involve unauthorised appointments or non-existent vacancies.
Buddhi Nath Chaudhary v. Abahi Kumar, (2001) 3 SCC 328 Long continuance in service may cure procedural irregularities in recruitment. Applied to hold that over twenty years of service deemed the respondents regularly appointed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Compliance with Regulations: The Court agreed with the High Court’s view that clause (vi) of the Regulations provides an independent mode of recruitment for clerks/typists, and the respondents’ selection satisfied that clause.

Participation of Nominee: A Government Order dated 27-7-1979 authorised the Assistant Registrar to nominate a substitute. Because that order was unchallenged, the nominee’s participation did not invalidate the selection.

Jurisdiction of the Labour Court: The Court noted that the jurisdiction objection should have been raised when the matter was first remanded; moreover, Cooperative Central Bank affirmed Labour Court competence in analogous circumstances.

Equity and Passage of Time: Even assuming some irregularity, the respondents had effectively served for over twenty years. Disturbing their employment now would be “harsh and inhuman.” Applying Buddhi Nath Chaudhary, such long service cured any irregularity.

Distinction from Ashwani Kumar: The appointments here were neither unauthorised nor against non-existent vacancies; hence the regularisation scheme approach in Ashwani Kumar was inapplicable.

Late-raised Argument Rejected: The Court refused to entertain the new contention regarding non-notification of vacancies as it had not been urged before the High Court.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed.

The Supreme Court affirmed the reinstatement of Respondents 2 and 3 with continuity of service and back wages. The decision underscores that (i) Labour Courts possess jurisdiction over employment disputes in cooperative societies, and (ii) prolonged, unbroken service can regularise appointments tainted by procedural irregularities. No new legal doctrine was created, but the judgment reinforces equitable considerations in long-pending service disputes.

Show all summary ...

1. Respondents 2 and 3 were selected by the Selection Committee constituted in terms of the U.P Cooperative Societies Employees’ Service Regulations, 1975 as in force then as clerks/cashiers. Appointment letters were issued to them on 28-4-1980 and they also reported for duty. Thereafter, by a resolution made on 9-5-1980 the said recruitment was cancelled.

2. Respondents 2 and 3 filed a writ petition before the High Court challenging the action of the Managing Committee of Agra District Cooperative Bank Ltd., the appellant herein. The High Court, however, declined to interfere with the action and asked the parties to work out their respective alternative remedies under the law. Thereafter, a dispute was raised before the Labour Court and the Labour Court declined to interfere on the ground that the High Court had already decided the matter.

3. Again Respondents 2 and 3 approached the High Court for appropriate reliefs and the High Court set aside the award made by the Labour Court and remitted the matter to the Labour Court for a fresh consideration on the merits of the matter. The Labour Court examined the matter on merits and came to the conclusion that the termination of services of Respondents 2 and 3 is invalid and directed their reinstatement with certain directions in relation to back wages. That award was challenged before the High Court.

4. Three contentions were raised before the High Court; firstly, that the selection process had not been done properly and in terms of the relevant Regulations, therefore, the same is vitiated; secondly, it was stated that the Assistant Registrar, Cooperative Societies who was one of the members of the Selection Committee, did not participate but his nominee participated in the selection process, therefore, the selection is vitiated; thirdly, it was contended that a dispute under Section 70 of the U.P Cooperative Societies Act should not have been raised in relation to termination of services of Respondents 2 and 3 and, therefore, the Labour Court had no jurisdiction to decide the matter. On behalf of the contesting respondents all these three contentions have been countered very effectively.

5. So far as the Regulations framed under the U.P Cooperative Societies Act are concerned, the High Court, after examining the scheme thereof, came to the conclusion that the recruitment under clause (vi) is independent of clause (i), sub-clauses (iv) and (vii), and the relevant clause (vi) reads as follows:

“(vi) Notwithstanding anything contained in clause (i) recruitment to the posts of typists and clerks in the lowest pay scales in a cooperative society shall be made by a Selection Committee constituted as under:

In the case of District/Central Cooperative Banks, District Cooperative Federations, Wholesale Cooperative Consumer Stores, including Naya Bazaars, Uttar Pradesh Postal Employees’ Cooperative Bank Ltd., Lucknow and Oudh and Rohelkhand Railway Employees Cooperative Bank Ltd., Lucknow, the Selection Committee shall consist of:

(a) Chairman/Administrator of the appointing society who shall be the Chairman of the Selection Committee. If Assistant Registrar of the district is the Administrator, Deputy Registrar of the region shall be the Chairman of the Selection Committee;

(b) Assistant Registrar of the district, who shall be member of the Selection Committee; and

(c) Sachiv of the appointing society, who shall be convener of the Committee.”

The view taken by the High Court in this regard, prima facie appears to be correct.

6. So far as the second contention is concerned regarding non-participation of the Assistant Registrar in the selection process, the High Court noticed that under a Government Order issued on 27-7-1979 if the Assistant Registrar is unable to participate in any such selection, he can nominate any other person and such nominee could participate in the selection process and that order was not under challenge before the High Court. Hence, the participation of the nominee for the Assistant Registrar does not vitiate the recruitment of the respondents and that finding of course prima facie appears to be correct.

7. So far as the third contention is concerned regarding jurisdiction of the Labour Court, we make it clear that it was not the first round of litigation that the parties had gone before the Labour Court, and at that stage if the Labour Court had no jurisdiction, that point should have been raised at once when the matter came up before the High Court when the matter was remanded to the Labour Court to decide on merits of the case. Apart from that this Court in Coop. Central Bank Ltd. v. Industrial Tribunal (1969) 2 SCC 43, (1970) 1 SCR 205 considered the identical provisions arising under the Andhra Pradesh Cooperative Societies Act and held that the Labour Court has jurisdiction in such matters.

8. The position is that when a question of employment arises, certainly it cannot be said that the doors of the Labour Court are shut. It is possible that in certain cases Section 70 of the U.P Cooperative Societies Act may be attracted. If parties avail of a remedy in one of the jurisdictions, that proceeding must be pursued to its logical end and should not be given up in the middle and start another proceeding under another enactment. That would be a wholesome rule to be followed rather than to state that one or the other tribunal has no jurisdiction.

9. In this matter none of the contentions need deeper examination for reasons to be stated now. In this case the appointments had been made as early as on 28-4-1980. Though the services were terminated the parties concerned invoked the jurisdiction of the Labour Court and the Labour Court directed their reinstatement and they were reinstated from the date of the termination itself. In these circumstances they must be deemed to be in service for more than 20 years now and to disturb their services at this stage would be harsh and inhuman.

10. Mr S.B Sanyal, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant submitted that this Court in Ashwani Kumar v. State of Bihar (1997) 2 SCC 1 held that appointments made in an unauthorised manner and against non-existent vacancies, were irregular and proper scheme will be framed to regularise the services and that same principle should be adopted in the present case.

11. We do not think that such a course is permissible. It is not a case where appointments have been made in an unauthorised manner. We have stated that prima facie there is material to show that selection process had been gone through by them and the candidates have been selected and such appointment is not against non-existent vacancies. In the special features of the case, the ratio of the decision in Ashwani Kumar v. State of Bihar (1997) 2 SCC 1 cannot be applied. Correct principle to be applied is what we have stated in Buddhi Nath Chaudhary v. Abahi Kumar (2001) 3 SCC 328. Even though there may be irregularity in the recruitment but by reasons of the respondents being in employment for more than 20 years the same stood cured by their long service and they are deemed to have been regularly appointed.

12. Mr Sanyal, learned Senior Counsel seeks leave of the Court to raise an argument that vacancies were not advertised or notified to the employment exchange. But it is clear that no such argument was raised before the High Court. Hence we do not permit him to raise the same before us for the first time.

13. The appeal is dismissed accordingly.