- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ircon International Ltd. v. Daya Shankar And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent was appointed in the appellant’s Ballast Project of Northern Railway as a khalasi, without a formal appointment letter. In 1988, he was transferred to the head office. By memo dated 29-6-1992, he was informed that his services were no longer required, and he was paid compensation under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
The respondent filed a writ petition before the High Court. In those proceedings, an order of the Supreme Court dated 2-5-1997 in Sufal Jha v. Union of India (2002) 9 SCC 693 was referred to. The Single Judge issued directions in purported consistency with that Supreme Court order, and the Division Bench upheld the Single Judge’s decision. The matter then came before the Supreme Court, where special leave was granted and the appeal was heard.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the High Court (Single Judge, affirmed by the Division Bench) was justified in directing that the respondent be treated as a permanent employee and accommodated in a project based on the Supreme Court’s earlier order in Sufal Jha.
- Whether, as a matter of principle, a project-appointed employee’s service can be directed to continue automatically beyond the duration of the project (or after retrenchment with compensation).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Submissions
- Counsel for the appellant (Mr Jaideep Gupta) stated that, despite retrenchment compensation having been paid, the appellant would, as far as possible, apply the directions contained in the Supreme Court’s order in Sufal Jha and consider the respondent for appointment as and when a vacancy arises.
- Beyond consideration for appointment upon vacancy, no other relief was stated to be grantable.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sufal Jha v. Union of India (2002) 9 SCC 693 (order dated 2-5-1997) | The earlier Supreme Court order proceeded on concession and contemplated preparation of a panel and offering appointments in projects as and when vacancies arise; it did not treat the project workers as regularly or permanently appointed, nor did it direct arrears by deeming continuous service. | The Court held that the High Court’s directions (including treating the respondent as permanent and protecting services except as juniormost/no vacancy) went beyond and did not flow from the Sufal Jha order. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the scope of the Supreme Court’s earlier order dated 2-5-1997 in Sufal Jha (2002) 9 SCC 693, which had been relied upon before the High Court. It noted that the Sufal Jha order did not treat the project workers as having been appointed regularly or on a permanent basis; rather, there was an undertaking by the appellant to provide employment as and when vacancies arose, based on a panel.
Against that backdrop, the Court found no basis for the Single Judge’s directions requiring (i) preparation of a list including the respondent’s name; (ii) accommodation in a project as per seniority; and crucially (iii) treating the respondent as a permanent employee whose services could not be disposed of unless he was the juniormost and there were no vacancies. The Court reasoned that these directions exceeded the Sufal Jha order, particularly because Sufal Jha was an order on concession and did not contain directions to deem continuous service or to pay arrears.
The Court further articulated a principle applicable to project employment: where an employee is appointed for the duration of a project, the question of automatic continuation of service after the project does not arise. On the appellant’s statement through counsel, the Court accepted that the respondent would be considered for appointment as and when a vacancy arises, consistent (as far as possible) with the approach indicated in Sufal Jha. It concluded that no relief beyond such consideration could be granted.
Holding and Implications
ALLOWED: The appeal was allowed, and the impugned orders of the High Court (Single Judge’s directions as affirmed by the Division Bench) were set aside.
The direct effect is that the respondent is not to be treated as a permanent employee on the basis of the High Court’s directions. The only relief preserved is that, as and when a vacancy arises, the respondent will be considered for appointment in accordance with seniority. The opinion applies the limited scope of the earlier Sufal Jha concession-based order and does not indicate that any new precedent was set beyond this application to the facts.
Order
1. Special leave granted.
2. The respondent, as is evident from the facts which emanate from the record, was appointed in a project of the appellant, namely, the Ballast Project of Northern Railway. He was appointed as a khalasi and no formal letter of appointment was issued. In 1988 he was transferred to the head office and by memo dated 29-6-1992 he was informed that his services were no longer required but he was paid compensation as per the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
3. The respondent filed a writ petition before the High Court. Before the High Court, an order of this Court dated 2-5-1997 in the case of Sufal Jha v. Union of India (2002) 9 SCC 693 was referred to. That was a case where certain persons working at the projects were sought to be retrenched and on concession it was directed that there will be an offer of appointment to those of the petitioners whose names figure on the panel to be prepared and they would be offered appointments in any of the projects in Madhya Pradesh as and when the vacancies arise.
4. It will be seen that in the said order of 2-5-1997 (2002) 9 SCC 693, this Court did not regard the petitioners therein as having been appointed regularly or on permanent basis. There was only an undertaking given by the appellant herein to give employment to those petitioners as and when the vacancies arise.
5. In the instant case, however, the Single Judge issued the following directions:
“Consistent with the direction issued by the Supreme Court, the second respondent shall also prepare a list along with the list prepared or to be prepared including the name of the petitioner, according to the records, which would show the first appointment of the petitioner in the second respondent and as per the seniority, the petitioner shall be accommodated in any one of the projects of the respondent Company. The second respondent shall consider the petitioner as a permanent employee in the second respondent Company and his services shall not be disposed of unless he is found to be juniormost in the list and if there are no vacancies in any one of the projects of the second respondent.”
This decision has been upheld by the Division Bench.
6. We do not find any basis for the Single Judge to have given the directions mentioned hereinabove. The earlier order of this Court dated 2-5-1997 in Sufal Jha case (2002) 9 SCC 693 was on a concession. That apart, to consider the respondent as a permanent employee was clearly going beyond the aforesaid order of 2-5-1997. Even in Sufal Jha case (2002) 9 SCC 693, there was no direction to pay arrears by deeming the employee to be in service continuously. The directions given by the Single Judge in this case and affirmed by the Division Bench do not flow from the order in Sufal Jha case (2002) 9 SCC 693.
7. As a matter of principle, when an employee is appointed on a project and for the duration of that project, the question of his services continuing automatically thereafter does not arise. Mr Jaideep Gupta, leaned counsel for the appellant states that despite retrenchment compensation having been paid the appellant will as far as possible apply the directions contained in this Court's order in Sufal Jha case (2002) 9 SCC 693 and as and when a vacancy arises, the respondent will be considered for appointment. Apart from this, no other relief can be granted to the respondent.
8. For the aforesaid reasons, this appeal is allowed and the impugned orders of the High Court are set aside. As and when a vacancy arises, the respondent will be considered in accordance with seniority.
Alert